Monday, April 11, 2022

Following Up with Record Club Alumni: Part 6


I'm gonna kill two birds with the same blog stone, since at least one of these was originally going to be a "Song of the Week" entry, but I couldn't decide which one. So you get mini-reviews instead.

New Preoccupations by Caracara
Released: March 25, 2022
Follow-up to: Better EP, Week 48

I haven't quite decided what I mean by this just yet, or how it relates to previous Caracara takes, but regardless: Caracara sound a lot more mature on this album. Maybe it's just cleaner—like, clearer production = more adultlike sounds? Maybe Caracara took all the right lessons from '90s alternative rock but I imagine that you have to be a certain age to even consider '90s alternative rock in the first place? Maybe, like the rest of us, Caracara has felt the world get smaller, harder, darker over the past few years, and that darkness is coming out in their songs?

Probably doesn't matter. What matters is that the big-guitar sounds on this album hit just like they should. It's just a huge fucking sound, what Caracara have going on here. Every sung lyric sounds like a shout from the tallest mountain. I love it.

So if we're following up on the previous RC review, then it's obvious that Caracara did what I had hoped they would do—take the sounds of their short EP and expand them. I just didn't realize they'd take that advice literally. But count me in.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5 (+0.5 from previous review)



THE UNRAVELING OF PUPTHEBAND by PUP
Released: April 1, 2022
Follow-up to: Morbid Stuff, Week 12

First, let me say that if I had to choose my worst review from the past 167 weeks (yes, there are a lot of candidates to choose from, ha, ha), I'd pick the Morbid Stuff review. The whole "if I'm not sad then I can't connect with sad lyrics" is the worst take I've ever cooked up. Fucking amateurish bullshit. Sorry, all. It's especially bad because it's clear after 100 additional listens of this band that PUP themselves aren't actually sad either. It's called irony, brah. Crafting a band's entire career around singing about how much you hate being in a band is a pretty great bit, when you think about it.

They take that bit to perhaps its logical extreme on THE UNRAVELING OF PUPTHEBAND, crafting a quasi-concept album about how shitty their band is and how miserable it makes everyone. I love the idea, even though it completely buries my shitty take from back in '19—the tension between happy/sad can't exist between band/audience when it already exists between band/band. It's so dumb in the most delightful way, honestly.

It's so delightful that I can't even bring myself to fault PUP for not including a right-away-year's-best catchy anthem on this album, like they did with Morbid Stuff ("Kids") and The Dream Is Over ("DVP"). Like Caracara, it feels like PUP took a lot of time to craft a piece of art that sounded exponentially larger and wider than anything they've ever done before. Unlike Caracara, this possibly made PUP forget—only slightly!—what it is exactly that they do best.

Okay, so this isn't their best. But the ambition means that they are still better than most of these other jabronis regardless.

GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5 (-0.5 from previous review)

No comments: