Thursday, December 5, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 168: Sunny

Prompt: "A song about traditions"

Selected by Sunny


"Family Table"
Bill Withers
Making Music, 1975

For YTT, our class has been reading The Body Keeps the Score, which I recommend, despite hearing that it's controversial and people get angry at some of the author's examples and conclusions. Which reminds me of Schoppes, "Every original idea is first ridiculed, then vigorously attacked, and finally taken for granted.”

The book's basic conceit, implied by the title, is that trauma / emotional pain / negative emotional patterns don't just live in the Brain, they live in the entire body—the nerves, the muscles, the joints. If you have an emotion, your body releases neuropeptides; if you are unable process said emotions because they're too intense or too traumatic, those peptides need to go somewhere, get driven down into the body system, and then they'll keep coming back up trying to get out in the future (i.e. flashbacks).

The implication is that a multi modality approach to healing is required to address many trauma cases. Attacking "mental challenges" with only talk therapy, pharmaceuticals, etc. may provide relief, but may not alleviate root causes for all patients. The book goes into other explored healing modalities and their effectiveness for a wide range of patients: touch, movement, stretching, breathing, chanting, internal family systems, EMDR (eye movement desensitization), Ketamine??, and others. And yes, talk therapy.

If you look at native cultures around the world (North and South Americans, Africans, South and East Asians, etc. etc.) you see long Traditions of therapeutic modalities including chanting, dancing, touch, etc. The Native American spirit quest. Acupuncture and traditional Chinese. The Inuit drum dance. The Indian mantra and pranayama. I've said it before on this blog, and I'll say it again, the healthcare system is overpriced and useless. I'm not saying throw it out (we need Shock therapy and Vaccines and MRIs and the West has mastered this stuff), but some integration of Traditional healing methods could provide untold relief.

My family doesn't have a lot of traditions. I think this is a combination of immigrant parents and busy parents. But that's OK, tomorrow's tradition could be whatever's significant today. Writing on PoYB, that's a tradition, we have a song about that yet?

5 comments:

Zach said...

I did talk therapy for a bunch of years but nothing has given me more release than punching a pillow over and over using the "Radically Alive" modality while my therapist looks on and smiles and nods along.

Joe K said...

I can't answer the question of "Ketamine??" myself but there has been a lot of talk about ketamine therapy in the social work community. My old supervisor went to a retreat in which she did it and she said that it worked really well for some and really awfully for others (including herself). She also did psilocybin therapy and said that was a lot better. But we'll probably see ketamine first in PA, if at all. I feel like you, Sunny, are the right person to take it on and report back to us.

To answer your final question: there isn't but there COULD be. My dream is to get all our PoYB pals together and book a studio for a day and make a Christmas album. Maybe around our tenth RC holiday album I'll look into it.

Joe K said...

Also, this song sounds distressingly like Van Morrison.

Nate said...

Can we have one blog where you aren't advocating for "chanting and touching?"

Gilson said...

Re: Ketamine, if it's good enough for Aaron Rodgers and Elon Musk, I'm staying away from it.