I thought it would be funny if we featured an Old Thug as the picture for today's discussion. Let's discuss how maybe it's not okay for me to even use the word "thug," since that seems to be a dogwhistle used by conservatives who
really want to use the N-word. Let's also discuss the album
Punk by Young Thug, and the reviews published today. Whatchya think????
15 comments:
I'm kinda surprised that no one defended this one! I mean, it wasn't going to be me, because this isn't my shit, but I thought for sure that someone "in the know" was gonna pop in here and say "no, you're wrong, this is really good." Ten reviewers can't be wrong, though, apparently. (Our youngest blogger, Galia, was supposed to write this week, and I know for sure we would've gotten a positive Punk review out of her. Maybe next time.)
Some stuff I'm glad people pointed out: that sad first song; the RICO trials; the fact that this album is not "punk" in the musical sense
Apparently a new Young Thug album is imminent? Let's meet back in this space to discuss it when it drops.
What's good this weekend? We're going to the LEHIGH VALLEY IRON PIGS game tomorrow night. I've never been.
Oilers tied it up. 2-2.
Oilers.
Oilers!
OILERS!!!!
OOOOOOIIIIILLLLEEEEERRRRRRS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Oilers.
I think I'd prefer if we supported sustainable energy here on the Puke on Your Birthday blog. Maybe if the hockey team wanted to change their name to the Edmonton Solar Panels, or the Edmonton Hydroelectric.
Would this have been more interesting if it was cut down? The first song held promise, but the rest just straight up wasn’t for me and it seemed to drag on and on
Really interesting to hear about how album length can skew streaming metrics/ chart rating. I wondered how much of this album was influenced by the idea of manipulating algorithms vs making art?
It’s Zach. The side benefit of Iranian drones: I was up at 4am to watch from the end of the second period onward. And what a game. What a series.
It will go seven games. It will go into OT. And our young son Connor McDavid will pass to German son Leon Draisaitl, who will deposit the puck in the net. You heard it here first.
The world must appreciate how good this series is.
I’m glad im not the only one who disliked this record
IronPigs games kick ass. There's a full playground in the stadium for when your kids inevitably get bored.
@Zach - Still open to the idea of someone writing a blog post about it. I promise I will read it and respond. That's gonna be my only place my life intersects with the Oilers, I fear.
@Pat - This is good to know. They will absolutely get bored. I think that's why we switched the annual K*** family outing to the minor leagues this year. Boredom is incredibly expensive at Citizens Bank Park.
This is probably the most important takeaway from this album, so thanks for reiterating it after Tom's review. I hate it because it puts the focus on playlists more than albums as art, and that is antithetical to what we try to do here in Record Club. But that's what a lot of musicians are doing these days, looking at their albums like playlists. Streaming is a pox on all our lives.
Like, my first thought after reading your comment was "I wonder if Young Thug's music would work better as a Greatest Hits compilation." But that's kinda the same thing. There were a couple good songs here. You're right, a 30-minute banger would have been well-reviewed, I think.
What's really exciting re: the Oilers game is not that they tied the series, not that they won from a 0-3 deficit score in OT, not that they won with that Draisatl shot that was such a wild hail mary one-handed "okay let's just push the puck in the direction of the net"....but it's in fact that I finally followed Stuart Skinner on instagram. What a long time coming. Granted, he did need to be taken out of the game pretty early on, but the Oilers aren't afraid of switching it up!
Check out the beautiful goalie hug between Skinner and Picard postgame. That’s true love.
@Maeve — I follow a music critic named Miranda Reinert who used to live in Philly and she's in her 20s and she's a really good writer. Back when Twitter was a thing, I followed her on Twitter too, to get some good emo music takes. One day she was like "I think I'm going to start following hockey," and so she picked a team and followed them intensely and is now a big hockey fan I guess. I am still subscribed to her Substack, and I like reading her stuff, whether it's about music or about hockey, even though I only actually care about one of those things.
All this to say that you should start writing about sports for Puke on Your Birthday. I know that it was specifically Sixers in the past, but maybe if you broadened it up to "sports that Maeve is watching right now," it might make it easier for you. Literally the only way to get me to care about some hockey bro's instagram account would be if Maeve D. wrote a blog post about it.
Post a Comment