Friday, April 1, 2022

Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not, Joe


Listening to Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not in a critical fashion also forces me to reopen and reexamine (yet again) the time in my life when this album was important. Just when I thought I was out, Record Club pulls me back in, back into those years of my youth when the world was my oyster blah blah blah you know this about me already, my struggles in grappling with nostalgia in the context of blogging. I don't know how to write about Arctic Monkeys' debut album without also pondering what life was like when I listened to the album over and over. They are inextricably linked.

Thankfully, the connection makes sense thematically—Whatever is an album that both soundtracked weekends of debauchery and is literally about weekends filled with debauchery. There is first the story of Alex Turner in Sheffield, UK, and then there is the story of Joe K*** in Northeast Philadelphia, US, and those two stories run on parallel tracks, 3440 miles away from each other. Each story is integral in my appreciation of this album—which is probably should've been on my Top 25 Albums All Time list, and will god willing be the final album from that ever-changing list that RC deigns to cover—even though both stories are tenuously connected at best, and even then probably just in the warped mind of a former eighteen-year-old who clearly had one too many pints in his day.

Something I was not aware of until this week is that there is a fan theory—never confirmed or denied by Turner et al.—that Whatever is a "concept album," that it tells one cohesive story, and every song shares the same protagonist. It's an exciting theory, albeit one that definitely breaks down by the time you get to the back third of the album. But it's also an unnecessary theory. High School Joe did not need to consider the protagonist of Whatever at all, because High School Joe wanted to consider himself the protagonist.

And when I say that this is "tenuous," I'm talking about the one big thing that precluded me from literally living out the scenarios described on this album—the drinking age in the UK is eighteen, and the drinking age in the US is 21. I wasn't going to clubs and bars at the end of high school and the beginning of college because I wasn't allowed. Whatever, meanwhile, shapes its narratives explicitly around pub and club culture in the UK in the mid-'00s, something I was only familiar with through listening to this album, and even then it barely registered. But c'mon, the general themes obviously resonated, even if the details were foreign.

Let's say that Whatever really is a concept album, though, for hypothetical purposes. What does that story look like? Well, our protagonist—a nineteen-year-old hetero-cis white male—starts his weekend in "anticipation" for the debauchery that is to follow that night, reminiscing about past dalliances formed over text ("The View from the Afternoon"), and imagining that the cute checkout clerk is going to find him in the club at some point ("I Bet You Look Good on the Dancefloor"). This is the best part of "drinking culture," in my mind, this anticipation for the good times ahead. The excitement for what could happen is half the fun. (A complete aside, but this is why I hate surprise parties.)

The next part in our hero's journey is "seeing the band." Live music was probably halfway between pregaming and the true start of the night, and we see at least two songs here covering that section ("Fake Tales of San Francisco," about a shitty band, with one of the best punchlines on the album—"proof that love's not only blind, but deaf"—and "You Probably Couldn't See for the Lights but You Were Staring Straight at Me," about making a connection with the hot lead singer of the band, or at least pretending to). This is probably the least analogous section as compared to what was going on in the depths of Rockledge, PA, but one could argue that music was integral to the true start to our nights as well (but we already kinda covered that in previous reviews).

Our hero is now drunk, and starts wondering who he is going to hook up with that night ("Still Take You Home"). He also grapples with the futility of life by attempting to mess with some cops ("Riot Van"). Finally, he starts that wild journey home in a taxi with a bunch of his mates ("Red Light Indicates Doors Are Secured"). That anticipation you felt earlier in the day? Well, that feeling that anything could happen is coming to fruition, now that you're a dozen beers deep. The most random makeouts, the wildest run-ins with the law, cab rides that you'll remember forever. What these seemingly disparate events have in common is that you feel utterly invincible as they are happening. The full force of youth is at your back. Note that it doesn't even have to be happening to you—"Red Light" is complete inaction, featuring only a lengthy debate about a fight that was only witnessed, not participated in. 

When I said that the "concept album" idea falls apart in the back third, then the crumbling starts at "Mardy Bum," either the best or the second best song on the album, depending on my mood. I can see an argument that our same protagonist from the first eight songs also stars in the final five, but these are more vignettes than a part of any grand, night-on-the-town story. "Mardy Bum" is about trying to keep the good times going through a fraught relationship. "Perhaps Vampires Is a Bit Strong But..." is mostly Arctic Monkeys breaking the fourth wall to shit on all their haters. "When the Sun Goes Down" is a real-life account of prostitution in their hometown. "From the Ritz to the Rubble" returns to the club on a separate occasion, and finds an existential crisis through a run-in with an aggravated bouncer. And "A Certain Romance"—the other best song on the album—attempts to find some sense of closure in the face of an uncertain adulthood future.

All of these songs, whether they are part of one cohesive whole or not, are worthy of further dissection than I can devote to them now. Like, fuck, even just that transition from "Ritz" (the whole "the haze has ascended" thing, when he's realizing that this lifestyle isn't good for you) into "Romance" (finding peace in the leaving it all behind... eventually) is worthy of 10,000 more words.

That's probably what I struggled with the most, the idea that any of this had to come to an end eventually. I thought that if I kept listening to Arctic Monkeys, then I could at least hold onto a piece of it forever. Even Alex Turner knew how toxic that idea is, though. This shit doesn't last. You grow up eventually. Letting go of the unlimited boozing and constantly womanizing and staying up till 3 AM drunk texting and trying to outwit the police and all that shit isn't the hard part. The hard part is accepting your own mortality, that's all. It's accepting the idea that you aren't invincible.

Not that this is new to me. Yes, as I've said, I've had my struggles, but I'm not currently struggling. I'm far enough removed that there won't be any Arctic Monkeys-induced relapses this week. And plus... ugh, how did I even get on this subject again? Fuck! I hate how, whenever I let myself just type without any sort of plan, I somehow always end up here, at this very specific theme, the motherfucking "good ol' days" bullshit. Tony Soprano was right—"remember when" is the lowest form of conversation.

Though, I'll admit, sometimes the "remember when"s feel good too, so whenever I need a hit of it, I text my own personal Paulie Walnuts—Kev C****r. I was 99% certain that he was the one who introduced me to Arctic Monkeys in the first place, and since I have been trying for three years to get him to write in Record Club himself, to no avail, I figured I could at least get his input regarding this music we once shared.

I have shared this in a previous review as well, but it's worth reiterating that Kev and I (along with PoYB contributor Mike) were in a garage band together from around 2005-2007. We were called Burholme. I reiterate this now because there was one single album that Burholme covered two songs off of, and that album is Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not (and those songs were, of course, "Mardy Bum" and "A Certain Romance"). I asked Kev why it was that Whatever ended up being such an important album to us.
"I feel like the two songs we covered, and probably the whole album for that matter, had a pretty solid mix of all three of our types of musical interest. Especially 'A Certain Romance.' The change in rhythms, the different guitar pieces, and the musical flow of that song, together I'd say were an even spread of your, my, and Mike's music tastes."
I like that idea. We can maybe even stretch it a little further. It goes beyond the fact that this album was a rare alchemy of my "Moby Dick," Kev's "Fight for Your Right to Party," and Mike's "A Decade Under the Influence." It perhaps speaks to the universality of this music, for everyone, even if you weren't in a amateur rock band that played mostly at the Presentation B.V.M. Church Hall. If you were young once, if you drank when you were, if you felt invincible when you did, then this album is for you. Or was for you. I guess you could theoretically have missed the jumping on point, I dunno.

I certainly didn't. I remember specifically listening to some of these cuts on MySpace, before I had enough money to afford the album purchase. This, apparently, had a lot to do with Arctic Monkeys' initial success—neglected to mention so far that Whatever was the fastest selling debut album in UK history up to that point—the idea that they could share their tunes over the internet for any poor teen shmuck who was spending all his money on Hurricane forties that he hid in his bass drum. A revolutionary idea at the time (the music on MySpace, not the forties-in-the-drum thing). We were already playing "Mardy Bum" in our sets, just based on what we heard on the erstwhile social media network.

And I remember the specific date that I finally got my hands on a copy of this album—April 22, 2007. It was easy to look this up on Google Photos, since it was waiting for me when I got home the morning after Gwynedd Mercy Academy's senior prom (and there are pictures of me from April 21, 2007, decked in a black tux with salmon-colored bowtie). I threw my cummerbund on the floor, popped the CD in my bedside boombox, and fell asleep sometime during the instrumental outro to "Perhaps Vampires." In fact, I guess that particular prom's afterparty had put a bullet through the idea that I "lived my life like an Arctic Monkeys album" at the time, now that I think about it. All fun people in attendance, but it's pretty clear in retrospect that I was only invited to this specific crew's parties because I had access to alcohol in the NEast that not many of these suburban kids had. There were no random hookups, no wild run-ins with the law, no limo rides I'd remember forever. I just got drunk and passed out, stuck about halfway between feeling invincible and feeling disposable.

When I listen to Whatever, I see my past through rose-colored glasses, but it's important to remember that the nights weren't all like that. On some nights, sure, I'm yelling out a Wildwood taxi van with the C***y boys, or I'm getting the shit beat out of me (financially) by the Rockledge police, or I'm finally connecting with my crush-of-the-night next to the firepit after we've split a case of Lionshead, but there were plenty of other nights just like the GMA prom afterparty in someone's basement. "The haze has ascended" indeed.

So maybe I've been listening to it wrong all these years. If we strip away the toxic nostalgia that has been lacquered on throughout the past decade-plus, you're luckily still left with a rock album that holds up.

I mean, I could give another thirteen paragraphs to just the music on this thing. I won't, because I've already gone on long enough and it's been a tight week, but know that I could. I could talk about the way "The View from the Afternoon" explodes in the pre-chorus and then drops for a measure right before the chorus. I could talk about all the gang vocals—the da-da-das on "Still Take You Home," the NO SURRENDER on "Red Light," the caustic and cathartic conclusion of "Fake Tales," it all hits so hard. I could talk about the galloping ending to "Perhaps Vampires," when they really stretch their legs to prove their mettle to the haters. I could talk about how that relentless guitar riff on "Red Light" reflects the dark turn that the story takes. I could talk about the fake start to "A Certain Romance," as if the band is getting all their anger out one last time before settling down to end this thing (and then can't help but bring back the noise before the album actually does end). I could talk about the relentless energy on this album, how it never seems to let up, how it is the type of music that could only be performed by someone young.

I asked Mike about Arctic Monkeys too (since I promised I wouldn't force him to participate for a while after I blackmailed him into doing a McGruff review), and his pithy response was along these lines, that the music is the only thing that matters here.
"Not a unique story—their demos were insanely popular on MySpace."
Some weeks, I might agree with Mike, but not this week. The music is fucking great, no doubt, but there is something special about it beyond what is coming out of the speakers. Just think about "A Certain Romance," how it acts as a conclusion to both the album and to this lifestyle. It's one of the best album-enders of all time because of this. And you better fucking believe that there was extra weight on this thing when Burholme played "A Certain Romance" at our End of Summer 2007 concert. We were off to college! Things were changing! We were (ostensibly) growing up! The physical distance between friends was about to grow, but we knew that friendship can overcome that distance, easily.
"But over there, there's friends of mine.
What can I say? I've known 'em for a long long time.
And they might overstep the line,
But you just cannot get angry in the same way."
There was comfort in knowing that, as much as I had seen my life reflected, metaphorically, in the lyrics and the rhythms and the energy, that it could also be reflected in what I valued most in life. Sure, technically that could mean the booze and the wild nights out, but I also sincerely valued the friendships we made along the way. The protagonist isn't alone in any of these songs, is he?

That is my attempt to say something sweet about this album, because otherwise this review is just another pathetic attempt at reaching back into the past. I couldn't help it though. This is literally what Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not means to me. It is a very specific sound from a very specific time, and like all those wild nights so many years ago, it echoes through the ages.

GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: