Monday, June 26, 2023

Summer Song Challenge, Day 29: Joe

Prompt: "A song in a weird time signature (i.e. not 4/4 or 3/4)"

Selected by Joe


"Robbery, Assault and Battery"
Genesis
A Trick of the Tail, 1976

If you want the best song of all time that features an irregular time signature, then you're gonna wanna listen to "7/4 (Shoreline)" by Broken Social Scene, which, the Puke gods willing, someone has chosen and has written about today. I love that song but I don't want to choose songs that I love for this project. I want to choose songs that challenge me. Not only challenge me musically, but emotionally too.

For the former, let's address the elephant in the room: "Robbery, Assault and Battery" is not entirely in an irregular time signature. Around two-thirds of its six-minute runtime is spent comfortably in 4/4. But the other third? From approx. minute 3 through minute 5? All of that is in 13/8. It's not even comprehensible most of the time. Like, it's really close to being 3/4 time, just with an extra eighth-note every other measure. Just enough to make you feel uncomfortable. Also enough to wonder how the fuck the rhythm section held it together. My brain almost broke just trying to count to thirteen in time while listening. Imagine playing the fucking instruments while counting.

Also worth nothing that this song, and this album, and this band were all already covered in Record Club a couple years ago, which, if you read my review, you can probably tell where the "emotionally challenging" component comes into play here. Here's a little behind-the-curtain explanation on that one. First, I gave A Trick of the Tail a serious listen (after dozens of casual ones), and took notes. After that, I used the notes to try to craft a review that I felt sounded as professional as I could muster. Then, I got up from my computer, and got loaded. Just no-joke fucking blasted. After getting nice and good and drunk, I sat back down at the computer, closed my eyes, and typed for approximately a half hour without stopping. (The next day, sober again, I did some very slight editing on the especially sloppy and incomprehensible parts of that second half, but let's not ruin the illusion too much here.)

I know the gag was supposed to be that I "took drugs" or whatever, and in a sense I did, but not the psychedelic drugs that were implied. No, it was the usual drug of choice for ol' Joey. And I'd like to think that that particular block of intoxication opened up a window into my inner psyche, captured in furiously typed words in an album review. Your tolerance for this process and its outcome may vary.

Where my mind seems to have gone during that moment of, what would you call it, self-pity or self-revelation or self-flogging or something, what you see is me thinking about roads not traveled, about how A Trick of the Tail was a lost opportunity to connect with my father over something stupid like an album he liked, about how maybe this Genesis album came to represent my deficiencies as a human being, especially compared to the resilience of the band itself, who lost a limb and kept on trucking, maybe even creating their greatest work under those trying circumstances, and there I was getting drunk during the daytime and stewing in my own failures.

I don't know. That's my own interpretation of that huge block of uninterrupted text. I guess it's purposefully left open to interpretation, even to the alcoholic who wrote it.

Now here's the funny part. I love this album. Probably one of my favorite albums that Record Club has ever done (shout out to the Sonman who picked it). And that's in no small part to getting intimate with it in two different realms, the sober and the drunk, the two sides of the same coin that is my life. It was in a dark place that I found Genesis in their peak form, but the process was also spiritual. If interpreting art is all about imposing your own meaning upon that art, then I issued one hell of a wallop to this fucking thing, was my thinking.

And then maybe a month ago, we're all sitting around in my parents backyard. Me, Pam, Martha, my dad, Uncle Ant, Bob who's writing his first SSC entry on his phone, and we're listening to some classic rock on the radio, which is S.O.P. for minor-holiday backyard BBQs at my parents' house, and we're chitchatting about music, and my dad poses the following question: "Have you ever listened to Genesis?"

Which was a really good perspective adjuster, let me tell ya. A real fucking exercise in humility. Because I had just a couple years prior gone through that whole painful psychological process of excising some demons from deep down through substance-assisted impulsive writing, a bargain-basement primal scream therapy for the hip blogging crowd, and what I had found was that there were feelings of inadequacy attached to this music, attached to the connection I have with my loved ones, in this case my dad specifically, and so in my mind now I think about all that when I get whipped by Tony Banks' insane keyboard playing in 13/8 time, the struggle to stay in time mirroring my struggle to be a better person a better friend a better husband a better son. And so the question took me aback. Have I ever listened to Genesis?!?!

I'm not saying this to say that my dad doesn't give a shit, or that he's losing his marbles or whatever. I just think that mainly it was a good reminder that the idea that you are a "Main Character" is a stupid one and if you ever think that you are then you are doing yourself a disservice. It was humbling to remember that. I remember something stupid like my dad recommending a Genesis album to me fourteen years ago because of what that memory means to me now. My dad has no reason to remember that. There is no reason that that memory has to be important to him. We are all living our own lives, and if you think otherwise then you're fooling yourself.

It should be clear to you at this point, here in this place specifically, why it's important for me to periodically receive these reminders about my infinitesimally small place in the universe, since I've been writing on this blog for a long time and a lot of it sure does seem to feel like me trying to pretend otherwise, that I'm some sort of main character to anyone else, that what I do matters. Listening to a song crafted partially in 13/8 time and crafting a huge disgusting attention-seeking album review around it, or maybe even a follow-up in which I talk some more about that emotional process under the guise of a "song challenge." Do not let me fool you for one fucking second, my friends. I may pretend that the millions of words spilled on this blog were speaking truth into legend, but at the end of this day, all those millions of words won't be shit but tears in rain.

1 comment:

Sam said...

In my heroes journey, I’m happy the Sonman incident has gotten such mileage.