Sunday, June 4, 2023

Summer Song Challenge, Day 7: Joe

Prompt: "A song that reminds you of the leaves changing colors"

Selected by Joe


"Slumber Party"
A Great Big Pile of Leaves
You're Always on My Mind, 2013

Here's a quick essay I wrote for my Practice with Children and Adolescents class last semester. The prompt was basically like "Apply some of what we have learned so far to an incident from your own childhood." I'm going to mostly leave it intact here, including the citations, because I think that makes it funnier. I also think it's amusing because the prompt is about the autumn leaves, and literally the only thing that any of this has to do with autumn leaves is the name of the band. Or maybe the incident took place in the autumn too, I dunno. That's another thing—while writing, I changed some of the details (including my age at the time, I was definitely two or three years older than described here) so that it would fit the guidelines and instructions for the essay. I kept the real names in there, though, because I didn't think at the time that anyone besides the professor was going to read this, so I'm going to change those names now. But everything else stays as is, as cringey as it all ends up being. Enjoy...?

~~~~~~~

A discussion about an experience in one's life before the age of twelve lines up nicely with Erikson's psychosocial stages of development, as the theory's "industry vs. inferiority" stage typically ends around age eleven. Children at this age begin to attempt to demonstrate the value of "competence," especially when it comes to their peer group. Peers become a "major source of the child's self-esteem" at this stage (McLeod, 2018).

When I was eleven years old, I had not experienced any significant sort of trauma that I can speak to now. However, I can pinpoint at least one incident that speaks directly toward Erikson's theory, as it pertains to my social group at the time, and a sense of inferiority that was developed based on this and other incidents within that peer group. I speak to the incident not to complain or to renew any sense of embarrassment, but rather to simply give an example of the theory's relevance to my life.

I was eleven years old and in fifth grade in the spring of 2000. The previous year, a classmate and someone whom I considered a friend in our peer group, Jason, had had a successful birthday party at his house that culminated in a sleepover for all the guys that were there. For his eleventh birthday, he had decided to have another sleepover, but made the guest list a bit more exclusive. I was on the basketball team with Jason and most of the other guys that were still invited to this latest party, so without asking, I assumed that I was still on the guest list. I was not. I did not realize I was not until I rang Jason's doorbell with sleeping bag in hand.

It was uncomfortable because it was insinuated almost immediately that I had not been invited, through mumbled comments. I don't know why I didn't just call my dad and have him turn around and come get me. Perhaps it was some mixture of shame and embarrassment that held me back. It is also likely that Jason's parents would have been embarrassed if my dad had to come back to get me, and so they probably just asked Jason to let me stay.

In any case, I was left out of most of the activities of the night. They weren't overt about it, but I wasn't clueless about the situation. I knew that I was an uninvited guest. Unfortunately, the feelings were indeed made overt in the early morning hours. After I had fallen asleep in my sleeping bag, a large quantity of shaving cream was sprayed into the bag, which meant I had to sleep on the floor without a blanket.

This was over two decades ago, so there are plenty of missing memories from the story. I don't remember the next morning, for instance. I assume my dad picked me up early, and I assume that there were questions about why my sleeping bag had shaving cream in it that were dismissed as "pranks" (leaving out the fact that I was the only one pranked). There were no further confrontations, and I even still hung out with these friends (or "friends") at least semi-regularly. In retrospect, however, I acknowledge that this was the turning point in the friendship, that my peer group was fostering a sense of inferiority within me, not competency.

I feel like one of my strengths has always been my awareness in social situations, and a sense of humility when it comes to the unshakeable fact that not everyone is going to like me or care about me. There was never a need to "try harder" to be friends with these particular peers. They had made it clear that my friendship was not a priority, and though it hurt, I didn't try to stop that friendship from fading away over time. I was not bullied after this night. I was elected class president, even. It was clear, however, that this would not be my peer group after eighth-grade graduation, and I am and was thankful for that sense of clarity.

I did not require services after this incident. I don't think my parents would have reacted in that way even if they did know the exact details of the night. There is definitely a sense of "boys will be boys" in terms of society's view of aggression in males as "normal" (Weiss, 2009). I say this with many years of hindsight—I do not believe that the incident was serious enough that I could be described as a "victim." It's possible that I am declining to describe it that way because, despite it being a rough night, everything seemed to work out well in the end. I consider myself fortunate in that regard.

"Working out in the end" is related to those who supported me during this period in my adolescence. Consciously or subconsciously, in reaction to this incident, I began to seek out peers who made me feel confident and competent. By the time I graduated elementary school, I did indeed find that peer group in my class. These friends remain some of my best friends to this day.

One critique of Erikson's theory is that not all humans experience these stages in this order during the exact years described (Flanders, 2023). For example, I certainly felt the inferiority that comes with my "initiative not being encouraged" (McLeod, 2018) from my peer group, and that did not change before I turned twelve years old. It took until I was about fourteen for me to feel confident and competent in my (new) peer group. This was well into the fifth stage, "Identity vs. Role Confusion." I was in that stage as well, but I was also finishing up unfinished business from the previous stage. Just because I felt inferior at age eleven didn't mean I was doomed to "never reach my potential" (Boeree, 2006).

This is possibly an important discussion about Erikson's theory to keep in mind when working with children through our work as adults. It is helpful to remember that being late for a stage or not completing a stage fully does not mean that all hope is lost. Each child develops at their own pace. Social workers can help child (or former child) reflect on their experiences, and facilitate work on obtaining those virtues that Erikson saw as integral to development. It may have been helpful to have been told at age eleven that what I had gone through and was going through was relatively normal at that age, and that with the support of others, I would make it through just fine.

1 comment:

Nate said...

Two Great Big Pile of Leaves songs!?!?