Friday, June 27, 2025

For Melancholy Brunettes (& sad women), Joe


This is Joe K***, roving reporter for the newest addition of the McD***** Family Newsletter, Vol. XL, Issue 14. I am reporting from a rental home in Selbeyville, DE. My assignment was to tell you about Japanese Breakfast's new album. I am not currently listening to the album. I usually do when I'm typing these reports, but I'm not this time. The sounds that I am currently hearing are two different TVs, overlapping in sound significantly, as one is in the living room and one is in the upstairs loft, and the TV on the upstairs loft has its sound source facing over the balcony into the living room. It's pretty disorienting. The upstairs TV features what sounds to me like Steve Zahn, but is actually some younger, wide-mouthed, broccoli-haired motherfucker who is telling my daughters and niece about, I dunno, building a roller coaster in his backyard or some shit. This is absolutely the bullshit that wouldn't fly if we were at home, but I have less control of the TV when we're on vacation. I'm a strict dad but have less agency to be a strict uncle, if that makes sense.

The living room TV, of course, featured A Minecraft Movie.

I can report that, before we left, Pam said something to me to the effect of "You don't have any albums you have to listen to this week, do you?" She asked it because she wanted to make sure we were going to be listening to calming, faux-French croissants-and-accordions music during breakfast and not whatever fifth-wave emo bullshit that I usually play at a reasonable volume in our kitchen at home. Still a pretty crazy question. Um, of fucking course I have fucking albums I have to fucking listen to? Have you visited the blog lately, dear love of my life?!

It worked out pretty well that the RC album scheduled for this vacation week was an album that I was already familiar with (jk totes did this on purpose). J-Brekkie is my girl. I love this shit. It's not even just "have to listen to it," it's "very much want to listen to it." And I don't think it's a tall order to want to listen to these particular sounds in a small-group familial setting. This isn't fucking Mindfuck Ultra. It's pleasant. It's catchy. It's calm. It has Jeff Bridges.

But that's all hypothetical. I pretty rarely choose the music when we're on a family vacation. It's not that other people are choosing other music that competes with mine. It's more that I am constantly faced with the reality that I am a fucking freak because I need to listen to music all the time, and no one else seems to be that way. And I'm usually at home living with four people who more or less put up with the way that I am, and the harsh reality only seems harsh when I'm living with ten other people and some are less willing to put up with me than others. 

It's not even that anyone is like "oh yuk, what is this music?" or "why the fuck are we listening to Jeff Bridges?" or anything like that. It's actually like: [nothing]. No reaction. Music might as well be the fucking beach-themed wallpaper. I'd rather someone feel something about this shit, then to feel so much and to be met with so little. It's weeks like this that make me appreciate what it is we are trying to do with Record Club—I'm trying to game the system, trying to surround myself (digitally) with people who actually act like they care, trying to not feel so alone in this world.

I wonder if I'm feeling a little low because For Melancholy Brunettes (& sad women) is designed to make you a little sad. It's right there in the title, and I am a brunette. "Can you see a life where we leave this behind?" That's the money line in the opening song, "Here Is Someone." A lot of the reviews I saw back in the spring quoted it, but most saw the context as "Michelle Zauner is a best-selling author now, she is contemplating 'leaving this behind' because maybe she doesn't need Japanese Breakfast anymore." That's a limiting perspective. To me, it feels bigger than that. She's contemplating the idea of the escape. How sometimes this life is too much, how maybe it would just be easier if you ran away, and how, ultimately, it's a pipe dream, you'll never actually leave, but the hypothetical prospect of it can still bring some comfort even if it never actually comes true.

I was chilling Tuesday morning with my father-in-law. "With" more like "sitting at the same dining room table on our respective laptops, occasionally making small talk." Something he told me while we were sitting there was that Mick Ralph died. I didn't know who that was, so I googled it, and found out that his name is actually Mick Ralphs, with an S at the end, and that he was a member of Bad Company and Mott the Hoople. I said I liked Mott the Hoople but was never a fan of Bad Company. The response was "well they were before your time." We've been over this countless times. That is not how I operate. There is no "before my time." Music exists as a living document and I try to explore and get to know as much as I can, the year it was released being the least important thing about it. I dislike "Bad Company" and I would've disliked Bad Company if it had come out in 1984, 2004, or 2024. I said something to this effect. I also said that there was a whole class of B-level classic rock that I've always felt an aversion to. I named Kansas and Styx as other examples. I could have kept going, but my father-in-law was back into his laptop, tracking his fantasy baseball league stats, and I receive no response to any of my musings about music.

But maybe he's onto something. He doesn't know me at all, knows nothing about how I operate as a human being, but maybe his original statement accidentally contained a nugget of hitherto unexamined truth. Maybe it's not that there might be a band that is "before my time," because there isn't. Maybe it's that there are certain artists who are definitively "of my time." Of my time, space, preference, personality, emotion, mindset, all of the above. That there's value in some music feeling like it's mine, all mine. I can listen to Bad Company and maybe even learn to love it, but Mick Ralphs is dead and I'll never make Bad Company mine. That opportunity is out of reach. But it's not with Japanese Breakfast. I've been here from the beginning. I've grown with this artist. I understand the language. I feel at peace when I hear this album.

I don't think that this is J-Brekkie's best album, but I think there are so many little moments scattered throughout that feel utterly sublime and touching in a deep and almost unknowable way that I can say that it's a clear success. The songs that don't have such a moment aren't bad, they are just forgettable. Think "Leda" or "Magic Mountain." The songs that feature such a moment aren't even necessarily perfect songs, but the small moments that stand out have been stuck in my head for seemingly a lifetime at this point, and aren't leaving anytime soon. Think the tossed-off "...isolation" in "Little Girl." Think the rising action of "all of my ghosts" in "Picture Window." Think the way that Zauner stretches out "California days" on "Winter in LA." Think the strings and flutes on "Here Is Someone." Think of the entirety of "Men in Bars."

This week has convinced me that "Men in Bars" is the song of the year so far, or at the very least the song of my summer. I don't know what it is about it. The notes and chords and lyrics and inflections, everything about it, it's all sunk deeply into my soul at this point. I almost wish Bridges wasn't the guy singing on it, because his celebrity is distracting, but I cannot deny that he matches Zauner in terms of wringing pathos out of his words. I still don't really know what they are talking about, and when I hear it in my head, I just kind of make up words. I'd look up the lyrics if I needed to, but I don't. It's on a different level than that for me.

Alright, alright... I should look it up. If I'm making a big deal about how I feel like no one on family vacation gives a shit about this kind of thing, then I should push against it and actually do the work. Plus, I don't want two weeks in a row of my RC review being like "this is how I feel and I don't know why, lol!"

Why does "Men in Bars" touch me so? The lyrics are a bit obtuse, but if I'm projecting, then theory #1 probably has to do with the idea of building the persona of a Man in a Bar in a previous life and "when it breaks apart" speaking to my personal experience. The sadness is welling up from within, and I can feel it even if I couldn't name it. Theory #2 it's about love gone wrong, and while the topic is cliché and not necessarily personally relatable at this juncture, it's just that J-Brekkie is just so fucking good at her craft, and she makes an otherwise rote subject fucking sing. The final theory, #3, is that it's hitting good because I recognized it, even if I didn't realize that I recognized it. Zauner did a quick one-off side project with the dude from Crying during the pandemic, and the final song on pop songs 2020 EP is called "Ballad 0," and it's a primitive, non-duet version of this song. 

I think when I say that an artist is "of my time," that this is what I'm talking about. That there are certain artists who are releasing music currently that somehow have this way of speaking to me and touching me somewhere very deep. Japanese Breakfast is one of them. I don't think I can explain it to anyone. I get the sense that Zauner doesn't even realize she's doing it (her own explanation of what "Men in Bars" is about is extremely surface-level). I certainly can't explain it sitting at this dining room table in this vacation rental home. The most I can say to anyone here is "these are sounds and they are arranged in a particular way and when they are arranged in this way we call it music." Anything beyond that and I might as well be speaking in tongues.

This is probably why I get so annoyed when any (or, more likely, all) of the five kids in this house currently completely ignore me when I give direction and attempt to make sure that they are safe, e.g. don't go near the bay with your scooter and throw heavy rocks in it because you might fall in?! You ever talk to someone and you can tell they aren't listening, and worse, they don't care enough about you to give a shit to even pretend? I'm not saying that's what the kids are doing. They are just being kids, testing limits. But I'm telling you that I in general have a rough time with not being heard. I spend so much of my goddamn time listening. I sit here and I listen to all kinds of bullshit. And I listen to the good stuff too. The art. Something like For Melancholy Brunettes (& sad women). I listen to it deeply and carefully. I am fully entranced. How do I get to be like that for other people? Maybe it'll never happen.

Or maybe it's happening now, if you are reading this news update for the McD***** Family Newsletter, Vol. XL, Issue 14. Thanks for listening to me. Hear me when I tell you that this is a good album.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments: