Saturday, April 9, 2022

A Year of Blind Spots: Smash


The challenge: can you love an album if you hate a song on that album? Smash might indicate that this is achievable.

Consider how terrible "Come Out and Play" is. Like, truly awful. A noxious earworm that has infested active rock radio since the mid-'90s. A cloying, half-hearted plea against gang violence. A eye-roll-worthy two-measure Arabian-style guitar riff that may or may not have been stolen. Drumsticks against the metal tube of the hi-hat, so nail/chalkboard-esque that my teeth hurt. I truly hate every inch of this thing.

So I guess I was kind of glad that the album opened with a 25-second clip instructing me to "relax," because I needed it. I know that the band meant the intro to be ironic, since a lot of the album moves at a really fast pace. But the intense tempos of "Nitro (Youth Energy)" and "So Alone" etc. are the type of music that relax me! Give me Motörhead by way of whiny vocals over whatever the fuck "Come Out and Play" is.

Maybe it was those whiny vocals that turned me off originally. For real, lead singer Dexter Holland sounds like Weird Al most of the time. If you had told me in 1994 that Smash was a "Weird" Al Yankovic album, my dumb ass would've believed you. It's shrill in such an off-putting way. I'm having trouble describing it. No matter—I'm here to tell you that it grew on me this week. The vocals work really well when the Offspring is just barreling through a two-minute punk song. This man could've lived forever in the deep cuts, and the world would've been better for it.

Actually, no, I'll even go so far as to say that the other two hits from Smash, "Gotta Get Away" and "Self Esteem" (and "hits" being relative—"Come Out and Play" is the only "hit" of the three to get to #1 on the Billboard Alternative charts) work a lot better in the context of Smash. Both seem like the Offspring kowtowing to the public's desire for all things grunge in 1994 (not a bad thing, all in all), and both work as sort of a breather in the middle of a slate of full-throttle punk mayhem.

But the full-tilt punk rock is where it's at. Literally every song besides the hits (and the intro) will do the trick. Explore a handful of them below, and tell me that this shit ain't miles ahead of "Come Out and Play."

I can't say that I liked this album enough to run to my nearest torrenting website and steal a copy of the next Offspring offering, but I liked it enough to admit that I "get it" now. It's not Offspring's fault, it's rock radio's fault. That's an obvious conclusion.

I will leave you with two more conclusions before we call it a day. First, this is going to be one of those blog posts that gets a smarmy Nate comment below it, because he wrote about Offspring twice last year on this very blog, so he clearly has things to say about it. Second, if I was too negative about this album (which I'd argue I wasn't, but clearly I don't have a handle on how negatively I come off in a typical album review!), then please find solace in the fact that Smash isn't the Offspring album with "Pretty Fly (for a White Guy)" and "Why Don't You Get a Job?", which, holy shit, if you thought "Come Out and Play" was bad!!!



No comments: