Prompt: "A song that is a fucking masterpiece, and yet something about it gives you slight pause"
Selected by Joe
"Your Deep Rest"
The Hotelier
Home, like Noplace Is There, 2014
I said all the way back on Day 38 that we'd be here today, Day 75, with this song, "Your Deep Rest," and I won't ever let anyone call me a liar. But I would be lying if I said that I felt like it was necessary beyond that. It fits the prompt—it gives me pause, it's a masterpiece—but I don't know. Maybe this isn't something I want to be doing today. The Hotelier takes a lot out of me. Their 2014 album Home, like Noplace Is There is my favorite album of all time for many reasons, and not all of those reasons necessarily feel good in the moment.
I almost regret that Day 38 write-up. I said almost. I get that it was something I had to do. But at the end of the day, it basically amounts to some fucking cis dude talking about being cis. It doesn't read like I wanted it to read, in retrospect. That's usually how these things go—the emotion I have rattling around in my head simply does not translate well onto the page. Still, if it failed as a public display, then it was mostly successful as a private therapy exercise. Primal scream via the blog. I felt mixed up before writing that thing and I feel considerably less mixed up afterward. I managed to avoid those therapy bills for another few days.
That's most likely the problem today—at this point, I don't really feel like I need to write about my relationship with "Your Deep Rest." I've already worked my way around it, and touching on the subjects I'd need to touch on will eventually start to feel like beating a dead horse. I am also afraid that if I go too far into the weeds and start mentioning the songs true themes (suicide) as opposed to the themes that I shoehorned into it (substance abuse), that I'll be out of my element, and it'll have the same foot-in-mouth quality that the "Life in Drag" write-up had.
Here's where I am at right this second. Temperature check: I am ready to try to write something for real, scream primally, at least for a couple minutes, and see how it goes.
I know I have issues with articulating how I feel inside to other people sometimes, but I can usually at least articulate it to myself. I'm usually self-aware to a certain degree. But during my lowest and most recent days of getting very drunk, I don't really know there was a point that I could articulate even to myself how I was feeling or why. I was drinking because drinking felt good and I was really good at it (too good, ha ha ha), but then what usually happened was that I would get pretty drunk and usually get that way by myself and I would get all wrapped up in my head and get really sad about... I don't know, just sad. Sad for myself that I was drunk again, sad as some manifestation of the unconscious guilt I felt for hiding that side of me from my family, sad as a placeholder for the physical illness that I would soon feel as the alcohol wore off as I traveled toward home and readied the breath mints.
A couple times a week, due to boring scheduling reasons, I would be "sobering up" on the drive home, usually I-76 to the Boulevard. And something compelled me, each of these times, to press play on Home, like Noplace Is There. By the time the speakers hit "Your Deep Rest," I was usually in tears.
It gets complicated because the song is about the protagonist grappling with a friend's death via suicide, and I was not contemplating that... but I also wasn't necessarily using the song as an ode to life or anything like that either. It was more that the protagonist is in the middle of an intense moment of grief, and feels emotion to the extent that they can't really stand to deal with it in any rational way, or articulate any way out of that feeling besides just being present for it, letting it hit them with its full force, and just fucking taking it and taking it some more.
I hope that makes sense, but it's possible that it doesn't. Nothing about substance abuse makes any fucking sense to me anyway, so maybe it shouldn't make sense here in this blog post.
The part that gives me pause, both now and maybe unconsciously then too, was that my story and the protagonist's story are not the same. Yes, they are wondering, as any friend probably would, what they could've done differently in that situation, whether there were signs that they could've seen, whether they could have reached out at a critical moment and saved their friend's life. But ultimately: not their fault. Breaking down at your friend's funeral is something that happens to you, and it is not a choice.
I hope that makes sense, but it's possible that it doesn't. Nothing about substance abuse makes any fucking sense to me anyway, so maybe it shouldn't make sense here in this blog post.
The part that gives me pause, both now and maybe unconsciously then too, was that my story and the protagonist's story are not the same. Yes, they are wondering, as any friend probably would, what they could've done differently in that situation, whether there were signs that they could've seen, whether they could have reached out at a critical moment and saved their friend's life. But ultimately: not their fault. Breaking down at your friend's funeral is something that happens to you, and it is not a choice.
Whereas I was making a choice, right? I was choosing to drink, I was choosing to drive, I was choosing to pop on the greatest emo song of our generation and punch the ceiling and scream until I was hoarse and risk everything to keep wringing myself out on clandestine beers at opportune and solitary moments of the day. A choice. And by comparing my sadness to the sadness in "Your Deep Rest," I was giving myself an excuse. Well it's okay that I'm drinking because I'm feeling something. No matter that those feelings were starting to mirror depression. I was okay, because the Hoterlier were sad too!
After coming to my senses, it took me a hot minute to reacquaint myself with this band and this album and this song, so entrenched were they in the part of my life that I was trying to excise. But the joy came back eventually, and it was purer this time. The music is still there. It's still larger than life emo music with heart on sleeve, catchy and knotty and both in all the right places, anthemic, and meant to be played loud no matter you BAC level.
It took listening to the album about a dozen times in full throughout the weekend that it turned ten for me to understand the deeper value than just "good music" for me at this point. This isn't a new subject for me or for what I write here but it's still true, maybe more true than ever in this case, but I'm talking about the sharing of stories. Real or fictional, the character in this story is sharing the story of a low point in their life. These stories are told for the listener to feel a connection, a kinship, maybe put some of their own pieces together, or just experience healing through empathy. I may be feeling it differently in sobriety, but I still feel sadness and regret and shame.
It took listening to the album about a dozen times in full throughout the weekend that it turned ten for me to understand the deeper value than just "good music" for me at this point. This isn't a new subject for me or for what I write here but it's still true, maybe more true than ever in this case, but I'm talking about the sharing of stories. Real or fictional, the character in this story is sharing the story of a low point in their life. These stories are told for the listener to feel a connection, a kinship, maybe put some of their own pieces together, or just experience healing through empathy. I may be feeling it differently in sobriety, but I still feel sadness and regret and shame.
I was reluctant to write about this song also because maybe I'm starting to feel like I've written too much about sobriety already, and it always seems to be in such a clumsy and reckless manner. And Gilson is writing so ably about the same subject in his posts, and Pat touches on the subject occasionally as the grizzled veteran, and Nate wrote a good one about drunk driving already. I questioned for a minute whether another blog post about my life before and then after drinking would even be necessary. But in thinking about the Hotelier's landmark album and about the stories that I've read on this blog and how fucking HELPFUL they have been to me so far, I figured that this might be an opportunity to pay it forward, maybe, I don't know. I'm not saying that I'm writing anything that anyone needs to hear. But I do write in the hope that maybe it could be helpful, at some point, to someone, maybe.
This is why we tell our stories. This is my story. I think "Your Deep Rest" is one of the most powerful and poignant songs that's ever been written. Whenever I hear it now, I think about my story. The story is what gives me pause when I hear the song. A slight pause, though, only to gently brush away the thin veneer of shame and regret and reacclimate myself and really get into the meat of this thing, the shit that matters. Not my story, but our story, a tapestry of stories stitched together on this blog and beyond.
5 comments:
I can feel myself wanting to get snarky with a lot of these. But I realized last night that the prompt had a typo (read "sight" but should have been "slight"), and I don't know if that affected anyone's interpretation, so I forfeit my right to be snarky.
This song blows. Next.
I will not be calling in sick for Nate's funeral.
There is no such thing as a wrong way to write about sobriety if it’s done honestly, in my opinion. So thank you for writing about it.
Gilson, I want to let you know that I will, in fact, be calling in sick for your funeral.
Post a Comment