A close and personal friend of mine told me this week that she often strives to "find exhilaration in repetition." And this isn't even one of those stupid metaphors that I might employ in an album review introduction like this; she was talking about music specifically. She said it like three or four times—repetition—which I see now was intentional.
The word rings in my mind as I sit and listen to Nakhane's Bastard Jargon. There are moments that sound like music repeating itself. I have heard these sounds move through my ears in the recent and distant past. Not a wholesale repetition, of course—this isn't We Are Scientists—but more a piecemeal collection of repetitions from before. Nakhane is a chameleon, changing their sound for what the moment requires, and what this moment apparently requires is more of the same. If that makes sense.
I have heard the voice singing "hear me moan!" before. Maybe not those words, but definitely the timbre and articulation and tone, in the late David Bowie, in his swan song. It's a repetition; shit, it's almost a pitch-perfect impression. The back half of "You Got Me (Living Again)" echoes LCD Soundsystem and, yes, The Suburbs-era Arcade Fire, albeit in a much safer space. I've heard it before. I just heard this shit last week, didn't I? Yves Tumor is like the weirder half-sibling of Nakhane, identical sounds but shoved through a dark mirror.
It's not even necessary to leave the confines of Record Club, though. Bastard Jargon might represent the tipping point for this music/writing group; we've listened to enough music at this point that everything starts melding together, and the comparisons come quickly and effortlessly.
Didn't we just listen to a sex-positive dance album a couple weeks ago? Nakhane and Jessie Ware approach the same goal from different starting points, and meet in the middle. Repeat. When they aren't sounding like the ghost of Bowie, they're sounding precariously like Sam Smith. Repeat. "Hold Me Down" sounds so much like a Perfume Genius song that I have to constantly remind myself that Perfume Genius doesn't show up for another two songs after that. Repeat. Am I fucking crazy or does the album / "The Caring" open like a Harry Styles song? Repeat. The album definitely ends with some Mary Lattimore-esque ambience and some Andrew Bird-esque whistling. Repeat, not a stretch—all music starts to sound like other music, especially under the big tent of Record Club.
But my close and personal and frozen friend also went on to explain that repetition can be exhilarating because only in repetition can we constantly find new meaning in the same ol' same ol'. New rhythms, new inflections, new emotions. Yes, I've heard Nakhane before; I've heard them in much of the music I'm already familiar with. But they repeat, and find something new, and I find something new in that process.
Think all the way back to January 2020, when we covered Kaytranada. His album Bubba can be connected sonically to Bastard Jargon. It's a repeat of dance music, of sounds and feelings and desires that you'd find in a club somewhere on the outer skirts of town. I didn't like Bubba. I couldn't feel a connection. But over three years later, and with enough repetitions, I'm getting there. I listen to Nakhane, and I hear Kaytranada, but I hear those same notes in different places, in a different order. They sound the same but they mean something different. They are repeating, but in that repetition, I find something new.
I am asked to pour another cup of coffee and tell them what I am embarrassed of. I am told to pour another cup of coffee and tell my morning sins. Sin, embarrassment, whatever, here it is: growth is a long, drawn-out process. 225 weeks in a row and I'm not even close to being there yet, but I'm close. I didn't like it the first time, but endless repetitions have led me here, to some semblance of appreciation, to an ability to parse out what I like from a sound that I'm only just learning to recognize, in its many, many, many repetitions.
I swear I'm not just saying this. I promise that it isn't Nakhane's hard gaze that is forcing me to say this, their eyes following me around the room from up at their podium, the men with guns in the rafters trained on me and waiting for me to make one false move. I'm not scared. I've been here before. I'll be here again. I will never Let It Go.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment