A Flock of Seagulls
1982
Approaching this without knowing anything besides the name, I'd say that this was a pretty good new wave album. Definitely sounds like "the '80s" in that way that I always have trouble explaining (my usual answer is something like "twinkly synths"). There's a hit that I'm familiar with, "I Ran (So Far Away)," a song that I would call "TV commercial music," in that insurance and credit card companies are lazy as shit and use broad cultural touchstones from the potential customer's childhood, which usually ends up being hits from the '80s and '90s. I've written about all this before.
But I've never written about Flock of Seagulls, and so I was a little nonplussed as to why, when I do finally do some cursory research, I find that this band is roundly mocked for being too '80s, or something, I'm not really sure. I think what it was was that they were mocked by contemporaries? Like in the '80s, when Flock of Seagulls was at their commercial peak, they were disdained by critics and maybe even audiences as well? It's just weird circling back on it forty years later and not really hearing anything to dislike.
The answer that is most cited—and it seems utterly ridiculous to me, but I'm just telling you what I've seen—is that they were mocked because of frontman Mike Score's haircut. Which, yes, sure, it was pretty silly, even for that decade. And let's also be real here, if there was an artist in 2025 with a absurd haircut, I would definitely make fun of them. E.g. maybe I'd have negative things to say about the racist Morgan Wallen's mullet or something. What I really mean is that I find it silly to judge the music based on the physical appearance of the artist. I don't hate Wallen because of his dumb fucking mullet, I hate him because his dumb racist music sucks shit. I wouldn't hate A Flock of Seagulls' music just because of a bad haircut.
But apparently this was a thing back in the day! It's also tough to determine whether this was actually a thing in that present moment, or if it's the type of thing that snowballs over time until it becomes the only thing that anyone remembers. The band gets an Austin Powers shoutout as one of the only things that anyone remembers about the '80s, so maybe that says everything right there. Basil wasn't schooling Austin about the intricacies of new wave deep cuts, he was dismissing the band outright as some haircut of the distant past, not even worth talking about. I don't get it.
I'm not in love with the album or anything. The hits are hits for a reason, the rest are good fodder. I probably didn't do the album any favors by accidentally downloading the U.S. version, which crassly frontloads the hits (the aforementioned "I Run," plus the epic "Space Age Love Song") and leaves the lesser deep cuts hanging out to dry. This is out of character for me, because I usually defer to the artist's intentions in all matters, up to and including sequencing, but here I am, listening to the album that artless suits cut apart and pasted back together. In any case, I'm still here defending the artist, so it's not that big of a deal, but still.
A Flock of Seagulls obviously has a particular sound that you will recognize, and possibly even be tempted to call "generic," depending on your familiarity with the successful rock bands of that era. Maybe that's the key here. Maybe I'm just not as familiar with that era as I should be, and so I'm a lot more tolerant of the music when I hear it. "I was born in the wrong generation" this is not. This is me being in the correct generation, with the hindsight to be able to appreciate something that maybe past generations were unable to. All this, despite the haircut.

No comments:
Post a Comment