Tuesday, January 7, 2020

Top Five Tuesday: Sesame Street Characters

We've made it a habit of making Top Five lists throughout the past decade or so on Puke on Your Birthday, but I'd like to start making it a true weekly column. We start with a subject that I know EVERY SINGLE FUCKING READER cares deeply about, as we rank the best characters from a television show for very young children. (P.S. As tempted as I will be to fill these Top Five lists with music week in and week out, I will do my best to restrain myself. Look for a music list maybe once a month, twice at most.)

Top Five Best Sesame Street Characters

5. Gonger

The "Monster Foodies" segments that occasionally play on Sesame Street are—no joke—some of my favorite television in general right now. Gonger is goofy as shit, pronounces words in a more ridiculous fashion than any other Sesame character (and the bar is pretty fucking high already), but still knows his shit. Utterly delightful.

4. Murray

I can see a case being made for Murray being annoying, just because he seems sometimes to literally know nothing about anything. But that's the whole point. Murray is a vessel for the kids watching to learn whatever he is learning. And Murray learns that shit with a strong sense of curiosity and wonder that I hope my kids can emulate eventually.

3. Nina

hot

2. Elmo

It's such a fucking hipster thing to say that Sesame Street was "ruined" when Elmo rose to prominence as its star character. I'll argue that he rose to the top of the cast for a reason. Elmo is friendly with everyone. He's not smart, but he shows a willingness to learn, and a humility when he's wrong or ignorant. Also, Elmo's eyes get crossed (like, literally) when he is confused or surprised, and it's hilarious. If you hate Elmo, you are missing the whole goddamn point of Sesame Street.

1. Cookie Monster

All that being said about Elmo, I personally feel like Cookie Monster owns this show, and that's simply because he's straight up the funniest character here. I'm saying that as an adult, of course; I don't necessarily expect a six-year-old to appreciate Cookie's crack comedic timing. But I'll always appreciate the humor he provides around the edges of this show, and how he gives me something to enjoy while the kids are learning their shit.



(Sidenote: let Cookie Monster's ranking be vindication for being unjustly slurred a decade ago.)


I won't be doing two lists every week, but I have enough to say about Sesame Street that I can fill out a worst characters list as well. So enjoy the following, in which I yell and curse about puppets.

Top Five Worst Sesame Street Characters

5. Snuffleupagus

It's probably for the best that they ended the old bit from the '70s in which only Big Bird ever saw Snuffy, and everyone thought Big Bird was losing his mind when he babbled on about a big snouted creature that supposedly roamed Sesame Street. That shit was uncomfortable. But even now that Snuffleupagus definitively exists, he's still a creepy character. Is his voice affected in some way? Like, it sounds like the voice actor is speaking through a broken voice box. I dunno. Fuck this guy.

4. Telly

Telly is clearly a fifty-year-old man pretending to be a child monster, right? Like, Telly should not be playing superhero make-believe with Elmo and Abby, et al. Telly is a predator.

3. Mr. Noodle

not hot

2. Rudy

A dumb shit who talks like he is constantly swallowing tobacco spit. I wish his big sister Abby would zippity-zap him into oblivion.

1. Grover

This was an absolute shocker to me when I first started watching Sesame Street with Willow. Grover is a fucking asshole! Really, the only prior experience I had with Grover was through Muppet Family Christmas, when he drops a good spoon joke and is gracious when he receives a Fraggle Rock from Robin and that's pretty much it. So I don't know if Grover has always been like this, or this is a recent development, but yo, Grover sucks ass.

Plenty of the Sesame Street characters are ignorant on a wide variety of topics, and that makes sense, because kids are typical ignorant on a wide variety of subjects too, and when the monster is humble and willing to learn (Murray, Elmo, etc.), it can make for a great experience for the audience. But Grover is not that. The dude is fucking ignorant, and such an asshole through the context of his obvious ignorance. He's the type of little shit who THINKS he knows everything, and brags about how much he knows, even though it's been proven time and again how little he really grasps in this world. It's fucking infuriating. FUCK GROVER FOREVER.

No comments: