Prompt: "A song that was important to you last week"
Selected by Maeve
"Not Strong Enough"
boygenius
the record, 2023
Where to start? This is my personal ~song of the summer~. You can read more about how I feel about this whole record, or should I say THE record (but read it as "the record"... ugh, this is more of a verbal joke I guess, but you get what I'm going for, right?) from my PoYB Record Club review. The song is the perfect encapsulation about how well their voices work together. They each get a verse, where the vocals build upon each other.
This song kicks off perfectly with simple guitar chords and then the lyrics, "Black hole opened in the kitchen / Every clock's a different time / It would only take the energy to fix it / I don't know know why I am the way I am"... damn. The first time I heard that verse, I paused and started the song over. Not to sound ultra millennial... but I felt SEEN. During the most recent daylight's savings time, I never changed the clock on my microwave and oven clocks. At first, it felt so mundane to do, but then the task became overwhelming, like so much time had passed, why even try? Definitely a touch of a "nothing matters, depressive nihilist behavior" that I can fall into when I'm at my worst. But then I noticed how much it pissed off my sister and friends to have the wrong time posted, and I couldn't change it. I might be a sad girl, but in my heart of hearts, I definitely want to laugh, while annoying the people around me. (Side note: the power went out in my building due to the storm yesterday and it's been 28 hours and I still haven't fixed the clocks, so this is really my heat check—complaining about this thing I've done, while doing it again. One day I'll learn.)
I really love that the repeated lyric of "I don't know why I am the way I am" is not posed as a question, but more an exhausted, "UGH I CAN'T HELP IT." I mean, who doesn't feel that? Who doesn't say that to themselves when they overtext strangers, when they can't help correcting someone during a story where it doesn't matter or when they get too drunk in a pool and cry to their best friends about how they think they've missed every opportunity for having a happy life? I mean, the lyric hits home. And the way it sounds melodically, "I don't... know whyyyyyyyy, I ammmmm..... the way........ I AM," it makes the sentiment stronger, how it's dragged out and professed.
The first chorus hammers home the sentiment of the first verse with, "I am not strong enough to be your man, I try, I can't stop staring at the ceiling fan and / Spinning out about things that haven't happened / Breathing in and out." Not to repeat myself, but Jesus Christ, this is relatable. Who hasn't spun out over things that haven't happened? Me—I do it 3x a day. Not to just break down the lyrics with a big "AMIRIGHT??!" but there's something to be said about how pretty and light this idea is sung, while how heavy and paralyzing it feels to me.
The second chorus changes the lyrics slightly. I truly love a chorus that sounds phonetically the same as the previous chorus, but it's changed the phrasing and flipped it. This time they sing, "I am not strong enough to be your man / I lie, I am just lowering your expectations." They backtrack to say, I actually am strong enough, and you didn't think I was, so I set your expectations low! It's perfect and, Jesus, once again hits home.
The bridge is a simple phrase repeated, with each girl (or boygenius boy) joining in repeatedly singing: "Always an angel, never a god." I watched an interview with Lucy Dacus where she explains it as, "[it's the idea of] receiving praise for being subservient. The best that you can do is be the best second in command. If you can't be powerless, at least you can excel in your powerlessness... that idea really annoys me." It's like this idea of being an angel, but not a god... you can never be the best, but if you repeat this mantra enough you'll be fine with being the second place angel. The first time I listened to this song, I connected so hard with this lyric. Not to be overly vulnerable on PoYB (which again, I know Joe is and we're all friends here), but the idea of being second place, or actually, someone's second choice has really hit *so* hard in the past month or two. And wow, singing this matra isn't positive, but it's almost me convincing myself that it doesn't matter, because who wants to be a god, when you can be an angel (not the point I know, I'm tricking myself with a fun melody instead of being hurt?!)?
The best part of this song is after the bridge, when Lucy's voice comes in on the third chorus, "I don't know why I am / the way IIIIIII AMMMMM."
Also, I'd be remiss to say that every time Beth and I walk to our local watering hole (mentioned in probably half of my posts) we truly just sing this album instead of talking. And normally it starts with us singing this song crossing the park after briefly complaining about something that went wrong at work and screaming, "I don't know why I am, the WAY I AM," which is followed by us fucking up the last few lines of Lucy's closing verse and then moving on to a different boygenius song instead of talking. Gotta save the gossip for the bar and belt it out outside.
This song kicks off perfectly with simple guitar chords and then the lyrics, "Black hole opened in the kitchen / Every clock's a different time / It would only take the energy to fix it / I don't know know why I am the way I am"... damn. The first time I heard that verse, I paused and started the song over. Not to sound ultra millennial... but I felt SEEN. During the most recent daylight's savings time, I never changed the clock on my microwave and oven clocks. At first, it felt so mundane to do, but then the task became overwhelming, like so much time had passed, why even try? Definitely a touch of a "nothing matters, depressive nihilist behavior" that I can fall into when I'm at my worst. But then I noticed how much it pissed off my sister and friends to have the wrong time posted, and I couldn't change it. I might be a sad girl, but in my heart of hearts, I definitely want to laugh, while annoying the people around me. (Side note: the power went out in my building due to the storm yesterday and it's been 28 hours and I still haven't fixed the clocks, so this is really my heat check—complaining about this thing I've done, while doing it again. One day I'll learn.)
I really love that the repeated lyric of "I don't know why I am the way I am" is not posed as a question, but more an exhausted, "UGH I CAN'T HELP IT." I mean, who doesn't feel that? Who doesn't say that to themselves when they overtext strangers, when they can't help correcting someone during a story where it doesn't matter or when they get too drunk in a pool and cry to their best friends about how they think they've missed every opportunity for having a happy life? I mean, the lyric hits home. And the way it sounds melodically, "I don't... know whyyyyyyyy, I ammmmm..... the way........ I AM," it makes the sentiment stronger, how it's dragged out and professed.
The first chorus hammers home the sentiment of the first verse with, "I am not strong enough to be your man, I try, I can't stop staring at the ceiling fan and / Spinning out about things that haven't happened / Breathing in and out." Not to repeat myself, but Jesus Christ, this is relatable. Who hasn't spun out over things that haven't happened? Me—I do it 3x a day. Not to just break down the lyrics with a big "AMIRIGHT??!" but there's something to be said about how pretty and light this idea is sung, while how heavy and paralyzing it feels to me.
The second chorus changes the lyrics slightly. I truly love a chorus that sounds phonetically the same as the previous chorus, but it's changed the phrasing and flipped it. This time they sing, "I am not strong enough to be your man / I lie, I am just lowering your expectations." They backtrack to say, I actually am strong enough, and you didn't think I was, so I set your expectations low! It's perfect and, Jesus, once again hits home.
The bridge is a simple phrase repeated, with each girl (or boygenius boy) joining in repeatedly singing: "Always an angel, never a god." I watched an interview with Lucy Dacus where she explains it as, "[it's the idea of] receiving praise for being subservient. The best that you can do is be the best second in command. If you can't be powerless, at least you can excel in your powerlessness... that idea really annoys me." It's like this idea of being an angel, but not a god... you can never be the best, but if you repeat this mantra enough you'll be fine with being the second place angel. The first time I listened to this song, I connected so hard with this lyric. Not to be overly vulnerable on PoYB (which again, I know Joe is and we're all friends here), but the idea of being second place, or actually, someone's second choice has really hit *so* hard in the past month or two. And wow, singing this matra isn't positive, but it's almost me convincing myself that it doesn't matter, because who wants to be a god, when you can be an angel (not the point I know, I'm tricking myself with a fun melody instead of being hurt?!)?
The best part of this song is after the bridge, when Lucy's voice comes in on the third chorus, "I don't know why I am / the way IIIIIII AMMMMM."
Also, I'd be remiss to say that every time Beth and I walk to our local watering hole (mentioned in probably half of my posts) we truly just sing this album instead of talking. And normally it starts with us singing this song crossing the park after briefly complaining about something that went wrong at work and screaming, "I don't know why I am, the WAY I AM," which is followed by us fucking up the last few lines of Lucy's closing verse and then moving on to a different boygenius song instead of talking. Gotta save the gossip for the bar and belt it out outside.
No comments:
Post a Comment