Wednesday, June 18, 2025

A Year of Blind Spots: Temple of the Dog

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


Temple of the Dog
Temple of the Dog
1991

It's not often that we get to have a sequel in this blog column. The (nebulous, frequently changing) point of A Year of Blind Spots is to discover something new that I wasn't already familiar with. That's tough to do if you're listening to a follow-up for another new (to you) album or whatever. But the game was rigged here. I knew in advance that two separate entities were intimately entangled, and I knew that eventually we'd get to both artists, so I coyly commented at the end of the aYoBS entry for Mother Love Bone's Apple that "I also probably should listen to Temple of the Dog at some point." A little over a year later, here we are.

A point of clarification is needed, I think, on the timeline. In case you missed the explanation last time, I'll start from the beginning (of my story re: Temple of the Dog, not of Temple of the Dog's story). I, like many of my peers who grew up passively listening to alt-rock radio stations in the 1990s, assumed that the song "Hunger Strike," with one half of the lead vocals clearly being performed by Eddie Vedder (the voice is unmistakable), was performed by Pearl Jam. I was eventually clued into the fact that the listed artist was actually Temple of the Dog. It took a while longer to figure out the why, i.e. why Eddie Vedder was also singing a song for another band that wasn't Pearl Jam. 

Okay, and you learned last time that there was a Seattle band called Mother Love Bone, and that they, in their short time in existence, brought with them a harbinger of grunge music to come. Sadly, their enigmatic 24-year-old singer Andrew Wood OD'd on heroin days after Apple dropped, and Mother Love Bone was no more. Everyone was sad, including Chris Cornell, frontman of another proto-grunge band, Soundgarden. That band wouldn't reach its commercial peak for another couple years, but it was picking up steam. Wood and Cornell had been friends and roommates, and Cornell decided to write some music in Wood's honor. This led to studio time.

Here's where I screwed it up last time. Because I had assumed, even after listening to and writing about Apple, that the sequence of events was: 1) Wood dies, MLB disbands; 2) Cornell forms Temple of the Dog, invites former MLB members to record as part of the band; 3) then-unknown Eddie Vedder coincidentally joins in on vocals for "Hunger Strike"; 4) those former MLB members, after recording with Temple of the Dog, decide to form another band, and tap Vedder to be their lead singer based on his performance on "Hunger Strike."

But I'm getting the sense that it didn't actually work that way. That's too neat of a timeline. What actually happened (probably) was that the guys from MLB (Stone Gossard and Jeff Ament) were looking to start a band, were hooked up with Vedder, and then Vedder got the TotD gig because he happened to be joining a band with guys who also happened to, at the very same time, already be recording some songs with Chris Cornell. Pearl Jam had already formed (originally under the name Mookie Blaylock), and Temple of the Dog was always a side project.

That didn't stop people from retroactively branding Temple of the Dog as a "supergroup," even though "Hunger Strike" didn't blow up on MTV and in the pop culture consciousness until grunge exploded, until Pearl Jam led that charge, until Soundgarden surfed that wave. And why not? Wasn't it kismet that two of the biggest voices in the ascendent new genre known post-Nevermind as grunge were already, at the time of the Big Bang, involved in a single project, a hit song and a video and everything? It makes sense that "Hunger Strike" was retroactively added to the grunge canon.

And it makes sense from a musical standpoint, I guess is what I'm saying. All the symptoms of the genre are totally present here—the cocktail of metal riffage and punk sensibilities, the sludgy guitars and gruff, passionate, working-class vocals, the loud/soft dynamic. Take the vocals out of "Hunger Strike" and you still might confuse it for Pearl Jam.

The album is more than its most famous song. It does peak with it, and being the third song on the album, that means that there is a gradually fall toward the back half. But those first three songs, goddamn. First, it's "Say Hello 2 Heaven," a soaring GnR-sounding tune. Then it's my personal favorite, "Reach Down," a ten-minute epic that basically writes the book on grunge and could've ended the whole fucking scene if it wanted to (it didn't). These two songs are by far the best non-"Hunger Strike" songs on the album. So it makes sense to learn later that these were the first two songs that Cornell wrote for Andrew Wood. Originally, TotD was going to just record those two songs. The chemistry was there and they put in the work to fill out the album, and there are definitely some hidden gems in the back half (I'm fond of the histrionics and the random-ass harmonica on "Times of Trouble"). But it makes sense that those first two songs had the longest gestation period, and were written from the purest place of the heart.

I don't really know if there's anything else to say here. You know the rest of the story. You know where Pearl Jam and Soundgarden fit into this. You even know the unfortunate epilogue for Temple of the Dog that occurred in 2016, when Chris Cornell closed the cycle with Andrew Wood and took his own life. Music tells a story. This is part of it. I don't mind if the sole purpose of listening to an otherwise very good album is to fill in a gap of that story. I appreciated that, and I appreciated listening to some of the purest grunge shit I've ever heard. 

2 comments:

Gilson said...

I would be remiss if I didn’t comment on this but listen to Pearl Jam’s Footsteps after listening to Times of Trouble, it was included as a b-side to Jeremy but didn’t make Ten.

Joe K said...

We can agree that it would've been weird if you hadn't commented on this post.