Monday, June 10, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 74: Joe

Prompt: "A song you sang in elementary school during some sort of assembly or recital"

Selected by Joe


"I'm a Believer"
the Monkees
More of the Monkees, 1967

In seventh and eighth grades, I was part of the "Philadelphia Archdiocesan Honors Band," which sounds more impressive than it actually was. You had to have your school's band teacher record you playing a particular song, maybe a couple, and she would send it away and judges would pick the best ones and you'd be in. She set the whole thing up; this wasn't something that I was, like, asking for. It's just something that happened. I was fifth chair the first year, and then second chair the next.

At one point, there was a CD recording of that first year, and a professional VHS recording of the second year, but both of those physical media have been lost in time. I recall listening to that CD a decent amount. Wish I could tell you what was on it (besides one song that might be needed on Day 92 and so I'm not gonna be a heel and ruin that for anyone here over a month prior). My dad was a Home Video Camera Dad, though, and so there exists maybe twelve minutes of footage from that first year. A lot of it are songs that I still remember but would have no way of looking up without lyrics. There is one that I recognized and so I have spliced out the minute or so of that song below:


YSC already used the Shrek version of "I'm a Believer," but I'm ASSUMING that the band is doing the Monkees version and not the goddamn Smash Mouth version in a goddamn honors band (either way, the writer of that song is Neil Diamond, and so his name would adorn the music sheets we used). I don't particularly like this song in either of its popular versions, but I didn't know it well enough in seventh grade to have an opinion.

I do look kind of angry, though, at least in other parts of this longer video that I cut down. Can't really see me here, but I assume I have the same face as I did in the other songs. I guess that's my concentration face. I've said that I didn't care about my future, but I usually care a little too much about the present. Most likely the twitchy sixth-chair was pissing me off, or the adult percussion moderator was being way too involved in the music that kids were supposed to be playing. The moderator would be back the next year, and I don't remember his name. The twitchy kid would come back as first chair the following year too—dude must've hustled in the ten months in between.

This is all very boring to you right now, I can tell. I can see through my computer screen and out of yours, and I can see your face, and how your eyelids are drooping down over your eyes as if sleep is threatening. I have nothing to wake you up today. I wish I could say something like "and that twitchy-eyed kid was the best man at my wedding!" but that's not even remotely true. I never saw that kid again. Or maybe like "and the song we played after the Monkees one was 'Thong Song' by Sisqó!" but this was a Catholic Church thing. No thongs to be seen, or heard. I wouldn't lose my virginity for another six years.

I guess what I will say about all this is: don't get too excited over the fact that I was selected for the Archdiocesan Honors Band. This was small-time stuff. Yes, it was "selective," but the true savants weren't anywhere near this thing. If you were really good at the trumpet or sax or whatever, then you were doing All-State or All-Country kinda shit. Like, these were just the mopes who went to Catholic school and participated in their small school's failing band program and happened to be better than the other seven people in the band. It was mid-tier at best.

I had fun, and I wasn't thinking about these things while moving through this experience. I wasn't saying "this isn't that important" and I wasn't saying "this is really important." I wasn't thinking about importance or ranking or success at all. It was just some fucking thing I was doing. 

Here's what I think about now, though: I seem to do really well in situations in which I'm a medium-to-big fish in a medium-to-small pond. I say this all the time about going to La Salle University, a fucking puddle compared to the big state schools. I was able to be the president of the jazz and pep bands and an editor on the newspaper and have speaking roles in six theater productions because the school we went to just didn't have the numbers to hold anyone who was all that significantly better. I wouldn't have done any of that shit if I had gone to somewhere like Penn State. I think about that sometimes, and I'm truly perplexed as to how the fuck I would've spent my time at that school, in some alternate universe that I go to State. What do the average folk do there? I have no fucking clue.

This is what I like, though. I think maybe ultimately it really is an ego thing. Or a weird, contradicting mix of terrible ego and pathological humility. I refuse to accept any accolades for being part of an "honors" band, but I also would never in a million years have tried out for a "higher" band than that because I knew I would hit the ceiling very quickly. Could I have been "more" than a social worker living in the fake suburbs of Northeast Philadelphia? Maybe. But that's not really my personality to try to find out. I'm cool where I am, and I'm cool coasting into whatever good things come my way in this small, small pond.

No comments: