Wednesday, July 17, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 98: Gilson

Prompt: "A song with a tempo that matches your heartbeat right now"

Selected by Gilson


"Get Right"
Megafaun
Megafaun, 2011

It's not that I'm not an emotional person, because I've always been a rather emotional guy. But I do not project it very much. Even in my drinking and lowest of depression, I was rather adept at keeping those emotions hidden in my public-facing life. 

Now that I've gotten help, begun my recovery journey, and begun taking antidepressants, sometimes I do wonder if maybe I have swung things too far the other way. I still do feel things, but I rationalize very quickly and I just kind of "accept" them and move on. This is the acceptance that recovery programs like AA preach and value, but at some point, I do not know if I am weaponizing acceptance, for lack of a better term. My lack of past mental and physical and spiritual wellbeing in the past has left me with a question I do not feel equipped to answer:

Am I healthy, or am I numb?

3 comments:

Nate said...

Speaking only anecdotally, this seems like a question a lot of people grapple with, especially people who are either in recovery or on anti-depressants, certainly both. I don't know if that's a comfort or not, but I do know this song whips ass.

Joe K said...

There's a conversation recently the in the social work community about the idea of "resilience," and whether this is a good quality to have or an unfair quality to impose on someone. I.e. whether being resilient means that you're strong in the face of arduous circumstances, or if whether it's fair to expect someone to be "resilient" in the face of those circumstances instead of doing our part to make sure those circumstances don't exist. Like how it would be fucked up to say that a young poor single mother is "resilient" because that excuses the fact that we are complicit in ensuring that the cards are stacked against her in poverty in the first place. Something like that, I dunno.

I think the conversation is happening under good intentions but I also don't think that we should kneecap the idea of "resilience" being a good quality to have, especially if the circumstances inflicted are arbitrary, random, something that no one could help, or even the person's own damn fault. You have a life, shitty things are bound to happen to you in that life, and there's no harm in saying that you are good at dealing with the shitty hand you were dealt with resilience.

So maybe it could be that "numb" is a glass-half-empty thing, and instead we should say that those who don't feel as much as other people are just... more resilient. Stronger. And I don't see anything wrong with that.

Gilson said...

I appreciate that I can talk through this here.

I think part of it is that I feel like as a culture we are conditioned to care about a lot of things that don’t affect us (reality tv, social media). And at the risk of sounding self-congratulatory, I think I’ve just stopped caring about things I can’t control or have nothing to do with me.