Wednesday, January 15, 2020

The Albums That Matter: Bay Dream

[In July 2020, Culture Abuse lead singer David Kelling was accused of sexual misconduct with at least one underage girl. These allegations were made by his bandmates, and the band dissolved. As is the case any time this type of allegation comes to light, I do not listen to Culture Abuse anymore. They have been deleted from my iPod. While this particular blog post has been deleted from the archives, I'm keeping it up for posterity. Let this editor's note serve as a trigger warning if needed.]

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe runs through every album on his iPod, mostly in alphabetical order, and offers some brief thoughts. Check out previous columns HERE.


Bay Dream
Culture Abuse
2018

I hope it doesn't seem like I write this column because I want to prove I know a lot about music. On the contrary! I don't know shit! And so I use The Albums That Matter as an excuse to learn something new about a band or an album that I wouldn't care enough to know otherwise. We can learn together!

Culture Abuse is a band that has totally changed for me while listening and preparing to write this. For instance, I had no fucking clue that the lead singer of Culture Abuse, David Kelling, has cerebral palsy. This made me subsequently realize a few things.

One, I didn't really have a grip on what exactly cerebral palsy even was. To Wikipedia! Cerebral palsy is a movement disorder, caused by abnormal development in the part of the brain that controls movement, balance, and posture. Typical symptoms are poor coordination, stiff muscles, weak muscles, and tremors. If you've ever seen Breaking Bad (who hasn't?!), this is the disease that affects Walt Jr.

Two, I couldn't really think of another band that I listened to with a physically challenged person in it. Seriously, think about it! Besides the empathy that comes with reading interviews with Kelling, where he talks about the various challenges he faces being handicapped (not too many ramps leading to venue stages out there), there's the realization that his cerebral palsy makes his perspective really unique in the indie rock world.

For me, the cynical listener, the whole cerebral palsy reveal really unlocked a whole new appreciation for Culture Abuse. Bay Dream contains a ton of optimism that originally seemed a little out of place, ya know what I mean? It's like, who's that positive these days? It almost came off as lame. But now I'm thinking that the optimism was earned. To be in constant pain and to have people assume you are drunk and to have to cling to the microphone on stage like it's a crutch just to perform, I can't imagine it's all that easy to maintain a healthy attitude about the world. And yet here's David Kelling, singing about what makes him feel good, and about being kind to everyone. What first appeared to be sophomoric now shows itself to be seasoned with life experience and challenges overcome.

You should know too that Bay Dream is a pleasant little punk rock album. Kelling sings like Joey Ramone if the Ramones shelled out for legit singing lessons, and it's pretty soothing, overall. It's catchy indie rock at its most simplistic. Again, it was probably not going to be anything to write home about, but then you discover this entire other universe when you do even the most basic research. Thank god for The Albums That Matter.

If this sounds interesting, try this song: "S'Why"

Stray Observations
  • Here are some interviews that I read to learn more about Kelling and about Culture Abuse: The Quietus; L.A. Record; The Guardian; Upset Magazine; a few others.
  • That last one is probably the most interesting. Not only do they call this album a "cruising record," which is just fucking perfect, but also, they don't mention the cerebral palsy once. Am I doing a disservice to the band by using the physical disability at the crux of my essay above? I'm not sure.
  • It's very interesting to read in some of these interviews that Culture Abuse was or is maybe still a "hardcore band." I am not familiar with the band's first two albums. I guess this was a departure?
  • ALBUM TITLE: It's also interesting to read in the interviews Kellings' thoughts on his hometown of San Francisco. It's a pretty expensive place to live, and a few times he mentions the shit apartments and warehouses that the band members have lived in and shared because they couldn't afford anything else. That's where the title comes in—they all love the Bay area, and they dream that it'll get better soon.
  • ALBUM COVER: That also ties in with the cover art, which is pretty simple block lettering. Inside the title, there are colors that evoke thoughts of the west coast, and also a chain link fence, perhaps alluding to the feeling of being "fenced in" by San Francisco's growth and change (Kelling refers multiple times to the "techie fucks" who have invaded the city). Also, at the bottom, there's a smiley face, telling you that, yeah, this is going to try to be a positive experience, despite the fences and whatnot.
  • That "Be Kind" ethos almost tips into parody with the song "Bee Kind to the Bugs." Maybe it's better if we don't think of it literally as a song about being nice to ants and spiders, but rather just a general message of "be kind no matter what, even in ridiculous situations."
  • This tweet made me love the band even more. There are many ways to spread positivity, and this is one of my favorite.
  • CHART PERFORMANCE: Clearly, this album didn't get anywhere near Billboard or the Grammys or anything like that—not a knock, just the way the world is. But it did get an honorable mention on PoYB's 2018 Best Songs list! Woohoo!
  • It's definitely worth checking out some videos of Culture Abuse performing live. Not only do you get to see how Kellings pulls off the frontman duties with cerebral palsy (ably, I'll add), but also you get to hear what Culture Abuse would sound like if they were actually hardcore. Here's one from February 2019. What's up with the vocal change? Is it a matter of studio vs. live vocals, and all that that entails? Did Kellings smooth out his voice purposefully on the album to convey the optimism? I'm not complaining either way—both vocal stylings are interesting in their own ways.
  • Would Walt Jr.—ahem, I mean Flynn—listen to Culture Abuse? I don't think Breaking Bad ever really got into what type of music he was into. I could see him trying to get into way shittier punk bands because that what his shitty friend Louis liked, and he wanted to seem cool.

NEXT TIME: Be the Cowboy by Mitski

No comments: