My first thought was that it was weird that we were reading an oral history of a movie for a book club. My main concern is that we'd be tempted to talk about the movie exclusively. Especially since the movie in question is Dazed and Confused, which I have historically had a lot to say about.
This is our thirteenth book club meeting, however, and I know these guys, and at no point was I concerned that we wouldn't have a lot to talk about. It's a short, breezy book, but there's lots of depths to plumb here. I promised naysayers (okay, Nate, who won't even be at the meeting today) that I would prove it by writing a list of 100 questions to bring to the table for our conversation. Let's see if I can get there.
100 Book Club Discussion Points for Melissa Maerz's Alright, Alright, Alright: The Oral History of Richard Linklater's Dazed and Confused
- What is the significance of the title? We all know it's McConaughey's famous line in the movie, but why is that chosen for the title of the oral history of the movie?
- Why did the book start with a description of Richard Linklater's house burning down?
- Richard Linklater is described as "opposed to the very idea of" nostalgia, and yet is the "master of exploring" it. What was he trying to do with Dazed and Confused? Does the book itself have a similar goal?
- Linklater says that he wants to prove that the '70s sucked. Did he succeed?
- Do the '70s suck? Why or why not?
- What does it mean to say that a decade "sucks"? Can we only judge decades that we live through?
- When you think about high school, what do you remember?
- Does Dazed and Confused remind you of high school?
- In what ways does the book underline the connection between high school and a movie about high school?
- "You act like you're so oppressed, but you guys are the kings of the school." Do we see our younger years through rose-colored glasses?
- "Old people in your face, fucking with who you are." Is having that distrust of authority in one's youth necessary? Does Dazed and Confused make that argument? Does the book?
- Is Dazed and Confused a comedy?
- A Huntsville alum, Lydia Headley, says that she saw the hazing scenes as "not a comedy." Is Dazed and Confused a comedy? Is it supposed to be?
- A throughline in the discussion about how this is based on real life Huntsville, TX in the 1970s is how a lot of the characters came from poverty or near-poverty. Does that come through in the movie?
- What do we make of Linklater's decision to transfer schools senior year to play baseball in Houston? Did he "abandon" his team?
- Do the characters have an opinion on the matter?
- In that vein, could the characters in the movie be described as representative of Linklater's often conflicting internal thoughts?
- Linklater gives off a "self-made man" vibe. Is that important to consider?
- Is Austin a "character" in the film, even though it takes place in an Austin suburb?
- Is it important to know Linklater's Austin roots when considering the movie? The book?
- Is "work" something you need to love? Or is what you love always separate from work?
- Linklater saying "you actually had to talk to somebody" sounds like boomer nostalgia for sure. Is this man nostalgic or what?
- Maybe he refused to admit that he's nostalgic even though he clearly is?
- Or is he separating his art from his life?
- Is separating even possible with such a personal film?
- How important is the idea of "unreliable narrator" in this book?
- What is the funniest example of unreliable narrator or A/B contradictions in the book? (Is it when the Butthole Surfers chick claims that she wasn't paid for Slackers, and Linklater immediately and indignantly refutes the claim?)
- Was Dazed and Confused an "unpitchable" movie? Why or why not?
- What makes a movie pitchable?
- Why do we give a fuck about pitches?
- Can a movie work without an antagonist?
- Can a movie work without a plot, or a very slim one?
- Does the book have a protagonist? Or is it like Dazed in that way?
- Did Dazed and Confused prove anything? Would the filmmakers agree or disagree?
- What is "Slacker punk spirit"? Why was that important to have?
- Is hindsight 20/20, or did producer Tom Pollock actually think that he had "a lot of young stars" in the cast?
- Is it important to consider "could have been" actors and actresses? E.g. Vince Vaughn almost playing O'Bannion. Does this amount to puffed up trivia, or is there something deeper here?
- Ties into the discussion about whether Claire Danes should have gotten a role in Dazed and Confused—why is that still a regret for the casting agent, years later?
- Why is it important to consider that the casting agent (allegedly) told Joey Lauren Adams that she "didn't have the tits to play Shavonne"?
- Another unreliable narrator moment, is this the funniest? "I've never worn underwear." Was this McConaughey being funny, or is that really true?
- He says that the story of him meeting casting agent Don Phillips has three parts: "What Don said, what he said I said, and what really happened." Is that true of all oral histories? Should we take everything anyone says with a grain of salt?
- The urban legend of McConaughey being "picked up off the street" to become an actor is denied by all parties involved here. It's theorized that the general public wants to believe such stories because they want to believe that they too can be plucked out of obscurity to become an actor. It's wish fulfillment. If it can happen to McConaughey, than why not me?
- Did you learn anything significant from reading this book? (For me, the big one is Jason Lee's involvement.)
- How did you feel about Anthony Rapp's loneliness in the book? Was there homophobic vibes or just an "Austin is for weirdos" vibe?
- Where was Jason O. Smith? Is there any connection between his non-involvement and Linklater's "one black guy" theory?
- Did any oral history subjects come off differently than you'd imagined? (Willy Wiggins came off as lovably square.)
- Where do we fall on the decades discussion? Where Cynthia says, "Well the '50s were boring" etc. How does that tie in with the juxtaposition of Linklater's view of the '70s vs. the actors' view of the '70s from their teenage vantage point in the '90s?
- Method acting is talked about a lot in the book. Some people deny it. Some people admit it. Some people use it as an excuse for shitty behavior. Where do we stand on method acting? (E.g. Parker Posey saying that her bitchy behavior was method acting; e.g. Nicky Katt explicitly comparing some of the behavior to Jared Leto's.)
- Linklater says that his directing style is "I want to empower you to collaborate with me." That kind of reminded me of something they press upon us in certain social work classes. Could this mindset be applied to any type of work? Or only specific kind of work?
- Affleck: "There are filmmakers who really believe that suffering is tied to good art, and maybe they have a point. But what I saw in Rick was, that wasn’t the only way to do it. It could be collaborative. It could be respectful. It could be joyful." What do we make of the suffering vs. joy discussion?
- There was a lot of "us vs. them" in the book, mainly concerning the cast and director vs. "the 80-year-old assholes with cell phones." Was that narrative necessary in the book? Did it propel the book's "plot" like it propelled the movie's "plot"?
- Or did it seem like Linklater himself thought he needed that on set, so as to inspire the actors who were portraying similar type characters? If so, was it conscious or subconscious?
- Did the author need to justify the "young romance" chapter in the intro by underlying the fact that this was all "innocent" because of Me Too? Was it comforting to read about young dumb romances in that context, or did any of it still come off as icky?
- Did that chapter have some of the best unreliable narrator stuff?
—When someone says that Linklater was sleeping around: "What the fuck is she talking about?!"
—Adam: "It would be funny if you A/B'd me and Cole, I bet he's not talking to his shrink about sexual tension between him and Michelle." Cole: "Oh yeah, Michelle was my chick the whole time."
—Rory: "She probably thinks I'm a kid." Joey: "He's such a sweet kid!" - Who is the most like their character (method acting or otherwise)? Least?
- How well does Ben Affleck come off in this book? Very smart and professional, in my opinion: "...and I'd watch them add dialogue and make it better. I'd always thought the ideal was, you have a scene and you try to get as close to that scene as you can. And here they were, like, 'No, forget about that. Just take the scene and make the actual scene itself better.' That was revolutionary to me."
- Is the whole thing about Shawn Andrews literally the only time everyone agrees about something in this book? Would the book improved with his input, or is it better/funnier that everyone is beating up on him and he has no say in it?
- Did Jim Jacks' death prior to the oral history free people up to say whatever they wanted about him? Do we believe the stories of his "bullying behavior"?
- How indicative of everyone's view of their own childhood is the quote "It's incredible no one got hurt"?
- Is the darkest moment of unreliable narrator / he-said-she-said when Ben Affleck is trying to justify actually smacking the freshman in the ass with a paddle? Does he deserve the jeers that he got from that?
- And is there any truth to the explanation that "everyone is exaggerating now based on my celebrity status" (paraphrasing)?
- "The fuck police" — there can't be any truth to the idea that people who would watch Dazed and Confused would be turned off by the language, right?
- Is this just one part of the overall argument here, and everywhere, of "Finance vs. Art"?
- How hypocritical is it that the studio wanted less cursing, but more nudity? What does Dazed and Confused say about America's values?
- There's a discussion about how the idea of "sex" in high school is more innocent than movies typically portray is as, i.e. "high school wasn't about sex, it was about making out." Is that true (both about movies typically and more broadly about high school in general)?
- Is there any truth to the theory, then, that my own historical tendency to prefer making out with women at bars is preferable to having sex has something to do with a subconscious and rather sad attempt at a prolonged adolescence?
- What do we make of the comparisons to Fast Times at Ridgemont High? I've always hated the comparisons.
- I suppose there are some dark undercurrents in Dazed that I don't often focus on during repeat viewings, so my argument of "Dazed characters are by and large good people, and Fast Times characters are by and large bad people" holds less water than I've traditionally thought. What do we make of that argument? Does the argument even matter?
- How do we feel about this Parker Posey quote: "This pitting [women] against [one another]. It's constant and it's catty. Do I think men like to see that? Yes. Do I think women play into that? Yes. When will this dialogue get so boring to the point of getting back to [something more] interesting and human?"? Re: the actresses bickering about their relationships, both then and now.
- Can filmmaking be seen as a form of personal growth? Literally or metaphorically?
- There is a discussion about the "I keep getting older, they stay the same age" line. Affleck alludes to Me Too. Linklater says that the line is on purpose, that there really are people like this, and that it's supposed to be sad and creepy. What do we make of the line?
- Is there room to be uncomfortable with it, or does the idea of a film provide a buffer between Wooderson's beliefs and your own beliefs so that they don't necessarily have to butt heads?
- Something new I learned: the moon tower was chosen as a setting because it is a believable light source, which is not something I would've ever considered, despite the fact that I mostly did my woods drinking as a teenager in complete darkness. What other moviemaking aspects of this book would be beneficial to point out to those like myself, who is not film savvy?
- What is the lesson to be learned from the tale of Milla and Shawn? Or is it just two idiot teenagers being idiot teenagers?
- Is the climax of the film the "just keep livin'" monologue? Was it meant to be then, or do you think it is just considered so now in retrospect?
- Bill Wise describes the line as "empty sloganeering," but McConaughey believes that it is a fundamental truth. Which is it? Can it be both? Does the line say more about the movie, about Wooderson, or about McConaughey?
- Why did all the Austin actors drop out of school after filming? Does this have to do with endings leaving gaping holes in your soul?
- Would this movie have been better or worse with some of the described cut scenes? Which would have added the most?
- How much does the "testing preview" thing reek of Hollywood bullshit? Do you think Linklater was right to tie it into the "self-serving Hollywood parasites throwing people under the bus" theory?
- Steve Hyden: "Music is an instant personality kit to put on while you try to figure out who you are." Is that true of the characters? Is that true of us?
- Should we "throw out previous generations' music"? Or do you agree with Gen Z that any musical style is okay to plunder and change?
- Do we agree with Hyden that music acts as a "greek chorus" in the film? The "Hurricane" thing seems spot on, but any other example I could come up with seems like a stretch.
- Is the funniest line in the book Linklater describing Robert Plant as "a construction worker with a good voice"?
- No one making the movie thought it was a "drug movie" and yet audiences think it's a drug movie. Not saying it is, I'm asking about audience perception. Do we have a right to that decision or should we let the author live?
- Is it inevitable that marketing is going to have so much say regarding the success or failure of a movie? Is there any way to escape that inevitability?
- Where do we stand on Linklater's "Dazed Diaries"? Was that the right thing to do? Is he a hypocrite for throwing people under the bus, or was it justified? Is this just another collision of art and commerce?
- Are those lawsuits as dumb as they sound on paper? Or is there any veracity to them whatsoever?
- What can we say about the fact that some of these actors found great success after Dazed, and some went back to living in obscurity? Is this just how Hollywood works? How life works?
- Is there any implication that such a story—that the best days really are behind you—is important for this group of artists who tried to portray that story (of the beginning of such a story) on film?
- The movie became a cult classic because of word-of-mouth. Could this book be such a phenomenon as well? Or is the cat already out of the bag?
- Why is it said that this movie resonated with "young men" specifically? Does that have any connection with why this book was chosen today?
- There was also an implication that lots of people were getting high while watching the film. Assuming that's true, then why? My friends and I (two different groups, actually), when we were younger, concentrated on getting drunk while watching it. This seems like more of a beer-drinking movie, no? Or is it actually a pot-smoking movie?
- A sequel would ruin it, right? (e.g. McConaughey: "it's already perfect as is.")
- People think of this movie as "theirs." It's a personal experience. I felt that way. Is there any risk of reading this book, realizing that plenty of people feel that way, and realizing that it isn't as personal as one might have hoped? Or can you still hold onto that feeling despite the truth?
- Is the idea of nostalgia the main point here (both film and book)?
- Do people who had never seen it before this week feel a nostalgia for a time past when they watch it?
- Is Kevin Smith right when he says about movies in general: "We can't pick what a movie is. The audience decides."?
- Does the film change for you as you get older, or could it from here on out? ("But then you watch it as you get older, and you realize the stakes are so much grander. It’s like: Will life ever get as good as this? Will I ever know people as well as I knew the people I knew in high school? Will I ever think about the coming summer with a sense of hope again?")
- Is self-mythologizing a good thing?
- "If I ever start referring to these as the best days of my life, remind me to kill myself." Are we missing the point if we the audience decide that Dazed and Confused is a nostalgic film?
Alright you guys, see you in three hours at Ray's Happy Birthday Bar.
No comments:
Post a Comment