Wednesday, May 17, 2023

Never Seen It, #104 of 200: Million Dollar Baby

I don't train girls, I watch movies. 200 of them, in fact. The movies I'd never seen before. There's a list. Here's the next one on the list.


Million Dollar Baby
2004
Clint Eastwood

I like a good underdog story. This has been established in this column over the past few years, as we sporadically move through various sports movies. However, I thought Million Dollar Baby brought a unique spin the the trope, in that the underdog story happened totally separate from the sports success, which was never in question until a freak accident cut that success short. Here is a character whose abilities in the ring are never really in doubt; it's outside the ring where the uncertainty lies.
 
This also isn't a movie like Invincible or The Garbage Picking... in which I apply the tenets of "the underdog" to the movie itself. My expectations were set appropriately. Million Dollar Baby won Best Picture at the Oscars in 2005; while that doesn't automatically equal "fantastic movie," the odds are more favorable at least. I have mixed feelings about Clint Eastwood as a "cultural icon of masculinity," but I wouldn't dare doubt his filmmaking bona fides. The movie is even narrated by Morgan Freeman! I knew that was a meme, but I didn't realize he actually narrated any other famous movies besides Shawshank!

I also think that Million Dollar Baby held up as a great movie even though I was aware that there was going to be a moment when Hilary Swank (deserving of her Oscar and then some) broke her neck on a stool that had been malicious placed on its side in the ring. Iconic film moments breed parody, and I just happened to see that parody first. It's Always Sunny didn't even have to spell it out for me to understand what they were making fun of (okay, fine, they did spell it out—the title of the episode in question is "Hundred Dollar Baby"). I think it's okay, though. Always Sunny used it as a gag, but Million Dollar Baby used it as an inciting incident: alright, now what happens when that underdog loses the one thing that makes her not an underdog?

And that leads to a whole separate interesting development in Million Dollar Baby, as sort of last-minute conundrum that tugs the whole movie together. We're talking about assisted suicide, something that I did not expect from this boxing movie. Eastwood's Frankie Dunn has come to consider Swank's Maggie Fitzgerald as a daughter (especially because he is estranged from his biological daughter due to unknown circumstances), and he has a crisis of faith when he realizes that the only way he can show his true love and respect for Maggie is to let her die. 

I can imagine that the movie, despite its accolades, received some heat from both sides of the aisle regarding its decision to pull the trigger. From conservatives who are anti-euthanasia, and from liberals, who might see this as disrespect toward handicap populations (in fact, the Disability Rights Education Fund publicly worried that "the mistaken assumption inherent in the message of the movie [is] that the quality of life of individuals with disabilities is unquestionably not worth living"). Again, not saying that Clint Eastwood is a model of rational beliefs in general, but in this case, his response was measured, and makes a lot of sense to me. Basically: these are characters, and I was telling a story, and that story involves individuals making personal decisions, as opposed to making blanket statements about what people should and should not believe.

I (me, not Clint Eastwood) believe that people have the right to a quality of life, and that they also have a right to end that life if they feel like quality is not possible for irreparable reasons. I think the fact that I was being made to contemplate such deep thoughts while watching what I thought was going to be a simple underdog boxing story really goes a long way in telling you how special this film is. As I said last time—the really great movies don't give you answers, they just give you some powerful questions, and then trust the audience to hold onto those questions and use them to fuel the search for answers. Million Dollar Baby was able to get there easily. No underdogs here.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Since we're doing two-a-days with blogging now, I'm obviously shooting for a lower minimum word count these days, if you haven't noticed yet. The above review was around 700 words, which is more than enough. I only say that here because the next movie I have to watch is Miracle on 34th Street, and I'm worried about squeezing out 500 words on a goddamn Christmas movie in the middle of May. We'll see.

No comments: