Way out front, you know I ain't frontin', hittin' home runs, I ain't about buntin'.
Friday, January 31, 2020
Manic, Joe
There's a lot to like on Manic; brace for the "but" if you feel like you need to, but I promise it's a soft one this week.
First, let's talk about pop music. It's an ever-shifting genre, beholden to its name—"pop" is short for "popular," and what's "popular" changes over time. The Beatles are not pop music, but they were pop music in their time. These days, pop music is mostly hip hop, but occasionally it is not, and it's in that exceptions circle where we find Halsey.
Here in 2020, when pop music is not hip hop, then it is a chilly, minimalistic affair. Gone are the days of exploding confetti over a towering and pink frosted Katy Perry hook. I blame Billie Eilish, but really, she too is symptom, and I'm not intimate enough with the history of pop music to be able to explain the root cause.
I'm describing all this like it's a problem, but it's mostly not. Would I prefer to hear a happy album full of Ariana Grande-in-party-mode music? Fuck yeah. I'll choose maximalism over minimalism any fucking day. But that's just not where pop music lives these days.
I accept it, as long as you accept the fact that there's no question that "3 AM" is the best fucking song on Manic, because it's the only song on here that reaches a moment of true catharsis. We start at Halsey lamenting her loneliness over some sparse guitar, and then the drums kick in, and everything builds to the point where she yelling "Pick up your fucking phone!" and it just hits so goddamn hard.
There are plenty of other songs on Manic that I adore, but by the end of song, I'm left with a feeling of wanting. They feel incomplete because they never get to that moment of revelation. "I HATE EVERYBODY" is just so fucking good, but it's all rising action. I keep waiting for the song to explode, and it never does. It stays right below the boiling point. I'm not saying that every song needs to be the most exciting goddamn thing ever, but if a song seems like it's leading up to that point and never does reach it, then I get blue balls.
There are slower/sparser songs here that are catchy in their own low-key way, like "Finally // beautiful stranger," or "You should be sad" (the latter with an almost cowboy-ish stomp that, again, never really reaches a climax, but the way she snarls the lyrics sure makes it seem like a climax anyway). Other songs are sparse but don't have much to talk about otherwise ("Forever... (is a long time)" for one), though these are exceptions, not rules.
There are also some interesting "interludes" with artists who have impacted Halsey creatively and personally. "Dominic's Interlude" sounds like something fun. would do, and I really like it, despite the fact that, yet again, there's no fucking payoff. "Alanis' Interlude" is only interesting because we all just spent a whole week earlier this month foaming at the mouth with Alanis Morissette praise, But yo, how are you going to feature Morissette and then make her seem like an afterthought? It's crazy.
So yeah, I really like this album, but I think that Halsey has an even better record in her somewhere. I said that about Maggie Rogers a year ago, but this feels different. Halsey feels even closer to creating an all-time great. The only thing that's holding her back is that she obviously feels obligated to work within the confines of current pop music. When I say she has potential, I'm saying that all she needs to do is to stop playing by these pop rules that I'm already bored with personally, and break the mold. She's so fucking close.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment