Wednesday, June 28, 2023

Never Seen It, #109 of 200: Moulin Rouge!

200 movies I've never seen before! So exciting! This blog series will run for fifty years! The audience will stomp and cheer!


Moulin Rouge!
2001
Baz Luhrmann

One of the challenges of this project, and thus one of the challenges I find in the art of "knowing cinema," is the idea of being able to watch a film and describe the ways in which a director imprinted his or her personal style or aesthetic to that film. I spoke to this challenge before—I wanted to know what made a Stanley Kubrick film "Kubrickian," and I found that even after watching four of his films early in the Never Seen It project, I still have no idea. But with a director like Baz Luhrmann? I don't know... shit doesn't seem so challenging.

Perhaps we're at the point where Luhrmann films are derided for being too, um, Luhrmannian(?). I'm not totally sure. I don't really have my finger to the pulse of pop culture like that. I am familiar with three of his films now. Most recently, Elvis was at once critically derided and also given multiple Oscar nominations (for the record: I liked it). And then about three and a half years ago, Sunny and I interviewed Sean about his favorite movie, which happened to be Romeo + Juliet. So that's only three films, but even now, having seen my third and the most critically acclaimed Luhrmann enterprise, I am relatively confident that I know what this dude's fucking deal is.
 
Now, describing what that deal is, in my own words, is the real challenge of this blog project, 'cause me ain't no good at da movie words, but let's give it a whirl. Baz Luhrmann films are pretty often showy and extravagant to the point of parody. Importantly, they keep one toe on the right side of that line, not totally devolving into a mess, but, like, they get close enough that it feels ballsy and almost dangerous. And the editing... woo, boy. There's a lot of it. A lot of quick cuts. Maybe I noticed that last characteristic in the other two films, but in Moulin Rouge!, it almost made me a bit nauseous.

I tried to google how many cuts there were in the entire movie, and I assume that there is no one crazy enough to attempt to count them, but I did find this one website that counted one scene—the Can Can Dance, 65 seconds long, and 85 cuts. Looking it up on YouTube (you can watch it for yourself here), I'm seeing that, yeah, this is the scene that I had to turn away from and write in my phone memo "so many edits though." Seriously, don't try to watch this scene with a full stomach. There's more whiplash here than an cheap carnival ride.

In fact, I'd say that there are so many that it becomes purposeful. That's the fucking point, the whiplash. You're supposed to feel disoriented, since this is a new and strange world that our protagonist is now entering, with so much light and color and sound and emotion that he (and we) shouldn't really know where to look, and so we're looking everywhere. I get it. I'm not gonna pretend that Luhrmann isn't self-aware about the ridiculous camera shit. Think about that one scene when they are pitching the made-up-on-the-spot idea to the Duke, and Harold is so close to his face, just yelling in his face, i.e. the camera is doing a close-up, but then there's a quick cut of a different angle, from behind Harold, as if to signal to the audience that, yeah, this looks fucking ridiculous, and that's the point.

Totally makes sense why some people can't take this kind of thing seriously. It seems silly on its face, like there's so much dumb bullshit crammed into this thing that it's like Luhrmann is making a joke. But I'm inclined to take it seriously anyway. It's kind of like one of those collages of little pictures that, if you zoom out, makes a completely different picture. A photo mosaic! Moulin Rouge! is like a photo mosaic that, at a distance, looks like a replication of the Mona Lisa, but if you look closely, you can see that all the little photos are all photos of penises. Should you be taking such a piece of art seriously? Depends on at what range you want to view it.

Something that maybe I struggled with a little bit, vis-à-vis questions of parody, was the choices in music. I had no idea that this was a so-called jukebox musical before we pushed play, but maybe I should've guessed how unhinged the soundtrack would be, knowing who the director is. "Anachronism" doesn't even cover half of it. I mean, it's one thing to have the partygoers at Moulin Rouge sing "Smells like Teen Spirit," which is ridiculous but also from a certain perspective makes sense. But it's a whole different thing to have Jim Broadbent sing "Like a Virgin," or try to fashion "Roxanne" into a dramatic moment. Jesus fucking christ. This is mostly like the editing thing, in that I don't know if I like it but I sure as fuck respect it, but it's different because music is sacred, and it makes me just a little bit uncomfortable that Luhrmann is so thoroughly able to take the piss out of the whole idea.

I guess all the slapstick stuff took me by surprise as well. There were points where Moulin Rouge! literally felt like The Three Stooges. There was also all that trickery with the camera speeds and whatnot, like when everything would speed up, I guess as a way to indicate that this was supposed to be silly. And yeah, man, it sure is.

I think maybe the expectation going into this film, knowing that it was critically acclaimed, was that this was the case because Luhrmann was able to tamper some of his crazier impulses. Moulin Rouge! tampers nothing. It is everything that makes this director who he is. Maybe this is "knowing a director" on easy mode, but regardless, I feel like I know what type of film it's going to be because the director is Baz Luhrmann. It is at the same time way too much and also just enough. I can probably say that it is "too much" as a movie, and "just enough" as a movie that I have to find something to write about. That's fine with me.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: We're watching Mr. Nanny, which I think is a Schwarzenegger vehicle? Don't quote me on that. We're at the point in this project that sometimes I literally won't even remember the reasoning for adding the movie to the list in the first place.

No comments: