Monday, July 15, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 96: Maeve

Prompt: "A cover that just hits better than the original"

Selected by Maeve


"Red Red Wine"
UB40
Labour of Love, 1983

Having a crush is the absolute worst. It's distracting, it has you thinking in hypotheticals, and for all intents and purposes, you feel like a child. And friends, I'm back on my bullshit because at minimum once a year I run into this man, and bam!

I feel like it's self-inflicted torture in which I'm playing the lead. I'm engaging in texts and daydreams. I'm a masochist. 

It won't work, I've tried to make it work for thirteen years. I don't know what I could do to change this. This feels like the plot of the worst rom com, where we are the best friends to mutual friends and have been a part of each other's lives for engagements, weddings, and christenings. We see each other multiple times a year and have become so close. There are shared moments, shared secrets, shared jokes. I think I have the bigger stake in this minuscule scenario, but cannot explain how or why. He's a boy (well, a man, but somehow at 34 that still feels cringey to type), but I still think that this knowing of my feelings would be a deep source of embarrassment for me, and probably humiliation for him. Why would he like me? I don't mean this negatively to myself, I'm just being realistic with situations, because as a wise friend once told me when I brought this up ten years ago—"if he wanted to, he would." There has been nothing but opportunity.

As close as we are—last time we hung out, he remembered something I mentioned in passing over five years ago—we are friends. I value my friends. I feel extremely strong that people of the opposite sex can be close friends. But... for about a month or at minimum a week after I see him, every damn time, I do wonder if I'll ever have such strong chemistry with someone? Will I ever feel as comfortable as I do in those moments? Will I ever feel as confident? Will anyone else ever make me feel like I'm the only person in the crowd whose opinion matters? As I go on these endless first and second dates trying to find someone to share my life, I wonder what I've done wrong and how do these dates hold up to this honest friendship and pure attraction? As I keep my secret exchanges so close to the chest, I can't help but wonder what this looks like from the other side. 

But in the end, it's a tale as old as time. If he wanted to, he would. Maybe the honest-to-god answer is just so easily that he's not attracted to me. That's fair! Maybe I'm not skinny enough—which isn't negative self-talk, just maybe the real answer. It feels like it's something tangible I can peg, not because he's said it, but because I need a common thread between all of the girls he's casually dated since I've known him. Maybe I'm too much—too loud and quiet at the same time? Maybe I just haven't figured out that perfect balance that people need from me. I'm thirteen years deep trying to figure out what I am doing that's not working in this situation, but it's annoying. Relationships have come and gone, but this miniscule—yet always prevalent—crush hasn't died, and here I am writing about it (embarrassing). But circling back—oh I'm sorry, am I too fun? Is living in Philly too much of a barrier? Oh, am I simply too close to home, where he doesn't want his friend to be caught in the middle? None of this matters, but it would be nice to know in this limbo as I anxiously await messages and live in a fantasy world where everything said in secret is real. 

But I'm not writing this as a "what's wrong with me?" post. I'm very confident with where I am in my life. I'm confident that these are the hottest years of our lives, I'm confident that I not only love my job, that I am great at it, and I am confident that I am working daily at trying to grow. I know what I want and am normally not afraid to try to make it happen. Therefore, I hate that I so easily fall into this trap whenever I see this man, but it's hard not to. All I can think of is the final scene of Fleabag Season 2 where the priest heartbreakingly says, "It'll pass." It's so poignant, yet accurate. I've thought of that clip so many times since I watched the show, but I've thought of it even more this past week. It's a tough place to be—the same place I was at 21, but with more examples and experience. But I guess that's the point. We only keep the important people around and as they grow, we grow. But ugh, I hate a problem without a solution. The idea of another thirteen years of this game devastates me. And I know this is only rec league, this game is barely real, it's just a waste of time—an activity to keep us both entertained. But what if after all this time, it mattered? Just kidding, it doesn't. I'm romanticizing something that's inconsequential. In the words of Joan Didion, "We tell ourselves stories in order to live." Maybe that is all that this post is. 

I can't wait to make Joe delete this post in two weeks when I talk too much about the Sixers and then become paranoid that I've told him to read my column (it's coming back, I swear!).

4 comments:

Zach said...

Hey thanks for sharing this! This is super vulnerable. As a total outsider with very little skin in the game it's always easier to say what you think. So with that prequel...I wonder if saying something to him, after 13 years, might be worth it? I totally understand why you feel like you wouldn't want to. It feels very risky. But I also wonder if getting an answer in some way, even if it's a 'no' or even if it's something that's triggering, will give you some measure of peace about your relationship with this person. You won't have to wonder for another minute, let alone another 13 years.

Then again, I don't really know anything about your relationship with him or your inner world and I'm just a guy on the Internet writing. All you can do is what feels right for you. But this is just what occurred to me when I read your post.

Joe K said...

Hell yeah, good work Maeve. I will defend this blog post from all requests for its deletion. And I'll agree with a lot of what Zach says above.

I have always and still to this day find the idea of telling a woman how I feel to be fucking TERRIFYING, and could easily imagine just not saying anything at all because I was so scared. "If he wanted to, he would"—not necessarily!

Sara said...

Maeve this was so beautifully written! Just another talent to add to the list. I'm not gonna lie, loving the male perspectives above.

Bridget said...

This was so beautifully and thoughtfully written Maeve... Such a hard thing to write about but I'm really glad you did. Always fun to hear boys thoughts on other boys too. Keep writing more like this!!!