Wednesday, January 8, 2020

A Brief Forray into YouTube Nonsense


I feel like I just had a hallucinatory experience. I don't even know if it really happened.

Without going into specifics about my employment, I ended up keeping an eye on a ten-year-old and a one-year-old in a controlled environment at my office. I was with them for about 45 minutes while their actual temporary babysitter was on her break. All I had to do was sit on a chair and make sure that there were no emergencies. There weren't. The two kids sat on a cot the entire time I was in there and simply watched what was on the TV. They had YouTube connected to the screen. We watched a 30-minute YouTube video, and this is where I think I hallucinated. I have no fucking clue what I just watched.

Okay, that's an exaggeration. I was tangentially familiar with the type of video I was watching. I'm familiar with the idea of kids watching people play video games. Most boomers, already irked at the idea of their kids whiling away the hours playing video games themselves, are doubly upset to learn that kids these days now watch other people play video games.

My thoughts on the matter are of the live-and-let-live quality; like, whatever makes kids happy and keeps them out of trouble, I guess. Also, I'm quick to point out that these same boomers (and sure, plenty of my peers) are acolytes in the American tradition of professional football, and they sure as shit aren't actually playing the sport, they're just watching. Just because I don't like Minecraft enough to play it or watch other people play it, doesn't mean there's no value in experiencing that whole thing in whatever way you choose.

But I can't say I've ever actually sat down to watch someone else play one of these online video games until I was forced to via babysitting duties. And it was... wow. It was something else, folks.

I will describe it as best I can, and then I will try to find this video on YouTube, through whatever means possible.

Okay, so I made sure to note the author of this video. "Funneh" is her name. I had never heard of this person before, but when I googled her, I found out that she (a Canadian professional gamer) makes $10 million annual, just through her YouTube channel. Look, this isn't what this blog post is about. Do I especially enjoy the fact that some goober is playing video games and making more in one year than I'll ever see in my entire lifetime? Not really, but I'm accepting by this point that this is a fact of life. Good for her for finding a niche and especially for monetizing that niche. Seriously.

Apparently there were multiple people playing this video game at the same time, and their voices came were over the video. They provided narration to what you were seeing, and also made what some prepubescent teens may or may not consider "jokes." I am neither a comedian nor Funneh's intended audience, but I didn't laugh once at anything that was said, and I am definitely too old to remember a time in my life that I would've laughed at any of these Z-level jokes. But this isn't what this blog post is either; it's not a review. I don't know what it is, but it's not that.

And so these video game characters, as far as I could tell, were visiting a digital amusement park. They could buy things in this park for unknown purposes with coins of unknown origin. For instance, the first thing they did was enter a "VIP room" where the main character kept buying "points" to earn a spot on the "VIP wall." I don't know what this was all about. Was this a wall for pictures of people who spent the most money? Was this fake money or a real piece of her $10 million/year salary? I do not know, and they didn't explain it.

I guess I should figure out what game they were playing? They didn't explain that either, but here's my best guess—it was Roblox, which, according to Wikipedia, is a game in which "you can create your own games." So the video I watched was some gamers exploring a world that I guess another gamer had created? Which is a snake-eating-tale scenario that I'll definitely touch on after we get through this hallucination's description.

Mainly, our protagonists were moving through an amusement park of sorts. There were thrill rides that they all could ride together, including a seated spinning ride with the theme of "Swamp," and then a roller coaster with the theme of "Cursed Egyptian Cat Eye" (theme descriptions my own). And then there would be gift shops after these rides where the characters could purchase merchandise related to the ride, just like you would in real life.

And there was a pizza shop where you could buy pizza, and so they all bought a slice and sat at a table together and had their digital avatars eat together. Funneh stated at one point "I've never actually had pizza before," and I had no idea if she was indicating that her avatar had never eaten digital pizza, or if she herself had never eaten actual pizza. I don't know enough about any of this to be able to guess; maybe it is harsh to assume that someone is so wrapped up in video games that they've never eaten pizza? I don't know.

So that was it. This is what me and a ten-year-old and a two-year-old watched for 25 minutes. I'm currently sitting at my work desk, trying to find the exact video, and... oh fuck. The ItsFunneh YouTube channel has about 120 videos in the past TWO MONTHS alone. And I already feel embarrassed at the potential for a coworker to stroll by and see me paging through fucking Roblox videos. Ugh, give me a second.

Aha.



Holy shit, I did it! It took some creative googling (I had to put quotation marks around "funneh" and "swampy," the latter being the most unique word I could think of that could relate to this specific video). I mean, you can watch it if you want. You probably don't want to. That's okay, I'm not going to watch it either. I can't do it again.

Okay, so we talked about how I don't have a problem with people watching other people play video games—like, you read about "Esports," and how there are professional gamers who compete to win games, and those games are watched by thousands (millions? no idea) of fans. I have zero issues or concerns with that, because you can compare it to any other competition that people watch. Whether you yourself, i.e. the person reading this, whether you can watch and enjoy Overwatch is besides the point. I think that watching professional gymnastics is a bit silly and a bit boring, but I acknowledge that it is a legitimate sport, I acknowledge that my aunt is kinda nuts about it and watches the Olympics coverage at like three in the morning to witness it, and I acknowledge that she is certainly not alone in this endeavor.

But the crazy thing about Funneh and the video I watched is that this is completely separate from something like Overwatch or whatever. Roblox, as far as I could tell, was not any sort of competition. It was literally just video game characters running around a digital amusement park, doing the kind of shit that you'd do if you were at an actual, real amusement park—ride a roller coaster, eat a pizza (for the first time?!?!?!), hang out with friends, etc.

I'll even make this concession—playing Roblox might sound like it could be fun to play sometimes! I've had a blast playing RollerCoaster Tycoon in my youth, and there's no "competition" or "winning" in that game. You just build an amusement park. I'm not sure if I would personally have as much fun pretending to ride the coasters I built and talking with friends while I do it, but I can see why some people might enjoy that. I assume Funneh is a shut-in of some sort, and this is how she gets her social interactions. Great! Good for her! I'm not shitting on this.

So watching video game competitions is totally fine, and playing non-competitive video games is totally fine, in my opinion. But here's the rub when it comes to my experiences this morning: Watching someone passively playing a non-competitive video game just seems like a bridge too far for me.

I'm struggling with this question (struggling with both the answer, and the boomer-like implications of actually asking the question in the first place): What is the POINT of all this? How can anyone derive any pleasure from watching Funneh eat a digital slice of pizza? I can see living vicariously through a digital avatar, but for there to be an audience who is vicariously living through someone who herself is living vicariously through a digital avatar? There are too many levels of lameness. The logic is too thin for me to comprehend. I just fucking don't get it.

I guess you could play devil's advocate and say that it would be the same as watching, like, an episode of Friends. The stakes are low. It's digital comfort food. But even with the Friends example, as shitty as that show mostly is, at least there is a tangible purpose. Each episode has a plot or two. The characters have motivations. There are (ostensibly) jokes designed to make the audience laugh. The end of the episode has some kind of payoff that is designed to make the audience feel a certain way (satisfaction, sadness, humor).

This YouTube video featured NONE of that shit. It was a bunch of teenagers aimlessly wandering around a digital theme park. The characters were completely devoid of empathy or purpose. Neither I nor the young children watching it laughed once at anything that was said or done. The episode ended with Funneh asking you to like and subscribe. That was it.

So no, this isn't like a sitcom, any more than it is like a sport. Either it is nothing, or I just don't even know what it is at all.

As much as this shit pisses me off a little bit—mainly due to the fact that a two-year-old was watching this useless shit when he could've been doing literally anything else—it infinitely fascinates me as well. Finding out what people "like" and consider "good," and why they think this way, this is all an endless pursuit for me. In the same way I'm going to try to dig deep and figure out why a friend likes his/her favorite movie, or even self-reflect and think about what it says about me as a person when I like a certain song, I'm also so fucking curious about what made these kids tick.

These millions of kids, I should say, since just this particular YouTube video has 2.3 MILLION hits. What do they all see in the exploits of Funneh? What does it say about these two kids, holed up in an unfamiliar place, family life in flux, what does it say that they can find comfort in something that I find so appallingly benign?

I don't know. I don't know if I'll ever know. I couldn't ask the two kids I was hanging out with (something told me that it wasn't the time and the place in their lives for adult skepticism, ya feel me?). I would love for someone to enlighten me. I probably won't be doing a "Your Favorite YouTube Video" series anytime soon, so you're going to have to reach out to me on your own.

1 comment:

sunny said...

You sound like an anthropologist who landed on another planet, bedazzled by a new species and their strange customs.

I've uhh, also struggled/wondered many of the things you do in this post. I regret watching even the 20 seconds of the video you linked, but I can't argue with 2.7 million views right?

I (semi shamefully) watch Twitch/Esports from time to time. Like you said, there's some competition of skill/thought in playing Overwatch, even if the degree is much different from football or chess. And some good can come of it -- there's an annual speedrun marathon going on right now that raised over $2MM for cancer research last year... so that's good right? (self-justifying maybe)

Anyway, all that's to say even I don't get this bleeding edge trend (that seems to align with tweens) of watching people just hanging out in virtual spaces.

Part of this, to me, is clarified from the uptick in Parasocial relationships. Of course these have existed for decades through TV and mass media. Still, the technology of modern media providing pseudo-interaction (like comment and subscribe, bitches!) and an increasingly isolating society within 'meatspace' has accelerated the appeal of these constructs.

Folks our age are probably more aligned to Podcasts to get their Parasocial hit. I mostly bring this aside up 'cause I know you hate podcasts and to link this meme I find eternally funny: https://i.redd.it/2302x89w2e8y.jpg

The sad part is that kids are probably even more susceptible and feel all this even more acutely than adults.

And then, of course, there's the YouTube algorithm that pushes several kinda-popular things to be a few super-mega popular to help sate advertisers, investors, and *dingding* capitalism.