Jimmy Buffett
1974
It's impossible to bend the rules when there are no rules. Jimmy Buffett felt like a Blind Spot and so I added an album to this list. Jimmy Buffett felt like good vacation music so I added him to the list in such a way that this album would line up with a week of vacation. Jimmy Buffett had some songs that I already knew and was already kinda annoyed by so I made sure to choose an album that didn't feature any of those songs.
Isn't it fascinating, though, that the album I chose was also the most critically acclaimed album? I guess it depends on what we mean by "critically acclaimed." When I use that phrase, I typically mean that it's the highest-rated album, quantitatively speaking, on a website that I usually visit, e.g. RateYourMusic. That probably says more about me than it does about Jimmy Buffett. It says that I gravitate toward spaces on the internet that feature people who listen to music in the same way that I do, and would be annoyed at "Margaritaville" in the same way I am. And, crucially, they would be spaces that are curious to know: is Jimmy Buffet MORE than his biggest hits? Do deeper cuts in the discography justify his inclusion in the canon?
I will also cop to the fact that I really only asked myself these questions when Buffett died. This was September 2023, after Buffett spent (I assume) one last summer playing to aging tanned beachgoers. I attended one of his concerts, back in the day. The focus there was drinking and comradery. The music itself was tertiary at best. I knew like two songs, and was too drunk at the concert itself to really care. I think those songs are corny as fuck. But an artist's death usually brings out a lot of Actuallys, and this was no different. "Actually, there are some worthy tunes in his discography, beyond the Landshark-haze concert bullshit." So I was intrigued. Took me almost two years to finally attempt it, but here I am.
Living and Dying in ¾ Time is pretty good. The most interesting aspect to it—besides the fact that it doesn't feature any songs that I was already familiar with, but I already mentioned that—is that it's basically a country album. If you didn't know anything about Jimmy Buffett, knew nothing of his reputation or his legacy, then you might listen to this album and make comparisons to Willie Nelson. RYM calls it "tropical rock," but only after it calls the album "country rock." You can probably make some sort of equation where you add country roots to yacht rock and get Buffett's tropical rock.
I wonder if the hits will sound different to me, now that I've explored the deep cuts. Like, will I hear any country rock influence in "Cheeseburger in Paradise" now that I hear country all over these songs? I don't know. It's not like I'm hearing "Fins" or "Volcano" every day. I don't have any motivation to listen to a Buffett Greatest Hits collection. That was the point of the concert, to take the focus away from the musical craft and place the focus on the ingenuity and passion of the audience. Ya know, because the musical craft is lacking a little.
I definitely do not want to sound pessimistic, because this is fun music, regardless of how annoying those hits are. I like this album a lot. I liked listening to "Saxophones" the most. That's the one that really has nothing to do with the hits or tropical rock or country. It's a meta exercise where Buffett questions whether his songs would be better with a saxophone, and then triumphantly ends the song with a saxophone solo. That's some fun shit. "Brand New Country Star" breaks the fourth wall in a similar way, underlining the question of whether this music is country music or not. The sounds of the song answer the question.
This album changes nothing. I still hold the artist at arm's length, due to the culture surrounding the popular songs that I cannot appreciate. This was a worthy exploration though, if only to know that his music isn't all cultural legacy. There are some good songs tucked away in the corner. It's nice listening to them on my own time, in private... and on vacation.

3 comments:
Fun Fact: Come Monday was Donna and Joes first dance as husband and wife
We now have official word that at least TWO PoYB contributors' parents have a Jimmy Buffett song as their wedding song. If there is anyone else, now is the time to let us know! It is imperative!!!
A perfect read after I just got back from Margaritaville (Ft Myers).
Post a Comment