Wednesday, June 12, 2024

It's Not Too Late: YSC, Day 75: Brianna

Prompt: "A song that is a fucking masterpiece, and yet something about it gives you slight pause"

Selected by Brianna


"Wake Up"
Arcade Fire
Funeral, 2004

While there's always been known faults in putting artists and celebrities on pedestals as the best of us, recent years have made it glaringly obvious that we are all humans and, let's get real, many humans suck. 

I've heard a lot of people say that it's okay to separate the art from the artist, but I honestly have a hard time doing that. You will not catch me putting a Michael Jackson tune in my Spotify queue, nor did I celebrate with my support teacher when she "snagged her front row Chris Brown tickets" in the middle of our class. There's not a cell in my body inclined to separate those awful men from the awful things they did. 

This is where Arcade Fire now gives me pause. In 2022, several accusations came out about frontman Win Butler. Not all were as serious as the two names listed above, but like isn't trauma trauma no matter what? To use fame as a way to cause hurt in another human being, you can just go ahead and put that all in the same basket. I haven't put the band on by personal choice since, and have removed their songs from my playlists. 

A friend and I grappled with this together one day. Going back to humans sucking, is there a chance these women are same and are using his fame for personal gain? I mean, maybe, sure, anything is possible. I do, however, find it hard to believe that five unconnected women could coordinate an attack on a middle-tier indie rock act. Does Arcade Fire have the standing, the money to be worth it? My mind has a hard time with that.

I tried doing some research today about the accusations and if there's been any progress on getting to the truth of the matter. Nothing, just continued denial and attempts to keep touring. For me, not enough to sway my musical enthusiasm back in their favor. The pause continues on.

No comments: