Sunday, August 6, 2023

Summer Song Challenge, Day 70: Joe

Prompt: "A song with complex guitar work"

Selected by Joe


"Smells like Teen Spirit"
Nirvana
Nevermind, 1991

The question we ask about today's prompt is "complex for whom?", and if the answer to that one is "the writer of the blog post," then this writer will indicate that every song is complex for him on guitar, save for maybe "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star" (but even that one gets butchered by shoddy finger-work whenever I give it a go). So the sky's the limit, I say, as far as today's requirements are concerned.

"Smells like Teen Spirit" has a guitar part that I would not be able to play. This is a fact. Rubbing against that fact is the widespread opinion that Kurt Cobain was a rather simplistic guitarist. I wouldn't know if I didn't look that up. And I don't think anyone means that to be an insult to his craft. Cobain himself is on record in saying that he has no respect for musicianship and couldn't have given less of a fuck about his guitar-playing abilities. I think that mindset is fine, but has a ceiling as far as artistic success is concerned, a ceiling that Cobain didn't live long enough to bump his head against.

So my take on the prompt today is to change the implied question, and offer a bit of a reflection on someone else for whom the guitar part is complex: the songwriter himself. I don't have a good grasp on whether the riff from "Smells like Teen Spirit" is complex or not, but I get the sense from other guitar players that it's not. But if Kurt Cobain was as technically unskilled as he's claimed to be, then it was probably complex for him to play, even though he wrote the damn thing (or stole it from Boston, or stole it from the Pixies, or wherever the urban legend stands these days).

In fact, my mind immediately went to this song because I recall reading an anecdote from someone—a producer, a bandmate, I forget who exactly, but there was a quote—who said that Kurt was embarrassed that he could not even play the "Smells like Teen Spirit" guitar part live, or at least struggled with it. That's stuck with me for a long time, because it strikes me as incredibly sad in a way that I don't know if I'll be able to fully articulate. It's like... here's this world-altering band, with a success perhaps not wide ("Smells like Teen Spirit" peaked at #6 on the Billboard Hot 100) but incredibly deep (spawned an entire alt-rock sub-genre, influenced countless rock bands, made Post Malone get a face tattoo), a song that by all accounts changed the music landscape for an entire generation, I mean like how hyperbolic can I possibly get without sounding ridiculous, probably impossible to get too hyperbolic about this, all things considered... and the dude who unleashed this wild, untamable thing into the world can't even play the fucking riff? Think about how helpless that would feel, to lose control of the thing that you are most known for in the history of our humankind. An imposter's syndrome that could absolutely smother.

Here's the thing, though: I don't know if that is actually true. I knew it to be true in my mind, I read it at a certain point—maybe even read it multiple times—and it made such an impression on me that I think about it all the time when I hear this fucking song, and it was the first thing I thought of when presented with the "complex guitar" prompt. And yet, I've done a fuck ton of google searching today, like enough to make my eyes hurt, and I can't find any proof that this thing was ever said about Kurt Cobain. Which means I'm terrible at googling, or the internet was whitewashed somehow of this anecdote, or that I dreamed it and somehow over the years turned that dream into fact.

I mean, I guess it wouldn't really make all that sense. Nirvana played it 177 times live in concert, and plus he recorded the guitar part originally in the studio. All of my failed googling points to the fact that the members of Nirvana didn't like playing "Smells like Teen Spirit" live, and in fact went to great lengths to play it as few times as possible. They hated it so much that they made "Rape Me" about it, and swiped the same exact riff as a sort of meta-commentary on how much they hated it and its popularity. So in this scenario, it's not so much that he couldn't play the riff, as much as he wouldn't.

My false memory also wouldn't make sense when we consider that thing I mentioned above about Kurt Cobain stating that he didn't care if he was a good guitar player or not. I specifically remember (falsely, I guess) that not only could Cobain not play the riff live, but he was also "deeply upset" that he couldn't pull it off. That doesn't sound like the Kurt Cobain that has been portrayed in pop culture in the decades since his suicide, the take-no-prisoners rebel who couldn't give two fucks what other people thought about him. Why would that Kurt Cobain be "upset" that he couldn't do something? In the wild, illogical hypothetical that he was struggling to play his own song, then he would just say "fuck you, I don't care, I'll play it how I want" and then give the audience the bird. I barely know anything about Kurt Cobain personally, I'm just saying that the little I do know (based on what has been told to me through various third- and fourth-hand sources) just doesn't correlate with a Kurt Cobain who would be wounded by something so stupid.

Look, I don't even know why I'm spending so much time pouring over this obviously false narrative. Plus, add the fact that I legitimately don't know whether the riff for "Smells like Teen Spirit" is even difficult or not. I don't know anything about guitars, besides the fact that they are an integral ingredient in like 90% of the music that I've ever loved. And Kurt Cobain has been mythologized enough already; no need to add some more bullshit to the pile. 

Something about all this really freaks me out, though. I was really convinced that this was true about Kurt Cobain, and I couldn't find a single morsel of evidence that it was. Beyond the fact that I'm getting old and possibly slipping, I think it also speaks to how willing we are sometimes to buy into the narrative that we want to believe. I personally see Kurt Cobain as this untouchable mythical character from a different time (the '90s), and maybe wanting to believe a story about him not being able to play the riff to his most famous song was my subconscious way of being able to see Kurt Cobain as more vulnerable, and thus more relatable.

Maybe it's the same for this prompt and my pick. I've heard "Smells like Teen Spirit" a thousand times. I remember discovering the video on some VH1 retrospective ("Best Videos of All Time" or some such) and being completely enthralled by the pageantry and mystery of the whole thing, and how over time that faded until it disappeared, simply through constant repetition. Calling it "complex" was maybe a way to bring some of the emotions that I felt as a teenager, back when this song was new to me and held a boundless wonder.

No comments: