Wednesday, March 9, 2022

Never Seen It, #189 of 200: West Side Story

Keep it cool, boy, while we're watching 200 movies.


West Side Story
Robert Wise and Jerome Robbins
1961

I had noted a couple months ago that I had this post written already, and then somehow deleted the whole fucking thing, because I'm a goddamn moron. But I've come to accept that. And in fact, it might have been a blessing. The thesis of that lost blog post was basically "here are the ways I think West Side Story might be improved in a remake." And now I am currently armed with the knowledge that, yes, Spielberg's 2021 remake of West Side Story really did hit all those marks that I felt were lacking in the original. It's no longer "this is great but could be better," it's "this is great but could be better and has been made better by a remake." This also means that I'm writing about a movie for this column (the 1961 version) two months after I saw it, but it's the right tradeoff to make.

When I use the word "spectacle," I could easily be referring to either version (there's a reason that the original is a classic in every sense). However, I'll also say that the original is slightly lacking just due to the filmmaking limitations of its day. It was more akin to the stage version, in that the sets were mostly empty besides the focus characters and the facades of fake buildings. This isn't "wrong," because that's how the stage version would be too, right? There aren't that many extras or three-dimensional set pieces on a stage. But when considering a movie, then I (admittedly a novice in the art of "movies") expect more.

And yes, the 2021 version goes bonkers in this regard. Everything is fuller, more crowded, more exciting. "America" goes from a nighttime dance on an empty roof to a daytime bonanza on a crowded street, where it feels like the entire city is involved in this dance number. Not every song or scene is expanded, but those that stay small with just the main characters now take place in tighter areas. Gone are the expansive and empty basketball courts, and replacing them are thin alleyways adorned with rubble.

That's something that they added to this new version that I think really adds to the story in multiple ways—the neighborhood that the Jets and the Sharks are fighting over is literally being torn down. Not only does it add to the aesthetics, but it also provides a neat wrinkle in the plot. I.e. these two groups of teens are fighting to the death of what seems like nothing, and the fact that what they are fighting over will literally not exist soon, the futility of their battle is made explicit. Plus, factor in the idea that "this way of life is fading away" could also be applied to West Side Story itself. Because no matter how much praise both I and possibly the Oscars will heap on this remake, we can't not mention that it was somewhat of a bomb at the box office. And if you are wondering what lies in the future for movies as grand and as old school and as showy as this, then you might feel how the Jets and the Sharks are feeling as their New York barrio is literally crumbling to the ground.

Maybe not all the changes were for the best. I was nonplussed with Rita Moreno's expanded role in the remake—I feel like the somber ballad she had was more fan service than anything, and didn't really add much to the movie. Like, do we really need the role of "drug store owner" expanded? Only if you insist on shoehorning Rita Moreno into a remake of the movie she won an Oscar for originally. I get the argument, but I could've done without it if need be. (And if your argument is "you need to expand Valentina's part because that affects Tony's part, then we need to talk about how much of a fucking creep Ansel Elgort is, and let's not do that today maybe?)

That's probably making a big deal out of nothing. The other "nothing" that I could point out is the fact that "I Feel Pretty" is moved to after the stabbings, which seemed weird at first. It made it feel slight—multiple main characters have just been murdered, and now we're going to have the female protagonist sing about being in love while trying on some fun dresses? Maybe the intention of this change was to add texture to the song, as there might be some dramatic irony in the fact that the object of her affection, the man whom makes her feel "pretty," now has some very unpretty blood on his hands. I'm on the fence about it.

Even if we consider the "I Feel Pretty" adjustment a failure, then the "Cool" adjustment more than makes up for it. In the original, Ice—a total nothing of a character—sings to "be cool" about the fact that they all just witnessed a double stabbing and the police will no doubt be questioning them soon. In the remake, Tony himself takes the lead on the song, imploring his buddy Riff and company to "be cool" about the fact that they now own a gun and intend on using it. It's not truly a necessary song in either version, but at least the placement and singer make sense in the remake.

I don't want to overexaggerate the thing I felt slightly uncomfortable about in the original, mainly because it's been a little bit and I don't think I can come up with many specific examples for you, but here it goes—the remake nails the issue of race in a way that the 1961 version stumbles over a little bit. Look, there's a huge difference between "the characters in this movie being racist" and "the filmmakers being racist by making this film." The difference is so large that it's kind of embarrassing that I feel the need to clarify. But I'm just saying that I thought the Spielberg version did a better job at widening that gap than the original did. Even beyond the fact that there was brown face in the original. I'm saying that the original kind of felt like it ultimately sided with the white Jets, even while devoting time to the Puerto Rican Sharks, whereas this version respects both sides (or, depending on how you look at it, neither side) of the equation. Maybe it's more intangible than I originally thought when I started this paragraph, maybe the choice to not subtitle the Spanish felt like such a success, or maybe it's just as simple as a film having an extra 50 years of societal change to get it right.

This was definitely a cheat for blog-writing today, the fact that I had a whole second movie to talk about, which is a great way at avoiding talking about the movie that I'm actually supposed to be talking about in this blog post. To reiterate the point once more about the 1961 version of West Side Story: it is undeniably a classic that, even in a vacuum, still had some noticeable flaws. The joyous part of this blog post, I'd argue, is the fact that I was immediately granted the opportunity to see another film that addressed pretty much all of my concerns, and then some. West Side Story (1961) is a great fucking film, and deserves its place in the canon (feelings that will be reflected in the PoYB grade below). West Side Story (2021) is probably the best movie I've seen this year so far, because it did an even better job of capturing what is so special about watching movies (feelings that will be reflected when I get around to writing about all the Oscar movies in a couple weeks).

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5


NEXT TIME: I've been meaning to watch The Godfather Part III for a while now, but the hunt to watch all the Oscar movies before March 27th has tripped me up (plus, it's tough to commit to watching a 160-minute movie under any circumstance). So look for that next time, whenever "next time" is (probably early April).

No comments: