New song, just like the old songs.
"New Song"
The Who
from Who Are You
1978
Those synths, man. They are something. They feel like something out of Disney's Tomorrowland, an erstwhile vision of the future that has soured like milk, and yet is also kind of interesting the more you think about it. How could one band have been so wrong about where music was headed? Could the Who have really thought that the meowing synth tones were cool in the late 1970s?
A lot about the Who probably didn't seem cool at the end of the decade. Punk rock was coming into fashion, and the Who were aging out. I almost wonder if their way of pushing back against the punk ride tide was to purposefully go in the opposite direction. With the synths, they pretty much predicted '80s hair metal, which I'll also have to go ahead and consider cool, that idea of being prognosticators, even if the sound itself turned out to the corniest shit imaginable.
More so than being just uncool, Who Are You was practically a nail in the coffin in some respects. And no, I'm not talking about the fact that the final track on Who Are You, the title track, is one of the worst songs of all time (though if anyone was wondering about whether the Who were cool still, that must have immediately dispelled the notion). I'm talking about the fact that Keith Moon OD'd about a month after the album's release.
The Who isn't the Who without Keith Moon, no matter how much Daltrey might try to convince you otherwise. The Who was barely even the Who during the recording sessions for Who Are You, when Moon was so deep into his alcoholism that he had trouble lifting the drum sticks. (The infamous "Not to Be Taken Away" on the cover of Who Are You wasn't actually a grim prediction, but rather it was placed there to hide Moon's huge beer belly.) Heading in the wrong direction, the Who finally came upon a dead end.
Moon's last words are allegedly: "If you don't like it, you can fuck off!" That's the thing, though. I actually really, really like this album (again, save for the title track), and I think "New Song" is an excellent opener to another classic Who album, synths and all.
A lot of the songs here were apparently rescued from the abandoned Lifehouse project that had imploded almost a decade prior (most of which became Who's Next in 1971), and it shows. These are songs rescued from a rock opera, with all the bombast that comes with such a premise. The epic "Sister Disco," for instance, has a electrical fiddle-type part that is akin to "Baba O'Reilly." So that's what's good with all the synths, even though it feels strange too, having all these songs awash with synths outside of the context of the next great rock opera.
Which I guess to a certain degree makes "New Song" an ironic title, no? Since it was at this point—a band trending downward, feeling old, and literally dying—that maybe the Who really did need a new song. But "New Song" is the same old song for this band. The Who reacts to their impending extinction by hunkering down and doing what they do and did and have always done best. There's courage to find in such a reaction.
Because we—you and me—now stand on the precipice of a brand new year ourselves, with all the uncertainty that comes with living in such a time in history, and it might be time to start thinking whether we need a "new song" as well. What will your reaction to the trials and tribulations of 2022 be? Dig in and hold strong? Crumble and die on Harry Nilsson's couch? Wield the figurative synth like a sword and say "bring it on"?
"I write the same old song you heard a good few times / Admit you really want to hear it." There's fear in uncertainty, and yet we face this new song anyway. Happy new year, everyone.
No comments:
Post a Comment