I've been thinking about crossdressing. I feel like it might be inappropriate to actually go through with it (or at least make public whatever I choose to do in private), since I am straight and cisgender. It wouldn't be right to presume that I'd be welcome in what I assume is an LGBTQ safe space via the world of drag, and I also don't want it to seem like I'm taking lightly any concerns in the transgender community specifically, or using my privilege to do things that other people may not have the luxury of being comfortable doing. I don't want to appropriate.
Still, it's something I've thought about recently. I've never in my life felt "hot." Like, I've never seen myself in the mirror and said, "damn, that's hot." I would like to feel that way. I'm a little jealous of women for more often having the opportunities to feel that way. To dress up and look good and feel good. I think any inclination I'd have to crossdress would be in service of these thoughts. I.e., could I feel that way about myself if I wore a cute dress?
I have to imagine Lindsey Jordan felt hot when she posed for the cover photo of Valentine, right? I don't know her, and I don't know if she usually wears fancy clothing that presents as male, or if she just feels more comfortable dressing however she damn pleases, or if she's like me and it amounts to not much more than a passing (but intriguing) thought, but regardless—she looks confident as hell, and that's hot.
What I do know is that Lindsey Jordan, a.k.a. Snail Mail, would be incredibly uncomfortable with me thinking about her in this context. Not because of who I am, but because of who she strives to be. She strives to be a musician first. She has stated in the past that being held up as a woman musician or an LGBTQ musician basically amounts to tokenism. She says that none of her songs are about being a woman or about being gay, so why should it matter to us, the audience, what her gender or her sexuality are?
True words, and I respect them and validate them. But then if that's true, I am forced to consider her music only, and when I do so, I don't really have many positive things to say.
I'm not saying that Valentine is a bad album. It's good. It's fine. It has its moments. That title track? Oh lord, that's some good shit. I can pick out some other bits and pieces and put 'em in between the m-dashes if you want—the keyboard tones on "Forever (Sailing)" that remind me of Caroline Rose; the "we're not really talking now" chorus on "Madonna"; when she says "raise your voice" and her voice cracks on "Ben Franklin"; the pure vitriol of the line "I'm like your dog"—but the overall assessment is that this is some pretty basic and occasionally bland and incredibly boilerplate indie rock music.
I feel the same way I've felt about Mike Krol and Free Throw and Hiatus Kiayote and Fastball and William DeVaughn, just in 2021 alone—all artists that I liked overall, but were trending so rapidly toward average that I couldn't help but be bored. Snail Mail is absolutely fine. I'd almost rather it be bad than be fine.
That's why I'm way more interested in Lindsey Jordan herself than in the music she creates. It's a self-defense mechanism for me. If I can imagine that she is the type of person who knows exactly who she is, and who she wants to be, and who she can be, then maybe she becomes somebody I can admire, separate from the music.
Because, just like everyone else, I'm still trying to figure out who I am. I know most of it, but there are still some blanks, still some thoughts that cross my mind that make me take pause, like, okay now what does that mean?
Honestly, that's exciting. Self-discovery is exciting as fuck. If I knew exactly who I was and who I wanted to be 100% of the time, we'd call that "being in a rut." We'd call that "listening to Valentine," maybe. Because I know sure as shit that Valentine is just fine and consequentially a little boring. I don't want that in my life. I want to try on dress and feel hot. I want to listen to music that surprises me. Valentine did nothing for me.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment