Wednesday, September 20, 2023

RC f/u Pt. 18: Tyler Childers, Kelly Clarkson, Carly Rae Jepsen

I know the Record Club-adjacent stuff on here isn't the most well-read of all PoYB blog posts, so I don't even know if anyone is reading this. If you are, and you have a desire to write about any Record Club artist's new album (post-selection to the club), then please, hit me up. I'd love to have your words in this space instead of mine. The alumni albums are coming in hot and heavy, and there's a lot to choose from at this point. (Go HERE and scroll down a little bit to see the full list of album we need reviews for.)


Rustin' in the Rain by Tyler Childers
Released: September 8, 2023
Follow-up to: Purgatory, Week 180

I've probably listened to more country in 2023 than I have in the previous few years combined. Not only did RC up the country content, but the whole genre became kinda en vogue, culturally speaking. We've already drawn a line in the sand on the blog, mostly along political lines, i.e. don't think that just because I'm listening to a lot of country music that I'm purposefully enabling fascists in any way.

Tyler Childers was even before this year established as one of the good guys in country music. I think Rustin' in the Rain does a lot to underline the point, and I'm happy for the guy, that he continues to be one of the coolest and nicest dudes in the scene. I also, unfortunately, think that Rustin' in the Rain is kind of bad, musically speaking. But that's fine; sometimes you can't have everything you want.

I imagine that the video for lead single "In Your Love" rustled some conservative feathers, in its portrayal of two gay miners who fall in love. Childers has long preached inclusion, and this is his boldest statement yet. I think it's a swell video. I hope the song soundtracks a million gay weddings. The thing is, 95% of songs chosen as "couple's first dance" are boring as shit, and "In Your Love" is gonna fit right in.

Otherwise, Rustin' in the Rain weirdly leans into the backwoods ho-down shit that I tend to shy away from when it comes to country / Americana / whatever. I guess it's not quite bluegrass, because I like the sounds of bluegrass, but it has the corny veneer of bluegrass. More, like, gospel country, I guess? This is music played during the post-service potluck at the one Alabama church that features a short-haired woman as the preacher. Extremely lame, probably too lame for me. Tyler Childers took so long to cross that line that I didn't even realize it as it was happening, but here we are.

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5 (-2.0 from first review)


Chemistry by Kelly Clarkson
Released: June 23, 2023
Follow-up to: When Christmas Comes Around..., Week 150

Yes, it's weird following up on a Christmas album. You can compare apples and oranges if you want to, since they are both fruit, but the comparison falls apart after a while. They're just too different. No, let's ignore that and talk about what's actually weird—the fact that my temptation here is to compare this Kelly Clarkson album to albums from, say, Olivia Rodrigo. The ballads, anyway. When really, it's the other way around, right? Clarkson was here first. It's not so much as one artist influence the other, but more so pop balladeers of different generations coming together to strengthen the fabric of pop music in toto.

Anyways, a lot of this is boring pop-by-numbers. I get it. I'm not asking anyone to reinvent the wheel here. But with Kelly Clarkson, it makes me wonder why she even bothered. She has a hit talk show now, right? And she's continuously making headlines for choosing really cool covers to sing every day on that show? So why the need for this totally generic pop outing?

As far as I can tell, the need was an emotional one. The Wikipedia "Personal Life" section tells me that Clarkson was married to her manager (and Reba McEntire's stepson) since 2012, but their divorce was finalized just last year. I am guessing, based on many of the lyrics all over Chemistry, many of which are about breakups and heartbreaks, that this was a sort of catharsis of some pain that built up over a long and drawn-out legal separation. So you won't find me saying that Chemistry was unnecessary. Maybe it's unnecessary for me, but clearly not unnecessary for Kelly Clarkson, and that's important too.

Otherwise... I mean, as always, the voice carries the day here. The towering rhythm on "high road" is cool, the gospel choir on "me" is distracting, the funny hat man Steve Martin feature on "i hate love" is lame, the lowercase letters for all these songs give away a certain need (conscious or subconscious) to appear "young" and "hip," and as much as I love Kelly Clarkson, she ain't that. The song "favorite kind of high" starts out like U2 and ends up like Dua Lipa, so that's pretty neat I guess.

But the key lyric here is on "rock hudson": "I found out the hero's me." This is an album filled to the brim with confidence, self-love, and oodles of talent. I think it's boring, but who am I to question someone's need to self-care? Not me. I know how it goes. Go take your music and enjoy it, preferably a little farther from me, if you don't mind.

GRADE: 2 pukes out of 5 (-1.5 from previous review, which was way too high of a grade to begin with)


The Loveliest Time by Carly Rae Jepsen
Released: July 28, 2023
Follow-up to: The Loneliest Time, Week 206

One of the best and most well-known pieces of the Carly Rae Jepsen lore is that her B-sides collections are guaranteed to match toe-to-toe with the album proper, and occasionally even outdo those original albums. It's like she's out here trying to prove that more of a good thing is a definitive good. She did it with E•MO•TION: Side B and Dedicated Side B, and now she's doing it again with The Loveliest Time.

My hook for the review of The Loneliest Time was that Carly Rae Jepsen is consistent and reliable and doesn't really mix it up too much. The Loveliest Time makes me eat my words slightly, as this is some of her most adventurous music to date. "Adventurous" is relative, but still! "Kollage" is has psychedelic flair. "Shadow" is like Jepsen's take on Burial, if you can fucking imagine. "Psychedelic Switch" is house music, and outdoes Beyoncé's attempts at the genre last year. Throughout, she never stops being catchy, but that's standard at this point.

The more I think about it, the more I kinda love the idea of grouping all your straight-up bangers on the first album, and then saving all the out-there genre exercises for a B-sides collection. See, this is why Carly Rae Jepsen is the indie rock dad's idea of a pop star—there's an immense respect for the motherfucking craft here. Start doing C-side collections, Carly!!

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5 (no change from previous review)


I really need to make this a weekly thing from here until the end of the year. Follow-ups still pending include new albums from Andrew Bird, Margaret Glaspy, Hozier, Spanish Love Songs, Burna Boy, Olivia Rodrigo, and Baroness, plus new ones from Lydia Loveless and CHAI this Friday. That's a lot! I'm running behind! Sorry! For real, hit me up if you want to write an extra review this week!!!

No comments: