He who creates a list of 200 movies he's never seen before ends up just listing his creations.
Mystery Men
1999
Kinka Usher
Lately I've been getting these flashes of memories about the pop culture weirdness I used to read about online, back before the internet was all social media and ads. And the weirdest part is that a lot of stuff I remember had been stripped from the internet long ago, and I don't remember enough about them to do any intense web.archive searching, so it's like they don't even exist, and I start to think that maybe my brain is making it up. For example, during my kids' 43rd viewing of the 1993 Super Mario Bros. movie (I'm not kidding), I spotted an random extra in the background of the steampunk Mushroom Kingdom who was holding a boombox and doing a little dance down the street. And all of a sudden, I remembered that there was some website that made a sort of joke about this dude, something like "WE NEED TO KNOW MORE ABOUT BOOMBOX MAN." That's all I remember, and of course Google was no help here in 2023. So am I imagining things? Or was there a mostly-not-serious campaign at some point in the internet's history where people were trying to figure out the deal with a random extra from a film that has only been resuscitated from its legendary flop status recently because the newer Super Mario Bros. Movie just sucks that much worse?
The reason I'm bringing this up (maybe?) is that I had one of those weird internet flashback moments after I watched Mystery Men—another flop, but I promise this blog post isn't a Mystery Men vs. Mario type of thing—and was doing some light research, and saw that the Mystery Men were originally the side characters for a comic book superhero named the Flaming Carrot. And after like twenty years of it lying dormant in my brain, all of a sudden I'm remembering being enthralled by this weird, off-center comic book character, reading all about how there was this whole different world that I didn't know about at that age. I don't even remember where I was reading about him. Maybe Something Awful? A website only an ninth-grade boy could frequent.
Actually, I don't even know if I could explain it to you now, and certainly couldn't then, why I thought reading about the Flaming Carrot was so intriguing to me. It could just boil down to this weird thing seeming kind of funny to me, plus an unending quest to learn about all pop culture things that are just kind of funny. I don't remember if the Flaming Carrot had anything to do with me putting Mystery Men on the Never Seen It list. Probably not consciously, but definitely subconsciously, because it's all part of that quest. Mystery Men isn't important to know, not really. But in my mind it is, and I'm going to work overtime to retroactively make it so for others. (And, yes, it was only kind of funny.)
I like to use the word "archaeology" when it comes to shit like this, even though that's stretching the word a little bit. The definition is "the study of human history and prehistory through the excavation of sites and the analysis of artifacts and other physical remains," and that's accurate if we take the literal and turn it figurative. Here was a movie that was important in the late '90s, mostly for bad reasons, but then ostensibly later hailed in a cult-film sort of way, and so I'm going to "excavate" it from the netherworld where films not deemed worthy of streaming services all live, and study it. What does this film say about audiences in the '90s, both those who rejected it and those who would eventually embrace it? And what does it say about the movie that it was destined for the margins either way?
Something that I find interesting—though less so than the rest of the modern-day internet, since every write-up I could find about Mystery Men written in the past ten years uses this as its narrative hook—is that this is a superhero film that is lampooning superhero films before "superhero films" was even a thing. Or at least before it became the box office juggernaut that it is now (whether that commercial imperialism is waning in the past couple years is a different blog post). This is a film that, in between its half-baked jokes, presents a worldview of the "heroes" as frauds and the real heroes as the working-class schmoes with little in the way of actual powers, except when they come together. Power in numbers. This is a proletariat fairy tale, the more I think about it. But let's also not get into that.
I'm less interested in the whole idea of Mystery Men being "before its time," like a sort of proto-Deadpool or something. I care very little about blockbuster superhero fare currently, and so I care even less about lampooning that shit. I think superhero movies are already silly enough that you probably don't need the vision of Hank Azaria throwing spoons to underline the silliness. Also, I've been clued into the reality of the situation (via archives of AVClub comment sections, from back when that was still a thing... god, the internet is old), in that this isn't a parody of superhero movies, but rather a parody of superhero comics. Which makes things a little dicier for this blog post, since my knowledge of comic books is very limited (though my kids are really into this one comic book lately, one that features the Super Mario Bros. in cartoon form, written in the early '90s... see, everything in this blog post is connected).
Regardless of all that shit, I think the big headline here is that this was one of those movies that was marked as "bad" upon its release, due to commercial expectations not being met and the critical consensus being lukewarm at best, but then is reevaluated as the kids who originally made up the bulk of the film's original viewing audience grow up and are able to express more complex emotions about this film that had an impact on them in their youth. That's the answer I've landed on over the years regarding the question "Why is this a cult film?" and I'm sticking to it here.
I have the list of 200 Never Seen It films in my phone, and I have next to some of the movies names of people who originally expressed interest (through a long-lost Facebook thread) in speaking with me about certain films on the list. Mystery Men had three names attached to it. I didn't reach out to anyone, mostly because I currently find myself in an extreme creative lull, having been gutted a bit by Summer Song Challenge's ending (but also, two of the names are people whom I haven't spoken to in a while, and the other is Fisher, who just helped us out for My Fair Lady, and whom I'm sure we'll see in the comment section below this post at some point—hey man!).
But that's more names than any other film on the list has next to it, and so, over the years, I've used that as proof that this film has a certain cult status about it now. And maybe that is true! But weirdly, I couldn't find too much on the internet to support this claim. Like, usually for cult films, you're gonna find a bunch of takes online, and many of them are going to be hyperbolic, like: "This was the best film ever!" Not that that makes it true, I'm just saying that cult films typically have your stalwart defenders protecting its legacy. That didn't seem to be the case with Mystery Men. There seemed to be a tacit acknowledgment that the jokes didn't always land, and that the tone was generally uneven (I read that the filmmakers and actors themselves couldn't agree on whether this was supposed to be a comedy or a drama).
Which is fine, but it doesn't answer the question of why I felt the need to watch and write about this film 21 years later (well, now 24 years, since apparently this film blog project is going to take me a half a decade to finish). Does anyone love this film? Does anyone care? Maybe now, and maybe that's okay.
I think the important thing here is that it's a subpar film that creates above-par conversation. Why it failed, the trends in film that it predicted, its maybe-or-maybe-not cult status, it's all a lot more fun than sitting down and watching the actual movie, to be honest. But you see, that's what intrigues me so much. That something can exist in some niche spot on the internet, and be made to feel way more exciting than it actually is. Maybe in another 20 years, someone will hear about Mystery Men, and think, "Well, I can't find it now, but I swear I read about this movie on some dude's blog, many years ago."
I mean, at the very least, we can all just try to remember that Mystery Men was the movie that originally featured Smash Mouth's "All Star," and that the original video actually featured clips from the movie, before it bombed so badly that they attempted to forget the whole thing, and tried again, and then served it up to the ogre, and... well, you know that story already.
The reason I'm bringing this up (maybe?) is that I had one of those weird internet flashback moments after I watched Mystery Men—another flop, but I promise this blog post isn't a Mystery Men vs. Mario type of thing—and was doing some light research, and saw that the Mystery Men were originally the side characters for a comic book superhero named the Flaming Carrot. And after like twenty years of it lying dormant in my brain, all of a sudden I'm remembering being enthralled by this weird, off-center comic book character, reading all about how there was this whole different world that I didn't know about at that age. I don't even remember where I was reading about him. Maybe Something Awful? A website only an ninth-grade boy could frequent.
Actually, I don't even know if I could explain it to you now, and certainly couldn't then, why I thought reading about the Flaming Carrot was so intriguing to me. It could just boil down to this weird thing seeming kind of funny to me, plus an unending quest to learn about all pop culture things that are just kind of funny. I don't remember if the Flaming Carrot had anything to do with me putting Mystery Men on the Never Seen It list. Probably not consciously, but definitely subconsciously, because it's all part of that quest. Mystery Men isn't important to know, not really. But in my mind it is, and I'm going to work overtime to retroactively make it so for others. (And, yes, it was only kind of funny.)
I like to use the word "archaeology" when it comes to shit like this, even though that's stretching the word a little bit. The definition is "the study of human history and prehistory through the excavation of sites and the analysis of artifacts and other physical remains," and that's accurate if we take the literal and turn it figurative. Here was a movie that was important in the late '90s, mostly for bad reasons, but then ostensibly later hailed in a cult-film sort of way, and so I'm going to "excavate" it from the netherworld where films not deemed worthy of streaming services all live, and study it. What does this film say about audiences in the '90s, both those who rejected it and those who would eventually embrace it? And what does it say about the movie that it was destined for the margins either way?
Something that I find interesting—though less so than the rest of the modern-day internet, since every write-up I could find about Mystery Men written in the past ten years uses this as its narrative hook—is that this is a superhero film that is lampooning superhero films before "superhero films" was even a thing. Or at least before it became the box office juggernaut that it is now (whether that commercial imperialism is waning in the past couple years is a different blog post). This is a film that, in between its half-baked jokes, presents a worldview of the "heroes" as frauds and the real heroes as the working-class schmoes with little in the way of actual powers, except when they come together. Power in numbers. This is a proletariat fairy tale, the more I think about it. But let's also not get into that.
I'm less interested in the whole idea of Mystery Men being "before its time," like a sort of proto-Deadpool or something. I care very little about blockbuster superhero fare currently, and so I care even less about lampooning that shit. I think superhero movies are already silly enough that you probably don't need the vision of Hank Azaria throwing spoons to underline the silliness. Also, I've been clued into the reality of the situation (via archives of AVClub comment sections, from back when that was still a thing... god, the internet is old), in that this isn't a parody of superhero movies, but rather a parody of superhero comics. Which makes things a little dicier for this blog post, since my knowledge of comic books is very limited (though my kids are really into this one comic book lately, one that features the Super Mario Bros. in cartoon form, written in the early '90s... see, everything in this blog post is connected).
Regardless of all that shit, I think the big headline here is that this was one of those movies that was marked as "bad" upon its release, due to commercial expectations not being met and the critical consensus being lukewarm at best, but then is reevaluated as the kids who originally made up the bulk of the film's original viewing audience grow up and are able to express more complex emotions about this film that had an impact on them in their youth. That's the answer I've landed on over the years regarding the question "Why is this a cult film?" and I'm sticking to it here.
I have the list of 200 Never Seen It films in my phone, and I have next to some of the movies names of people who originally expressed interest (through a long-lost Facebook thread) in speaking with me about certain films on the list. Mystery Men had three names attached to it. I didn't reach out to anyone, mostly because I currently find myself in an extreme creative lull, having been gutted a bit by Summer Song Challenge's ending (but also, two of the names are people whom I haven't spoken to in a while, and the other is Fisher, who just helped us out for My Fair Lady, and whom I'm sure we'll see in the comment section below this post at some point—hey man!).
But that's more names than any other film on the list has next to it, and so, over the years, I've used that as proof that this film has a certain cult status about it now. And maybe that is true! But weirdly, I couldn't find too much on the internet to support this claim. Like, usually for cult films, you're gonna find a bunch of takes online, and many of them are going to be hyperbolic, like: "This was the best film ever!" Not that that makes it true, I'm just saying that cult films typically have your stalwart defenders protecting its legacy. That didn't seem to be the case with Mystery Men. There seemed to be a tacit acknowledgment that the jokes didn't always land, and that the tone was generally uneven (I read that the filmmakers and actors themselves couldn't agree on whether this was supposed to be a comedy or a drama).
Which is fine, but it doesn't answer the question of why I felt the need to watch and write about this film 21 years later (well, now 24 years, since apparently this film blog project is going to take me a half a decade to finish). Does anyone love this film? Does anyone care? Maybe now, and maybe that's okay.
I think the important thing here is that it's a subpar film that creates above-par conversation. Why it failed, the trends in film that it predicted, its maybe-or-maybe-not cult status, it's all a lot more fun than sitting down and watching the actual movie, to be honest. But you see, that's what intrigues me so much. That something can exist in some niche spot on the internet, and be made to feel way more exciting than it actually is. Maybe in another 20 years, someone will hear about Mystery Men, and think, "Well, I can't find it now, but I swear I read about this movie on some dude's blog, many years ago."
I mean, at the very least, we can all just try to remember that Mystery Men was the movie that originally featured Smash Mouth's "All Star," and that the original video actually featured clips from the movie, before it bombed so badly that they attempted to forget the whole thing, and tried again, and then served it up to the ogre, and... well, you know that story already.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: I have sincerely no idea what Mystic Pizza is about. I assume pizza.

No comments:
Post a Comment