In the past, I have periodically exploited this blog's active status for posting random criticism outside of Joe's projects. My bandwidth to do so has waxed and waned. But this year, I am back with my personal Top Tens for the past twelve months (well, June to June). The origin story is here. Below this year's picks are the links to the one past year I wrote, as well as the lists for the intervening years.
1. Andor, Season 1 (2022) Disney+
I'm not alone in my appreciation for this Tony Gilmore-helmed Star Wars story. But this venture along with the first few seasons of The Mandolorian have brought me back in the fold for Lucas Ranch. Two things serve both shows well—tertiary connection to the greater Jedi universe and creators being allowed to create. Andor exceeds Mando in that it's more serious, has larger thematic elements, and seems way harder to pull off. More/less the show tackles the little people at the fringe of the rebellion. In a way that is not grating, Gilmore honestly explores how greatness comes to the reluctant when history interferes. Also, that one large event (i.e., blowing up the Death Star) was the culmination of thousands of little rebellions leading up to it. The show also slaps due to the cast—Diego Luna at the helm with Stellan Skarsgård, Fiona Shaw, Eben Moss-Bachrach (from fucking The Bear, wait until next year for that one), and Faye Marsay (aka the Waif in Game of Thrones), among many, many others pinch-hitting on the sidelines. I don't throw around perfect often, but there's like three episodes that would be hard to top. Let's finish Season 2 out strong!
2. Better Call Saul, Season 6 (2022) AMC
The swansong of television's best sequel. Over the years, Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould gradually ramped up intensity and focus in the greater Breaking Bad crime world. It was a delicate balance to make us care about new characters—Nacho, Kim, and Lalo—but say something new and different about Saul/Jimmy, Mike, and Gus. Ultimately, we have a harrowing story about the intersection of love, ambition, and loyalty. All told in excruciating detail with some of the best cinematography around. It's high art to make you root for bad people without exalting or exploiting the bad things they do. This show threads that needle and stuck the landing.
The swansong of television's best sequel. Over the years, Vince Gilligan and Peter Gould gradually ramped up intensity and focus in the greater Breaking Bad crime world. It was a delicate balance to make us care about new characters—Nacho, Kim, and Lalo—but say something new and different about Saul/Jimmy, Mike, and Gus. Ultimately, we have a harrowing story about the intersection of love, ambition, and loyalty. All told in excruciating detail with some of the best cinematography around. It's high art to make you root for bad people without exalting or exploiting the bad things they do. This show threads that needle and stuck the landing.
3. Squid Game, Season 1 (2021) Netflix
A little late to the party on this one, but it was worth the wait! One of the most original shows I've seen in some time, and it's nice that there's no pre-existing IP. South Korea is one of my favorite nations for original TV and movies. Of the content that reaches our shores, there's generally a class struggle at the center. If you're going to combine a fucked up concept with stellar production design and Lost-esque back stories, I'm fine eating up whatever larger themes exist. But it's nice when all the gore and games also excellently work on different levels. It's hard to imagine the first season here will be topped, but I am willing to be persuaded.
4. The North Water, Limited Series (2021) AMC+
Sometimes I'm such a sucker for recommendations from Chris Ryan and Andy Greenwald of The Watch podcast. Maybe it's their Philadelphia roots, Slate magazine pedigree, or penchant for gritty crime dramas, but I take very seriously a favorable rating from these two (they also properly gave Andor all the laurels). That resulted in me signing up for an AMC+ trial and devouring this masterful North Atlantic mariner show set in the 1800s. Like another past favorite, The Terror, this show depicts man at his most basic surviving the elements and nature's greatest beast, man himself. And Colin Farrell stars as essentially the devil incarnate in this five-part miniseries. Get ready for some gnarly harpooning and laudanum-trip scenes if you cue this up.
5. Severance, Season 1 (2022) Apple TV+
If there's a quirky sci-fi plot with stellar production design and a killer cast, I'm the fuck on board. This Adam Scott led joint establishes simple rules, gives the characters mysterious justifications for opting in, and slowly rolls out some twists and turns. Again, what a cast: Patricia Arquette, John Turturro, Christopher Walken, and, my favorite, Michael Chernus (aka Cool Rick from Patriot). Ben Stiller keeps showing off these different sides to what used to be a pretty one-note performer, too.
6. The Bureau, Season 2 (2016) Vudu
7. Succession, Season 4 (2023) HBO
I never got into horse-race aspect of Jesse Armstrong's satirical drama of the Roy family. It didn't matter to me who won, nor did I think that was the point of the show. Armstrong artfully depicts the vapid cut-throat culture of the American media/corporate landscape while taking down the characters each trying to fill the hole in their lives. But I was tickled of the outcome. The last season had a bit too much Alexander Skarsgård for my taste, but there's enough crabs-in-barrel drama to hold me over. The best decision was to end it now, rather than forcing us to watch Kendall fade into oblivion. I could go for a Greg-Tom spinoff though!
8. Reservation Dogs, Season 1 (2021) FX/Hulu
Sterlin Harjo and Taika Waititi do what great story-tellers should—transport the audience to a place it didn't otherwise know and challenge notions about these places and people. The magical realism and fucking devastating poignancy exhibited by the young cast in this dram-com exceeds many other stories I encountered in the last year. It's brilliant in that universal themes (yearning for something better) on display here can both criticize and romanticize rez life. Plus, it's funny as hell.
9. Our Flag Means Death, Season 1 (2022) HBO Max
Another Taika joint, though this one far sillier. Rhys Darby, of Flight of the Conchords fame, stars as "The Gentleman Pirate," as we have a period swashbuckling affair. Taika himself plays the reoccurring Blackbeard and much shenanigans ensues. This show appearing high on my list largely centers on how much it made my wife laugh out loud. And as the saying goes, it feels good to laugh.
10. Barry, Season 3 (2022) HBO
I just missed including the final season on this list. Although Season 3 doesn't hit the depth or nuance that the finale reaches, the early season hitman hijinks all but fade away here. Barry himself has to live with his consequences, as do Gene, Sally, and NoHo Hank. The last season puts a great bow on it, but you don't get there without this one.
The Rest (ordered by preference):
The Larry Sanders Show, S.1, Max (the rebrand!)
Abbott Elementary, S.1, Hulu
The Americans, S.5, Prime
Halt and Catch Fire, S.2, AMC+
The Crown, S.5, Netflix
The Rehearsal, S.1, HBO
Only Murders in the Building, S.1, Hulu
Curb Your Enthusiasm, S.8, HBO
White Lotus, S.2, HBO
Station Eleven, Limited, HBO Max
Pachinko, S.1, Apple TV+
The State, S.1, Paramount+
The State, S.2, Paramount+
Big Mouth, S.6, Netflix
Rick and Morty, S.5, HBO Max
Winning Time, S.1, HBO Max
Call My Agent, S.3, Netflix
Billions, S.6, Showtime
House of the Dragon, S.1, HBO
Atlanta, S.3, Hulu
Archives
2021-22
- Patriot, S.2, Prime
- Mare of Easttown, S.1, HBO Max
- Unbelievable, S.1, Netflix
- White Lotus, S.1, HBO
- Better Call Saul, S.5, F2Movies
- The Other Two, S.2, HBO Max
- Call My Agent, S.1-2, Netflix
- The Bureau, S.1, F2Movies
- Righteous Gemstones, S.2, HBO
- I May Destroy You, S.1, HBO Max
The rest: How to with John Wilson, S.1, HBO Max; Detroiters, S.1, Paramount+; I Think You Should Leave, S.2, Netflix; Ted Lasso, S.2, AppleTV+; Documentary Now, S.1, Netflix; Central Park, S.1, Apple TV+; South Side, S.1, HBO Max; Aunty Donna's Big Ol' House of Fun, S.1, Netflix; Dave, S.2, Hulu/FX; Bo-Jack Horseman, S.4, Netfix; The Mandalorian, S.2, Disney+; Gomorrah, S.1, HBO Max; Schmigadoon!, S.1, F2Movies; Stath Lets Flats, S.1, HBO Max; Billions, S.5, Showtime; Big Mouth, S.5, Netflix; The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, S.4, Prime; One Mississippi, S.1, Prime; Insecure, S.4. HBO; Black Monday, S.2, Showtime; Mrs. Fletcher, S.1, HBO Max; Dark, S.3, Netflix; Babylon Berlin, S.3, Netflix; Arrested Development, S.5, Netflix
2020-21
- Mr. Robot (S.4) USA
- Patriot (S.1) Prime Video
- Lodge 49 (S.2) Hulu
- The Mandalorian (S.1) Disney+
- Review (S.1) F2Movies
- Halt and Catch Fire (S.1) Netflix
- Russian Doll (S.1) Netflix
- DEVS (Limited) Hulu
- Dave (S.1) FXX
- Counterpart (S.2) Prime Video
The rest: The Crown (S.4) Netflix; Mindhunter (S.2) Netflix; Mrs. America (Limited) Hulu; Sex Education (S.1) Netflix; Curb Your Enthusiasm (S.7) HBO; One Day at a Time (S.3) Netflix; The Queen's Gambit (limited) Netflix; Killing Eve (S.3) Hulu; Pen-15 (S.2) Hulu; Big Mouth (S.4) Netflix; Bojack Horseman (S.3) Netflix; Undone (S.1) Prime Video; Philly DA (limited) PBS; Rick and Morty (S.4) Cartoon Network;
Silicon Valley (S.5) HBO; Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt (S.4) Netflix
Honorable mention for shows I binged with Hannah during COVID: Billions (S.1-6) Showtime; Search Party (S.3-4) HBOMax; What We Do in the Shadows (S.1-2) Hulu





No comments:
Post a Comment