Thursday, July 4, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 90: Joe

Prompt: "A song about American history"

Selected by Joe


"The Battle of Hampton Roads"
Titus Andronicus
The Monitor, 2010

Okay, alright, we're halfway through after today. How goes it, Song Challenge fam? We're down to a dozen regulars, which is still great. I appreciate those of you who have stuck with us. I hope you're having fun! Fun listening! Fun writing! Fun participating in an intense twelve-month blogging project! Fun fun fun!

I am here, on a major holiday, typing about one of my favorite songs from one of my favorite albums. And I suppose the onus is on me to explain why I am here writing about it. Here you go: History tends to repeat itself.

I am using this as my thesis statement so that I can both lean on a single word included in today's prompt and also so that I can explain away any shortcuts that I may be using by choosing this particular song. "Shortcut" because I've previously expressed interest in using YSC to write about music I've never written about before, and avoiding blogging about any subject I've previously blogged about, and, as you may be able to guess, I've written a whole lot about Titus Andronicus and The Monitor already throughout the past fifteen years. It even earned a few stray paragraphs in a previous YSC entry penned by yours truly. And I forgot, I already chose a song from the damn album! Oh no!

You hate to see it, because it's lazy. "Hey, remember when I wrote about this before? Good times." I don't like that and I don't think that's worthy blogging. Personally, I don't like repetition, but sequels are okay. Following up on a previous subject is fine as long as you're adding new depth to the subject, or providing a different perspective, or expressing changes based on new information or maturation of some sort. I don't know if I'll be able to do that here. But I'm going to try.

Something interesting that I will write about is a realization that I had the other day that, presently, on most days, I'd prefer to listen to The Most Lamentable Tragedy over The Monitor. I think that this might be related to a "favorite vs. best" conversation, but I can't decide which is which in this case. The Monitor holds more meaning for me, so I guess that would be the "favorite," and The Most Lamentable Tragedy, I'm starting to see, bests The Monitor musically in many or maybe even most facets. The songwriting is stronger on TMLT even if the overarching conceit is just a hair weaker. There is more filler on TMLT, but the ten best songs beat the ten best Monitor songs in head-to-head matches all the way down. And it's not like that filler doesn't serve a purpose on TMLT; thus, it is tolerable at worst.

If I wrote about this too already then just blame it on history repeating itself: it was extremely sad to hear Patrick Stickles get frustrated at the fact that people by and large valorize The Monitor and just simply really, really like The Most Lamentable Tragedy (at the tenth anniversary tour for The Monitor, no less, though I was drunk as fuck so maybe don't take my inferences as pure uncut truth). I've thought about that a lot in the years since, how frustrating that must have been. TMLT was a very purposeful attempt at besting The Monitor, and Stickles let everyone know it, and the fact that it was very well received but also has nowhere near the critical/nostalgic cache as The Monitor does in certain circles must make TMLT feel to Stickles, on some level, like a failure.

Much like I will probably feel after I'm done writing this blog post, and see that it doesn't come close to feeling as important as some of my writing about The Monitor has felt. History repeats itself.

What I should do—now that I'm here and I'm stuck and I've chained myself to the "history repeats itself" bit and need to thus ride it into the fucking ground—is write once again (but with much more detail and nuance and strong language and a clearer voice, LOL) write about my theory for "The Battle of Hampton Roads." Here we have a fourteen-minute rock opera epic, a long song that never gets boring or quiet, not once. It instead grips you and then escalates, escalates, until we're at the end and the guitar is barreling toward a violent conclusion, a guitar riff ringing out into the night, a sort of noodling that ends each bar with three big hits, each one coming down at the same time as everyone else, most crucially the crash cymbals, over and over the guitar does this, leading to a big finish, and then—then, on the second-to-last hit, the guitar goofs. Kinda does a high-pitched squeal, as if it's too close to the amp or something. On the second-to-last note of this really long fucking and epic song!

My thought has always been that this was done on purpose, or at least left in on purpose, as some sort of full-circling of the theme that has been hammered into us for well over an hour at this point—that we are all flawed, and that our stories are not perfect, and that it is an act of hubris to think that we are flawless protagonists and that everything will always work out well in the end.

I'm wondering now, however, whether this isn't even a fuck-up at all. Like maybe it's just a purposeful and played-correctly note on the guitar, and I just have always imagined it was a fuck-up because I know literally jackshit about guitars. It's possible, and if that's the case, then I'll have to be okay with that. Maybe one of our various guitarists in this space can chime in via blog comments below.

What I do know is that the mystery of it, my own personal mystery, is worth preserving. And I'm glad, in retrospect, that I was too drunk to ask Patrick about it during the one moment our paths physically crossed in our lifetimes, back in 2012. I would hate to hear that I'm wrong, just dead fucking wrong. I think killing the author is a more worthy endeavor for art as rich as this. I have felt deeply about this song and this album for so long that it would be pretty painful to surgically remove the roots of some of those emotions. I think I'll just let the mystery be.

How am I doing so far? Is this blog sufficiently adding to previously established blogging narratives? Or do you find that blogging history is repeating itself? Or is this maybe even the first time you are ever hearing this song? If that's the case, and you like it, well then, boy, do I have a band for you.

Oh shit, okay, there's one thing I should probably lean on here. This is specifically a song "about American history." I didn't choose "The Battle of Hampton Roads" because it's a good song, even though it is; I chose it because it explicitly references a battle during the American Civil War. The Battle of Hampton Roads, taking place on March 8th and 9th in the year 1862 (and, humorously, the album's March 9, 2010 release date was described by Stickles as "our way of celebrating the 148th anniversary of this historic event"). It was notable for being the first battle in world history between two ironclad warships. Almost all the wooden ships involved were destroyed, but once USS Monitor showed up to defend the last U.S. wooden ship, it turned into a stalemate.

I guess that's interesting to consider, though. Yeah, man, here's something new. Never wrote about this shit before!!! A stalemate. You would think that a celebrated battle would involve one side winning over the other side, but no. We are celebrate the advancement of technology, we are celebrating the Monitor showing up in time to defend the other U.S. ships, we are celebrating blocking the Confederacy from advancing... but we aren't celebrating victory. Which is important in the context of this album, since the much ballyhooed premise is that the Civil War is an allegory for the two sides within each of us, fighting it out, the choices we must make in our lives, the good and the bad, the righteous and the ill-intentioned, how no one among us is all of one thing, that we're complicated, complicated like war is complicated, how even though there is clearly a good side and a bad side here (only one side was advocating for the continuation of slavery, after all), that "victory" isn't always necessarily going to look like "good prevailing over evil." Sometimes it's enough to stave off the bad for one more day. Sometimes it's enough to bring the boys back home. Sometimes it's enough to fight for the stalemate.

Choosing another Titus Andronicus song (with more to come!) and writing yet again about this seminal album and even repeating some themes that I've already written about on this very blog might seem like a cop out, and in many respects it is! But that's how it goes with history (and blogging). We are sometimes doomed to repeat ourselves. Maybe sometimes, though, we can learn from what was written before (on the blog; in the history books). Maybe sometimes, we can improve on what we already know, and find new history to explore.

Or maybe it ain't that fucking deep. It's a fucking blog. Who cares. Go watch some fireworks and eat some hot dogs, you jabronis.

1 comment:

Joe K said...

Understandably not much discourse today. I will say that I was impressed how many people got emotional about the ol' USA. Didn't expect that. Happy Fourth everybody!