"She Loves You"
a single, later on Past Masters
1963
I wonder if the importance of this song threatens to overshadow how good the song itself is. It's a great song, it's an important song—for this list, for Beatles fans, for rock music in general. I wonder if it would have been as important if it wasn't so great. I also wonder if it would've been considered as great if it wasn't so important. At a certain point, none of this matters; everything converges on the point that "She Loves You" is a sort of Big Bang for what we're trying to do here (archaeologizing the Beatles).
Personally, I probably overrate "She Loves You" due to the fact that it was impressed upon me at a critical age that this was a song that made the earth stand still. That's okay! We wouldn't be here if the Beatles weren't mythologized to the extent that they were. It feels like every fucking week there's another Beatles documentary or biography or whatever the fuck on its way, which is tedious as fuck for someone who knows a lot about the Beatles already, but which is also important because that means there's a new Beatles fan every week too, discovering them for the first time.
I was, I dunno, fifteen or sixteen maybe, and I was going backwards. I already had Sgt. Pepper's in the arsenal, but now I wanted to know about the suits, the moptop hair, the yeah yeah yeahs, the Ed Sullivan appearance, the "Invasion." I had a DVD about the Beatles' first trip to America. I'm 99% sure it was this one. I don't remember specifics (except for the fact that they returned to Britain on February 22, 1964, the day my mother was born), but I do remember being blown away. The documentary did an excellent job building the myth. Whether these four young 20-somethings actually were all that important ceases to matter at that point, because I'm watching with my own eyes and I fucking believe it, man.
The book makes a point in saying that critics at the time were harsh about it, and that makes sense too. I had the advantage of time and history on my side, exploring "She Loves You" over 40 years after it dropped for the first time. I knew it was good, and had I not, then there would have been plenty of documentaries to convince me otherwise. I don't blame anyone for not being able to see the forest around the tree in 1963. It was probably tough to hear, both literally and figuratively, "She Loves You" over the screams of a million teenage girls. The screams have faded, and most of those teenage girls are dead (or in their 80s). We are left with the pure sound of "She Loves You."
Those sounds include Ringo's drumming, of course. It's pretty cool that one of the greatest pop songs of our lifetime opens with a drum fill. I also appreciate how there aren't any cymbals in the chorus, which adds some depth to the sound in an unexpected way. That's not even to mention the syncopated rhythm after each of the third "yeah"s, one that is not quite on the beat, but one that makes sense anyway. Patented fucking Ringo Starr shit. I love it. (We'll get an even better example of the form in "Ticket to Ride" eventually.)
The drumming is all in support of the vocals though. As we've seen already, a lot of Beatles songs later on become a question of "is this a Paul song or a John song?" With "She Loves You," however, it's a true Lennon/McCartney. They both made the song, and they both sing at the same time (George sings half the time too). It's not quite a harmony, but their voices still blend in some magnificent way, so much so that it might as well be one voice. That one voice forces "yeah, yeah, yeah" into the canon, as well as the "woo!" that brings us into each chorus. I mean, this is just fucking iconic stuff. The book quotes Billy Corgan (of all people) making the argument that "She Loves You" was the only thing the Beatles had to do to become legends, and I find that argument hard to disagree with.
I think I do take issue with the argument that Spignesi and Lewis make, however, in which they claim that "even people who have never bought a Beatles record have heard and know 'She Loves You.'" I guess there is some truth to it—I had never bought a Beatles record, but I recall becoming familiar with "She Loves You" partially because there were endless TV commercials hawking the Beatles 1 compilation—but in spirit, I need to disagree. The thing about "She Loves You" is that you need to discover it. It is a portal to another world. It's not ubiquitous. It lies dormant until you are ready. And once you hear it, you are a Beatles fan. If you know "She Loves You," then almost immediately after the fact, you become someone who has bought a Beatles record. That's the power of this song.
BEATLES TRIVIA: One truth and one lie, as presented by the book. The lie: the band the Yeah Yeah Yeahs were named after the phrase made popular by the Beatles in "She Loves You." I found no evidence that there was anything but an indirect lineage. The truth: the Beatles were still young (as humans and as a band and as a commercial enterprise) at this time, and so the powers that be forced them to do shit that they probably didn't want to do. A) "She Loves You" was also recorded in German, as "Sie liebt dich," and B) they were made perform this song for the Royal Family, who were and are some of the worst people on earth, but don't worry, John got a crack in about not clapping but instead "rattling your jewelry."
BETTER BEATLE: This is up there with the best, so naming an actual better Beatles tune would reveal too many cards at this point. However, let's use this space to begin to consider whether the other big hit from around this time, "I Want to Hold Your Hand," is a better song. It's coming up at #20, so we can talk about it more then, but it's a worthy question. "She Loves You" is better though.
NEXT TIME: "Here, There and Everywhere" at #16
No comments:
Post a Comment