Prompt: "A song that, if the cute person sitting next to you on the bus let you borrow their earbuds and hear this song, you'd be like, 'Damn, this person is cool'"
Selected by Joe
"I've Underestimated My Charm (Again)"
Black Kids
Wizard of Ahhhs EP, 2007
I'm writing most of this before I choose the song. The plan is to think out loud (i.e. in print) about what this prompt really means, and then hopefully the answer will fall into my lap. Because, like, what is "cool"? It's a subjective term. I guess when I picture the scenario, I'm forced to examine what I myself would consider "cool," since I'm the one taking this person's (unsanitary) earbuds into my ears. And so I see now that this is going to say more about me as the listener then it would the hypothetical person who is hypothetically choosing the music for me to listen to in the first place. In the act of writing about this hypothetical, I am making the cute stranger an avatar of my own desires and opinions. What I consider "cool" will magically manifest in this fake scenario that I now have to describe.
I don't think she—wait, I'm allowed to describe this hypothetical earbud-sharer as female, right? It is a "cute" person, and I am the one using that adjective, and sorry fellas, I've never found any male above the age of like 8 months old to be "cute." If it makes you (Pam) feel any better, I can say that this interaction is totally aromantic and platonic, like she sees my wedding ring on my left hand and also maybe happened to see me scrolling through Google Photos and looking at pictures of my daughters or something. She knows the score, this stranger. She's just letting me listen to this song because she thinks it's a cool song and she's a cool person who likes sharing cool music with strangers with no ulterior motives.
I don't think she's listening to pop music. Being "cool" is, if not synonymous with, then at least strongly associated with the idea of being "unique." Pop music, regardless of quality (which, for the record, can be anywhere on the quality spectrum, from "dogshit" to "masterpiece"), is by definition "popular," and thus one cannot be unique by listening to it.
I don't think she'd be listening to anything I've never heard of, either. Nothing too obscure for yours truly. I'm not saying that I only listen to "cool" music, not even remotely. I'm just commenting on the prompt here—if my reaction to hearing a song is to make a snap judgment about the person sharing that song, then I need to have known the song already, or else the judgment wouldn't be fair. It may be true that someone listening to some obscure punk rock seven-inch from 1983's bargain bin is the coolest motherfucker on the planet, but I'm not gonna be the one to have the capacity and wherewithal to say it.
I also don't think that she can be listening to any music from any of the genres that I don't feel like I have a good handle on yet (whether I'm currently attempting to build a personal rapport with that genre or not). It may well be that someone shares with me a rap song, or a jazz song, or a metal song, or an R&B song, or a hardcore song that I already know and maybe even love. But I don't know enough about any of those genres (according to my own, admittedly higher, standards) that I would feel comfortable making a judgment about whether a song from that genre is "cool" or not.
That's basically a long-winded way of saying that she's probably going to be sharing what we'd call an "indie rock" song. I have plenty of blind spots even in this genre (which has a genre description that is pretty watered down at this point anyway, all things considered), but I would be comfortable saying that this is my genre, my go-to if you will. I'm familiar with enough of it (having lived my formative years through its peak in the '00s) that I can say that an indie rock song is "cool" without feeling like a fucking poser.
I don't think she'd be listening to anything I've never heard of, either. Nothing too obscure for yours truly. I'm not saying that I only listen to "cool" music, not even remotely. I'm just commenting on the prompt here—if my reaction to hearing a song is to make a snap judgment about the person sharing that song, then I need to have known the song already, or else the judgment wouldn't be fair. It may be true that someone listening to some obscure punk rock seven-inch from 1983's bargain bin is the coolest motherfucker on the planet, but I'm not gonna be the one to have the capacity and wherewithal to say it.
I also don't think that she can be listening to any music from any of the genres that I don't feel like I have a good handle on yet (whether I'm currently attempting to build a personal rapport with that genre or not). It may well be that someone shares with me a rap song, or a jazz song, or a metal song, or an R&B song, or a hardcore song that I already know and maybe even love. But I don't know enough about any of those genres (according to my own, admittedly higher, standards) that I would feel comfortable making a judgment about whether a song from that genre is "cool" or not.
That's basically a long-winded way of saying that she's probably going to be sharing what we'd call an "indie rock" song. I have plenty of blind spots even in this genre (which has a genre description that is pretty watered down at this point anyway, all things considered), but I would be comfortable saying that this is my genre, my go-to if you will. I'm familiar with enough of it (having lived my formative years through its peak in the '00s) that I can say that an indie rock song is "cool" without feeling like a fucking poser.
Okay, but let's go back to that idea of "popular" being antonymous with the idea of "cool," and then let's consider that "popular" can be relative. When we're talking about music in general, then "popular" would be your Swifts and your Beyoncés and your Drakes. But when we are talking about mid-'00s indie, we can also talk about what was "popular" within those specifications, and discard them as an answer to this prompt. I'm talking about songs such as: "New Slang" or "Young Folks" or "Wolf like Me" or "The Rat" or "All My Friends" or "Maps" or "The Funeral" or "I'll Believe in Anything" or okay you get the point. All of these songs are fucking great, and all of them would get the reaction of "Holy shit hell yeah what a great song," but none of them would get the ultra-specific reaction of "You, specifically, are cool because you are listening to this."
So what, am I asking for a deep cut, I guess? From a band that was popular then and whose music I still like but also a song that feels like it comes with no baggage from that band's quasi-popularity (read: generally not well-known to those outside the indie rock listenership), i.e. a song that wasn't one of that band's hits but can stand tall next to those hits in terms of quality, and thus could simply exist as this tiny platonic but meaningful connection between strangers on a SEPTA bus?
We've culled down the possibilities enough that I can just throw the proverbial dart at the board at this point and come up with a reasonable answer. Here is the where the dart landed: "I've Underestimated My Charm (Again)" by Black Kids, off their 2007 EP Wizard of Ahhhs. (Sorry for spoiling it above, but that's just how these blog posts are structured, and there is nothing I could do about it.)
My thinking is that, not only does it satisfy all the arbitrary criteria that I blabbered on about above, but also, there has to be a measure of kindness in a person to still care about this particular band in 2023. They had a minor indie rock hit called "I'm Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How to Dance with You" off this same EP in 2007 (just heard it on the radio the other day, in fact—gotta love WXPN), and then, infamously, Pitchfork tanked their careers with a shitty, lazy review (back when Pitchfork had the cultural cache to tank a band's career) for their debut LP. Wikipedia uses present-tense verbs on the Black Kids page, so I guess they are still out there making music? I just hope they are happy. And I think that the act of sharing one of their deep cuts with a stranger on a bus would be an act of kindness too, a way of sticking it to the man (again, if Pitchfork is or ever was "the man" in this context), in addition to sharing a good song, and kindness is cool, yo, especially when it comes to indie rock music from the mid-'00s.
But then of course I'd make it weird because I'm listening to the song and thinking this chick is cool and starting to get like a little nervous because maybe the song she shared with me has romantic undertones (in a cool, understated, very indie-rock-2007 kind of way), and I don't think she's hitting on me, but I get nervous thinking maybe she is, even though she saw the ring, and I'm a fucking dope and so insanely out of my element that I pull the cord and get out at the next stop even those I'm nowhere near my destination, and for the next like four years I'm getting on the bus praying that I don't see the cute stranger because if I do I'm going to awkwardly ignore her and sit on the other end of the bus and it's just fucking weird, man. Weird prompt. Very glad that strangers don't actually share music like this.
We've culled down the possibilities enough that I can just throw the proverbial dart at the board at this point and come up with a reasonable answer. Here is the where the dart landed: "I've Underestimated My Charm (Again)" by Black Kids, off their 2007 EP Wizard of Ahhhs. (Sorry for spoiling it above, but that's just how these blog posts are structured, and there is nothing I could do about it.)
My thinking is that, not only does it satisfy all the arbitrary criteria that I blabbered on about above, but also, there has to be a measure of kindness in a person to still care about this particular band in 2023. They had a minor indie rock hit called "I'm Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How to Dance with You" off this same EP in 2007 (just heard it on the radio the other day, in fact—gotta love WXPN), and then, infamously, Pitchfork tanked their careers with a shitty, lazy review (back when Pitchfork had the cultural cache to tank a band's career) for their debut LP. Wikipedia uses present-tense verbs on the Black Kids page, so I guess they are still out there making music? I just hope they are happy. And I think that the act of sharing one of their deep cuts with a stranger on a bus would be an act of kindness too, a way of sticking it to the man (again, if Pitchfork is or ever was "the man" in this context), in addition to sharing a good song, and kindness is cool, yo, especially when it comes to indie rock music from the mid-'00s.
But then of course I'd make it weird because I'm listening to the song and thinking this chick is cool and starting to get like a little nervous because maybe the song she shared with me has romantic undertones (in a cool, understated, very indie-rock-2007 kind of way), and I don't think she's hitting on me, but I get nervous thinking maybe she is, even though she saw the ring, and I'm a fucking dope and so insanely out of my element that I pull the cord and get out at the next stop even those I'm nowhere near my destination, and for the next like four years I'm getting on the bus praying that I don't see the cute stranger because if I do I'm going to awkwardly ignore her and sit on the other end of the bus and it's just fucking weird, man. Weird prompt. Very glad that strangers don't actually share music like this.
No comments:
Post a Comment