Tuesday, June 11, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 75: Pat

Prompt: "A song that is a fucking masterpiece, and yet something about it gives you slight pause"

Selected by Pat


"Lost in the World"
Kanye West ft. Bon Iver
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, 2024

I hadn't thought about this song in a long time. But then I came upon this video while researching for Epimemeology. I suddenly remembered "Lost in the World" was high in the running for Best Songs Pat Has Ever Heard. It makes perfect use of Justin Vernon and autotune. The lyrics are beautiful in their simplicity. I still get chills up my spine when I hear Elly Jackson sing "Run from the lights, run for your life." And it concludes one of the greatest albums of my lifetime. 

We all know what gives us pause, right? Kanye West (I guess he's Ye now) is a terrible person. He always kinda was, in both highly public and unseen ways. But in the last few years, the scales have shifted to where his obvious talent is now outweighed by how damaging he is. 

We could sit here all day and debate about Ye. Truthfully, PoYB is probably one of the last best places to do it online. Does mental illness excuse or explain any of this? Does Kanye's behavior and belief require people of conscience to shun his whole body of work? Can art be separated from this particular artist? 

I can only speak for myself in this post. In this particular instance, I can't separate the art from the artist. Any time I listen to Kanye West now, I feel a deep pang of uneasiness. It's not simply because of what he's done. It's also because I foresee Kanye West doing far more damage in the future. He keeps running for President. He has mysterious ranches in the countryside. Hell, Donda Academy might still be operating. He's not sorry and he's not stopping. Kanye's not even close to being done with his bullshit. The worst might be yet to come. 

So I'm out. My ears love "Lost In The World," but my stomach can't handle it.

6 comments:

Joe K said...

I appreciate you describing PoYB this way, and I hope you're right. I feel like I have personally written too much on the subject. I don't know how much of that is tuned out, maybe all of it. But I like the discussion and would love to hear other people's thoughts on it (though I already have a sense of some people's thoughts on it through their song choices and writings throughout the year).

Nate said...

Legitimate question, meant in the best possible faith: If one accepts the premise that Ye has been, if not reviled, certainly reconsidered in the eyes of the larger pop cultural public, would that de-centering have occurred if the music was still good? Had he not seemingly lost all interest in writing and recording music two weeks before the album was due, and if he continued to produce "Flashing Lights" and "Gold Digger"-level hits, would all this bad behavior look / be responded to differently?

Pat said...

It's an interesting question. To paraphrase Oppenheimer, talent makes up for a lot. A ton of people still defend him. I don't speak for the whole world. But I think what Kanye's been doing lately (i.e. going on InfoWars to talk about how great the Nazis were) is pretty indefensible, no matter how talented you are. I also think a Kanye West who was still releasing great music would be getting enough positive attention that he wouldn't feel the need to go on InfoWars and talk about great the Nazis were.

Joe K said...

The thing that I always say is that this is all a personal choice. We want to believe that there are great social movements to uphold or tear down certain artists based on their morals or lack thereof, but it's all a personal thing and nothing else. I choose to not listen to artists like Kanye West (or, for another example today, Mystikal) due to certain reasons, but I have to accept the fact that there is nothing I can do to force someone else to make the same choice. Just generally surveying the land, both society at large via the lens of the internet, and my friends here on this specific blog, I'd say that at least 50% of humans, probably way more, can separate art from artist.

Something that I was thinking about today is that this is fine when you're talking about the audience, that personal choice. I don't think someone choosing a to listen to a Kanye West song in 2024 necessarily makes a difference to that person or who they are or who they think they are. However, it DOES make a difference to the artist themselves. Let me see if I can do this succinctly (fat chance).

Okay, so say there's a new Kanye song. Now say there are two million people who are making a decision about whether to listen to that song, based on all that they know about the artist. One million of those people say fuck it, art and artist are completely separated, I'm listening to the song, and they listen to it, and it's pretty good, and they don't feel anything about themselves because they separated art and artist.

Except, in that scenario, there are one million people listening to Kanye's song, and so let's also think about how the artist himself is interpreting this data. He's not separating art and artist. He can't! It's impossible! Instead, he knows that one million people are listening to his song, and he interprets that as justification for his actions. He is a Nazi and it's okay for him to be a Nazi because he still has a Billboard #1 song in America in 2024.

What I would argue is that this means that you can't separate art from artist without consequence, no matter if that consequence doesn't affect you personally. As always, collective action would be key, and as always, we as Americans can't seem to do it, but instead lean on that rugged individualism that we so cherish, claiming that we are our own person and that everything we do should only mean anything to ourselves. When it doesn't.

I'm not meaning to be preachy. I am acknowledging that there's nothing I can do individually. If I had said something like "you cannot choose a song by a racist or by a rapist for Song Challenge," then the only thing that would have come of that would be me making two friends feel worse today, and subsequently that would make me feel like an asshole. I'm not listening to the Kanye song or the Mystikal song but that's my personal choice. I'm just wondering out loud whether that's not cowardly on my end, to say that, or if I should be doing more to convince people that it's never just a personal choice, it can't be.

To answer Nate's question: yes, better music would make it easier for your average listener to ignore the heinous shit and justify to themselves the act of bolstering that heinous shit.

To answer Pat's claim: I actually think that Kanye would feel BETTER about going on InfoWars if he had more listeners because the music was better.

Gilson said...

A line that I love (that I got from Last Podcast On The Left, which has its own issues) is “mental health is not your fault, but it is your responsibility.” Ye has seemingly abdicated that responsibility. If at some point in the future he decides that he needs to get better, then it’s fair to reconsider things. As it stands, for me at least, it’s difficult to extend that grace when ownership and accountability are not part of the discussion.

Pat said...

I, too, love that line and listen to LPOTL.