Thursday, June 26, 2025

Never Seen It #227: Magic Mike

You are the husband they never had! You are that dreamboat guy that never came along! You are the blogger watching 400 movies you've never seen before!


Magic Mike
2012
Steven Soderbergh

Zoom: June 24, 2025, 9 PM to 10 PM

Participants: Allison, Brianna, Gloria, Joe, Kait, Sean E., Sunny, Walter

I did an awful job at taking notes during our discussion. But every once in a while I remembered to write something down. Then I fell asleep, so I probably forgot some points of our conversation. Drop a comment if I missed something, or if you have anything else to add!
  • Phrase of the night was "hustler culture." More or less defined as needing to work hard on multiple jobs to make a living. Working hard as a way to achieve the American Dream. And maybe this film exposing the fact that the American Dream is unobtainable within this framework.
  • Discussion about the difference between male strip clubs and female strip clubs, how the latter is more "pornographic" and the former tends to be more of a cabaret-style show.
  • Was their chemistry between Mike and Brooke? Is Cody Horn a good actor, or a product of nepotism?
  • What if the lack of chemistry was on purpose? That Magic Mike felt like himself onstage and lost that "magic" offstage and so the lack of magic in his romantic relationship was indicative of his confusion in life?
  • Good discussion about the tragic nature of being good at something that doesn't give you fulfillment. Important counterpoint being that maybe you can give TOO MUCH of yourself in your art and that can wear you down.
  • Channing Tatum was in Ricky Martin's "She Bangs."
  • A top google result is "am I gay if i watch magic mike." This movie performed better in red states than blue. Most importantly, this movie was a minor "cultural phenomenon" in that groups of (straight) women made it a point to go to the theater to see this movie.
  • Was the Kid's acting bad? Why was he nineteen? Did the actor look nineteen??
  • Was Riley Keough's Nora a figment of the Kid's imagination? (Also: my in-laws think that Elvis Presley is a non-fictional person.)
  • The ending was open-ended. Was that frustrating, or poignant, or neither?
I started the conversation by asking: what do you want to talk about in a typical Film Club discussion? Magic Mike felt like a good movie to ask that question of, because you could go in two different directions with it. First, what happened, and what do we like and dislike about what happened? Second, what did it mean, and what does what it mean mean to you? I think we covered both pretty well in our hourlong conversation, and I was happy about that. But I'm down to talk about whatever. Like if either side of the discussion feels more meaningful, we can lean into it.

Something I haven't asked during the Zoom meetings, and probably won't because it's not riveting discussion, but still important probably, is: what would you grade this film? That seems like something for the comment section. I'd give it a 3.5 pukes out of 5. The craft was great, the stakes were hit-or-miss. It was refreshing to just have a movie like this hang out with the characters instead of manufacture drama, but maybe that means there wasn't as much to hang onto as their might be other, deeper films. I really enjoyed it though.

Thanks for hanging out on a Tuesday night. See you in the comments.

(NEXT TIME: Finding a way to speak your truth again through the art, but this time with a piano in The Piano.)

11 comments:

Zach said...

One of these days I hope to join a Zoom. A few thoughts on my end:

- I thought a lot about the "female gaze" while watching this. The movie seemed to show all the women at the show reacting pretty much exactly the same, all the time, except for Brooke during that one scene. Is that fair? Should there have been more nuance in how it showed the women reacting to the strippers? Or was that not the point of the movie - was the point to focus on the characters themselves, and on Brooke, and so on?
- I think Cody Horn is a fine actor. I had no problem with the chemistry between the two.
- The ending was a little abrupt and a little too clean. I wish it had been a less-satisfying final scene. It wasn't a complete happy ending, but it was somewhat close.
- Tampa itself felt like a character in the movie. I loved the scenery, the shots, the beautiful rivers and the general shittiness of strip mall-like architecture as well.
- Mike lives in an amazing house! How did he get the money for that?
- When Mike asks the Kid to go talk to the two women in the bar, and the Kid asks him what to say, and he says "I don't know...be creative!" Some things come effortlessly to Mike, like talking to women, and many men might look up to him for that. Important to remember that Mike is probably looking up to people who are more 'successful' economically and wishing he could be like them, too. He doesn't have it all. But he does have 'game,' as defined by traditional standards of 'game' and by the movie itself.

Joe K said...

@Zach - Blogger at it again, marking innocent commens as spam. I got it out of the spam folder for ya. I will join this discussion in a moment.

Zach said...

Thanks Joe! Also for me it's 4/5 mostly because I thoroughly enjoyed myself the whole time I was watching this movie.

Joe K said...

That last point is a great one that could've gotten some mileage in the discussion. Isn't it interesting that the Kid is told to be creative, and his act of creativity is being violent toward a stranger?

Joe K said...

I will also admit here that I don't really have a good grasp of what "male gaze" and "female gaze" means. It's been used on this blog before by other people, and I've looked it up multiple times, but I feel like my mind glazes over whenever I think about it.

That aside, I think the point about the monolith of the female audience is a great point. Would the film have been improved if we got to know the audience members? Are there really people who would pay money to see a male strip show and spend their time critiquing the art? Is there a whole movie that follows women as they go about their lives and patronize male strip shows at night?

Sam Fran said...

Very sad I missed the conversation due to oversight/sleepiness. I really liked it! Mostly impressed with Tatum, McCaughney, and Soderbergh. God, Steven S. is just so good at cranking out anything across all genres. I wish he made a few less movies and few more excellent ones. But you can't argue that the floor is so high when he's invovled.

The brother and sister were two of the worst actors and characters I've ever come across. They arguably created all the problems in his life and he would have been better off having never met them. He is much farther away from achieving his American dream at the end of the film than at the beginning.

Maeve said...

I couldn't make it to the zoom, but did anyone point out how Magic Mike XXL is the far superior film? Donald Glover is great in it, Joe Manganiello's gas station dance is iconic and Andie McDowell shows up??

Joe K said...

Love the hyperbole of "worst acting of all time."

I made up this theory during the Zoom and have convinced myself since then that it's true. That the acting / lack of chemistry is purposeful. Magic Mike tragically finds himself on stage. Off the stage, nothing seems quite right. Including the people off stage. Same with yellow camera lens in Tampa, but full bright colors on stage.

Joe K said...

I have certifiably Never Seen It™ for the sequels. I didn't get the sense that to many people on the Zoom had seen them either. I will take your word on it, and will say that I definitely liked this film enough that I'd love to watch the sequels one day.

Gloria said...

The house came up in our discussion as well and my thought was that 1. It’s a movie, but 2. He’s a contractor. He could have inherited or bought a shitty house that needed work and did 100% of the work on it himself.

This came out was when my older sister was buying a home. There was some kind of program that she qualified for and was able to put a $500 deposit only down for her house. That was in Reading, PA, but still the housing market in 2012 was way different then vs when we bought our home in 2022 and were constantly being outbid

Joe K said...

I appreciate this take, Gloria. Feels like a reasonable explanation.

It makes me zoom out a little bit and think about the act of trying to explain stuff in movies for yourself. Like if there's something in a movie that doesn't seem quite "right," maybe it feels better to attempt to explain it for the movie instead of assuming it makes the movie worse or more poorly made.

So instead of saying "is Magic Mike seriously trying to tell us that Mike lives in this huge mansion?" we can say "it could be reasonable that he would live here because..."

Instead of saying "this actor does not look 19," you say "the film is trying to make a statement about the maturity or lack thereof of this character."

I get why it's fun to point out flaws in a movie. I just think it feels more fun to enjoy a movie and have fun attempting to explain away its so-called flaws.