Wednesday, May 24, 2023

Never Seen It, #105 of 200: Miracle on 34th Street

The real Santa Claus would've helped me with the list of 200 movies that I had never seen before and have since committed to writing about.


Miracle on 34th Street
1947
George Seaton

This is probably a great place to emphasize that this project is being completed in a semi-strict alphabetical order. There have been exceptions—exceptions for the Oscars, exceptions for book club prep, exceptions for Halloween, exceptions for, uh, errrr, Jason Biggs. But other than those few exceptions, the alphabet is my master, and I follow it wherever it goes. This week, the alphabet made me watch a Christmas movie.

Though, to be fair, if we're going to watch a Christmas movie during the warmer months of the year, then Miracle on 34th Street might coincidentally be the best one to watch. Because, you see, it was actually released in theaters in June. I know! Movie executives in the mid-to-late-'40s were as dumb as I am now! The thought by the head of the studio was that "more people go to the movies in warmer weather." Is that true now? Was it then? I don't know. I just giggle at the pure synchronism of the universe, that I was forced to watch a Christmas movie in the same month as audiences in 1947 were. (Sidenote: apparently the marketing department attempted to hide the fact that Miracle on 34th Street was a Christmas movie in all promotional material, which is also fucking hilarious.)

I feel like the more prevalent argument when it comes to Christmas movies is that a non-Christmas movie is argued as a "Christmas movie" by a certain subset of the population. E.g. Die Hard, which is probably not a Christmas movie, even though some folks claim that it is. Which is fine, I don't care, it's not that important. I only bring it up to say that Miracle on 34th Street represents the opposite argument: it is most definitely a Christmas movie, and yet there might be a certain subset of the population that argues that it is not a Christmas movie. I might even find myself among that subset.

Yes, it takes place during the Christmas season, and features plenty of Christmas imagery, and speaks to the "meaning of Christmas" in a roundabout way; all the criteria is met. But then explain why I'm sitting here in May and I'm loving this movie. I'm not that guy. I don't partake in anything Christmasy outside of the season. I think that's fucking lame. And yet here I am, perplexed at how much I fucking loved this film. Baffled. There had to have been more to this movie than "Christmas." There is no other explanation.

Let's start here: we're not even sure if the guy who claims he is Santa Claus is actually the Santa Claus. It's not even established whether there is a Santa Claus who exists. Yes, it might be that the man whose name is Kris Kringle is the real Santa Claus, who delivers toys to children all over the world every December 24th. But equally likely is the possibility that Kris Kringle is a kind and gentle old man, a regular human who has some mental health concerns but who is nevertheless benevolent and actually improve the lives of everyone he meets. Either one could be true! And the film never really gets around to saying which one it is!

The genius of the film is that the question is asked a thousand times by every character, and never answered. You might be familiar with the famous climax of the movie (SPOILERS!!!!!!!!!!), in which it is "proven" in court that this Kris Kringle "is" the "real" Santa Claus, because the U.S. Postal Service delivers their letters to Kris Kringle in the courtroom. But even that is established as pure chance, since a rogue post office mail sorter impishly redirects all the dead letters to the courtroom on a lark. Could the real Santa Claus manifest such a coincidence with his magic? Probably! But it could go either way.

Okay, so my point here is that everyone is asking the question, "Wait, is Santa Claus real?!" And the film never purports to answer that question. But that's the point. You're not supposed to know the answer. You aren't supposed to know in the same way that your own life has its own mysteries that will never be answered. You can't prove that there isn't a Santa Claus in the same way you can't prove that there isn't a god. You can't prove that your bedroom roof won't collapse in on you as you sleep, and you can't prove that your husband will always remain faithful, and you can't prove that the world isn't going to burn into ash before your grandkids reach retirement. 

But what Miracle on 34th Street does indeed argue is the fact that, despite the lack of proof, you need to HAVE FAITH. Not a baseless faith or an ignorant faith, but a faith that is going to inspire goodness and kindness. A faith that will lead to fulfillment. Is Kris Kringle Santa Claus? If you believe that Santa is a positive force in the universe, then he absolutely is. Kris Kringle brings happiness and joy to the children and adults that he interacts with over the course of the movie, and if that fits your definition of "Santa Claus," then he is Santa Claus. You can't prove it, but you have to have faith.

The protagonist of this story is a woman named Doris Walker (played by Maureen O'Hara, in one of the most natural performances I've ever seen in an Old Hollywood film), and she is established as someone who only believes what is right in front of her eyes, and nothing more. She teaches her daughter Susan that Santa Claus is not real, but a fairy tale. Then Doris meets two men. One is a man who claims that he is the real Santa Claus. The other is a lawyer named Fred Gailey. She doesn't trust either man. She is a divorcee, and it's implied there were some trust issues, and she just doesn't have faith that Fred could be the man for her. This mirrors her lack of faith she has in Kris Kringle. When she realizes that what matters is that Kris Kringle brings joy just like Santa Claus would, she learns to have faith in the concept, that it is real, even if Santa Claus himself may or may not be real. This mirrors her journey of faith in love—she can love again, because she now finds the ability to have faith in a partner again.

So you see, this is why I have a hard time committing to the idea that Miracle on 34th Street is a straight-up Christmas movie. Concepts like faith and love and optimism and joy and kinship with your fellow man are not holiday-specific. They are universal concepts. Here, they are applied to Christmas, because of the "magic" that Christmas tends to evoke slides nicely next to the higher concept of "faith." But they could apply elsewhere. You can have a crisis of faith in May, if you wanted to.

This was my crisis of faith: I dreaded having to watch a Christmas movie at the beginning of summer. I have watched well over 100 movies for this stupid project, and I still don't have faith sometimes. That's messed up. I should know by now that there is a magic in certain movies, no matter the context. I found the magic here, in this fucking Christmas movie, a full seven months prior to the next Christmas. I have faith.

GRADE: 5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Our friend Mike F. is back for the first time since It Follows, and we're gonna chat about Mission Impossible. Get pumped.

No comments: