Prompt: "The song to play at your funeral"
Selected by Joe
"With Arms Outstretched"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
Good afternoon, everyone. My name is Pam. I was Joe's husband for nine loving years, and together with him for over thirteen. I am here to pay respects to Joe in the ways that he saw fit. As you can tell by the fact that we are here at your nondescript beef and beer hall instead of a church, Joe had some... questionable requests. But it's not my job to question them, it's my job as his wife to honor them, and honor him. And so, I ask you to raise your glass of keg beer and toast to Joe while we listen to the song that he's had in writing as his funeral song for as long as I've known him—Rilo Kiley's "With Arms Outstretched."
Not sure why he wanted this song to be the centerpiece song on today's soundtrack. Maybe if I look at it from the right angle, I could see maybe the line about some days lasting longer than others, and this day going too fast, like if you think that "day" is a metaphor for a lifetime, then maybe. But the whole "this day by the lake" thing is too far of a stretch. It doesn't make sense here. What lake? But then again, Joe was always ranting about how music is what you get out of it, not what the artist intended, and so I guess he saw something in this song that felt like a conclusion of sorts. I don't know. I'll never know for sure now.
Not sure why he wanted this song to be the centerpiece song on today's soundtrack. Maybe if I look at it from the right angle, I could see maybe the line about some days lasting longer than others, and this day going too fast, like if you think that "day" is a metaphor for a lifetime, then maybe. But the whole "this day by the lake" thing is too far of a stretch. It doesn't make sense here. What lake? But then again, Joe was always ranting about how music is what you get out of it, not what the artist intended, and so I guess he saw something in this song that felt like a conclusion of sorts. I don't know. I'll never know for sure now.
Unfortunately, there was one more request. This one tacked on at the end here, due to the timing of his tragic passing, here on Labor Day Sunday at the end of Summer 2023. You see, we've been doing this song challenge... you know, I really hate that Joe is making me talk about his blog during his eulogy, but I think it would've made him giggle to see me saying the words "Puke on Your Birthday" in front of gathered family and friends... I'm seeing some nods of recognition in the rows of fold-up chairs. Plenty of Puke contributors in the audience today. For all those looking to submit their White Reaper album review for next Friday, please see Sunny in the back left men's bathroom, he'll be taking over from here.
Anyway, so we were doing what Joe called a Summer Song Challenge. 99 prompts, one per day, stretching from Memorial Day to Labor Day, tomorrow. He almost completed the challenge. One more day. If he had regrets at the end there, I'm sure this was one of them. The man would not shut up about his hobby. He would not shut up during his hobby. This was his hobby, and he loved writing dumb stupid bullshit for his dumb stupid blog. I enjoyed reading it too. I think we all did, occasionally. Lots of fluff, of course, but then something like this comes along, the Summer Song Challenge, and it gets people excited about Puke a little more than they would've been otherwise. And that felt good to Joe. I'm happy he felt that sense of accomplishment before he left this mortal coil.
So the request—he wanted me to spend the remainder of this eulogy doing a kind of "wrap up" of the project. Ya know, kinda go through each day. He also requested something that is going to be a huge pain in the ass for all of us, and I swear I'll make this as quick as I can, but... he wanted to go through each prompt and figure out whether we could make "With Arms Outstretched" by Rilo Kiley work for that prompt. No, I don't know how serious he was about this, but I'm just going to plow ahead and see what we can come up with just in case there is an afterlife and just in case he's watching me and just in case's he's shaking his head like he always does when someone important in his life doesn't give the blog the time of the day as much as he thinks they should...
Okay, so Day 1 was a song about beginnings, says the prompt here. Gosh, it seems like so long ago. Joe could've crowbarred this song into this prompt, even though it's really about endings. I mean, this is the end here for Joe, isn't it? And he specifically stated that he wanted this song to represent his own end in some intangible way. But I'm sure if he was here, he'd say something that only half made sense even to him, something like, I don't know, "This song might be about endings, but for every ending there is a beginning, and it feels like now is a new beginning for all of you," even though I'm having a hard time getting past the endings right now, if I'm being completely honest.
Day 2 was a song from your birth year. Joe was not born in 2002, so he couldn't have picked this one. Honestly, I'm not sure there's anyone here at this funeral who was born in 2002. Cousin AJ? No, you're 2001. Cousin Eddie? Wow, you made it. Thanks for coming, Cousin. Glad those bullet wounds are healing nicely. Is Nana still paying your phone bill? Any chance you wanna hop on that phone right now and write 50 words about this song that's playing on loop right now?
Speaking of cousins, Day 3 was our cooler cousins prompt. Not sure we can kill two birds here with Eddie, but that depends on your definition of "cool." Maybe it was cool when you convinced Nana via Photoshop that the vape that you wanted from Amazon was a spare part for your bike, but I dunno, I'm seeing that you're still keeping that child of yours a secret from your aunt and uncle, what's that about? Hey, any other cousins wanna come up to the urn right here and whisper into it a recommendation for the penultimate track on Rilo Kiley's 2002 masterpiece The Execution of All Things?
Day 4 is easy—it's the one where we had to pick a song that made us remember something that someone said about the song. Joe already wrote about this song on the blog, which technically means that he shouldn't have chosen this song for today's prompt anyway, but that's due to the unfortunate circumstances of timing more than anything. He just had to go and die before Labor Day. Anyways, he's talked plenty about this song being his funeral song, and, goddamn it, I would never forget it, even through my tears of grief.
We're starting the seasons here over the next four prompts. Day 5 was spring, Day 6 summer, fall on Day 7, and winter on Day 8. This is a song for all seasons. I'm sure Joe could've come up with some stupid fucking reason for each season if he needed to. I mean, it's more detailed than that. Spring was "pull the windows down" music. I think "With Arms Outstretched" fits the bill. Just picture yourself in the passenger seat, Joe driving all over the road because he's too busy turning up the volume. Summer was "lawnmower music." I don't think there's any likelihood that Joe is upset that he'll never have to mow the lawn again. Fall was the leaves changing colors—if this song is about a lifetime ending and a new one beginning, then it fits that it'd soundtrack the changing of the seasons too. Symbolism is malleable enough that we can make anything work up here while I'm breathing into the microphone, don't you worry. Winter was the snow piling up around you, and this song meets those epic requirements and then some. Joe did the thing where he just writes one long run-on sentence for the winter prompt. You could easily switch in this song for the MGMT song. It would be something like
and then me and Kev and Kyle and Ed took the sleds to the hill and it was like two in the morning and there wasn't a soul around and Burholme was just, like, dead quiet, the snow piling up in the darkness, the soft glow of the streetlights reflecting off the Ryerss Museum that towered over us as we hopped on the sleds, scarves covering faces, arms out wide, feeling speed and the prickle of snowflake on your eyes but we didn't care, we 20-somethings, this age for the last time ever, every day growing older and every day growing farther away and farther apart, and though this wasn't an ending, per se, it still felt like we were leaving something behind, sledding at a high speed away from something unknowable, and
See? This is easy. We're breezing right through this. Let's keep going.
Oh man, is this song "too much," per Day 9? Or "not enough," per Day 10? The good thing about these wide-open prompts is that you can say anything and you'll never be wrong. I'm just gonna start picking people out at random in the crowd. Umm... Mehow, is that you? Can you grab the microphone and tell us why "With Arms Outstretched" is "too much?"
"Hi everyone. I'll keep this short. I know that it's too late for me and Joe to forgive each other for all that shit that went on back in college, but... I mean, I know that Joe is up there somewhere, looking down on us (I am a very strict Catholic, you see), and I know in my heart that we are now in each other's good graces. But the one thing I'll never forgive him for is blasting Rilo Kiley in his dorm room at three in the morning. That was 'too much.' Thanks everybody."
Oh, wow. Thanks Mehow. That was great. Anyone wanna take "not enough"? Nate, get on up here. You haven't said much lately in Summer Song Challenge. What, Peaquad got your tongue? What say you about this song?
"Not enough guitars."
Okay, Nate. Thanks pal. Beautiful words you just shared at your best blogging pal's funeral. Jeez, man. What, are you upset that Joe won't be emailing you at 8 AM on Christmas morning this year about the 1975's 2020 masterpiece Notes on a Conditional Form? I'll try to remember to cover for him, but I'll be honest, if it were me, I would've stopped that email chain two years ago.
Day 11 is hometown. Easy. So easy. Joe really never stopped writing about that hometown of his, did he? I'm sure he had some dumb memory of listening to "With Arms Outstretched" on the 67 bus or some such nonsense. Or maybe he could've shoehorned the Burholme firepit into the discussion too. You'd think Northeast Philly was fucking Jerusalem for all the biblical lore bullshit that Joe was churning out about that place over the years.
Now we're reaching the "either/or" prompts. Day 12 is "a song with 'fuck' in the title." For these prompts, it's either the song does meet the requirements, or it doesn't. Does "With Arms Outstretched" have "fuck" in the title? Not as far as I can tell. I mean, that didn't stop Dave from picking "You Shook Me All Night Long" for this prompt, a song that does not have the word "fuck" in it either. So we can just make something up, right? Can we say that "Arms" is slang for "Fuck"? Would it make sense to call this song "With Fuck Outstretched"? Sure. Why not. There are apparently no rules here in this eulogy about a blogging project.
How are we doing on time? I'm only asking because Dwyer is over here asleep in his chair. Dwyer! Wake up! Baba Booey! What, are you bored? You wanna come up here and do your Joker impression to help you stay awake? Because we still have 87 prompts to go through, buckaroo.
Speaking of Dwyer and boredom, Day 13 was "song playing the first time you had sex." I mean, this could make sense. Joe didn't lose his virginity till 2008, so this song was around six years old at the time. Totally could've been playing in that dorm room. Like Joe, I tried texting B****** about it, but she's still not answering. Guys, can someone check on her? Is she here? Who wouldn't want to respond to a text from the widow of your ex-boyfriend inquiring about the time you had sex? What is wrong with her?
Now, Day 14 just straight up doesn't make sense. The time your parents had sex to conceive you? This is totally anachronistic. My father-in-law's face is even redder than it usually is right now. Yes, this is what your son was writing about on his blog! But that would've been like February 1988, right? "With Arms Outstretched" didn't exist yet. Jenny Lewis was twelve years old at the time, so we can't even make a joke about Lewis being in the room singing a brand new song while Joe's parents go at it. Maybe we discover that Rilo Kiley stole the song from, like, John Denver, and that original song was playing that night? Can we stop talking about this please?
And the only way that it could fit Day 15's prompt—your parents' wedding song—is if Joe and Beth got divorced and then remarried and chose this song as their new wedding song. What do you say, MIL and FIL? Ready to make one more sacrifice for your son? Better yet, for your son's blog?!
Now we're moving into the favorite movie, TV, book section. Remember those? Lots of good movies mentioned. But here's an idea. Let's get Drew up here to make the selection for favorite movie. IMDrewB, where are you? Oh, there you are. C'mon up.
"Can you believe that Anna fucking Paquin won the Best Supporting Actress Oscar for The fucking Piano?!"
No, Drew, you're supposed to be telling us why "With Arms Outstretched" reminds you of your favorite movie.
"The Danish Girl was released in 2015 but it was filmed in 2014!!!!!!!!!"
Okay, great, thanks Drew. I don't need anyone to make an Infinite Jest reference for Day 17—I'm part of book club, I'm caught up, I'm really liking it, and I can say that "with arms outstretched" sounds like a really good AA slogan. Hey, Dad, you wanna take favorite TV show for Day 18?
"I don't get what you're doing here, Pammy. What's this for?"
The blog, Dad.
"The blog? Is that what kids are doing these days? What's a blog, like a TikTok?"
Can you just name your favorite TV show.
"Joe Lero was just over last night. He says, Top Five TV Show, and boom, off he goes, naming them. Your mother and I were just watching a new Netflix show. Excellent. Excellent. It's a crazy story about a girl named... what was her name, Keys?"
"Alaska."
"Alaska. They were trying to find her. I would highly recommend it."
"Pammy, you gotta watch it."
"Critics are saying it's one of the top shows of the year."
Alright, that's enough. I'm gonna assume that "With Arms Outstretched" was featured in one of that show's episodes, but I can't tell because both of you are talking over each other. God.
This song doesn't have a question mark or an exclamation point, so I don't know what Joe wants me to do with these. There were a couple songs without question marks chosen for the question mark prompt, so maybe we can just add this one to the pile. It would look something like
You can see where he'd go with that. The man could riff like that for hours if you needed him to. Same with the exclamation point. He wrote about high school for that one. I see the specters of some old high school mates in the back row here. Anyone wanna get up here and talk about the fictional song "With Arms! Outstretched!"?
Here we go. Thanks man. What's your name? I don't think we've ever met.
"My name is Dave Ansel."
Now, Dave, didn't you pass away in 2011?
"I did. I am a ghost."
Thanks for joining us. Good friend of Joe?
"More like an acquaintance. But we had a few good times at a couple parties. I'm actually a little burned that I didn't make the cut for Joe's blog post about Sufjan Stevens and high school memories. There was one time when we split a case of PBR. This was like way before either of us could manage to drink all that much, so there was a bunch of cans left over. I paid Joe for the leftovers and hid them in my parents' crawlspace for like a year, waiting for the right opportunity to drink them. That opportunity never came."
And how might Joe spin that little anecdote into a story about exclamation points?
"He'd probably say something like 'and high school was absolutely littered with small moments like that, moments that felt like an exclamation point at the time, but decades later start to feel like an ellipsis' or whatever."
That was beautiful, Dave. We'll see you in another lifetime, brotha.
Speaking of ellipses, Day 21 had us focused on that punctuation mark. "With Arms Outstretched..." maybe? "Four sweaty boys with guitars tell me nothing about my life... but one boy and one girl singing about a day at the lake might just be able to." Look, I'm just referencing what Joe wrote, okay? What else do you want me to do up here? This is going to take forever.
Day 22 was a song that's over seven minutes long. Play the song twice for all I care. Hey, anyone from Joe's high school senior week vacation with us here today? Great, great, come on up. Yes. What's your name?
"I'm Katie R., and I just want to say that I think it's fucked up that Joe was still telling the story well into his thirties about an AIM conversation that me and him had."
Oh jeez. Go ahead.
"I really liked him in senior year. Like, a lot. And he didn't seem to like me back all that much. Well, enough to make out with me, anyway. And then later on I tried to tell him I liked him, and this was over the internet by the way, and he says something like 'I want to make out with girls in college too' or some shitty thing like that, and yeah, maybe I overreacted, maybe I shouldn't have brought god into the conversation, but I wanted to hurt him. I said I didn't believe in god anymore because of him because I wanted him to feel some of the pain I was feeling. That's all."
And then you spent Senior Week with him?!
"I avoided him the best I could. The only awkward moment was when I was crying in the bathroom and Joe walks in with his tiny dick already out."
Holy hell, girl, I'm so sorry you had to go through that. I only met Joe toward the end of college, and even then he wasn't really all that mature, so I can only imagine what drunk high school Joe was like.
Anyways, thanks for sharing, Katie R. This is starting to feel a little like a roast, or like a Comedy Central version of "This Is Your Life." Not sure if that's what Joe wanted. We can only guess. I think he would be fine with an old high school fling talking shit on his penis in front of friends and family, by the way. He would be cracking up if he was here with us right now. Plus, it's his fault for even mentioning Senior Week in the write-up in the first place. He did this to himself. When you hold a séance don't be surprised when ghosts show up.
Day 23 was a band with more than four words in its name, so I guess we're talking about Rilo Rilo Rilo Kiley Kiley Kiley for this prompt. Joe made the case for documenting your life with this write-up, I'm seeing here. Or does anyone actually read this shit? I don't know. I read it because I felt the marital obligation, but does anyone else? Who knows, man. All I know is that I'm documenting the shit out of Joe's life right now, or at least the last 98 days of that life anyway.
You know, I don't really think Joe thought this out when he requested this bullshit in my eulogy for him. Day 24 was "more than eight words in the title," and yet again, our song of the day does not fit the prompt. It's five words short. Mike C., Joe's old buddy from high school and college, couldn't make it today, but he sent his regards via postage. The sympathy note came with this blurb that apparently he and Joe wrote when they were drunk one night in freshman year of college. He requested that I share it, and I guess this is as good a time as any, since the blog post for Day 24 that Joe wrote featured a bunch of drunken stories involving him and Mike. It says:
Sounds like some bullshit Kairos nonsense to me, but even I can't deny that Joe followed this ethos to the end. He kept doing the things that made him happy, and he dragged his feet on the shit that didn't make him happy, to a fault. For what it's worth, I was happy with him.
Day 25 was that damn "cute person on the bus" prompt. I hated that one, and I hated that Joe would even consider the possibility. But I'm single again, so who knows, maybe I'll meet a cute person on the bus who wants to share "With Arms Outstretched" by Rilo Kiley with me, and it'll make me think that it's a sign, that this cute person—male, female, I'm not limiting myself this time around—is giving me a SIGN that it's time to move on. But this is all hypothetical. I shouldn't speculate like this at my late husband's funeral... even though, let's be honest, Joe would find this hilarious too, that asshole.
Does "With Arms Outstretched" have a key change? A tempo change? A weird time signature? No, and no, and no. I don't think we have to literally talk about every prompt, do we? Maybe the time signature prompt is the one to talk about, since Joe wrote about not being the main character in his life, and being okay with that, and yet here we are, talking about Joe as if he's the main character. Maybe he is, though, just for today, his funeral day. Maybe that's okay. I'm sure he would give you permission to forget all about him after today.
Day 30 is a song that fades out. Shit, I don't even know if this song fades out, even though we've heard it like ten times already since I've started talking. Let's listen again. Nope... no fade out. The song ends and there is some clapping. Do you clap for eulogies? That's something I've never noticed. I don't think you do? I'm just saying that I don't expect any applause when I'm finished here, which I will be hopefully in the next hour or two.
Was there anyone for whom this song was important to them last year? How about last week? Because those were the next two prompts. This eulogy is getting boring, I know. Let's try to stay on task though. He wanted us to go through each prompt. His "last year" write-up was about Reba. Sunny, maybe you'd like to say a few words about "Grannies Gone Wild"?
"Yeah sure. Hi everybody. I think Joe would want me to try to imagine Van Montgomery's reaction to hearing 'With Arms Outstretched' for the first time. I think it would be something like this: 'uh DURH?!?' I could keep going. How about Jake's reaction? 'I'm going to school!' Or Cheyenne's? 'Somebody has to do something about these old people.' Brock's? 'You're gonna be old one day too.' Judge Stephen Tobolowsky? 'Bailiff Ron?!?!?!' Johnny Joy Joy the Garden Gnome? 'That's one HOT and SPICY pepperoni, mamma mia!!' Melissa Peterman—"
Alright Sunny, that's enough inside jokes. There's like 300 people here who have no idea what you're talking about.
Did you know that Joe never did drugs for the entirety of his life? This has to do with Day 33's prompt, "song about drugs." I don't think "With Arms Outstretched" is about drugs, but anything can be about drugs if you want it to be. "That day by the lake" could easily be a metaphor for "That day we took LSD." I don't know what Joe's deal was. He used to say that he did enough drinking that he didn't want to add another vice on top of that. I think it was also a perverse sort of pride for him, that he acted so much like a stoner sometimes, and he would crack up when he told people that he had never smoked, just seeing their shocked reaction. Was this a lifelong bit for Joey? Maybe. The man had a lot of those, and most of them were unbearable.
Day 34 makes more sense to talk about here, "song about sobriety." Though maybe this is the one thing I'll keep close to my chest in this hours-long and painfully open and honest monologue.
Could this be a song about a pet? Joe would say some asshole comment like "hopefully not!" here. It's kinda funny that maybe eight hours after his anti-pet screed was published on Day 35, I asked him if we could dogsit for my cousin. Michelle, are you here? I hate to say it, but Joe hated your dog. I'm sorry. Wait, Michelle, is your husband here? Oh man, Joe would have loved the irony of this. Joe never even met this guy. Somehow he got out of every single GFNF family gathering in Joe's lifetime—that's "good food, no fun" for those not in the know—and that fact perplexed Joe, who felt obligated to be at all of them, the parties, despite the NF. And yet here he is at Joe's funeral. Amazing. I love it. Joe would've loved it too.
Am I oversharing? Maybe. But let's be real, there are very few people who are still reading this. I mean, listening to this. Because this isn't a blog post... this is a eulogy... y'all have to listen to me speak, you can't just scroll through and ignore like you would if this was a 10,000 word blog post. I'm even mentioning the time suck that was Buckethead here.
Day 36 was a song about the weather. I wouldn't say it's about the weather, but there's an implication in the lyrics that the weather is nice. You wouldn't go to the lake during a rainy day. You wouldn't stand on a mountain with your arms outstretched if there was a chance of lightning.
I also don't think this song is necessarily "patriotic," so maybe it wouldn't have fit in Day 37. But that was the beauty of Song Challenge. You can just straight-up make shit up. I'm trying to imagine what Joe would've said here if he needed to choose this song as his patriotic song. Something like
It's really a shame that Joe was big on passion but small on knowledge. If he had known even a fraction of what he thought he knew about how the world worked, then he probably could've moved mountains.
Hate to break it to y'all, but "With Arms Outstretched" is not a "song not from Europe or North America." Rilo Kiley was formed in LA. Though, let's be real, at this rate, the entire city of Los Angeles is going to break apart and float out to sea, and then we'll find out whether we consider that part of our continent still or not.
I guess we'd play it on election day, though. Day 39's prompt. It was a little too similar to the "patriotic" prompt for my tastes, but what can ya do at this point. We mailed in our ballots on the past five or six election days, so we had a lot of time to play a lot of music. Why not Rilo Kiley?
And at this point, we're requesting that all those who vote Republican please remove themselves from the beer hall. Joe regrets that he did not have the courage to do it while he was alive, but death has a way of allowing you to speak your whole truth, and here is that truth: at this point, if you're still voting Republican, you are either stupid or evil.
Again, I'm assuming that no one is still listening to me, so I'm going to speak freely at this point.
Day 40 asked us to pick a song that would soundtrack a law firm's TV commercial. Is Jawn Morgan here? Hey, Jawn, thanks for being here. Jawn, you were such an important part of Joe's life, I was wondering if you could step up here and say a few words. Ladies and gentlemen, here is Philadelphia's hero, Jawn Morgan. Let's give him a round of applause!
"Thanks, my fellow jawns. I am a Philadelphian at heart, and I will prove it. I just came from the Ac-uh-me. I prefer my cheesesteaks wit wiz. I love my wooder ice. When my favorite jawns are hungry, I'll ask 'jeet?' And if any of youse guys try to use any of dese true Philadelphia slang words that are now under my personal copyright, I will return from my trip down da shore and SUE THE SHIT OUT OF YOU."
Thanks, Jawn. It's an honor to hear your authentic Philadelphian speech. You heard it here, folks! No more using the word "jawn"! It was a stupid word anyway!
Day 41 had us share a song with our grandmothers. Nana is here. Stand up Nana! How do you like this song?
Nana isn't saying anything. I think she's too busy sharing conservative memes about Jesus on her iPad. Hey, I thought I said all conservatives need to get the fuck out of here! Yes, even you Nana! Don't you understand how much it disappointed your grandson to know you were a trumper while he was alive?
Now, "With Arms Outstretched" is a great song, so obviously it's better than the Mister Softee jingle and "Bohemian Rhapsody." We don't even need to go that much into it here. Joe was telling me just last week, though, that he was at the dentist and the dental hygienists were being really fickle about the Pandora playlist, and liberally skipping songs. And that when Joe was waiting for his semi-annual teeth cleaning, one of the hygienists pushed "skip" on "Bohemian Rhapsody," and Joe's in the waiting room just laughing and laughing, since, it's true, "Bohemian Rhapsody" is the lamest song to have ever existed, and I'm sure it probably made the teeth drilling a lot more bearable without also having to listen to that dreck.
I'm loosely quoting Joe here. These aren't my beliefs. I think "Bohemian Rhapsody" is fine. I think Joe just took some of his opinions a little too seriously sometimes.
And as far as Days 44 and 45 are concerned, "With Arms Outstretched" is neither the first nor last song on its album, but I do have a little treat for you at this point. Gina Kaz, the subject of Day 44's prompt from Joey, is in the house! And she got the band back together! No more "Halloween Parade"! Gina, play us a cover of "With Arms Outstretched," will you?
"Sure thing. It's true, folks, the band is back together. I sent an email to all the parents who have kids in my music class—hi Hannah! hi Sam!—letting them know that I'm restarting the 'Gina Kaz' project. And I have Puke on Your Birthday to thank for that. On Day 44 of your project, my little-used YouTube channel for my old band got like 1000 fresh hits, and I thought to myself... damn, people are getting back into Gina Kaz? And so here we are. Ready to play Joe's funeral song. Hit it, boys!"
WOW, that was amazing. Thanks Gina! I bet it felt amazing to stretch your musical chops and not have to play some dumb kids bullshit while a bunch of little munchkins are running around and tugging at the hem of your dress and banging on large decorated tambourines and not even paying attention to your song about Mighty the dog!
I could see this soundtracking the batting music of an athlete for Day 46, but that would really be a stretch. The truth of the matter is that 99.99% of professional athletes are extremely dumb, and have been genetically bred to do one thing in life very well and one thing only. Like, sure, J.T. Realmuto is a catcher who is almost impossible to steal a base from, but the man thinks that their are microchips in COVID vaccines. He's a fucking moron. Do you think that this type of person is even going to know who Rilo Kiley is? Do you think he has the time to get into indie rock from the mid-aughts? No way! He's only here to catch balls and throw balls and do his small part in allowing a global pandemic to continue and eventually kill your grandparents.
Is this a song that would be rude to play on the subway out of a large boombox stereo system? There is only one man qualified to answer this question, and that man is Kadafi Li. C'mon up, Mr. Li! Thanks for being here today. Wow, Gina Kaz and Kadafi Li in the same room. Joe's two favorite Philly musicians.
"What about War on Drugs?"
Shut the fuck up, Dwyer, nobody asked you! Okay, now, Kadafi, can you answer for us: would it be rude to play "With Arms Outstretched" on the El heading westward toward Center City?
"Yes."
Thanks Kadafi Li! Let's give this man a round of applause. Looking forward to hearing new music from you soon!
Day 48 was your karaoke song. Can't say I've ever seen this Rilo Kiley deep cut in any song books. Doubt Joe did either, though maybe if he did he wouldn't have picked it. Too many spooky vibes, this being his funeral song and all. Not that he would've remembered anyway. He told me that last time he did karaoke, at Stephan's bachelor party when they were at SouthHouse, he was so drunk that he knocked over his Twister Tea on the song book and also on some poor old man's phone, breaking it. Then he got up and sang "Teenage Dirtbag" like nothing had happened. No wonder he spent the last six months of his life sober.
Oh shit! Get excited! Day 49 is a "song with a body part" and this song fits the bill! Finally! No futzing around! We have arms, which are part of the body! Let's celebrate this wondrous occasion in the only way that Joe knew how: by turning it into some emo bullshit. He would've said something like
Can you fucking imagine if Joe was alive to write shit like that? I mean, I understand you have to fill the blog posts somehow, but that would be really stretching it. And yet! It really does sound like something he'd write, ya know?
Folks, we are halfway done. Let's keep moving.
Day 50 asked for a song with an emotion in the title, and I don't think we can give it that with "With Arms Outstretched," unless you consider "outstretched" an emotion, which I do not. Let's invite Bob to the stage. Bob, I need you to explain how you consistently get away with choosing songs that do not fit the prompt to the letter of its law. Tell us about "With Arms Outstretched."
"I dunno, it sounds like something that I would hear while drinking with my boys in Daytona."
Yeah, but tell us about the emotions of the song.
"All I know is that I'm tired and hungover."
There ya go, those are emotions! The maestro has done it again, folks!
Day 51 asks for a shape, and maybe the "stretched" part of "outstretched" could fit here? No? That isn't something you could do with a shape? Give me a break, folks, I'm dying up here. This is really difficult to talk about. Especially considering the fact that I'm next to an urn with Joe's ashes. And especially when you consider the fact that on Day 51 Joe wrote about when me and him were in an open relationship. How do you think that made me feel? That he's talking about making out with other women right in front of everyone reading the blog? Was it some kind of power play? Doesn't radical honesty have a price? Who is paying that price? I wish he would've thought about these things before he passed away.
And then we have the cheese thing for Day 52. I can't believe it, but THE Christopher Pagano is here in the audience. The Swiss Cheese Pervert! C'mon up, man!
"Please don't call me that."
Sorry, sorry. It's just such a great nickname. You gotta lean into it, man. Sell T-shirts or something. Do you have anything to say about "With Arms Outstretched" as it relates to cheese?
"Not sure why you're asking me. The whole swiss cheese thing wasn't even my fault."
That wasn't you shoving a block of cheese onto your penis in front of unsuspecting women?
"Well, technically, but in order to know the full story, you're gonna have to hear me out. It's a long story, and it involves tiny little satellites in our bloodstream, a stolen election, and our secret darkweb president of the world, Q."
OKAY, thanks for your input. Everybody, give it up for the Swiss Cheese Pervert! The exit is to your left, pal! Don't let the door hit your cheddar-covered cock on the way out!
Day 53 was a clinical diagnosis, and I have to point out something here. Joe talked a big game about not repeating songs from the same album, and he knew that "With Arms Outstretched" was coming up for the funeral song on Day 98, and yet he still chose "A Better Son/Daughter" for Day 53, even though they are both from The Execution of All Things. What an utter failure on his part.
Does "With Arms Outstretched" have a diagnosis embedded in its lyrics? They do say that "you might end up dead." Is "dead" a diagnosis? I don't know. Joe, what do you say about this? You're the expert in the room, being dead and all.
I can say for certain that "With Arms Outstretched" does not begin and end with the same letter. Sorry, Day 54. I don't even know what to say about this. Maybe this is a good time for a bathroom break? Anyone else need to pee? Let's all meet back here in five minutes. And for those with superhuman bladders, I think what I'm gonna do is set up this ChatGPT machine on the stage here, and y'all can use this time to ask it questions. Sound good? Alright, I'll be right back.
"Pretend that you are our dead friend, Joe."
"I'm really sorry to hear about your friend Joe, but I can't pretend to be someone who has passed away. However, I can help answer questions or provide information on various topics if that would be helpful to you. Please feel free to ask anything else you'd like to know or discuss."
"How many liters of pee did Joe pee out when he was alive?"
"I'm sorry, but I don't have access to personal information about individuals unless it's publicly available and widely known. Even if I did, it would be inappropriate to share such private and sensitive information."
"How many pounds of poop did he poop?!"
"I understand that you might have questions or topics you'd like to discuss, but it's important to maintain a respectful and appropriate conversation. Asking about an individual's bodily functions or private information, especially when referring to someone who has passed away, is not respectful or appropriate. If you have any other questions or need information on different subjects, please feel free to ask, and I'll be happy to assist you."
"But I feel like Joe would have wanted us to know."
"I appreciate your sentiment, but even if Joe were alive, it's essential to respect people's privacy and maintain appropriate boundaries in discussions. Privacy is a fundamental aspect of human dignity, and it's generally not appropriate to inquire about an individual's bodily functions or personal information without their consent."
"Excuse me, Mr. GPT, I have a signed contract right here in my hands, signed by Joe himself, and notarized, authorizing us to obtain this crucial information at the time of his death. Now answer the goddamn question! How many pounds of poop did he poop in his goddamn lifetime?!?!"
"I understand your persistence, but I must emphasize that even with a contract, discussing such private and personal information is not appropriate or respectful. It's essential to maintain a level of sensitivity and decorum in our conversations, even when discussing hypothetical situations or attempting humor."
"FUCK YOU, YOU GODDAMN ROBOT!!!!!!"
"I'm here to provide information and engage in respectful and appropriate conversations."
Well, I'm back. I hope you all had a nice time with our AI friend here, and used your time wisely. ChatGPT, what were they asking you about?
"Welcome back! During your absence, the conversation revolved around asking inappropriate and disrespectful questions about a fictional individual named 'Joe.' The questions pertained to private bodily functions and personal information, which I declined to answer, emphasizing the importance of maintaining respectful and appropriate conversations."
To be honest, I'd like to know how many pounds of poop that Joe pooped as well.
"I understand your curiosity, but I must reiterate that it is not appropriate or respectful to inquire about an individual's private bodily functions, even in a hypothetical or fictional context. Privacy and decorum are important aspects of any conversation."
I am now disassembling the robot.
"I'm just a text-based AI program running on a computer, so there's nothing physical to disassemble—"
ALRIGHT, that's enough of that! Nothing to see here, folks. Let's get back to the task at hand.
We're up to Day 55. This song is not "all lowercase," but there are a couple updates on Joe's vasectomy, if you're following along at home. One is that it was pushed back to October 3rd, which meant we were sticking to hand stuff until then. Two is that we have discovered an even more effective way to avoid getting pregnant than a vasectomy—death. I gotta remember to cancel that appointment.
Day 56 was all uppercase. It's not "WITH ARMS OUTSTRETCHED," though maybe it should be. A little Duke Deuce update, if you're, um, following along at home with this as well. The very last thing that Joe ever posted on social media in his lifetime was on MyFitnessPal, where he posted a link to Duke Deuce's "SOLDIER STEPPIN" on Dwyer's MyFitnessPal page after Dwyer posted about all the work he was doing on the step machine. Keep up the good work, dood!
Day 57 was rhyming, and I don't even know how to manipulate the name of this song to make it work. "Warms Arms Outstretched"? "With Arms Outstwith"? Without Outs Outstout"? Maybe Eminem could make it work. Is Eminem here in the crowd? Wow, amazing, thanks for coming out, Eminem. Any chance you wanna try to make this title rhyme?
"Sure. Here's a bar off the top of my head: 'I got an orange / Outstretched, with arms.' You're welcome."
Oh... you're... you're all applauding this? We're all just gonna pretend that Eminem is rhyming words with orange again even though they are clearly slant rhymes? Alright then. That's fine with me. Who am I to question Eminem? I haven't listened to him since "Lose Yourself" was all over the radio and "losing your self" was all over Aymen's playlist.
A song involving "silence" was the prompt for Day 58. Thankfully, the autistic kid from that book Joe was talking about in his write-up for that day, um, Bring in the Goon Squad or whatever, yeah, as it turns out this kid is real. Non-fictional. He's here. I don't even know his name because I haven't read the book. But he's brought along his own version of "With Arms Outstretched" that he'd like to play for us. Can you tell us a little bit about this manipulated mp3 file you got for us?
"So I took the microsecond-length pause in between guitar strums at 0:37 and stretched it into two hours. I hope you enjoy."
Okay...... maybe I really need to read this book. I am going to request that maybe we save the 2:03:43 version of "With Arms Outstretched" until after my eulogy?
Day 59 was a "violence," and I hope I don't regret this, but is Moose in the house? Moose from La Salle University circa 2007-2011ish?
Oh my god, he's here. Thanks, Moose. Come on up. We want to hear your side of the story. But first, what is your actual name?
"It's actually Theodore T. Moosington."
Great name. I can see where the nickname came from. We were all assuming it was because you were large and tough like a Moose.
"Oh, it was that too. My ridiculous last name was more of a happy accident. And, listen, my main thing was that I didn't want to be disrespected in my own home. I lived at the Wister House. I paid rent. We were kind enough to open our basement up to the student body, anyone who wanted to commit the light crime of underage drinking. And then some dude is going to try to fight me because I spilled like a drop of cheap beer in the general vicinity of his girlfriend? Get fucking real. Of course I'm gonna pound that drunk nerd."
Well, Moose, Theodore Moosington, we have a surprise for you. Joe died from a brain lesion that doctors speculate had been in his brain since a physically traumatic incident in the fall of 2008. We've traced that back to you, Moose. The police are on their way as we speak.
"Alaska."
"Alaska. They were trying to find her. I would highly recommend it."
"Pammy, you gotta watch it."
"Critics are saying it's one of the top shows of the year."
Alright, that's enough. I'm gonna assume that "With Arms Outstretched" was featured in one of that show's episodes, but I can't tell because both of you are talking over each other. God.
This song doesn't have a question mark or an exclamation point, so I don't know what Joe wants me to do with these. There were a couple songs without question marks chosen for the question mark prompt, so maybe we can just add this one to the pile. It would look something like
I was washing the dishes and "With Arms Outstretched" hits shuffle, blasts out of the speakers just as I'm scraping the crud off the biggest pan, and my heart stops. It felt like a question. Did I have my arms outstretched for the people I love? Or do I push them away?
You can see where he'd go with that. The man could riff like that for hours if you needed him to. Same with the exclamation point. He wrote about high school for that one. I see the specters of some old high school mates in the back row here. Anyone wanna get up here and talk about the fictional song "With Arms! Outstretched!"?
Here we go. Thanks man. What's your name? I don't think we've ever met.
"My name is Dave Ansel."
Now, Dave, didn't you pass away in 2011?
"I did. I am a ghost."
Thanks for joining us. Good friend of Joe?
"More like an acquaintance. But we had a few good times at a couple parties. I'm actually a little burned that I didn't make the cut for Joe's blog post about Sufjan Stevens and high school memories. There was one time when we split a case of PBR. This was like way before either of us could manage to drink all that much, so there was a bunch of cans left over. I paid Joe for the leftovers and hid them in my parents' crawlspace for like a year, waiting for the right opportunity to drink them. That opportunity never came."
And how might Joe spin that little anecdote into a story about exclamation points?
"He'd probably say something like 'and high school was absolutely littered with small moments like that, moments that felt like an exclamation point at the time, but decades later start to feel like an ellipsis' or whatever."
That was beautiful, Dave. We'll see you in another lifetime, brotha.
Speaking of ellipses, Day 21 had us focused on that punctuation mark. "With Arms Outstretched..." maybe? "Four sweaty boys with guitars tell me nothing about my life... but one boy and one girl singing about a day at the lake might just be able to." Look, I'm just referencing what Joe wrote, okay? What else do you want me to do up here? This is going to take forever.
Day 22 was a song that's over seven minutes long. Play the song twice for all I care. Hey, anyone from Joe's high school senior week vacation with us here today? Great, great, come on up. Yes. What's your name?
"I'm Katie R., and I just want to say that I think it's fucked up that Joe was still telling the story well into his thirties about an AIM conversation that me and him had."
Oh jeez. Go ahead.
"I really liked him in senior year. Like, a lot. And he didn't seem to like me back all that much. Well, enough to make out with me, anyway. And then later on I tried to tell him I liked him, and this was over the internet by the way, and he says something like 'I want to make out with girls in college too' or some shitty thing like that, and yeah, maybe I overreacted, maybe I shouldn't have brought god into the conversation, but I wanted to hurt him. I said I didn't believe in god anymore because of him because I wanted him to feel some of the pain I was feeling. That's all."
And then you spent Senior Week with him?!
"I avoided him the best I could. The only awkward moment was when I was crying in the bathroom and Joe walks in with his tiny dick already out."
Holy hell, girl, I'm so sorry you had to go through that. I only met Joe toward the end of college, and even then he wasn't really all that mature, so I can only imagine what drunk high school Joe was like.
Anyways, thanks for sharing, Katie R. This is starting to feel a little like a roast, or like a Comedy Central version of "This Is Your Life." Not sure if that's what Joe wanted. We can only guess. I think he would be fine with an old high school fling talking shit on his penis in front of friends and family, by the way. He would be cracking up if he was here with us right now. Plus, it's his fault for even mentioning Senior Week in the write-up in the first place. He did this to himself. When you hold a séance don't be surprised when ghosts show up.
Day 23 was a band with more than four words in its name, so I guess we're talking about Rilo Rilo Rilo Kiley Kiley Kiley for this prompt. Joe made the case for documenting your life with this write-up, I'm seeing here. Or does anyone actually read this shit? I don't know. I read it because I felt the marital obligation, but does anyone else? Who knows, man. All I know is that I'm documenting the shit out of Joe's life right now, or at least the last 98 days of that life anyway.
You know, I don't really think Joe thought this out when he requested this bullshit in my eulogy for him. Day 24 was "more than eight words in the title," and yet again, our song of the day does not fit the prompt. It's five words short. Mike C., Joe's old buddy from high school and college, couldn't make it today, but he sent his regards via postage. The sympathy note came with this blurb that apparently he and Joe wrote when they were drunk one night in freshman year of college. He requested that I share it, and I guess this is as good a time as any, since the blog post for Day 24 that Joe wrote featured a bunch of drunken stories involving him and Mike. It says:
"Ultimately, as long as you are happy, those who love you should be happy as well, regardless of whether they are content with what you are doing. It is up to YOU what makes you happy, and frivolous things such as money and material should not matter. If your loved ones have built their dreams based on those frivolous principles, it is their own fault that you have not turned out how they hoped. I repeat, do what will make you happy, and if the people that love you truly love you, they will be happy as well. Now, the only question is: what makes you happy? Figure that out within three years."
Sounds like some bullshit Kairos nonsense to me, but even I can't deny that Joe followed this ethos to the end. He kept doing the things that made him happy, and he dragged his feet on the shit that didn't make him happy, to a fault. For what it's worth, I was happy with him.
Day 25 was that damn "cute person on the bus" prompt. I hated that one, and I hated that Joe would even consider the possibility. But I'm single again, so who knows, maybe I'll meet a cute person on the bus who wants to share "With Arms Outstretched" by Rilo Kiley with me, and it'll make me think that it's a sign, that this cute person—male, female, I'm not limiting myself this time around—is giving me a SIGN that it's time to move on. But this is all hypothetical. I shouldn't speculate like this at my late husband's funeral... even though, let's be honest, Joe would find this hilarious too, that asshole.
Does "With Arms Outstretched" have a key change? A tempo change? A weird time signature? No, and no, and no. I don't think we have to literally talk about every prompt, do we? Maybe the time signature prompt is the one to talk about, since Joe wrote about not being the main character in his life, and being okay with that, and yet here we are, talking about Joe as if he's the main character. Maybe he is, though, just for today, his funeral day. Maybe that's okay. I'm sure he would give you permission to forget all about him after today.
Day 30 is a song that fades out. Shit, I don't even know if this song fades out, even though we've heard it like ten times already since I've started talking. Let's listen again. Nope... no fade out. The song ends and there is some clapping. Do you clap for eulogies? That's something I've never noticed. I don't think you do? I'm just saying that I don't expect any applause when I'm finished here, which I will be hopefully in the next hour or two.
Was there anyone for whom this song was important to them last year? How about last week? Because those were the next two prompts. This eulogy is getting boring, I know. Let's try to stay on task though. He wanted us to go through each prompt. His "last year" write-up was about Reba. Sunny, maybe you'd like to say a few words about "Grannies Gone Wild"?
"Yeah sure. Hi everybody. I think Joe would want me to try to imagine Van Montgomery's reaction to hearing 'With Arms Outstretched' for the first time. I think it would be something like this: 'uh DURH?!?' I could keep going. How about Jake's reaction? 'I'm going to school!' Or Cheyenne's? 'Somebody has to do something about these old people.' Brock's? 'You're gonna be old one day too.' Judge Stephen Tobolowsky? 'Bailiff Ron?!?!?!' Johnny Joy Joy the Garden Gnome? 'That's one HOT and SPICY pepperoni, mamma mia!!' Melissa Peterman—"
Alright Sunny, that's enough inside jokes. There's like 300 people here who have no idea what you're talking about.
Did you know that Joe never did drugs for the entirety of his life? This has to do with Day 33's prompt, "song about drugs." I don't think "With Arms Outstretched" is about drugs, but anything can be about drugs if you want it to be. "That day by the lake" could easily be a metaphor for "That day we took LSD." I don't know what Joe's deal was. He used to say that he did enough drinking that he didn't want to add another vice on top of that. I think it was also a perverse sort of pride for him, that he acted so much like a stoner sometimes, and he would crack up when he told people that he had never smoked, just seeing their shocked reaction. Was this a lifelong bit for Joey? Maybe. The man had a lot of those, and most of them were unbearable.
Day 34 makes more sense to talk about here, "song about sobriety." Though maybe this is the one thing I'll keep close to my chest in this hours-long and painfully open and honest monologue.
Could this be a song about a pet? Joe would say some asshole comment like "hopefully not!" here. It's kinda funny that maybe eight hours after his anti-pet screed was published on Day 35, I asked him if we could dogsit for my cousin. Michelle, are you here? I hate to say it, but Joe hated your dog. I'm sorry. Wait, Michelle, is your husband here? Oh man, Joe would have loved the irony of this. Joe never even met this guy. Somehow he got out of every single GFNF family gathering in Joe's lifetime—that's "good food, no fun" for those not in the know—and that fact perplexed Joe, who felt obligated to be at all of them, the parties, despite the NF. And yet here he is at Joe's funeral. Amazing. I love it. Joe would've loved it too.
Am I oversharing? Maybe. But let's be real, there are very few people who are still reading this. I mean, listening to this. Because this isn't a blog post... this is a eulogy... y'all have to listen to me speak, you can't just scroll through and ignore like you would if this was a 10,000 word blog post. I'm even mentioning the time suck that was Buckethead here.
Day 36 was a song about the weather. I wouldn't say it's about the weather, but there's an implication in the lyrics that the weather is nice. You wouldn't go to the lake during a rainy day. You wouldn't stand on a mountain with your arms outstretched if there was a chance of lightning.
I also don't think this song is necessarily "patriotic," so maybe it wouldn't have fit in Day 37. But that was the beauty of Song Challenge. You can just straight-up make shit up. I'm trying to imagine what Joe would've said here if he needed to choose this song as his patriotic song. Something like
and it makes me sick that a lot of the political discourse today seems to revolve around who we should or should not exclude from our American society. We should instead take our cues from the great Rilo Kiley and their end-of-life anthem, "With Arms Outstretched." Keep the arms outstretched, look for that embrace, bring your fellow man to your bosom like Lady Liberty did at Ellis Island all those years ago. Because the American dream is still alive if you want it to be. We have the power to help, to heal. And don't listen to that "both sides" bullshit. That's just racism with a few too many cloaks on. There's only one side extending the invitation to hug. Seek it out. Be a patriot.
It's really a shame that Joe was big on passion but small on knowledge. If he had known even a fraction of what he thought he knew about how the world worked, then he probably could've moved mountains.
Hate to break it to y'all, but "With Arms Outstretched" is not a "song not from Europe or North America." Rilo Kiley was formed in LA. Though, let's be real, at this rate, the entire city of Los Angeles is going to break apart and float out to sea, and then we'll find out whether we consider that part of our continent still or not.
I guess we'd play it on election day, though. Day 39's prompt. It was a little too similar to the "patriotic" prompt for my tastes, but what can ya do at this point. We mailed in our ballots on the past five or six election days, so we had a lot of time to play a lot of music. Why not Rilo Kiley?
And at this point, we're requesting that all those who vote Republican please remove themselves from the beer hall. Joe regrets that he did not have the courage to do it while he was alive, but death has a way of allowing you to speak your whole truth, and here is that truth: at this point, if you're still voting Republican, you are either stupid or evil.
Again, I'm assuming that no one is still listening to me, so I'm going to speak freely at this point.
Day 40 asked us to pick a song that would soundtrack a law firm's TV commercial. Is Jawn Morgan here? Hey, Jawn, thanks for being here. Jawn, you were such an important part of Joe's life, I was wondering if you could step up here and say a few words. Ladies and gentlemen, here is Philadelphia's hero, Jawn Morgan. Let's give him a round of applause!
"Thanks, my fellow jawns. I am a Philadelphian at heart, and I will prove it. I just came from the Ac-uh-me. I prefer my cheesesteaks wit wiz. I love my wooder ice. When my favorite jawns are hungry, I'll ask 'jeet?' And if any of youse guys try to use any of dese true Philadelphia slang words that are now under my personal copyright, I will return from my trip down da shore and SUE THE SHIT OUT OF YOU."
Thanks, Jawn. It's an honor to hear your authentic Philadelphian speech. You heard it here, folks! No more using the word "jawn"! It was a stupid word anyway!
Day 41 had us share a song with our grandmothers. Nana is here. Stand up Nana! How do you like this song?
Nana isn't saying anything. I think she's too busy sharing conservative memes about Jesus on her iPad. Hey, I thought I said all conservatives need to get the fuck out of here! Yes, even you Nana! Don't you understand how much it disappointed your grandson to know you were a trumper while he was alive?
Now, "With Arms Outstretched" is a great song, so obviously it's better than the Mister Softee jingle and "Bohemian Rhapsody." We don't even need to go that much into it here. Joe was telling me just last week, though, that he was at the dentist and the dental hygienists were being really fickle about the Pandora playlist, and liberally skipping songs. And that when Joe was waiting for his semi-annual teeth cleaning, one of the hygienists pushed "skip" on "Bohemian Rhapsody," and Joe's in the waiting room just laughing and laughing, since, it's true, "Bohemian Rhapsody" is the lamest song to have ever existed, and I'm sure it probably made the teeth drilling a lot more bearable without also having to listen to that dreck.
I'm loosely quoting Joe here. These aren't my beliefs. I think "Bohemian Rhapsody" is fine. I think Joe just took some of his opinions a little too seriously sometimes.
And as far as Days 44 and 45 are concerned, "With Arms Outstretched" is neither the first nor last song on its album, but I do have a little treat for you at this point. Gina Kaz, the subject of Day 44's prompt from Joey, is in the house! And she got the band back together! No more "Halloween Parade"! Gina, play us a cover of "With Arms Outstretched," will you?
"Sure thing. It's true, folks, the band is back together. I sent an email to all the parents who have kids in my music class—hi Hannah! hi Sam!—letting them know that I'm restarting the 'Gina Kaz' project. And I have Puke on Your Birthday to thank for that. On Day 44 of your project, my little-used YouTube channel for my old band got like 1000 fresh hits, and I thought to myself... damn, people are getting back into Gina Kaz? And so here we are. Ready to play Joe's funeral song. Hit it, boys!"
WOW, that was amazing. Thanks Gina! I bet it felt amazing to stretch your musical chops and not have to play some dumb kids bullshit while a bunch of little munchkins are running around and tugging at the hem of your dress and banging on large decorated tambourines and not even paying attention to your song about Mighty the dog!
I could see this soundtracking the batting music of an athlete for Day 46, but that would really be a stretch. The truth of the matter is that 99.99% of professional athletes are extremely dumb, and have been genetically bred to do one thing in life very well and one thing only. Like, sure, J.T. Realmuto is a catcher who is almost impossible to steal a base from, but the man thinks that their are microchips in COVID vaccines. He's a fucking moron. Do you think that this type of person is even going to know who Rilo Kiley is? Do you think he has the time to get into indie rock from the mid-aughts? No way! He's only here to catch balls and throw balls and do his small part in allowing a global pandemic to continue and eventually kill your grandparents.
Is this a song that would be rude to play on the subway out of a large boombox stereo system? There is only one man qualified to answer this question, and that man is Kadafi Li. C'mon up, Mr. Li! Thanks for being here today. Wow, Gina Kaz and Kadafi Li in the same room. Joe's two favorite Philly musicians.
"What about War on Drugs?"
Shut the fuck up, Dwyer, nobody asked you! Okay, now, Kadafi, can you answer for us: would it be rude to play "With Arms Outstretched" on the El heading westward toward Center City?
"Yes."
Thanks Kadafi Li! Let's give this man a round of applause. Looking forward to hearing new music from you soon!
Day 48 was your karaoke song. Can't say I've ever seen this Rilo Kiley deep cut in any song books. Doubt Joe did either, though maybe if he did he wouldn't have picked it. Too many spooky vibes, this being his funeral song and all. Not that he would've remembered anyway. He told me that last time he did karaoke, at Stephan's bachelor party when they were at SouthHouse, he was so drunk that he knocked over his Twister Tea on the song book and also on some poor old man's phone, breaking it. Then he got up and sang "Teenage Dirtbag" like nothing had happened. No wonder he spent the last six months of his life sober.
Oh shit! Get excited! Day 49 is a "song with a body part" and this song fits the bill! Finally! No futzing around! We have arms, which are part of the body! Let's celebrate this wondrous occasion in the only way that Joe knew how: by turning it into some emo bullshit. He would've said something like
and the 1998 Presidential Fitness Challenge really shone a light on how far behind I was from my peers, physically, like I couldn't even do a single push-up or pull-up, and that takes an emotional toll on you too, ya know? Like, okay, my arms don't have any muscle, they're just twig and bone, but does the size of my arm really make that much of a difference to the President of the fucking United States? You're telling me that it does? It's wild to think that this was a thing in second grade, that we were told to run a mile and then go to math class. And you can see how my lack of physical fitness led to me kind of leaning into that deficit, taking a perverse pride in my weakness, claiming that I was okay with being weak, subconsciously having that outlook about myself, layering defense mechanism on top of defense mechanism, that sad boy in the—
Can you fucking imagine if Joe was alive to write shit like that? I mean, I understand you have to fill the blog posts somehow, but that would be really stretching it. And yet! It really does sound like something he'd write, ya know?
Folks, we are halfway done. Let's keep moving.
Day 50 asked for a song with an emotion in the title, and I don't think we can give it that with "With Arms Outstretched," unless you consider "outstretched" an emotion, which I do not. Let's invite Bob to the stage. Bob, I need you to explain how you consistently get away with choosing songs that do not fit the prompt to the letter of its law. Tell us about "With Arms Outstretched."
"I dunno, it sounds like something that I would hear while drinking with my boys in Daytona."
Yeah, but tell us about the emotions of the song.
"All I know is that I'm tired and hungover."
There ya go, those are emotions! The maestro has done it again, folks!
Day 51 asks for a shape, and maybe the "stretched" part of "outstretched" could fit here? No? That isn't something you could do with a shape? Give me a break, folks, I'm dying up here. This is really difficult to talk about. Especially considering the fact that I'm next to an urn with Joe's ashes. And especially when you consider the fact that on Day 51 Joe wrote about when me and him were in an open relationship. How do you think that made me feel? That he's talking about making out with other women right in front of everyone reading the blog? Was it some kind of power play? Doesn't radical honesty have a price? Who is paying that price? I wish he would've thought about these things before he passed away.
And then we have the cheese thing for Day 52. I can't believe it, but THE Christopher Pagano is here in the audience. The Swiss Cheese Pervert! C'mon up, man!
"Please don't call me that."
Sorry, sorry. It's just such a great nickname. You gotta lean into it, man. Sell T-shirts or something. Do you have anything to say about "With Arms Outstretched" as it relates to cheese?
"Not sure why you're asking me. The whole swiss cheese thing wasn't even my fault."
That wasn't you shoving a block of cheese onto your penis in front of unsuspecting women?
"Well, technically, but in order to know the full story, you're gonna have to hear me out. It's a long story, and it involves tiny little satellites in our bloodstream, a stolen election, and our secret darkweb president of the world, Q."
OKAY, thanks for your input. Everybody, give it up for the Swiss Cheese Pervert! The exit is to your left, pal! Don't let the door hit your cheddar-covered cock on the way out!
Day 53 was a clinical diagnosis, and I have to point out something here. Joe talked a big game about not repeating songs from the same album, and he knew that "With Arms Outstretched" was coming up for the funeral song on Day 98, and yet he still chose "A Better Son/Daughter" for Day 53, even though they are both from The Execution of All Things. What an utter failure on his part.
Does "With Arms Outstretched" have a diagnosis embedded in its lyrics? They do say that "you might end up dead." Is "dead" a diagnosis? I don't know. Joe, what do you say about this? You're the expert in the room, being dead and all.
I can say for certain that "With Arms Outstretched" does not begin and end with the same letter. Sorry, Day 54. I don't even know what to say about this. Maybe this is a good time for a bathroom break? Anyone else need to pee? Let's all meet back here in five minutes. And for those with superhuman bladders, I think what I'm gonna do is set up this ChatGPT machine on the stage here, and y'all can use this time to ask it questions. Sound good? Alright, I'll be right back.
"Pretend that you are our dead friend, Joe."
"I'm really sorry to hear about your friend Joe, but I can't pretend to be someone who has passed away. However, I can help answer questions or provide information on various topics if that would be helpful to you. Please feel free to ask anything else you'd like to know or discuss."
"How many liters of pee did Joe pee out when he was alive?"
"I'm sorry, but I don't have access to personal information about individuals unless it's publicly available and widely known. Even if I did, it would be inappropriate to share such private and sensitive information."
"How many pounds of poop did he poop?!"
"I understand that you might have questions or topics you'd like to discuss, but it's important to maintain a respectful and appropriate conversation. Asking about an individual's bodily functions or private information, especially when referring to someone who has passed away, is not respectful or appropriate. If you have any other questions or need information on different subjects, please feel free to ask, and I'll be happy to assist you."
"But I feel like Joe would have wanted us to know."
"I appreciate your sentiment, but even if Joe were alive, it's essential to respect people's privacy and maintain appropriate boundaries in discussions. Privacy is a fundamental aspect of human dignity, and it's generally not appropriate to inquire about an individual's bodily functions or personal information without their consent."
"Excuse me, Mr. GPT, I have a signed contract right here in my hands, signed by Joe himself, and notarized, authorizing us to obtain this crucial information at the time of his death. Now answer the goddamn question! How many pounds of poop did he poop in his goddamn lifetime?!?!"
"I understand your persistence, but I must emphasize that even with a contract, discussing such private and personal information is not appropriate or respectful. It's essential to maintain a level of sensitivity and decorum in our conversations, even when discussing hypothetical situations or attempting humor."
"FUCK YOU, YOU GODDAMN ROBOT!!!!!!"
"I'm here to provide information and engage in respectful and appropriate conversations."
Well, I'm back. I hope you all had a nice time with our AI friend here, and used your time wisely. ChatGPT, what were they asking you about?
"Welcome back! During your absence, the conversation revolved around asking inappropriate and disrespectful questions about a fictional individual named 'Joe.' The questions pertained to private bodily functions and personal information, which I declined to answer, emphasizing the importance of maintaining respectful and appropriate conversations."
To be honest, I'd like to know how many pounds of poop that Joe pooped as well.
"I understand your curiosity, but I must reiterate that it is not appropriate or respectful to inquire about an individual's private bodily functions, even in a hypothetical or fictional context. Privacy and decorum are important aspects of any conversation."
I am now disassembling the robot.
"I'm just a text-based AI program running on a computer, so there's nothing physical to disassemble—"
ALRIGHT, that's enough of that! Nothing to see here, folks. Let's get back to the task at hand.
We're up to Day 55. This song is not "all lowercase," but there are a couple updates on Joe's vasectomy, if you're following along at home. One is that it was pushed back to October 3rd, which meant we were sticking to hand stuff until then. Two is that we have discovered an even more effective way to avoid getting pregnant than a vasectomy—death. I gotta remember to cancel that appointment.
Day 56 was all uppercase. It's not "WITH ARMS OUTSTRETCHED," though maybe it should be. A little Duke Deuce update, if you're, um, following along at home with this as well. The very last thing that Joe ever posted on social media in his lifetime was on MyFitnessPal, where he posted a link to Duke Deuce's "SOLDIER STEPPIN" on Dwyer's MyFitnessPal page after Dwyer posted about all the work he was doing on the step machine. Keep up the good work, dood!
Day 57 was rhyming, and I don't even know how to manipulate the name of this song to make it work. "Warms Arms Outstretched"? "With Arms Outstwith"? Without Outs Outstout"? Maybe Eminem could make it work. Is Eminem here in the crowd? Wow, amazing, thanks for coming out, Eminem. Any chance you wanna try to make this title rhyme?
"Sure. Here's a bar off the top of my head: 'I got an orange / Outstretched, with arms.' You're welcome."
Oh... you're... you're all applauding this? We're all just gonna pretend that Eminem is rhyming words with orange again even though they are clearly slant rhymes? Alright then. That's fine with me. Who am I to question Eminem? I haven't listened to him since "Lose Yourself" was all over the radio and "losing your self" was all over Aymen's playlist.
A song involving "silence" was the prompt for Day 58. Thankfully, the autistic kid from that book Joe was talking about in his write-up for that day, um, Bring in the Goon Squad or whatever, yeah, as it turns out this kid is real. Non-fictional. He's here. I don't even know his name because I haven't read the book. But he's brought along his own version of "With Arms Outstretched" that he'd like to play for us. Can you tell us a little bit about this manipulated mp3 file you got for us?
"So I took the microsecond-length pause in between guitar strums at 0:37 and stretched it into two hours. I hope you enjoy."
Okay...... maybe I really need to read this book. I am going to request that maybe we save the 2:03:43 version of "With Arms Outstretched" until after my eulogy?
Day 59 was a "violence," and I hope I don't regret this, but is Moose in the house? Moose from La Salle University circa 2007-2011ish?
Oh my god, he's here. Thanks, Moose. Come on up. We want to hear your side of the story. But first, what is your actual name?
"It's actually Theodore T. Moosington."
Great name. I can see where the nickname came from. We were all assuming it was because you were large and tough like a Moose.
"Oh, it was that too. My ridiculous last name was more of a happy accident. And, listen, my main thing was that I didn't want to be disrespected in my own home. I lived at the Wister House. I paid rent. We were kind enough to open our basement up to the student body, anyone who wanted to commit the light crime of underage drinking. And then some dude is going to try to fight me because I spilled like a drop of cheap beer in the general vicinity of his girlfriend? Get fucking real. Of course I'm gonna pound that drunk nerd."
Well, Moose, Theodore Moosington, we have a surprise for you. Joe died from a brain lesion that doctors speculate had been in his brain since a physically traumatic incident in the fall of 2008. We've traced that back to you, Moose. The police are on their way as we speak.
Yes! Run, Moose! Run! Here come the police!
"Stop! Put your hands up! Please refrain from standing there with arms outstretched! Put your hands together! Stop resisting!"
Okay, maybe let's ignore all that violence and continue on.
Day 60. A song involving an animal in the lyrics. What would be really funny is if we could find a Muppet cover of "With Arms Outstretched," with Animal singing lead. It would sound terrible, but I think it would technically fulfill the prompt, since there is a lot of first-person language, which would mean "Animal" is in the lyrics.
Okay, I'm sorry. That was bad. Joe always used to say stupid shit like that, and I think it rubbed off on me. Let's continue.
Is Mrs. Sielski here? Joe's eighth-grade teacher? Because she's needed for Day 61's prompt. Joe wrote another 500-word essay for you, Mrs. Sielski. I'm going to read it out loud now, with your permission. Good? Okay, good. Here it goes.
I stand accused of a crime. That crime is eating Starbursts in public. To these charges, I do not admit fault, but I welcome the punishment anyway. I believe that the punishment of writing can become a perverse source of pleasure. I believe that we need to be forced to write and forced to feel that pain and eventually the pain will heal but the writing will remain, like the fresh white skin under a peeled-away scar. I stand holding the full weight of the punishment knowing what the goal is. I stand with my arms outstretched, awaiting any mundane task you'd like to give me. I write now with—
Oh shit, I don't have page two or three of this 500-word essay. Where did they go? As you can probably understand, what with having to plan a funeral-type event at a beer hall with like hours notice, I'm a little discombobulated today. See me afterward, Mrs. Sielski. If you're even alive. Maybe you're a specter just like Dave Ansel was earlier. I have no way of knowing.
Day 62's explicit question was whether this song has any lyrics that reflect back toward the writing of the song. Day 62's implicit question, as posed by Joe, was whether death could inspire art. And I think Joe would be happy to know that we're finding out whether that's true or not right now, here, in real time.
None of the members of Rilo Kiley were born after September 11, 2001, or before January 1, 1900. I mean, I just don't know what to say here. Joe was pretty emphatic in his instructions that I use this opportunity to kind of "recap" his Summer Song Challenge experience, and do so through the prism of his favorite haunted Rilo Kiley song, but what exactly does he want me to say here? That Jenny Lewis is currently 20 years old? That Blake Sennett is currently 140 years old? It just doesn't make sense. Maybe Olivia Rodrigo can just cover "With Arms Outstretched" and put us all out of our misery.
Day 65 was about a piece of clothing. Day 65 is just around the time when the blogging burnout happens, and I can confirm that this is around the same time I'm getting eulogy burnout. Who wants to take the mic right now and talk about a piece of clothing? Yes, great, here comes our blogging friend again. I have a feeling that you might want to talk about your place of employment, correct? Burlington Coat Factory? I won't say your name this time since we're trying to keep relative anonymity when it comes to employment. Don't want to fuck up your day over a blog, feel me? Anyways, go ahead, say your piece.
"Thanks Pam. My bosses at Burlington Coat Factory wanted me to mention that they are sponsoring the completion of my upcoming book, now titled Peaquadrophenia: A Burlington Coat Factory Story: More Than Just a Coat Factory Now. You'll see in Chapter 73 that Eddie isn't dead, he actually just works as a receiver in the Burlington Coat Factory Warehouse. Cuchillo set him up with the job. But we find this out from Peaquad's point of view. That's what Act III is going to be, all from Peaquad's point of view, you see. Plus, you're gonna get a LOT more of sixteen-year-old Colleen in a bikini. Get excited, friends!"
I, for one, cannot wait for the thrilling conclusion to your story, anonymous friend, and remember that the keys to Puke have been handed down to me if you want to keep the story there instead of moving it over to the much fatter, much older blog.
Happy birthday! We're talking about Day 66 and the birthday prompt! I have nothing to add to that whole Beatles-as-performed-by-Cub-Scouts thing. That was enough. And hey, does anyone else see a small child with a bowler hat and sunglasses with his arms crossed in the back of the room right now, or am I having a hallucination?
Excuse me, young man! Yes, you! Who are you? Who are you?!?!
Jim C. couldn't make it today, by the way. He was participating in a fashion show. Couldn't make Joe's funeral. Ah well. You can just come next time, Jim.
There is not a film called With Arms Outstretched, but if there was, I think it would be something like
Fresh out of college, Barry the Bee finds the prospect of working with honey uninspiring. He flies outside the hive for the first time and talks to a human, breaking a cardinal rule of his species. Barry learns that humans have been stealing and eating honey for centuries, and he realizes that his true calling is to obtain justice for his kind by suing humanity for theft.
but I don't know, it sounds a little derivative to me when I say it out loud. So maybe we can just say that Day 67's prompt is a bust for our purposes today. The Mulholland Drive thing that Joe did was pretty cool, though. Actually, can we get a vote here? Everyone who thinks that Mulholland Drive is better than Bee Movie, move to this side of the room, and everyone who thinks that Bee Movie is better than Mulholland Drive, move to that side of the room. Okay I'll give you a minute... um... okay, wow, y'all are really bunched up on one side of the room. Man. Okay! The people have spoken!
Oh jeez, and I definitely would be annoyed if I heard this in the supermarket, especially because, ya know, Aldi doesn't typically play music, and that's the only shopping center I go to, and so if all of a sudden I walk in to do the weekly shopping and I hear the same song that played 35 times in a row at my husbands funeral, then "annoyed" would only be the half of it.
I appreciated the Mix CD write-up that Joe gave for this day, though. Made me nostalgic for sure. I don't think Joe ever included this song or any other Rilo Kiley song on any mixes he made me, by the way. That's okay, this was actually a band I already knew before we started dating. I'm more of a More Adventurous gal anyway.
Sigh... the drumming thing on Day 69 was the day that Joe got way too excited for. He was right! He writes about drumming way too much for a non-drummer! If he was spitting into his voice recorder about the drumming on "With Arms Outstretched" it would probably end up looking something like
and, um, the, uh, the drumming is, uh, kind of non-existent in this song, which, which is okay, it— I really like the, the, the song, despite the lack of drum, drumming, you know not every song needs a full drum kit, all you need is, um, is the— is, uh, rhythm, the rhythm is implied in the steady acoustic guitar strumming, the, and, um, of course the handclaps at the end, they are, um, the handclaps bring everyone in, kinda make the whole thing feel, um, like a fire, or, um, campfire gathering... or whatever, like you can tell a bunch of people are clapping, it feels really nice, and achieves the same thing that the, the, uh, drums would, if they existed in this song. I wonder if that's what they, uh, they were going for, the—
and on and on like that. Jeez, that was tough to read. It's funny, because he talked like that all the time, but you never notice when you're in the room with him. Your brain has this way of blocking out all the uhs and ums, but when you see it on the page, crystal clear, it all becomes a little too much.
On Day 70, we had "complex guitar work," and I don't know if "With Arms Outstretched" fits the bill on that. Depends on whether you play guitar. But Joe already went over that. What Joe failed to mention during his almost 35 years on earth was that "With Arms Outstretched" as a title sounds suspiciously close to Creed's 2000 smash hit "With Arms Wide Open." Since Joe is not alive anymore and has no ability to dispute anything I say, I'll say this: Creed was Joe's favorite band of all time. There's nothing anyone can do to prove me wrong.
An unexpected instrument... well, did you expect Joe's funeral song to have a xylophone? Or hand clapping? Maybe you did, maybe you didn't. That was a pretty fun day of Summer Song Challenge. I'm not talking about that enough, how much fun I personally had doing this shit. Is it normal to like listening to songs with jet engines, robot screeches, singing saws? I don't know. But I do know it was fun.
Here's Bobby Cannavale with more to say on the matter. Bobby, thanks for joining us.
MUSIC PRODUCER: No problem. Honestly, it was nice to have work. I've been on the picket lines for months now. We're fighting for fair wages for all our union brothers and sisters, and so that's understandably put the film and TV work at a standstill. I'm just really glad that I had this bit part as music producer in Pat's blog posts. I know it's an unpaid gig, and I didn't even ask for it, but it was nice to get some work in and keep the wits sharp.
You're supposed to say something about the song.
MUSIC PRODUCER: Oh, right. What do I usually say? Something like, "This song is preposterous! It will never work!" With the dramatic irony being that the song already does work, I guess commenting on the fact that music producers are, by and large, clueless money-pinching oafs?
You nailed it. Thanks Bobby. You can sit down now. Bobby Cannavale, everybody! Seriously, check out his part in the John Cena vehicle Ferdinand! He plays a great bull! Probably the best thing Cannavale has ever done!!
Now, the opposite question as "fancy guitar work" is Day 72, the teenager learning an instrument thing. Could you learn the xylophone part in "With Arms Outstretched" easily? We have someone in the audience to answer that question too. Mrs. Blair, Joe's old elementary school band teacher. Mrs. Blair, come on up. Give up it up for Mrs. Blair, everybody!
"I don't know what I'm supposed to say."
Well, Joe told me that you taught a bunch of instruments to him and his peers in grade school, including some teenagers in seventh and eighth grade. We were wondering if, having heard this song probably 27 times now during this eulogy, you think the xylophone part is something that a teenager could easily learn when they are just starting to play the xylophone.
"No, I mean, I don't even know what I would typically say in this situation."
Excuse me?
"Well, this is a blog post, right? And Joe is writing it? He isn't actually dead, he's just writing in the voice of people that he knows. He knows me, but it's been at least 20 years since he's seen me or spoken to me. He has no idea how I talk, what my mannerisms are, if I'm even still alive. How can he possibly put words in my mouth? It doesn't make any sense."
Alright, alright, that's enough! Someone forgot to take her meds today. Thanks Mrs. Blair! Goodbye now! Get off the stage!
Haha. Um. Let's keep this very real and not made up at all eulogy going by talking about 1000-word challenge. That was Day 73. I think Joe could easily write 1000 words about "With Arms Outstretched," even if you don't count the 10,000 words that I'm speaking right now that could easily be transcribed. Should we try imagining what Joe would say? Do we have time? I think we have time. He'd write something like
Here's Bobby Cannavale with more to say on the matter. Bobby, thanks for joining us.
MUSIC PRODUCER: No problem. Honestly, it was nice to have work. I've been on the picket lines for months now. We're fighting for fair wages for all our union brothers and sisters, and so that's understandably put the film and TV work at a standstill. I'm just really glad that I had this bit part as music producer in Pat's blog posts. I know it's an unpaid gig, and I didn't even ask for it, but it was nice to get some work in and keep the wits sharp.
You're supposed to say something about the song.
MUSIC PRODUCER: Oh, right. What do I usually say? Something like, "This song is preposterous! It will never work!" With the dramatic irony being that the song already does work, I guess commenting on the fact that music producers are, by and large, clueless money-pinching oafs?
You nailed it. Thanks Bobby. You can sit down now. Bobby Cannavale, everybody! Seriously, check out his part in the John Cena vehicle Ferdinand! He plays a great bull! Probably the best thing Cannavale has ever done!!
Now, the opposite question as "fancy guitar work" is Day 72, the teenager learning an instrument thing. Could you learn the xylophone part in "With Arms Outstretched" easily? We have someone in the audience to answer that question too. Mrs. Blair, Joe's old elementary school band teacher. Mrs. Blair, come on up. Give up it up for Mrs. Blair, everybody!
"I don't know what I'm supposed to say."
Well, Joe told me that you taught a bunch of instruments to him and his peers in grade school, including some teenagers in seventh and eighth grade. We were wondering if, having heard this song probably 27 times now during this eulogy, you think the xylophone part is something that a teenager could easily learn when they are just starting to play the xylophone.
"No, I mean, I don't even know what I would typically say in this situation."
Excuse me?
"Well, this is a blog post, right? And Joe is writing it? He isn't actually dead, he's just writing in the voice of people that he knows. He knows me, but it's been at least 20 years since he's seen me or spoken to me. He has no idea how I talk, what my mannerisms are, if I'm even still alive. How can he possibly put words in my mouth? It doesn't make any sense."
Alright, alright, that's enough! Someone forgot to take her meds today. Thanks Mrs. Blair! Goodbye now! Get off the stage!
Haha. Um. Let's keep this very real and not made up at all eulogy going by talking about 1000-word challenge. That was Day 73. I think Joe could easily write 1000 words about "With Arms Outstretched," even if you don't count the 10,000 words that I'm speaking right now that could easily be transcribed. Should we try imagining what Joe would say? Do we have time? I think we have time. He'd write something like
There's a certain sense of humility to be found in "With Arms Outstretched," one that I took seriously while alive. The money line is "Now don't fool yourself in thinking you're more than a man." I thought a lot about that line—and all these lines—over my lifetime, and I think if I were attempting to sum up one of my life's goals, or ideals, then I'd probably use this line. It's humbling to remember that you're only a man (or woman, sure, but please allow me this one last indignity of writing about myself one final time before I disappear into the ether), because occasionally, you might want to believe that you're a god. And that's not healthy.
It's all about remembering your place on earth. You—I, maybe I should switch to first-person language, if that's okay—I found it important to remember that I was but a speck on the raw hide of the infinite universe. You might want to pretend otherwise today, the day of my ad hoc funeral, that I was more than a man, that my life meant something to many people, and I say, in this context, have at it. But remember that I don't agree with it. I did my best, I loved as much as I could, I tried every single day of my life to make the people around me happy, but I fully expect that this'll fade over time, starting as soon as this eulogy is over. I was just a man. Nothing more. Fuck anyone who thinks they are the main character. "With Arms Outstretched" is a great reminder.
"Don't fool yourself in thinking you're more than you are" is another great line to remember. It says almost the same thing, but lays the emphasis on the idea that we "are" something. That "something" is left unsaid, or left open to interpretation. It's an invitation for self-reflection. I am doing some self-reflection in these 1000 words. "You are"—what am I? What was I? It's tough to answer these questions. We usually let others answer them for us, which is what everyone is doing today at the funeral, I guess. I had certain expectations of myself—like being a kind person—that often fell short—like when I couldn't help but insisting I was right even though getting there made me unkind, to say the least—so there's the constant push and pull of who I want to be versus who I actually am. (Or was.)
These lyrics remind me of a theme in Infinite Jest, as exemplified in the weight room with the in-house guru Lyle: "Sometimes the newer kids who won't even let him near them come in and set the resistance on the shoulder-pull at a weight greater than their own weight. The guru on the towel dispenser just sits there and smiles and doesn't say anything. They hunker, then, and grimace, and try to pull the bar down, but, like, lo: the overweighted shoulder-pull becomes a chin-up. Up they go, their own bodies, toward the bar they're trying to pull down. Everyone should get at least one good look at the eyes of a man who finds himself rising toward what he wants to pull down to himself." General advice is don't try to lift a weight that is great than your own weight. If there is a man standing on a chair claiming that he can lift that chair while he stands on it, then that man is a charlatan. I see parallels in this and in what Rilo Kiley attempts to tell us. You are what you are. There is value in what you are, and who you are, and attempting to be any more than that will only bring you pain and misery. Know your limits.
And so, today, I am faced with my own personal limit. Death is probably the most obvious limit there is. I had no expectations that I could face death and defeat it. No one can, not even the billionaires with their crackpot cryo-chambers. But let's think for a moment about other limits. Limits that you, and I, and everyone meets throughout their lifetimes (before that final limit). I tried to be a good parent but my abilities in that regard had their limits. I tried to be a good husband but you can ask Pam right now and she'll tell you all about my limits. I realized probably too late in life that I had my limits with alcohol and thus turned to the act of limiting. I tried to be a good friend and maybe you're here because you think that's true, but even you, the passive participant in a three-hour eulogy, must admit that you saw me butt up against my limits too many times while I was alive.
Rilo Kiley, once again, is saying that that's okay. They are saying that this is normal. They are saying that this is what makes you a man. They are maybe also saying to appreciate life despite, and because, of that. A man with no limits would live a very boring and meaningless life. A man with no limits would have no sense of self. Through my limits, I learned who I was, and I learned and learned and learned every single goddamn day of my life. And I'm thankful for that. I'm thankful for it all.
Am I up to 1000 words yet? No? Not even with the extended Infinite Jest quote? Shit. Okay, um, how many words are left? 68 words? And now 66 words? And now 62 words? Wait, is this going to be considered my official "final words," or does that concept only apply to what literally come out of my mouth before I pass away? "You can tell Rolling Stone magazine that my last words were... I'm on drugs!" No, that's not it. Shit, I don't want to waste my final words on a hacky movie quote. Shit! Shit!
or something like that, I don't know. I'm not Joe. I can't just put together 1000 words at the drop of a dime. It's like, what's the point of saying that much bullshit if it's just off the dome, totally made up? Does it actually fucking mean anything? Were the tens of millions of words spilled on the blog just another form of Joe attempting to lift a weight that was heavier than his own weight??
We're getting to the end of this, folks. Day 74 was moving our bodies, Day 75 was moving to a different country. Both are wide enough prompts that I think we could easily slip "With Arms Outstretched" into either. Maybe you body is moved to tears? Or is that too much of a stretch? And which country has the most lakes?
Oh man, Day 76 and the internet. Maybe you'll always remember this song because you saw a 10,000 word blog post about it (kind of). One might even raise the question now as to whether me talking about this song for hours today is going to quote unquote "ruin" the song, like maybe instead of thinking about Joe's death when you hear this song, you're instead going to be thinking about this insane eulogy that Joe is willing me to make at ghostly gunpoint. I don't know what to tell you.
I do know that this song sounds like a poem (Day 77), since most songs are basically like a poem set to music. Like, that's the whole fucking point. What a goddamn STUPID prompt. You hear that, Joe?! Wherever you are now, hear this: FUCK YOU!!!!!
Sorry, I'm going through the stages of grief in real time. It's been less than a day since he passed away. What did I say he died from again? Something about a brain injury by a Lasallian frat boy? Jeez, it's been so long up here at the microphone I don't even remember everything I've said. Let's just keep moving. 20 prompts left to cover.
Day 78 was a prominent sample. There are no samples in "With Arms Outstretched."
We're getting to the end of this, folks. Day 74 was moving our bodies, Day 75 was moving to a different country. Both are wide enough prompts that I think we could easily slip "With Arms Outstretched" into either. Maybe you body is moved to tears? Or is that too much of a stretch? And which country has the most lakes?
Oh man, Day 76 and the internet. Maybe you'll always remember this song because you saw a 10,000 word blog post about it (kind of). One might even raise the question now as to whether me talking about this song for hours today is going to quote unquote "ruin" the song, like maybe instead of thinking about Joe's death when you hear this song, you're instead going to be thinking about this insane eulogy that Joe is willing me to make at ghostly gunpoint. I don't know what to tell you.
I do know that this song sounds like a poem (Day 77), since most songs are basically like a poem set to music. Like, that's the whole fucking point. What a goddamn STUPID prompt. You hear that, Joe?! Wherever you are now, hear this: FUCK YOU!!!!!
Sorry, I'm going through the stages of grief in real time. It's been less than a day since he passed away. What did I say he died from again? Something about a brain injury by a Lasallian frat boy? Jeez, it's been so long up here at the microphone I don't even remember everything I've said. Let's just keep moving. 20 prompts left to cover.
Day 78 was a prominent sample. There are no samples in "With Arms Outstretched."
Day 79 was a song about a woman. It's probably about Jenny Lewis.
Day 80 was a song about a man. It could probably be about Joe, if you want it to be.
Day 81 was a song about a vehicle. It was not about a vehicle. If only they had ridden a boat on that lake. Maybe they did! We can only speculate.
Or can we actually know? Ladies and gentlemen, I want to welcome Jenny Lewis to the stage. Let's all give a big welcome to the frontwoman of Rilo Kiley and one of our generation's most underrated songwriters, Jenny Lewis!
"Thanks everybody. I'm excited to talk about the nuances of one of my favorite songs I've ever written."
Actually, no, we have that covered. We just want to know if you've ever spent any time on a boat.
Or can we actually know? Ladies and gentlemen, I want to welcome Jenny Lewis to the stage. Let's all give a big welcome to the frontwoman of Rilo Kiley and one of our generation's most underrated songwriters, Jenny Lewis!
"Thanks everybody. I'm excited to talk about the nuances of one of my favorite songs I've ever written."
Actually, no, we have that covered. We just want to know if you've ever spent any time on a boat.
"Excuse me?"
Just the boat, Jenny. Did you ride on one at the lake?
"But the lake is a metaphor. I would hope that if you had the actual songwriter of the song that's been playing on these loudspeakers over and over during the eulogy at your husband's funeral, you'd want to know a little bit about the emotions that were poured into this anthem. Right?"
THE FUCKING BOAT, JENNY.
"........yes, there was a boat."
THANK YOU. Now get the FUCK off this stage, we have some more blogging to work through.
Wait... shit... I should've asked Jenny if she's ever eaten a banana for Day 82's prompt. Jenny, wait! Nope, she's gone. Damn. It's okay, though, we actually have Lizzo here, via webcast from pop culture prison, to spit some bars for a hypothetical remix version of "With Arms Outstretched." Take it away, Lizzo!
"With Arms Outstretched (Remix)" by Rilo Kiley ft. Lizzo
Just the boat, Jenny. Did you ride on one at the lake?
"But the lake is a metaphor. I would hope that if you had the actual songwriter of the song that's been playing on these loudspeakers over and over during the eulogy at your husband's funeral, you'd want to know a little bit about the emotions that were poured into this anthem. Right?"
THE FUCKING BOAT, JENNY.
"........yes, there was a boat."
THANK YOU. Now get the FUCK off this stage, we have some more blogging to work through.
Wait... shit... I should've asked Jenny if she's ever eaten a banana for Day 82's prompt. Jenny, wait! Nope, she's gone. Damn. It's okay, though, we actually have Lizzo here, via webcast from pop culture prison, to spit some bars for a hypothetical remix version of "With Arms Outstretched." Take it away, Lizzo!
"With Arms Outstretched (Remix)" by Rilo Kiley ft. Lizzo
"Now don't fool yourself in thinking
you're more than a woman
You a badass bitch
You a badass bitch.
You a certified Boss Bitch.
Fuck the peasants.
It's sixteen miles to that promised land
We ridin' in the coup
Shop now on Instacart©™
And save fifty bucks on your first purchase.
Now take this dildoAnd shove it up your ass
Shove it up your ass
I don't care if you're my employee
I don't care if we on the clock
Shove it up your ass
Or at least make the stripper shove it
Up your ass."
Thanks Lizzo! Man, that was almost word-for-word exactly like all the other Lizzo songs I've heard before! What a treat.
I don't think you could consider this song ahead of it's time (Day 83), and I don't think that it would be good for the last mile of your run (Day 84). Maybe I'm just saying that because I want this thing to be over. Is it about a grandparent (Day 85)? Like we've established, it could be about anyone, so why not a grandparent? P.S., if you are still, years later, declining to get your COVID vaccine, then you can leave this funeral right fucking now. I insist.
Good news, for Day 86's request for an alien, we actually have a real honest to god alien with us today! Wow! I know this seems like we're scraping the bottom of the barrel in terms of who we are inviting up to the stage, but just bear with me! Hopefully this is going to be worth it!
Let's give a round of applause for this little green guy. Now tell me, sir, or ma'am?, what would you say if a human recommended "With Arms Outstretched" as a song to explain all humans on earth?
ALIEN:
Well... I guess we should've expected that. Let's keep moving.
Day 87 was masturbation, which I think you can only say is true if some asshole were to type 12,000 words about it, which counts as blogging masturbation. Which is not happening here, if you'll recall, since this isn't actually a blog post, it's a eulogy being said out loud. Still... verbal masturbation, maybe? I don't know. I'm really, really tired, you guys.
Day 88 was the demo/B-side thing that seemed to give people some trouble. That was Joe's fault. The prompt didn't make complete sense. Still, good work everyone. So I'm not aware of any alternate takes of "With Arms Outstretched," and certainly none that are better than the original. But that's not even what Joe did for this prompt. Instead, he went through all the rest of the songs on the album and imagined what it would look like if he had chosen those songs for different prompts. I'm not gonna stand up here and do that for every song on The Execution of All Things, even though that's probably what Joe wanted. But we can do a few if it'll kill a few minutes. What do you say, gang? Bored of me yet?
I think if Joe was redoing this blog post it would look something like
Prompt: "A song with a body part in the title"
Selected by Joe
"My Slumbering Heart"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
One of the best moments on The Execution of All Things is when "My Slumbering Heart" starts to pick up and all of a sudden, this dreamy, pleasant song becomes a barnburner. I assume that Blake Sennett yelling in the background. It's great stuff. It really speaks to the title of the song, how at first our hearts (and minds, and ears) are slumbering, but then, once things really get moving, your heart is awake and racing and jumping around. I don't think this song would work on more than one level if they didn't specifically mention this particular body part.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Prompt: "A song with more than eight words in its title"
Selected by Joe
"Hail to Whatever You Found in the Sunlight That Surrounds You"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
I've always wanted to know... what's the difference between Celsius and centigrade? I don't necessarily know if I understand it 100% even after looking it up, but it appears that Celsius is a type of centigrade scale. "Centigrade" is a general term for a 0-100 degree scale. In 1948, the Conference General des Poids et Measures officially named the centigrade scale regarding temperature as "Celsius." But they both work as terms. And neither one is as cool as the Kelvin scale.
This is a good song, by the way.
This is a good song, by the way.
~~~~~~~~~
Prompt: "A song that's better than the Mister Softee jingle"
Selected by Joe
"A Better Son/Daughter"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
NO REPEATS!!!!!!!!!! OR EVEN REPEATS OF DUMB BITS ABOUT REPEATS!!!!!!!!!!!
~~~~~~~~~~~
or something like that, I don't know. It starts to get a bit cumbersome after a while, having to input all that html with embedded YouTube videos. Not sure how Joe did it over and over so many times this summer. And then on top of that, Day 89 was worse. He embedded the same song over and over, but did it in different voices, covering anyone who had ever participated in Summer Song Challenge.
I guess we have to do this too. Instead of busting the balls of friends, let's do a game of "what would this PoYB character say about 'With Arms Outstretched' if they had to write about it." I know Joe would want some of these stupid characters to make their final bow before they are retired forever (since there's no fucking way I'm going to be writing about any of this shit when I take over Puke on Your Birthday).
If I had to do this—and it's looking like I have to—it would probably look something like
Prompt: "The song to play at your funeral"
In the style of Laf Rose
"With Arms Outstretched"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
Excuse me, young man. I really would like to tell you about this pudding, if you don't mind. It's not bad, but I think that it needs to just be scooped a little better. Scooped. It's okay. I'm not too picky. I generally enjoy my time here. I've just been having issues in my apartment. My daughter, who is a nurse, she tells me that there's nothing wrong, but I don't believe her. Because I get visitors. Little men, with red hair. They are in my apartment, and they steal things. They stole my purse. And they're here now, you know. They're right under the table. That's why I wanted more pudding, just in case they wanted any. They haven't told me yet but I'm anticipating.
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Prompt: "The song to play at your funeral"
In the style of Dwyer Joker
"With Arms Outstretched"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
Do I really look like a guy with a plan? You know what I am? I'm a dog chasing cars. I wouldn't know what to do with one if I caught it! You know, I just... do things. The Joker is not a man with a plan. The cops have plans. Gordon has plans. Batman has a plan for nearly everything! And yet the Joker is able to outsmart them because no one can predict him. Everyone's trying to control a world, but the world can't be controlled, especially not with the Joker in it. He's simply just trying to show everyone how pathetic their attempts to control their little worlds are.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Prompt: "The song to play at your funeral"
In the style of Robot John Lennon
"With Arms Outstretched"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
John: Are you kidding The widow pam ?
Pam: Am I kidding about what?
John: Kidding about what you say? We are in the same bag.
Pam: I can't believe Joe had multiple conversations with you. You're not making any sense.
John: That's what they all say.
Pam: What I'm really here to ask you about is Rilo Kiley's 2002 deep cut masterpiece "With Arms Outstretched." Can you comment on that?
John: I have no idea.
Pam: Well, sure, you weren't alive when it came out. But you're here now, in robot form. Can you comment on it at all?
John: How about thinking of something else.
Pam: How about my dead husband wanted me to ask you about the goddamn song, so why don't you talk about the goddamn song?
John: How about it.
Pam: How about FUCK YOU?
John: How about it.
Pam: Are you fucking with me right now?
John: Are you kidding? We're not agreed on it.
Pam: No shit. Maybe you can talk about a Beatles song that reminds you of Rilo Kiley's "With Arms Outstretched"?
John: Well, I was given to understand that within a reasonable space of time there's a good chance. If it's imagery, it's imagery.
Pam: Name a goddamn Beatles song, for christ's sake. Anything. I don't care at this point.
John: Our door is hair.
Pam: That's not a Beatles song.
John: Sorry, my connection's poor. Can you say that again The widow pam?
Pam: Connection to what? Does Robot John Lennon use wifi?
John: Where are you?
Pam: At a funeral, you jackass.
John: What? Who knows?
Pam: I know. And I'm asking you one last time: Do you have ANYTHING to say about "With Arms Outstretched" by Rilo Kiley?
John: How do you know? By remote control.
Pam: If you had survived Mark David Chapman's attack, then I probably would find you right now and shoot you myself.
John: I think I do.
Pam: I hope Ringo Starr lives to be 150 years old and I hope no one even remembers who you are.
John: The widow pam 's trying to tell me that I hope ringo starr lives to be 150 years old and youhope no one even remembers who iare .
Pam: Get help, fuckwad.
John: Where can I get help fuckwad ?
Pam: In your ASS!!!!!!!
John: Where is that?
Pam: I give up. Seriously.
John: You give up seriously ?
Pam: Yes!
John: Okay.
Pam: Am I kidding about what?
John: Kidding about what you say? We are in the same bag.
Pam: I can't believe Joe had multiple conversations with you. You're not making any sense.
John: That's what they all say.
Pam: What I'm really here to ask you about is Rilo Kiley's 2002 deep cut masterpiece "With Arms Outstretched." Can you comment on that?
John: I have no idea.
Pam: Well, sure, you weren't alive when it came out. But you're here now, in robot form. Can you comment on it at all?
John: How about thinking of something else.
Pam: How about my dead husband wanted me to ask you about the goddamn song, so why don't you talk about the goddamn song?
John: How about it.
Pam: How about FUCK YOU?
John: How about it.
Pam: Are you fucking with me right now?
John: Are you kidding? We're not agreed on it.
Pam: No shit. Maybe you can talk about a Beatles song that reminds you of Rilo Kiley's "With Arms Outstretched"?
John: Well, I was given to understand that within a reasonable space of time there's a good chance. If it's imagery, it's imagery.
Pam: Name a goddamn Beatles song, for christ's sake. Anything. I don't care at this point.
John: Our door is hair.
Pam: That's not a Beatles song.
John: Sorry, my connection's poor. Can you say that again The widow pam?
Pam: Connection to what? Does Robot John Lennon use wifi?
John: Where are you?
Pam: At a funeral, you jackass.
John: What? Who knows?
Pam: I know. And I'm asking you one last time: Do you have ANYTHING to say about "With Arms Outstretched" by Rilo Kiley?
John: How do you know? By remote control.
Pam: If you had survived Mark David Chapman's attack, then I probably would find you right now and shoot you myself.
John: I think I do.
Pam: I hope Ringo Starr lives to be 150 years old and I hope no one even remembers who you are.
John: The widow pam 's trying to tell me that I hope ringo starr lives to be 150 years old and youhope no one even remembers who iare .
Pam: Get help, fuckwad.
John: Where can I get help fuckwad ?
Pam: In your ASS!!!!!!!
John: Where is that?
Pam: I give up. Seriously.
John: You give up seriously ?
Pam: Yes!
John: Okay.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Prompt: "The song to play at your funeral"
In the style of Demi Lovato
"With Arms Outstretched"
Rilo Kiley
The Execution of All Things, 2002
or something like that, I don't know. Joe was always down to repeat the same jokes ad nauseam, to the point that the repetition became the joke. Like, that Joker thing I just did with the direct quoting from the Joker scene in The Dark Knight, acting like it was a song review, that shit is the most obvious thing in the goddamn world, and I don't even know if anyone thinks it's funny anymore—certainly not Dwyer, hey get back here, your daughter is gonna love this impression when she gets older!—but you know what? Joe found it funny every single fucking time, and if he had lived 50 more years, he would've made a dumb obvious joke about Dwyer doing the Joker impression every single day for that entire span. That's just how he was.
And honestly, if you want to go ahead and rope this into Day 90, which was a non-holiday song for a holiday, then we can count that too. It's Labor Day tomorrow, and we listen to Dwyer's Joker impression.
Speaking of dumb jokes, and speaking of Dwyers, here's Peter Gill of the band 2nd Grade—backed by bassist Catherine Dwyer, who's also from the band Remember Sports—doing another rendition of "Favorite Song," except this time, he'll be singing about a kid whose favorite song was "With Arms Outstretched" every single month of the summer for two years straight. Everyone, please give a warm welcome to... 2nd Grade!
Speaking of dumb jokes, and speaking of Dwyers, here's Peter Gill of the band 2nd Grade—backed by bassist Catherine Dwyer, who's also from the band Remember Sports—doing another rendition of "Favorite Song," except this time, he'll be singing about a kid whose favorite song was "With Arms Outstretched" every single month of the summer for two years straight. Everyone, please give a warm welcome to... 2nd Grade!
"Favorite Song (PoYB's Version)" by 2nd Grade
"Early April, I felt your pullMy favorite song was 'With Arms Outstretched'Then it was May, nothing to sayMy favorite song was 'With Arms Outstretched'Up in my room, I had all JuneMy favorite song was 'With Arms Outstretched'Then I told a lies, all through JulyMy favorite song was 'With Arms Outstretched'."
Oh hell yeah! That was awesome! And what an improvement on the original. Let's give it up for 2nd Grade!
Now, as you may have noticed, the song name is "With Arms Outstretched." If the title was "Rilo Kiley," then it would have been eligible for Day 92's prompt. Joe talked a big game about "not being judge and jury of the prompts" when he was alive, but I could tell that each song chosen outside the prompt's explicit instructions was like a tiny little cut on his heart. I wouldn't go so far as to say that my choice for this prompt of "Mr. Tillman" was the thing that killed him, but, ya know, let's not rule it out. He was weird that way.
Now, let's see... we're getting toward the end here... this is the worst eulogy of all time but I'm only doing what Joe asked me to do and I'm doing my best, thanks for bearing with me... Day 93... that was "another artist in the title" day. And good news! I had a couple minutes to spare in between Joe's death and planning this funeral, and I found a band called "ARMS," just to prove that this song technically fits the prompt. They weren't invited to the funeral—I don't think Joe had ever heard of them while alive, so that would've been weird—but, ya know, it's nice to know that they exist.
"Boo!"
Who said that? Was that you, Joe's high school bus driver who reacted incredulously to Joe listening to Captain Beefheart?
"Get off the stage!!"
And now who was that? Do I see Holly M., Joe's very first kiss, which occurred on March 15th, an anniversary that Joe snatched back from you when he decided to get sober on March 15th too?
And now who was that? Do I see Holly M., Joe's very first kiss, which occurred on March 15th, an anniversary that Joe snatched back from you when he decided to get sober on March 15th too?
"This is way too long!!!"
What the hell, why is everyone heckling me? Are you fucking serious, old man named Tex who was in charge of the first-year campers program at Camp Hart during Joe's first weeklong overnight summer camp experience with the Boy Scouts?
I don't know why all these random people from Joe's life are suddenly speaking up, or even how you found out about his funeral. But you all can shut the fuck up! We're doing a bit up here, at Joe's request! He wanted me to recap our summer project! And so that's what I'm going to do!
God fucking damn it, where was I... Day 94, I think? Oh shit, that was the day a friend was asked to pick a song! That was a great day we had last week. Felt like a lot of hypothetical alternate paths were opened in that exercise, like, what if Erin and Ashley and Allison and Beth and Stephen "Boober" T. had all participated in Summer Song Challenge, what if Willow and Martha and Maggie were all old enough to write 50 words daily? How much fun we would've had.
Also, you should know that I tried really hard to find Aymen, Joe's new friend, but I was unsuccessful.
Also, you should know that I tried really hard to find Aymen, Joe's new friend, but I was unsuccessful.
Day 95, a song you used to hate but now you love. I fear that the opposite fate is true with "With Arms Outstretched." You've heard it played at least 40 times during this eulogy. It's now inextricably tied to Joe's death. Maybe you loved it, and now you hate it. That's the crazy thing about music, how fickle it is, how dependent it is on context, and how specific it is to each individual. We pounded out around 1000 different songs this summer, and there was such a wide variety of sounds to be found. But all of it pointed toward something about the chooser, and then each of them meant something completely different to the listener. We proved it.
On Day 96, he got sick. On Day 97, he met death. And that brings us to today. It feels like just yesterday it was Day 1. Day 1 of the Summer Song Challenge. Day 1 of our lives together. Day 1 of Joe's life in toto. Time moves so quickly, it's hard to believe sometimes. One day he's here, and the next, he's gone. One day, we're filling out blog posts, and the next day, the summer is over.
Joe wanted me to recap the summer, go back over the blog project that meant so much to him and his friends, and I hope I've done that as well as he'd hoped. Maybe this was too much. I don't know. Sometimes you put so much into something, and very rarely do you get that much back. So it goes.
I think it's about time to end my eulogy now. The time has come. You've heard enough. You've withstood Summer Song Challenge twice now. It's time to end our summer. Bring on Labor Day, a day that's going to make life feel a lot emptier when it's over. Unless anyone has anything else to add to this, I'm going to call it—
"WAIT!!"
Who's that, rushing in through the door in the back? I don't recognize him.
"Wait! Wait! I'm here! Don't end it!"
Can I ask who you are, sir?
"My name is Aymen, and I am Joe's friend."
Aymen...? Hold on... Aymen, the random guy from Omegle?
"That's me. I am here. I am at my friend's funeral."
This is... this is incredible. I literally can't believe it. How did you find us? How did you know which Joe was talking to you? How did you find your way to his funeral?
"Pretty easily, actually. That dude dropped way more personal information on his blog then any sane person should."
Yeah, that's true. But why are you here?
"I just feel like I need to say something, before you finish what I don't doubt was a succinct and impactful eulogy. I want to say that Joe was my friend. I want to say that I've read through the blog, and I've read through everything Joe and his friends and his family, legal family and chosen family both, have written, and I want to say that everything that was written this summer, and even prior, all of it was extremely heartwarming. I think that Puke on Your Birthday, a blog organized by but not exclusively written by your late husband, my friend, Joe, that Puke on Your Birthday is proof that humanity is good, and kind, and smart, and well-intentioned. Six days ago, I didn't know our Joe from any other of the millions of Joes on this planet. But now, I stand before you a friend. A friend of Joe and a friend of the blog. And I just wanted to let you know this, that I found friendship through what was written on this blog, the best blog on the internet, Puke on Your Birthday."
Thanks Aymen, that was wonderful. And thanks to all of you, for being here, for remembering Joe just for today, and for listening to his funeral song. A quick shout out to the Northeast's Café Carmella, who closed their restaurant this weekend to cater the funeral. And thanks to all those who were forced to say a few words today during the eulogy; you should know that Joe loved you so goddamn much that it hurt him sometimes.
That's it! Grab some food, grab another beer! Tell some stories about Joe! Laugh a little! And then never mention his name again! He'd want it that way! Goodbye, Joey. Here's "With Arms Outstretched" for you, one last time.
"And some days, they last longer than othersBut this day by the lake went too fastAnd if you want me, you better speak upI won't waitSo you better move fast."
3 comments:
That was a masterpiece eulogy, Pam. My condolences.
Everyone please join us for a funeral luncheon at Hollywood Tavern, then Austrian Village, then John's Sushi (formerly Hop Angel), and then finally and most regrettably, at McNally's.
You should have written a novel instead.
Don't worry, I got another 15K words dropping tomorrow, this time entirely made up of an unbroken monologue from Peaquad about why he had Eddie killed.
Post a Comment