Prompt: "A song that was important to you last year"
Selected by Joe
"I'm a Survivor"
Reba McEntire
Greatest Hits Volume III: I'm a Survivor, 2001
This was a surprisingly hard prompt to come up with an answer for, but only because I'm trying not to repeat myself, and that's hard to do when I spend a lot of my free time writing about songs that are important to me in the moment. That's kind of the whole point of Puke on Your Birthday at this point, and "last year," i.e. in 2022, we collectively wrote 801 blog posts, most of them about music. So the challenge for today was to write something new, something that I could've written about last year but didn't. The answer is obvious to all those who were hanging around PoYB last summer. You would think it's a repeat song, but I don't think it is. At least off the top of my head, I can't think of any GGW post that went deep on "I'm a Survivor." Sure, it was mentioned, but my explanation is that I am going to try to wring a little bit more blood from the Reba stone and not repeat anything that I wrote in any Reba-related blogging since then. An alternative explanation is that no one gives a shit about any of this.
So. "I'm a Survivor." Theme song to the hit television network sitcom Reba. I am intimately familiar with exactly 20 minutes and 44 seconds of that series, and know literally nothing else about it (still). I'm assuming Cheyenne's kid was kidnapped or something. But a big part of every episode was the theme song, which was reworked into a 30-second version for the intro credits, but which originally existed in three-minute-eight-second form as a new single off Reba's third Greatest Hits collection (we talk about "title tracks" as the song that the album was named after, but this is the only instance I can think of that a song is a "subtitle track").
I was also made aware, during my sojourn in this otherwise unfamiliar world last summer, that there was some sort of—ahem—TikTok challenge based on this song. My understanding is that each "TikTok challenge" consists of the same clip from the same song, and the "challenge" is that you are completing some task or making some kind of joke in the video as that song clip plays over top of it. Please someone younger than 30 years old hop in the comments and correct me on this point. But so the "I'm a Survivor" "challenge" was to play the "I'm a surviiiiivorrrrrrrr" portion of this song while the star of the video is performing some banal or menial task, like cleaning a toilet or buying a pear at the supermarket. The joke was one of irony—the song is about surviving severe trauma, and it's "funny" to play such a song over a task that is in no world traumatic.
The true irony is that I came to love this song over the course of 102 days, and grew to take it seriously. Like, maybe more seriously than it was even intended. I don't see how you could listen to the full version and find anything funny about it. Call it schlock country pop if you insist, but you can't deny the power of the lyrics and the ultimate catharsis of the "I'm a survivor" climax. Maybe you'd have some points if you argued that the 30-second sitcom version isn't meant to be serious, since it's supposed to introduce a lighthearted weekly comedy series, and the shit that the titular Reba is "surviving" basically boils down to wacky hijinks. But still. My tendency is to take things more seriously over time, through repetition. Sure, my first viewing of "Grannies Gone Wild" seemed silly and stupid and the theme song sounded dumb and picayune. But over 100 viewings later and over 50 minutes worth of the theme song later, and I'm starting to think that it's one of great songs of our generation.
I was also made aware, during my sojourn in this otherwise unfamiliar world last summer, that there was some sort of—ahem—TikTok challenge based on this song. My understanding is that each "TikTok challenge" consists of the same clip from the same song, and the "challenge" is that you are completing some task or making some kind of joke in the video as that song clip plays over top of it. Please someone younger than 30 years old hop in the comments and correct me on this point. But so the "I'm a Survivor" "challenge" was to play the "I'm a surviiiiivorrrrrrrr" portion of this song while the star of the video is performing some banal or menial task, like cleaning a toilet or buying a pear at the supermarket. The joke was one of irony—the song is about surviving severe trauma, and it's "funny" to play such a song over a task that is in no world traumatic.
The true irony is that I came to love this song over the course of 102 days, and grew to take it seriously. Like, maybe more seriously than it was even intended. I don't see how you could listen to the full version and find anything funny about it. Call it schlock country pop if you insist, but you can't deny the power of the lyrics and the ultimate catharsis of the "I'm a survivor" climax. Maybe you'd have some points if you argued that the 30-second sitcom version isn't meant to be serious, since it's supposed to introduce a lighthearted weekly comedy series, and the shit that the titular Reba is "surviving" basically boils down to wacky hijinks. But still. My tendency is to take things more seriously over time, through repetition. Sure, my first viewing of "Grannies Gone Wild" seemed silly and stupid and the theme song sounded dumb and picayune. But over 100 viewings later and over 50 minutes worth of the theme song later, and I'm starting to think that it's one of great songs of our generation.
My point being that the TikTok crowd can fuck off. The problem with these "challenges" is that they take something that wasn't intended to be humorous, and make a fucking cheap-shot joke out of it. It's okay to live life jovially, but at a certain point, if everything is a joke, then nothing is. You need something to anchor the jokes to the ground. Note how there is no laugh track during these 30 seconds of a Reba episode. There isn't supposed to be. You need those 30 seconds to consider that maybe there's more to life than yukking it up. People on TikTok don't give a shit about any of this, and it's tiring. I take offense to TikTok for many reasons, but this is the big one: it's the social media equivalent of pointing at someone's necktie and indicating that they spilled ketchup on that necktie and when the owner of the necktie looks down the pointer pulling his or her finger up and rubbing it across the necktie-wearer's face. Cheap fucking jokes, and only the dumbest of the dumb are laughing unironically.
If I had to describe my 2022 as either "challenging" or "not challenging," then I'd probably choose the former. Not as a comparative exercise (comparing my year to anyone else's, I mean), but more as a general either/or statement. It was more challenging than not challenging. I could list the reasons, but even by 2023 they are already looking a bit petty, back there in the distance through the rear-view mirror. Plus that might betray a false sense of pessimism that sincerely wasn't there for most of the year. At the end of the day, though, I do think that the rallying cry of "I'm a Survivor" is a great thematic representation of the 2022 I experienced. There's no irony needed. It's a good song, I listened to it a lot, and outside of my experiences with music, I survived.
If I had to describe my 2022 as either "challenging" or "not challenging," then I'd probably choose the former. Not as a comparative exercise (comparing my year to anyone else's, I mean), but more as a general either/or statement. It was more challenging than not challenging. I could list the reasons, but even by 2023 they are already looking a bit petty, back there in the distance through the rear-view mirror. Plus that might betray a false sense of pessimism that sincerely wasn't there for most of the year. At the end of the day, though, I do think that the rallying cry of "I'm a Survivor" is a great thematic representation of the 2022 I experienced. There's no irony needed. It's a good song, I listened to it a lot, and outside of my experiences with music, I survived.
I know I said that the point of this blog mostly boils down to describing music that is important to the blog post's author, but that's only half the story. The other half if the why. Why is that song or that album or that artist important to you? That's the opposite approach of TikTok, which over time shaves down the "importance" of any given piece of music and reduces it to its barest existence, which it then argues that existence is the equivalent of a soft exhalation of breath out of your nostrils after seeing a meme. Puke on Your Birthday goes in the other direction. Pieces of art accumulate meaning over time. Something that starts as a theme to a sitcom's intro credits sequence eventually becomes a means of examining imposter's syndrome in the midst of attempts at becoming a "master," or a way to process the complex grief of losing a stepgrandfather, or questioning the essence of life and reality itself.
The best songs are also survivors, and over time—a week, a year, a lifetime—they can become more and more important to the listener. I'll always argue that an integral function of one's interaction with art is the examination of that importance, examining the why of it all. Don't fucking debase it with a stupid ass throwaway TikTok video. Take art seriously. What was important to me last year? "I'm a Survivor" by Reba McEntire. No, I'm not joking. I don't joke about this shit.
The best songs are also survivors, and over time—a week, a year, a lifetime—they can become more and more important to the listener. I'll always argue that an integral function of one's interaction with art is the examination of that importance, examining the why of it all. Don't fucking debase it with a stupid ass throwaway TikTok video. Take art seriously. What was important to me last year? "I'm a Survivor" by Reba McEntire. No, I'm not joking. I don't joke about this shit.
No comments:
Post a Comment