Saturday, May 6, 2023

Song of the Week: "Thinking Out Loud"


"Thinking Out Loud"
Ed Sheeran
from ×
2014

I've long been a proponent of the idea that musical ideas should be shared. Yes, there are limits to that idea—if you are covering a song, or stealing the song wholesale, or copying entire sections to be repurposed, then give credit where it's due. But just because something "sounds like" something else doesn't automatically mean that royalties need to be paid. Chord progressions or guitar riffs or lyrical themes or whatever, I say they are fair game.

Now, y'all know I hate Ed Sheeran. What a smug little nerd of an artist, with a musical output that smells like dogshit on my shoe. "Thinking Out Loud," a song that I hadn't heard in like eight years, until it ended up as today's spotlighted song, is so goddamn lame. I hate it. But let's all agree that this is all Ed Sheeran's fault. Let's not try to say that it was also stolen. That's a bullshit argument, somehow even more of a bullshit argument than "But 'Thinking Out Loud' is a good song."

The only reason any of this matters is that Sheeran was brought to court over "Thinking Out Loud" and it's alleged "similarities" to Marvin Gaye's "Let's Get It On" (total coincidence that I mentioned that song in yesterday's review). This, according to the heirs of co-songwriter of "Let's Get It On," Ed Townsend, who died 20 years ago. And all this after Gaye's own estate won a court case claiming that Robin Thicke's "Blurred Lines" was a theft of Gaye's "Got to Give It Up," almost 35 years after Gaye was murdered by his own father.

I talk shit on Ed Sheeran all the time, but these court cases prove that there are worse people out there than moppish little shits who write bad music. Worse still are the children of musicians and songwriters who attempt to use the court system to squeeze more money out of their ancestors' art, fucking vultures who are abusing a system by getting some asshole judge who doesn't know shit about music to say "uh durhhh they share a similar aesthetic I guess," which, come the fuck on. Fuck all these monsters.

You can read more about the legalities of the case on websites better equipped for that type of thing instead of some moron's blog on a Saturday morning post, but the main point being that this would've spelled doom and gloom for the music industry, had Sheeran been found guilty a couple days ago. Yes, we all had a hoot when Sheeran said he would "quit" if he was found guilty, because haha, Sheeran sucks shit and the world would be a better place, musically speaking, without his punchable face. But situations like these require cooler heads to prevail. Had Sheeran been found guilty, it would've sparked ten thousand copycat lawsuits, everyone suing everyone else because the precedent would have been established that "sounding like" equals the crime of theft. Not good. Not good.

Okay. The verdict is in. Not guilty. We're good. We can breathe a little easier this morning. Maybe even have a good laugh. Here's one: I was listening to the new Liquid Mike album, S/T, an eighteen-minute pop punk gem, and I snapped to attention when I heard "American Record," because it has the exact same guitar riff as the New Pornographers' "Myriad Harbour." I'm talking fucking exact. And I'm trying to picture Dan Bejar's kids bringing Liquid Mike to court in like 2046 because they need to pay their bookie or something. That's stupid—I like Liquid Mike, I think it's possible that the guitar riff was a subconscious theft and meant no harm, and honestly at the end of the day I'm checking out Challengers again because of all this—but it would be the reality if Ed Sheeran was found guilty!!

So that's the other funny thing. We talk a lot of shit on Sheeran on Puke on Your Birthday, but the irony is that it was up to that little fucking weasel and his no doubt sniveling lawyers to uphold the entire music industry. Had Sheeran failed, then the entire musical community would have fallen with him, since a guilty verdict would have meant that musicians and songwriters would have eventually lost their ability to make any money whatsoever, since everything sounds like everything else, and royalties would have to be split too many ways, so many that being a musician in the first place just wouldn't make sense financially (not that it does now either, but a guilty verdict would've really been the proverbial coffin nail).

I think the ultimate solution here is to really examine how it makes any sense at all to let the descendants of an artist to continue to benefit from that artist's work long after they are dead. I might understand if Ed Townsend had actual reason to believe that Sheeran had stolen the song, but these are Townsend's widow and kids we're talking about. They had nothing to do with "Let's Get It On." I say that rights should not be transferrable, under any circumstance. Collect the money that the artist made during their lifetime, and then, when they pass, force that money into a collective pool for up-and-coming musicians or something. Let them benefit from the same system that Marvin Gaye benefitted from, instead of attempting to pick meat off the bare bones that are left.

But that's just me... um... thinking out loud. Let's stay focused: for today only, we celebrate Edward Sheeran, not the hero we deserved, but the hero we needed. Tomorrow, it's back to hating his guts for being one of the worst pop stars of the modern era. Today, though, we exalt his name. All hail Ed Sheeran.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

He's like poop on shoe in the Summertime when its 90F out. The discovery sniff has that undertone of hot rubber with shit on top.

Joe K said...

Anonymous strikes again!!!!!