Friday, January 14, 2022

Fine Line, Joe


We enter the scene to find The Writer sitting at his desk (which is really a makeup vanity converted into workspace temporarily, this whole work-from-home thing being new to The Writer), and he has his face buried in his hands, his fingers gripping the tips of his hair. It is this narrator's opinion that The Writer appeared frustrated, though as to what, we can only surmise for now.

Enter The Cat. The Cat's name is "Frisky." We know this because The Cat leaps onto The Writer's lap, eliciting a soft "hey Frisky" from The Writer. The Cat snuggles in, and The Writer absentmindedly begins petting. "Thanks Frisky" says The Writer, "I needed this." And then, after a short pause, The Writer again addresses The Cat: "Frisky, what should we say about Harry Styles?"

The Cat, of course, does not answer, as your humble narrator has taken great pains to ensure that this short story remains firmly in the realm of nonfiction. The Writer did not expect The Cat to answer, either, at least it doesn't seem like he did, because after inquiring about the former One Direction member, he stares not at The Cat, but out the window. The Writer, we can thus assume, is simply speaking out loud, making his thoughts verbal so as to try to make sense of them. He continues:

"The problem, Frisky, isn't that I like or dislike Fine Line. I like it a lot. It's not even that I'm disinterested, because I think there's a lot to say about this album." The Cat purrs. "I know, I know, I've never been one to keep it short and simple. You're right. I could talk about this album for a good long while, and probably will, if you're not in a hurry to get off my lap." The Cat doesn't stir, perhaps giving her answer by not stirring. "The issue—the reason you found me head in hands and moaning in frustration when you entered the room—is that everything I have to say about Harry Styles' 2019 pop album, I feel like I've already said about one or more albums we've come across in Record Club before. If there's anything I hate when it comes to writing about music, it's when I find myself repeating old points ad nauseam."

The Cat stretches his slender frame as far as he can. The Writer takes this as a sign that he's boring even the damn cat, and that maybe he should provide some examples to hammer the point home. "Okay, Frisky, I hear you." The Cat is done stretching and is now curled up. "This is a pop album, so of course those same arguments are cropping up, the ones that I always seem to touch on when we get to a Dua Lipa or a lizard person Demi Lovato or an Olivia Rodrigo. I could open my review the same way I did the Rodrigo review, in fact. Remember? The whole 'it's nice to get to a pop album when it is firmly out of the zeitgeist because it allows us to examine it without societal pressure to hold a strong opinion one way or the other' and all that shit? Remember?"

The Cat gives no indication that he remembers anything past breakfast this morning. "Well, Fine Line seems to fall into the same category. I'm familiar with 'Watermelon Sugar.' I called it 'some dumb fucking bullshit' all the way back in October of 2020, and that was like ten months after the album came out! It doesn't matter whether I still think it's dumb fucking bullshit, Frisky, because I'm not trying to repeat myself! Don't you understand?!" The Cat does not understand, nor does he care. This narrator cannot read cat minds, but you don't have to be a mind-reader to understand the response to such histrionics.

After a few sharp breaths, The Writer continues. "And here's something that I've said for every single pop album that we've ever reviewed. I've said every single time that I want my pop music to be quote unquote 'different' then any other pop music that I might happen upon via the radio. The term 'different' is nebulous, but still, I know it when I hear it. So, we I prone to repeat myself and bore the two and a half readers who are going to be reading my review, I'd definitely talk about that."

The Cat might be asleep, I don't know. The Cat is turned away from your humble narrator, and The Cat's face is out of view. Let us assume she is asleep. "There would actually be a lot to talk about here. I would probably say something along the lines of 'The first half of this album is boring generic pop, and the second half of this album goes to some weird places.' If I was being completely honest, I would probably write 'The second half of this album is fucking wonderful, and I kept returning to these songs.' Frisky, I swear, they were so neat that they even provided the necessary motivation to get past that first handful of songs, every time."

The Writer is picking up steam now. "Ah, but I can't write about that, because I already have! Remember Halsey, how I felt like she didn't go far enough? Remember 100 gecs, how I felt like maybe they went a little too far? Yeah, sure, Harry Styles seems to split the difference better than most of the pop artists we've covered, at least on par with Rodrigo I'd argue, but no one would want to read that, trust me. I'm even boring myself." The Writer suddenly realizes that The Cat is asleep. "Oho! See! I've even bored my dear Frisky to sleep!"

"I suppose, in a perfect world, I could just do the whole comparison thing, right? I could say that 'Sunflower, Vol. 6' is Harry Styles doing Vampire Weekend, that 'Canyon Moon' is Joni Mitchell, that 'Fine Line' is Bon Iver, that, yes, all these songs are on the aforementioned back half of the album, that it may or may not be because Styles is imitating artists that I like that I also like the back half a lot more than the front half. But that thread is tired, Frisky. It really is. It makes me tired just thinking about it. Like, if I try to do one more hokey bullshit review where I say 'X sounds like Y and Z sounds like A' like I did for, I dunno, Stereo League—no, wait, I already swore I would never do again in another hokey bullshit review all the way back in November 2019!!—if I go down this path again, then every single Puke on Your Birthday reader might just have to join you for that nap."

Suddenly, The Cat darts out of the room. "Hey!" exclaims The Writer, "where are you going?" The Writer chases The Cat out of the room. This narrator, unfortunately, only has observation powers limited to this one room, so I have no choice but to wait for their return. I twiddle my thumbs for a bit. I think about there's no fucking way The Writer mentions the Vogue profile, because then he'll have to mention the whole crossdressing thing from the Valentine review again. Like I said, I've been confined to this room, so I can confirm that The Writer has not yet worn his wife's clothing in an attempt to feel 'hot,' don't you worry your pretty conservative head now. I'll let you know if The Writer ever gets around to it. (It might even have tempted The Writer to pretend that Harry Styles was actually in the room for the purposes of pretending to ask him about how it felt to wear a woman's dress in public, but like I said, dear reader: this story is firmly set in the realm of nonfiction. No imaginary conversations with celebrities today! Not if I can help it!)

Ah! Here comes The Writer, followed by The Cat, back into the bedroom. Though he'd never say out loud, I'm assuming that The Writer had to address The Cat's litterbox concerns. I'm only guessing this based on the fact that I could see The Writer dispose of a plastic bag in the hallway, and his eyes are watering slightly as he enters the room. Anyway! He's sitting down now. Let's see if he picks up where he left off with his monologue to no one...

"You see, Frisky"—oh good—"there's another angle through which we could address the front/back dichotomy here. And that's by discussing my unshakeable conviction that fast songs are always going to be better than slow songs, and that artists—especially pop artists, or maybe even only pop artists? I can't decide—should more or less stick to the fast songs if they want to make me appreciate their work. But everyone already knows that boring and simplistic and condescending opinion, because I've written about it plenty of times. I've broken it down into parts. I've pretended that Tina Turner was joining a picket line to underline that point over and over and over. It's overdone. Yes, it's probable that I like 'Golden' better than 'Falling,' for example, simply due to tempo. But it doesn't matter, because to write about it yet again would be so fucking mundane."

The Cat looks up, almost as if expecting The Writer to put a pithy postscript at the end of this rant. The Writer does not disappoint: "And plus, 'Falling' sounds like Adele, and it sucks, and that should prove what it needs to prove to any naysayers still claiming that I dislike Adele because she's a woman."

It almost looked like The Cat gave a smirk at that statement, but I can't be certain. Maybe he hates Adele's music too? No, no, nevermind, this is nonfiction. No reading cat's minds! Sorry, your narrator tends to digress occasionally. Maybe The Writer is rubbing off on me.

"What do you think, Frisky, should we talk about 'Treat People with Kindness'?" The Cat gives no indication as to whether The Writer should talk about "Treat People with Kindness" or not, so I suppose The Writer is taking this as his cue to elaborate. "Oh, but I can't! No repeats! This kind of cloying 'why can't we all just get along' sentimentality was already eviscerated in that Guy Fieri review, right? The readers get the point."

The Cat looks up. "What? No, I don't think the point is that I am jaded. Wait, is it? Could my heart be so hard that I cringe at a pleasant, soft conviction of 'treat your fellow man a little better'? I don't know, Frisky, I just don't know. All I know is that I don't like it. I like the song itself, but I don't like the gooey saccharine bullshit that Styles is peddling." (By the way: your humble narrator has no idea if The Writer actually heard The Cat communicate with him. Not likely, seeing as how this story is nonfiction, and telepathy isn't real. But I wonder if there are some behavioral health issues we need to address here, since it sure fucking seemed like The Writer heard The Cat call him "jaded." Hmm.)

"In any case, I think the main point here should be Harry Styles does a very good job mixing up the genres here. I know Nate kind of wrote about that in a review already, how young pop stars are creating these amalgams of all different kinds of sounds, but I'd argue that the stakes are different here than they were for PinkPantheress. This is a global pop superstar! This is an A-list celebrity! Harry Styles is a fucking Avenger now! And to hear him put out a pop album that covers this much ground within an otherwise constricting genre is refreshing."

The Cat isn't moving at all, despite the yelling. "I know! I know! That can't possibly be my takeaway from this! A conclusion that speaks of genre! I know! Not again! Oh god! What the fuck am I going to write about then? For real, Frisky! Fucking tell me, or else I'm going to lose it!" The Cat still isn't moving.

Dear reader, The Writer is truly fucking losing it now. He stands up, his face is beet red, he grabs his laptop and violently throws it toward the ground, where it shatters. He's in bare feet but he's still stomping on the glass fragments, and even though I'm an ethereal spirit even I'm backing up now, and jeez, now there's bloody footprints all over the bedroom floor. Oh christ, this is gruesome. The Cat, by the way, hasn't moved at all this whole time, and now he's laying on the floor. The Writer finally notices The Cat's stillness.

"Wha... oh god. Frisky! Oh no! Oh god, what have I done! My precious cat! Killed by my indecision about a Harry Styles album and my lack of originality in expressing opinions about it! Had only I the foresight to just settle down at my computer and write a damn review! Who cares if it's original or not! Oh god! I'm sorry Frisky! I'm sorry!" And at that, The Writer crumples on the floor, sobbing, cradling The Cat in his arms.

We can skip ahead now, dear reader, if you'd like. A lot of the action that takes place after this scene occurs outside of this bedroom, and as I have already mentioned, your humble narrator is confined to this space and this space alone. I could see the cat funeral from my vantage point through the bedroom window, however. I couldn't hear what The Writer was saying as he held his head low, next to the tiny cat gravestone. I can't imagine it had much to do with Fine Line, seeing as this album is apparently about "having sex and feeling sad." I've heard The Writer's wife remind him on multiple occasions that "Watermelon Sugar" is code for "Pussy Juice," so there's no way that that filth ended up anywhere near The Cat's funeral.

I will tell you, humble reader, that in the ensuing days and weeks and months, I've observed The Writer mumbling in his sleep about The Cat, tossing and turning, as if tortured by the grief. And I've also observed The Writer as he awakes, and how he talks out loud to no one at all, still, admitting that The Cat is "the first one I see, and I don't know why." I can fathom a guess. It's probably because The Writer knows that "She" is the best song on the album. (Your humble narrator agrees.)

In any case, it is time for us to leave this place, dear reader. There is nothing else to see here. Harry Styles Week has long been over. The Writer has said all he's going to say on the matter. And as we fly away from this bedroom, from this planet, to universes hitherto unknown, it might be wise to consider whether, for all the hemming and hawing and death and destruction, The Writer was even able to say anything original or constructive or meaningful at all.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: