Thursday, April 14, 2022

no blog today here is a paper i wrote

Just finished my second-to-last paper, and it's a true blue piece of dog shit. For real, I hated writing it, just as much as the professor is going to hate reading it (though I'm confident that that hatred will translate into a good grade, since she's going to hate it so much that she won't be able to bring herself to make too many corrections or ask too many questions about it—this is how it works in the ivy league diploma factory!).

Anyways, you're not going to read that one today, it's too embarrassing. Here is instead my third-the-last paper. I'm copying and pasting it here, with only minor adjustments, because 1) that other paper wiped me out and I don't feel like blogging for today, and 2) it's actually related to a blog post I wrote two years ago. Yes, I turned one of my Never Seen It entries into a college Mental Health Diagnostics paper! Blogging is paying off every single day!

~~~~~~~~~~~~


Film:
A Beautiful Mind

Movie Reaction

A Beautiful Mind was released in 2001, and was directed by Ron Howard. It is based on a 1998 biography (of the same name) about the mathematician John Nash. Russell Crowe plays the protagonist Nash. So while John Nash the mathematician was a real person, for the purposes of this essay we will be discussing the “character” of John Nash in the film.

The film begins with John Nash entering Princeton University in 1947 on a mathematics scholarship. Nash immediately pressures himself to come up with a new theory in his field, and eventually does develop a theory. The theory comes to him as he and his friends are discussing how to pick up a woman they see at the bar. The specifics of the theory itself—an early version of “game theory”—are not discussed in detail in the film, and may be beside the point for the purposes of our exercise. Regardless of what the theory actually means, it is established that John Nash has a mind for mathematics, and has genuinely come up with something new in this case. Nash is invited to join the staff of MIT, and eventually the Pentagon.

At this point, it is important to acknowledge how much any one audience member knows about the life of John Nash. I, for one, did not know anything about him before watching A Beautiful Mind, so the mid-film reveal was genuinely shocking to me. My apologies if spoiling the film makes it less enjoyable to watch. It is eventually revealed that John Nash has symptoms of schizophrenia. This was surprising to me because, up until Nash’s hospitalization, the film’s story is told from Nash’s point of view. Without knowing that Nash would eventually be diagnosed with a mental health disorder, the audience is led to believe that the events that Nash is seeing and reacting to are actually happening. However, they are, in fact, hallucinations and delusions.

For instance, the film shows Nash being contacted by a “William Parcher of the U.S. Department of Defense” with a “classified assignment” for Nash. He becomes involved in Parcher’s work in decoding secret messages from Soviet Russia, and eventually finds himself so embroiled in the work that he is involved in a shootout between Parcher and the Russian spies who are attacking them. While watching this segment of the film, I started to feel disappointed, because it seemed like a half-baked take on the spy genre. This wasn’t the type of movie I wanted to watch. However, it was eventually revealed that Parcher, and the shootout, and other characters in the film were actually hallucinations that Nash was experiencing. Thus, it is revealed that A Beautiful Mind is not about spies and espionage at all, but rather Nash’s struggles with addressing his mental health concerns.

John Nash is married early in the film to Alicia Larde (not a hallucination), and we see her struggle as well. Larde and their newborn child are directly affected by Nash’s erratic behavior. At one point, Nash hallucinates that Parcher is going to kill Larde and the baby, and so in trying to “protect” his family, Nash accidentally knocks his wife and child onto the ground, injuring them. Nash’s ability to care for the newborn is also compromised due to his disorder; at one point, Nash leaves the child in the bathtub by himself as it fills up with water. One feels not only great empathy for Nash as he struggles with his disorder, but also for his family, who bear the brunt of the outcomes of Nash’s symptoms.

Nash is hospitalized, and given shock therapy and medication. He is released, but eventually relapses, working on the “assignment” from Parcher in his shed. This leads to further hospitalizations.

Eventually, Nash learns to “live with” his hallucinations. One of the hallucinations that he experiences throughout the movie is that of a college roommate whom he stays in touch with. Nash, at a certain point, comes to understand that this roommate is a hallucination, since he is not aging at all, even after decades. Nash goes against medical advice and stops taking his medication. For the rest of his life, he still experiences the hallucinations of his roommate and the FBI agent, but he simply learns to ignore them.

While opinions may vary as to whether this could constitute a “recovery” for Nash, his condition certainly improved enough that he was able to return to MIT to study, and even begin to teach some classes. His mental health diagnosis had no effect on his mathematical abilities, and toward the end of his career, Nash received a Nobel Prize for his continued work in “game theory.” The film makes it clear that even after the Nobel Prize, he is still experiencing hallucinations.

My own empathy for the character of John Nash stems from my understanding how isolating such an experience would be for any human being. It must have been incredibly difficult for Nash to feel so misunderstood through his hallucinations and delusions. His doctor and other characters were quick to point out that the people he was talking to were “not real,” but Nash’s negative reactions to being told this were completely understandable. It’s difficult for any of us to explain what being “real” means; to Nash, his roommate and the FBI agent were extremely real. To be told otherwise must have been a harrowing and lonely experience.

One should come away from this film feeling uplifted, despite the circumstances of the plot. In the end, Nash was able to successful treat his condition, regardless of whether that treatment was doctor-approved or not. What matters is that it worked for him, and he found academic success and personal success even after being diagnosed with what is usually an extremely debilitating disease. Nash’s strength should serve as a symbol of hope for others who are experiencing similar challenges.

Presenting Problem

Patient reports to strong feelings of being followed throughout the day by entities who intend to harm. Patient states that he has only discussed these concerns with a contact at the U.S. Department of Defense. Patient indicates that his wife has told him that she does not know the people who patient is talking to, and she is concerned for patient’s well-being.

Demographic Information

27-year-old white male. Married, with one newborn child (male). Formerly employed by MIT in mathematics department. Currently unemployed after being let go from previous position at MIT. Patient met current wife at MIT, when she was a student. Wife works part-time as a computer programmer and data analyst.

Mental Status

Patient presented wearing seasonally-appropriate suit and tie, stating that this is what he “usually” wears when leaving the house. Patient appears mostly well-groomed, though face presents unshaved. Relatively high psychomotor agitation—fidgeting, looking over shoulders, a general air of restlessness. Patient’s speech presented with pressured speech; spoke with urgency, as if trying to finish the session as soon as possible. Patient’s thoughts appeared disorganized. Patient prone to taking tangents in conversation. Heightened affect. Mood appears congruent with cognitive processes. Concerns regarding cognitive processes, however. Memory appears intact. Oriented x3. No concerns regarding IQ; patient presents as having very high IQ.

Clinical Information

Patient states that he is extremely stressed from work. He states that he was previous employed at a prestigious university, but that the stress from his part-time employment caused him to lose his full-time job. Patient indicates that he is being forced to work for the U.S. Department of Defense. Patient indicates that he has been employed in this capacity for “at least three years.” He has a contact at that department that often shows up at his home unannounced. Per patient, he works out of a secret garage in his backyard, where he tacks his work to the wall so that he can attempt to observe patterns more efficiently. Patient also states that, due to the sensitive nature of the job, that he has evidence that he is being “followed” by unknown entities. Patient indicated that during the most recent incident, he observed a black car outside his home. When asked who was in the car, patient stated it was “you know who—them.” Patient recounts that he attempted to remove his wife and child from the home at that point to “keep them safe,” but that his wife refused, and appeared worried about him. Per patient, wife often looks at him like she is worried about him. On at least two occasions, wife has entered the room and asked “who are you talking to?” Patient cannot recall anyone else ever being in the presence of him and his employer’s contact. Patient’s narrative suggests that he is experiencing hallucinations (his “employer”) and delusions (being “followed”). Patient has difficulty in expressing a coherent thought regarding these stresses. Patient also indicates mistrust of social worker; patient asked social worker “how do you say your name in Russian?” Patient states that he is being “threatened” and was very recently in the vicinity of unknown agents who were “shooting guns” at his employer. Patient acknowledges the requirements of his job are causing trauma, but indicates that he “wouldn’t be able to quit if he wanted to.” Likely that the “gun” incident was hallucination as well.

Strengths

Despite health concerns, patient exhibits remarkable intelligence. When not discussing the stresses in his life, patient is extremely well-spoken. Indicated that patient was previously on scholarship at an Ivy League school, and is published in his field. Patient is ambitious with his academic work. In addition, patient has expressed great care and concern for his family. Though the hallucinations and delusions that he experiences cause him great stress, the stress actually appears born out of his need to protect his family. When he feels that his wife and child are in danger, he attempts to remove them from that danger, even though he indicates that his wife does not experience those same feelings of danger. Patient has family supports, both through his wife and through his former colleagues at MIT (who wife indicates to social worker are indeed real).

Diagnostic Impressions

Patient presents with signs and symptoms of Schizophrenia (F20.9). Likely that experiences with “employer” are signs of patient experiencing hallucinations, as patient was not able to provide any third-person evidence that employer’s contact existed. Patient has also expressed feelings of being in danger, which indicate probable delusional thinking; patient admits that no one else in his life can collaborate on these intense feelings of danger. Patient possibly experiencing disorganized behavior “at work” (in his shed) based on the description of what he does for his “work.” Clear that patient is experiencing disorganized thought throughout session, as he has trouble explaining his stresses (the delusions and hallucinations). Patient indirectly indicated that he has possibly been experiencing these symptoms regularly for three years, which is well beyond the six-month requirement for this diagnosis. Patient has indicated that these concerns are affecting his family life, and has noted that he lost his full-time job because of them. No indication of substance abuse, medication intake, or autism.

Differential Diagnoses

According to information from DSM-5, we can rule out Delusional Disorder (F22). While it is evident that patient is experiencing delusions, those delusions also appear quite debilitating. Additionally, patient is experiencing severe hallucinations, and are related to the delusional theme.

Rule out Brief Psychotic Disorder (F23). While patient is experiencing at least one symptom (and possibly all four), it is evident that patient has been experiencing these symptoms for years. To fit this criteria, one would need to experience the symptoms for less than one month, before returning to previous level of functioning. Rule out Schizophreniform Disorder (F20.81) for the same reasons (symptoms present for longer than maximum required).

Rule out Schizoaffective Disorder, both bipolar type (F25.0) and depressive type (F25.1). No indication that patient is experiencing any major mood episodes in the absence of schizophrenia symptoms. No indication that patient’s baseline features any signs or symptoms of bipolar or depression.

Rule out Substance/Medication-Induced Psychotic Disorder, especially for other hallucinogens (either with substance use disorder (mild: F16.159; severe: F16.259) or without (F16.959)). Patient gives no indication that he ingests hallucinogens or any other substance prior to hallucinations or delusions. We would need to know more information about previous drug history, but without that information, we can rule out Hallucinogen Persisting Perception Disorder (F16.983) as well.

Rule out Schizotypal Personality Disorder (F21). While patient exhibits many symptoms of this disorder (odd beliefs, unusual perceptual experiences, odd thinking, suspiciousness, eccentric behavior, etc.), patient has outwardly expressed desires to form close relationships, especially with family and close friends. Patient feels need to “protect” family. Patient does not feel “discomfort” in his bond with his wife; he only believes that his wife feels uncomfortable with her relationship with him (due to her reactions to his behavior). Social worker would need many more sessions to diagnose with a personality disorder at all.

No comments: