Monday, June 16, 2025

Monday Morning Mixtape 024: As a Bisexual, Am I Only Allowed to Celebrate Half of Pride Month?

Welcome to Monday Morning Mixtape, a PoYB Contributor-curated playlist of songs, made just for you at the start of each week.


"As a Bisexual, Am I Only Allowed to Celebrate Half of Pride Month?"
Joyful songs by queer artists
chosen by Gloria








"I Want You (Fever)" by Momma
from Welcome to My Blue Sky, 2025

Through this prompt, I discovered the website them, which calls itself "the best of what's queer." Spotify played me a song by Momma last week. The two sides met in a perfect harmony. This song is one to play at night when you are driving fast through the suburbs.

Has it ever happened to you that something so significant or usual or traumatic happens in your life that you can't help but have it creep into every single element of your writing? I feel a wave washing over me, but I don't want to write about it. I want to write about the light things of life. And then I think I'm going to give in and write about it anyways. Is it performative? Is it "woe is me?" Is it some kind of messed up way of showing off? Do I actually really want to write about it? I don't know. The human brain doesn't make sense. But I'm tired, and I worked from home today, and I'm going to work from home tomorrow, too, and my phone is always charging. None of them standard operating procedure.  —Zach


"Boy's a Liar Pt. 2" by PinkPantheress ft. Ice Spice
from Heaven Knows, 2023

I don't think it's wrong to google someone's sexual preferences, but it still feels wrong. I guess I knew Ice Spice was bi for some reason (it quite possibly might be the ONLY thing I know about Ice Spice), but I didn't want to choose a song about shitting or farting for this mixtape (not joyous enough), so I went with this (fucking great) song by RC alumna PinkPantheress. Which meant that I had to google what her sexual orientation is. There were no clear answers, which made me feel worse. Like I was intruding or something, I don't know. I would really only need to know if she likes boys or girls or both or neither or somewhere on the spectrum in between if I was a potential sexual partner of PinkPantheress, of which I am (probably) not. So it's none of my business. Except for the mixtape. She's probably bisexual, which makes it a good pick for the mixtape, in my opinion (other opinions may vary). It made me think about why this is something that we as fans typically feel like we need to know, or even deserve to know (for the parasocially desperate among us). Yes, you're expected to leverage your personal life to sell records, and many celeb artists gleefully do this (noT nAming anY names, aLthOugh i ceRtainly could). But it shouldn't be a requirement. I shouldn't need to know anything about PinkPantheress beyond the good music that she's making (and probably that she, I dunno, didn't vote for trump???). (1/2)  —Joe


"Wrestlemania VIII" by Martha
from Love Keeps Kicking, 2019

If one of my kids—Martha or otherwise—came out as gay, or non-binary, or trans, or whatever, anything, then I have confidence that I'd be able to handle it appropriately. There are so many aspects to parenting that I'm bad at, but I feel pretty decent at being able to establish open communication and total support. It's called unconditional love, yo. There are no conditions. They don't have to prove anything or do anything for me to "earn" my love. It's just there. I don't know what else to do. Maybe I need to do more. Maybe I'm a failure in countless ways. But this seems to be a good guiding light, this idea of unconditional love, and I'm gonna follow it.  —Joe


"THATS WHAT I WANT" by Lil Nas X
from MONTERO, 2021

(2/2) Which reminds me that I recently read an article about Doja Cat (who features in another Lil Nas X song, not this one, but again, I'm going for "joyous," and this is my favorite non-"Old Town Road" Lil Nas X song... also, when I googled PinkPantheress' sexuality, there were a few hits about she and Lil Nas X being in a "fake" relationship, as some sort of bit... it all connects, here in the blurbs, and the parentheticals to those blurbs) in which she accepted some branded T-shirt from some social media influencer, and but later went on her own social media and basically was like, hey, fuck that guy for putting me in that position, I don't know him and I don't need him touching me out in public like that. Pretty fair! For all her many, many, many faults, Doja Cat seems to be the most reasonable when it comes to striking down parasocial relationships. Me and Doja, of the same mind in this very specific subject—that shit is creepy! You don't know your favorite artists, so leave 'em the fuck alone, even if you're sitting next to them at the bar. Probably what complicated things in this particular Doja Cat incident was that the shirt was a Pride shirt, and the guy went on his Insta or whatever and said something along the lines of, I feel embarrassed, I'm gay and happy and this wasn't the reaction that I expected. But see, that makes the whole thing feel ickier, doesn't it? I think it's awesome that this dude can be his true authentic self out in public... but if the end game is selling shirts on your influence Instagram, then I can confidently say FUCK YOU to him, regardless of sexual orientation. Please, everyone, just get offline. This shit isn't healthy. (Besides PoYB, of course. You're safe here.)  —Joe


"Take Your Mama" by Scissor Sisters
from Scissor Sisters, 2004

There's an all-time classic Simpsons episode (Season 8) where the family befriends a gay man and Homer struggles with accepting his sexuality. In the year 2025, there are absolutely some jokes that do not land as well as one would like, but to me, it is important to realize that, while not groundbreaking in 1996/97, this was still the era when Ellen DeGeneres coming out on her show was front page news everywhere. I only bring this up to say that whenever I listen to the Scissor Sisters, who are fantastic, I am reminded of a Homer quote from this episode: "I like my straights straight, and my homosexuals FA-LAAAAMING."  —Gilson


"Sober to Death" by Car Seat Headrest
from Twin Fantasy (Face to Face), 2018

Twin Fantasy is the best Car Seat Headrest album (but not my favorite, which is Teens of Denial). The 2018 version is more or less a major-studio remake of the original 2011 version. I didn't listen to it until 2018. I pored over the lyrics a lot back in the day, I don't know why. It's a great album and it felt deep. It's interesting thinking now, though, seven years later, who normal and unobtrusive it was, the idea of this being not only being a musical drama about love, but one about gay love. Like, there are so many important aspects to the story presented here, and that felt like it wouldn't even crack the Top 20 if ranked. That's either because I'm straight and so that part of the narrative was unimpactful by design, or because by the late-'10s, we (progressives, at least) were taking this type of thing for granted. Imagine if the album had come out in 1978, and Will Toldeo had been that upfront and matter-of-fact about his sexual orientation. It would've felt revelatory and essential to the text. There's a lot of bigotry out there, still. Lots of hate, many homophobes (there's even one living in the White House!). But sometimes, when it all feels too heavy, it might be at least a little helpful to remember how far we as a society have come so far.  —Joe


"Becky's So Hot" by FLETCHER
from Girl of My Dreams, 2022

I see her down in the basement every few hours these days. We talk about shelter construction. "You're an urban planner," she said. "You should know!" Last week I was late, and she looked up at me, all fake mad. "You're an idiot!" she said. Today she saw me eating cookies in the basement. "You guys are like a comedy duo," she said, addressing me and my partner. Then she went back to her phone. We were all dressed strangely. I hadn't showered from my COVID-esque virtual workout earlier, closed gym and all. She was ready for bed but looked effortlessly stunning. Becky so hot, indeed. I am sure I'll see her again today, somewhere between 2 and 5 AM, down in the basement, trying not to die.  —Zach


"The Sentinel" by Judas Priest
from Defenders of the Faith, 1984

I was oh so close to writing a blurb for a Queen song just to irritate Joe, but I decided to highlight a different LGBTQ rock/metal icon: Rob Halford from Judas Priest. Now, I might be a bigger fan of Iron Maiden than Judas Priest (I have a friend and colleague who I debate this subject with whenever we hang out), but I recognize and appreciate the massive impact Judas Priest had on the genre of metal. This specific song is one of my favorite songs by the legendary band. It works as a more welcoming intro to Judas Priest in a way that "Painkiller" or "Screaming for Vengeance" might not be.  —Batts


"Purse First" by Bob the Drag Queen ft. DJ Mitch Ferrino
a single, 2016

Yes mama. Bob the Drag Queen is one of my all time favs. I'm gooped and gagged by this song. Ok, let's spill the tea... let's walk into the room purse first. This song is giving, and I'm living, and it. is. sickening. Bob owns 51% of this company and she betta werk! 10s across the board. Shantay you stay.

Oh, and Bob... don't fuck. it. up.  —Pam


"Love Nobody" by Jenn Champion and OYSTER KIDS
from Love Nobody EP, 2021

Here's a song about falling in love with someone despite yourself. It works for anyone, but with this being Pride Month and this song being performed by a queer artist, I wonder if there is any subtext about discovering your sexuality in this song. However, as a straight cisgendered white man, I'm probably not an authority on that subject. But that doesn't mean we can't be allies.  —Batts


"Grace Kelly" by Mika
from Life in Cartoon Motion, 2007

I have a difficult time believing people that say they never questioned their own sexuality for even a second. I'm not saying I had to think very long and hard about it, but I know for a fact there were a number of times in my life that I wondered, "Wait... am I?" before I came back to the conclusion that I am, in fact, straight. Or, at the very least, on the straight end of the Kinsey Scale. Though I'd certainly wager that I am not particularly close to the absolute straight end of the spectrum.  —Gilson


"Critterland" by Willi Carlisle
from Critterland, 2024

Take me to Critterlaaaaaand. Honestly, take me to Critterland. Give me some possums and squirrels and a crow friend and I'll be so content. I think I must have been a granny witch or an herbalist in a past life, because "Critterland" just gives me the warm fuzzies. I'll always stand by the idea that nature can teach us a whole lot if we listen.  —Pam


"Road Head" by Japanese Breakfast
from Soft Sounds from Another Planet, 2017

My life changed because of road head I never got. Let's say I had gotten it? I'd be trapped in an unhappy marriage, somewhere in Charlotte or Houston. I'd never bring dairy or soy or gluten into the house. I'd have to go to her sister's wedding, which was basically an homage to Donald Trump. I would have a frustrating sex life. I would not be happy. I only got road head once in my life, and that was sixteen years ago. It didn't happen that other time, and for that I am eternally grateful.  —Zach


"Red Moon" by Big Thief
from Dragon New Warm Mountain I Believe in You, 2022

I've written about this before, but Adrianne Lenker's joyous, gleeful, legendary hollering of "That's my grandma!" has got me thinking about it again. Just the idea of how I (and my sisters and cousins and yes of course my dad) lionize the idea and memory of my paternal grandparents, and how I wonder sometimes if that's a product of only knowing them until right before all this stuff ("politics," me "being a woke libturd" I guess) became actually, legitimately important to me. I wonder how much I would've seen that would've disappointed me if my own grandma lived through her 90s, if my grandpa had survived to see 100. My maternal grandma is still with us, and she is constantly disappointing me with what she says and how she acts in this realm. As of this writing, it's been only seventeen hours since I've heard her say something disgustingly racist. I wonder if I would still think about them fondly if I ever learned about, for example, what my grandpa thought about joyful music from queer artists. Probably not. I know this is pessimistic, and maybe I'm wrong. But I don't really have time in my life for people who are equally pessimistic about basic human ways of life. Doesn't matter who they are, family or fucking whoever. No time for it.  —Joe


"Lollipop" by Mika
from Life in Cartoon Motion, 2007

You're eighteen
You're a freshman in college
It's Halloween and you're getting ready to go out with your best friend
Your listening to Life in Cartoon Motion as you get ready
Her favorite album
You have such a crush on her
She knows this
But she'll only make out with you when you're both drunk 
She wants to borrow your dress, and she gets changed in front of you
You look away too shy to look at her 
The most beautiful girl you know
Later that night you'll stumble home
Alone
Drunk
High
One broken heel, and one bloody foot
Dried leaves stuck in your ripped fishnet stockings
She'll still be at a party with a guy you introduced her to
"Love's gonna get you down"
     —Gloria


"Cherry" by FLETCHER and Hayley Kiyoko
a single, 2021

Working in healthcare during the pandemic, there were certain times when I would listen to the same song on repeat during my commutes—maybe it was a decision fatigue response? Like how Steve Jobs always wore a black turtleneck to keep brain power for more important things. Although, I'm not comparing anything I did to be even an ounce as transformational as his work. But when this came out near the end of 2021, I listened to it for about a month on my drive.  —Gloria


"QUEER" by BROCKHAMPTON
from Saturation II, 2017

I like the idea that we can take ideas and words and symbols and make them our own if we want to. I think about the fact that, for a while, we had a plaque with the "don't tread on me" snake on it. It went up before me or Pam knew its significance (i.e. that it had been commandeered by the rabid conservative Tea Party movement, a precursor to maga), but after I learned about it from a few weary liberal friends visiting and brave enough to say something, I doubled down. No, we're not removing that shit. I'm taking it back. A fucking COP isn't allowed to put that shit on his coffee mug. He's the boot. I'm the fucking snake, getting tread on. Not that I deserve to have an opinion on the matter, but this is something that I appreciate about the LGBTQ movement—how they have reclaimed the word "queer." I haven't done research, but I'm assuming (based on the dictionary definition of "strange, odd") that it was original used to denigrate and disparage gays and lesbians, no? But people were just like, nah, you're not gonna use that term, WE are gonna use that term, and we're gonna celebrate it. And now we get to celebrate today, on this mixtape, with queer artists. Use the verbiage of your abusers against them! Fuck those pieces of shit!  —Joe


"MUDDY" by Jamila Woods
from LEGACY! LEGACY!, 2019

There was never a question about whether we should do a mixtape to celebrate Pride Month. It's a shame that there can only be one, to be honest. I only fear that maybe Puke on Your Birthday can do it justice. I want this to be a space online where people feel comfortable with who they are. I know that this becomes a difficulty thing to even test because the majority of contributors are straight men. I don't know! As always, I get worried about my own writing, how it's perceived, whether I'm misspeaking, whether I'm being insensitive in micro ways and don't even realize it. I'm speaking my truth but that doesn't mean that how I'm can't be improved, thus altering my truth for the better. Sometimes I write a lot and I can hear Jamila Woods screaming in the background: "Motherfuckers won't shut up!" She's talking about me. My bad.  —Joe


"Pynk" by Janelle Monáe ft. Grimes
from Dirty Computer, 2018

Sometimes I forget how lucky I am to work for a place that didn't dismantle DEI. I work for a company that recognizes and celebrates the marginalized whenever possible. It's still corporate bullshit, but after subjecting myself to attempting to stay up with the news, it's a nice reprieve from what could be. So this month is Pride! This month my queer coworkers can safely joke "you can't ask me to do that!? It's PRIDE!" and for that I am grateful.  —Sara


"She" by dodie
from Human EP, 2019

This is such a pure and tender song. I think that "She" so clearly encapsulates the feeling of being young and kind of in love with your straight friend. It's not really a joyful song, but an honest one that is full of beautiful bittersweetness. It's vulnerable; it's the feeling of a secret that you can't say out loud.  —Gloria


NEXT WEEK: "This Blog Is Not a Political Blog" — Just pick a few good songs about these completely arbitrary subjects, chosen randomly: frozen water; pork; peace; civil liberties; state violence; standing up for what you believe in (chosen by Joe)

15 comments:

Joe K said...

Good morning and welcome to the Monday Morning Mixtape.

The song order this week is: all characters counted in song titles (including punctuation and spaces), and ordered from most to least, tiebreaker is reverse-alphabetical.

First song: Zach is lying, he heard this song on his beloved WXPN, they play it ten times a day.

Joe K said...

I think up until 2025, I have mixed up Scissor Sisters and Sister Sledge? It was good to finally understand that they are two completely different bands. I did not expect Scissor Sisters to be fronted by a dude. I liked this song! I will say that Wikipedia is very clear about where they get their name, and the picture on that Wikipedia page is very NSFW, depending on what kind of supervisor you have.

Joe K said...

20 songs, only one of them is a song from the Drag Race universe. I am waking up thankful this morning—it could've been so much worse. (Pam's blurb is fucking great, and ably captures the vernacular.)

Joe K said...

And no one did Queen! Guys, this is a great mixtape!!

Joe K said...

TWO songs from RC album Life in Cartoon Motion. Wow. Haven't thought about this one in a minute. I am sorry to report that Gloria and Gilson are now contractually obligated to review the album for RC. (I also take it back about the "no Queen on this mixtape," I forgot that Mika makes a very overt reference to Freddie Mercury on "Grace Kelly.")

Joe K said...

I forgot that once upon a time I was pushing the new genre tag of "Found Drama" for pop music. I may need to reevaluate, since there is a lot of Found Drama on this mixtape, and so maybe queerness is an important aspect of the genre? I don't want to ask for thoughts about a genre that I made up, but feel free to give me your thoughts.

Joe K said...

Thanks for celebrating Pride with us, friends. Good mixtape.

BEST SONG: "I Want You (Fever)" by Momma

ALBUM TO DOWNLOAD: Gotta be that Scissor Sisters s/t.

Looking forward to hearing the full road head story during next week's "The First Time I: Got Road Head."

Pam said...

Join, or Die NOT Don’t Tread on Me. Still have the sign, it’s in the living room closet! Join the revolution!

Joe K said...

Good call. I think the sentiment of the blurb remains the same. For example, I just learned via Wikipedia that white supremacist and group message texter of war plans Pete Hegseth has the Join or Die illustration tattooed on his right arm.

Gloria said...

Somewhere I have a shirt with the same flag, except the snake it gagged and it says “Oh, please tread on me,” haha

Also, agreed love when people can reclaim words

Gloria said...

I haven’t listen to the full album in a long time, but I’m pretty sure these are the best two songs from it

Zach said...

I would throw in "Big Girl (You Are Beautiful)" and "Happy Ending" as options but I am biased when it comes to "Happy Ending" as a YSC post proves

Zach said...

PS now that a Guster album was reviewed I'm getting FOMO, I might have to take Life in Cartoon Motion if no one else does

Zach said...

I heard it on WEXT, the pride of Amsterdam, NY, the better choice for independent radio.

Zach said...

The story will make its appearance here: Late night flight back to Albany, NY (most likely from Indianapolis but not sure); 10 months of dating; adventurousness; 2am, a Toyota Corolla; an hour-long drive back to Gloversville = recipe for an initial road head experience.