Thursday, December 2, 2021

2021 in Review: Top 20 Songs


Gotta be real with y'all: I'm probably gonna put even less effort into this list than I did for yesterday's list. Sorry! You're lucky homework didn't make me implode before I could rank anything at all!
 
(There is a Spotify playlist if you'd prefer to explore the songs that way!)

Top 20 Songs of 2021

 
"We did our best, but what does that really mean?" Courtney Barnett's sardonic wit usually doesn't cut this deep, especially when she gets in jangly guitar rocker mode. But man, the short time I've spent with this song convinces me that she knows my end-of-semester blues better than anyone else in my life right now.
 
19. "Angel of Death" by Manchester Orchestra
 
I could see the argument that Manchester Orchestra sounds uncomfortably close to generic festival rock. I really could close my eyes and see myself at my very first festival, listening to them belt those towering choruses. But that's backwards. Manchester Orchestra aren't stooping lower; every other goddamn festival rock band only wishes to scale these heights, and their failed attempts shouldn't sully M.O.'s name.

18. "Out Loud" by Remember Sports
 
If the bulk of my Remember Sports fandom has been me expressing my appreciation for how tightly they can pack a hook into a quick two-minute package, then imagine my delight when the best song on their newest album ends up being the one where they stretch their legs and allow the hooks to sprawl over a length close to seven minutes.

17. "Girl Is a Gun" by Halsey
 
Halsey's new album hit me in some pretty uncomfortable parts of my psyche this year, but that was mostly to do with theme, and not makeup. Overall, I was glad to have the insane Nine Inch Nails-inspired (and practically NIN-created) "Girl Is a Gun" to distract me with the loud noises.
 
16. "Stop Making This Hurt" by Bleachers
 
Oh gosh, the whole "Is Jack Antonoff actually good?" argument is one that I will never tire of. Perhaps the answer is both yes and no. Perhaps he can have a hand in possibly the most disappointing album of the last five years and then also sneak in some real fucking bangers around the edges of his discography. "Stop Making This Hurt" is one such example of the latter, one that is so tasty that I can't help but think that, despite all the evidence to the contrary, Jack Antonoff's legacy is secure.
 
15. "Fewer Afraid" by the World Is a Beautiful Place & I Am No Longer Afraid to Die

Look, I don't know this band from any other goddamn emo band on this planet. Apparently they are marquee names; I'll take your word for it. I know that such a name carries the implication that maybe this is a crew that bites off more than they can chew on the occasion. I won't deny it. I especially won't deny it three months from now, when I'm bored on an hour-long drive and I decide to strike up the "Best of 2021" playlist, and get stuck on a goddamn song that's almost 20 goddamn minutes long. But let's be as clear as possible: "Fewer Afraid," though long, is worth the length when you commit to it. Any 20-minute song this epic is worth it. Any 20-minute song that ends on the self-mythologizing catharsis that "Fewer Afraid" does is worth it. If we do really get to the point where we are all blasting into space to escape the destruction, make sure that this song soundtracks the adventure.

14. "Back to Oz" by Sufjan Stevens and Angelo De Augustine
 
Much to do has been made over the past couple decades about Sufjan's "50 States Project," a project that was doomed to stay incomplete the moment the indie rock community latched onto it. I was disappointed that he never got around to making Pennsylvania, sure, but as I get older I'm starting to see the whole idea in a new light. I think that putting the focus on "states in America" is the wrong way of looking at it. What are the songs on those states albums if not hyperspecific stories that happen to take place in a specific geographical place? And couldn't those same hyperspecific stories take place somewhere else that isn't necessarily a specific state or city, but perhaps a movie? Even a bizarre 1985 children's film starring Fairuza Balk? Wouldn't it work from those same strengths and be just as wonderful?

13. "777" by Silk Sonic
 
Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar, motherfuckers.
 
12. "Sandy Sheets" by Dave Hause
 
I gotta imagine that Dave Hause is so good that he's able to coast at this point. There is nothing revolutionary about a song that recalls halcyon days of drinking beers at the beach with your best friends while you are listening to your favorite songs, but goddamn it if this doesn't immediately and obviously tickle my nostalgia bone. He must've known, right? He must've.
 
11. "good 4 u" by Olivia Rodrigo
 
There are walls, always. Walls here include the uncomfortable reality that this was, for a week anyway, the most popular pop song in America, and then also the fact that it approximates pop punk in the same way that some fucking Kardashian approximates pop punk when she PDAs Travis Barker. To scale the wall, we have a tremendous hook, and a frighteningly accurate energy (real or manufactured, who gives a fuck). The wall is so far away on the ground that I can't even see it.

10. "CYHSY, 2005" by Clap Your Hands Say Yeah

Clap Your Hands Say Yeah is pretty much the saddest endeavor in music today. I will never stop listening to them.

9. "Checker Drive" by Telethon
 
The first half of the song is Telethon proving that they can play by the rules and still be the catchiest motherfuckers on the planet; the last half of the song is Telethon proving that there are no rules at all. Not sure which half is better.
 
8. "Weird Carolina" by Camp Trash
 
My attempt at avoiding Twitter as much as possible this year was like 80% successful, and if the other 20% of it was failure, then at least I failed upward by being aware of whatever Camp Trash stuff was happening on Emo Twitter. I don't understand any of it—hence the attempt to just avoid Twitter altogether—but it seems hype enough that I checked out an emo EP, and I've been extremely thankful for that. Camp Trash is a real band.
 
7. "On My Way" by Alex Lahey
 
A points converge here, making "On My Way" one of the best songs of the year: I am uncomfortable with a song being closely associated with visual media, but it helps if that visual media is also one of the best of the year, which The Mitchells vs. the Machines absolutely is; current music from this year that I can share an appreciation with my daughters over is few and far better at this age, and so if there was a song like that, then that's only going to strengthen my love of it, since I, ya know, love my daughters; simply put, Alex Lahey has never been better than she is here, and I really hope this song puts her on the map (or at least some kind of map).

6. "Spices" by the Hold Steady
 
As I said yesterday, the great success of the most recent Hold Steady album was that this shit is mostly pretty dark, and yet it still remains pretty fun also, somehow. See "Spices," and how it generates cathartic pleasure from the line "Vanilla vodka and a Diet Dr. Pepper!" which, in the context of the characters in this song, ends up being pretty damn bleak the more you think about it. Let it say what you will about the year I had, but there I was, on Easter morning, also drinking a vanilla vodka and diet Dr. Pepper.

5. "Favorite Song" by 2nd Grade
 
I don't know what it says that there are two songs on this year's list that namedrop other well know song titles (the other is #12). "Favorite Song," for instance, lists "Yesterday," "Sixteen Blue," and "My Baby Cries" in the first verse alone. Maybe it's shorthand for creating a sense of nostalgia, that we can use specific songs as anchors, keeping us tethered to a specific time and specific place. I look forward to remembering 2021 with the same mixture of appreciation and regret whenever I hear "Favorite Song."

4. "Wasted" by the War on Drugs
 
The War on Drugs still sound like the War on Drugs. This is the general consensus for I Don't Live Here Anymore, no? But I am here to propose the following: the War on Drugs sounding like the War on Drugs is the best scenario possible, and they should never change. "Wasted" is the sound of the War on Drugs sounding exactly like they have always sounded, and it is one of my favorite songs of the year. Keep doing this. Keep hitting the pleasure button. I'll be here for it.
 
 
If you say that this is some kind of ode to pessimism, then I would respond that that is your privilege showing. Racism exists. Classism exists. To say that everything is going to be alright is betraying the fact that you live in a world where things tend to go right. It completely ignores the fact that, for many people in this country and this world, things very often go terribly, terribly wrong. "It ain't gonna turn out alright!", on the surface, sounds incredibly grim, but if you step back for a second and think about it, it becomes incredibly realistic as well. And then the additional layer on top of this is that, in Yola's hands, it remains grim, and realistic, and then also sounds absolutely electrifying. It's so powerful that you almost start to believe the opposite is true: that maybe there is something we can do about all this.

2. "Paprika" by Japanese Breakfast
 
What I find most interesting about "Paprika," the opening salvo to Japanese Breakfast's fantastic Jubilee, is that not a single lyric includes the word "music," and yet the song is so fucking clearly about the idea of music. "How's it feel to be at the center of magic, to linger in tones and words?" There is no way the song is about anything else. I've never felt within myself the "center of magic," except when I'm listening to a particularly great song. In that sense, "Paprika" becomes self-reflective. It's a great song about how great it is to hear great songs like this great song right here. It's a rush!!!!!!

1. "Narrator" by Squid
 
In the lead-up to the frantic finale, Squid frontman Oliver Judge repeats the phrase "I play mine" 78 and a half times, screaming the final fourteen (and a half) of those. (I counted.) He's shortening an earlier phrase that he uses: "I play my part." He is the titular "narrator," and he is attempting to maintain some agency in his own life as it spirals out of control. Hence the repetition: I play mine. I play mine. None of this is going to shit. I play mine.

Of course, that's all a feint, because no one is really in control here. In fact, guest vocalist Martha Skye Murphy, who plays what the band calls the "unreliable narrator," absolutely bursts into the scene at the tail end of all those "I play mine"s, to prove it. She lights a stick of dynamite, and brings the whole goddamn story crashing down. To do this, she screams.

I don't think there is a way to overplay it, when describing the scream. Like, I don't think it's possible to be hyperbolic about it. To me, it feels like the drum fill that leads into this section is a gunshot and the screaming is the reaction to the wound. I'm surprised that this song doesn't get a NSFW tag. To Pam, she knows this as "the haunted house song," and that's pretty accurate too. I know it's not real, but it feels real, ya know? It's fucking brutally haunting. I don't think I've been the same since I heard Martha Skye Murphy scream. I'm scarred.

And I'm trying to figure out what it means, the fact that this is the second year in a row that my favorite song of the year involves a titanic scream as its centerpiece. I want to believe that I love these songs because they give me a sense of catharsis from the screams, that it really is akin to the gooseflesh when a ghost pops out at you in a haunted house. I want to believe that, because the alternative is too terrible to consider.

During my worst days, I still consider it: that maybe I just wanna scream too. That sometimes this world seems too deranged to go survive. That sometimes I really do feel out of control, no matter how many times I act like the narrator and repeat the mantras till I'm blue in the fucking face. That maybe if I just let go, like really let go, alone, in the car, volume up, just fucking screamed bloody murder, that maybe I could finally find some peace.

Or maybe we can all scream as much as we need to and it'll never be enough. I have no idea. All I know is that "Narrator" gave me, in a completely fucked up way, some measurable sense of comfort this year. If I just needed to scream, then I did it. If I needed to understand that I'll never be able to scream loud enough, well then, I can just hit repeat, and try again.


No comments: