Wednesday, January 15, 2020

This Is My Blood: Duck-Rabbit Schwarzbier

a dark picture for a dark beer
We all know the aphorism of "Looks can be deceiving." We can, of course, apply this aphorism to beer tasting. Think back to how the senses of taste and aroma are linked to a primitive part of the brain, and that's why those sensations are tough to put into words. Now think about vision—it's a sense that is connected to higher-powered sections of the brain. Knowing too that all the senses are connected and can get quite muddled, you can understand that the act of seeing something is going to fuck with your other senses.

Mosher takes great pleasure in bashing wine tasters in his book (it's a great ongoing bit), and he describes how wine judges were given tart white wines dyed red with food dye, and a lot of them were able to taste berries, even though there was no actual berry taste. They were tricked by what they saw! Credit where it's due, Mosher also turns the mirror to his fellow beer tasters, because we are not any better. Apparently, before the craft beer revolution, brewers would just add caramel-colored food dye to pilsners to make their black IPAs? There was no roastiness in the flavor, but drinkers saw the color and tasted the roastiness anyway. That's fucked up!

There are plenty of other things to see that fuck with our other senses besides color. The type of glass matters too; the fancier the glass, the better a beer tastes. This made me think about our trip to Ireland a couple years ago, and how every type of beer had its own particularly branded glass. It was the case at every single bar! Did drinking Guinness out of a certified Guinness glass make the Guinness taste better? Probably!

You can also get tricked by just reading a word. If a beer has the word "salt" on the bottle, you're probably going to taste salt, even if there isn't any salt in there. I would love to say I'm above this trickery, but I've been reading BeerAdvocate.com for most of these beers, and I'd be lying if I said that my taste and my impression wasn't affected by what I read.

We are social creatures, and whether we try to or not, there is a natural tendency to assimilate with the herd. If someone tells us that a beer is good, then we're more likely to think that beer is good, because we just wanna fit in, ya know? That's how it goes. All we can do when attempting to taste beer and figure it the fuck out is to collect impressions, and then later categorize those impressions. Most importantly, we can just be open to new experiences. (I'm pretty comfortable with that last point.)

Enter today's beer, Duck-Rabbit Craft Brewery's Schwarzbier. I chose this out of the fridge because it was literally label as "black lager," so it was clear that the color was important to this brewer. Sure enough, pouring the beer (into a nice beer glass, for what it's worth) revealed its inky black color.

Here's the interesting thing, though—it didn't really taste the way it looked, if that makes sense. The beer had a light body, and was almost sour in taste. Had I been blindfolded (as Mosher suggests), I think I would've assumed this was a medium brown color, at most. I certainly would've assumed a creamy texture and a roasty taste just based on the color alone.

This is interesting to me, because Mosher put me on guard with that faking-dark-beers-with-food-coloring fable. I cannot claim that I have any evidence that Duck-Rabbit created an artifice with their dark beer by adding artificial bullshit, because there are many different avenues to create any given color, not all of them devious. I think I'm just confused by the dark color, is all. Looks can be deceiving. They deceived me here.

NOTES

BEER: Schwarzbier

GENRE: German Schwarzbier

ABV: 5.8%

BREWED BY: The Duck-Rabbit Craft Brewery [A note, I guess, about why this brewery's name is in the title, whereas other brewery names are left out of other blog posts. I'll include the brewery's name only if I need to distinguish the beer from other commonly named beers. If a beer doesn't have a name besides the genre of beer, then I'll need to specify. This happened with the Poplar Pils and Sour Rosé too, and it'll happen again I'm sure.]

LOCATION: Farmville, North Carolina

PURCHASED AT: Port Richmond Bottle Shop @ IGA

PRICE (AT THAT LOCATION): $2

PAIRED WITH: Mediterranean salmon and broccoli (Pam is the pickiest eater on the planet, and left 1/3 of her salmon on the plate)

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5

BEER COUNT: I'm going to start keeping track of all the beers I've had this year down at the bottom of each entry, now that it's getting a little more complicated than exactly one beer every day, and it's important to keep in mind my hard limit of 550 drinks in 2020. For instance, last Saturday, I had four Hamm's total. And now today, I had an extra beer when I was interviewing Jim about his favorite movie of all time (coming soon!). So the Duck-Rabbit Schwarzbier was #18 of the year, and the—ahem—Pabst Blue Ribbon Extra I had was #19. Yes, PBR has a "heavy" version of their signature beer. No, I will not be writing about it.

No comments: