Wednesday, May 27, 2020

Bring Back My Girls: A Drag Race Season 12 Discussion


It's really weird to start watching a television show in its Season 12, regardless of what show it is. Even competition shows establish patterns and traditions, build running jokes, etc. Nevertheless, I watched Season 12 of RuPaul's Drag Race with Pam this year. I mostly enjoyed it! It's possible that I more enjoyed thinking about it and discussing it than I did actually watching it. So, in that same vein, I figured it would be nice to talk with some friends before the season finale, especially those friends who have watched Drag Race from the beginning.

Below is our group discussion, transcribed from Facebook Messenger. It took place over two hours last Sunday night. Other than changing the order of some of the responses (to fit them chronologically when Facebook Messenger lagged), and adding a couple italics and a couple apostrophes, the conversation is presented exactly as is.

Thanks to my friends for spending some time with me in a non-Zoom setting, and for being cool with me sharing their insights on the blog. And make sure you check out the finale, this Friday at 8 PM.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe: I first wanted to ask about general impressions of Season 12. This was a weird season of TV, right? I'm asking this as someone who didn't watch the first eleven. And I'm not even talking about the Sherry Pie or the COVID of it all (we can talk about both in a bit). Was there something off about this season? Or is that just my RuPaul ignorance showing?

Bridget: I think the editing around sherry really messed things up for me! 
Bridget: I know we’re not supposed to talk about that but to me that’s why it fell a lil flat

Allison: I think the editing had something to do with it

Hannah: I loved the season and felt queens were more talented than most recent ones

Maeve: I think this has been the most “prepared” season thus far? Like all the queens came in knowing exactly what to expect, so that alone made it weirder than normal. And then the editing was nuts

Joe: It almost became a game, like, "alright, how would this episode have been with Sherry in it?"
Joe: (some other good points made by y'all, we'll circle back to them!)

Bridget: yeah so much talent this season! And nobody can be surprised about the snatch game

Hannah: Beyond sherry and covid it didnt feel off to me
Hannah: Maybe less drama

Allison: I don't think I would have liked Sherry even if she had been fully in this season

Maeve: I feel like I probably would’ve liked her? She feels like a Nina west/Ben dela creme combo-ish? Idk, so tough to say. But also it was wild she never had to lipsync towards the bottom eps

Allison: Less drama for sure. "This isn't Rupaul's best friend race" has become the mantra but... it kind of is?

Joe: Alright, let's go down the "less drama" road, and circle back to Sherry
Joe: Drama is important to reality TV, right?

Maeve: They all know they’ll perform together in the future on tours etc, right? So it’s in their best interest to get along? But the less drama has made Untucked unwatchable

Bridget: As someone who never watches Untucked I never really follow the drama

Hannah: This is more of a competition show than reality tv?  Are those things different? I don’t expect drama on British Bakeoff
Hannah: That being said i do think the drama is what makes this show fun its just not the only reason to watch it

Maeve: That’s true. And I get mad at any drama on Top Chef. But it feels like drag queens should be “shady” and full of drama?

Joe: Yeah, I mean, RuPaul the TV show is advertised as a show with drama. Like all those soundclips at the beginning of Untucked. That's the expectation

Allison: I will admit, I was on the fence about even watching this season until the Sherry Pie story broke

Joe: Interesting, how come?

Allison: I've watched every season since the first but my love for the show has been waning in the last few years

Bridget: It just sucks that it broke so late that they couldn’t even talk about it!

Joe: Where would you say this ranks in the 12 seasons? Toward the top? Bottom?
Joe: haha bottom

Hannah: Allison is a good example of a person who caught this before it was mainstream and honestly joe this is not an ideal season for you to watch as your first

Allison: Towards the bottom for me. I think it will be memorable unfortunately for the Sherry Pie drama "Remember that season where they had to cut around that one queen for being a creep?"
Allison: Not to say that there havent been some really stand out queens this season
Allison: but there have been over 100 queens at this point. It's really hard to make a lasting impact at this point

Bridget: Good point. And I feel like they tried to make broccoli the schtick of this season and it really didn’t work.

Joe: I'll admit, I laughed at the broccoli thing

Hannah: The element of perfection and that standard is so high that the more perfect they get the less room there is for shade.  Earlier seasons you see more raw stuff less perfect clothes and makeup and less practiced queens
Hannah: Thats why uk was entertaining they were trash

Bridget: Omg I did love the UK!

Allison: I didn't catch the UK, but i'll have to seek that out

Maeve: The UK feels like season 3 of normal drag race!

Allison: Oh perfect

Hannah: But jackie cox sucks right guys

Joe: That's a really good point though, Hannah. I feel like that ties in with the point you made a couple minutes ago: what is the point of all this? competition or reality TV?

Maeve: The point is definitely competition, you’re rooting for girls to make it to the end.

Allison: NOOOOOOoooooooooooooo

Hannah: Allison im not sure if you heard but shes middle eastern

Joe: Are the queens always talking about their moms this much?

Hannah: Joe pretty typical

Allison: And Gigi loves her mom and Crystal is kooky, you gotta have a thing to get air time

Maeve: I didn’t mind Jackie, but I thought she was there too long

Hannah: Haha yes

Maeve: Brita was from New York

Allison: Who would you have preferred to see in the top 5 spot?

Hannah: Heidi instead of jackie

Bridget: Def Heidi!

Maeve: Heidi!
Maeve: I wanna watch a Heidi show....just not the one she performed that sent her home

Allison: I thought Heidi was adorable but she needed SO much help

Hannah: Haha id watch that but she was not good

Bridget: I’m still laughing at Jaidas solo performance

Allison: I do wish Ru would have let up about her name, though

Joe: Alright, if we're getting "she's good, she sucks," I feel like we gotta talk about what it means to "like" a competitor on this show

Hannah: Solid performance outfits and all around threat and not a horrible person backstage.  Also needs a personality ( my biggest issue with jackie )

Joe: Yeah, I feel like there are different categories of reasons to like/dislike a queen, and I have trouble combining them

Hannah: Last seasons winner was a complete and total crazy person back stage and when that happens you are like come on Ru.

Maeve: I think it’s personality and also how they perform throughout the show?

Joe: 1) Are they good at their craft (good at "drag queening"?)
Joe: 2) Do they seem nice/fun or annoying?

Hannah: Yes.

Joe: 3) Do they give me a boner (i.e. is she conventionally attractive to me, a heterosexual male)?

Hannah: Haha noooo

Allison: ...sure

Joe: I know I'm the wrong audience for this, and this is the wrong crowd for this, but #3 is legit

Hannah: The third one no.  You dont have to be attractive to be a good drag queen

Joe: No, I'm not saying that
Joe: I'm just saying, if you're asking who the "best" queen is, then there's different ways of looking at it

Allison: i think it's an interesting perspective

Maeve: I also feel like it’s just whatever type of queen you prefer? Like comedy queen, pageant queen, etc

Hannah: To be a winner then you still dont have to be conventionally attractive

Joe: Not saying "winner" either, just personal preference of who one could like as a queen/competitor

Hannah: Oh like some people prefer that? Sure. Then you like a pageant queen

Maeve: "fishy queen"

Bridget: Yeah cause there’s so many different types of makeup!

Maeve: And personality!

Joe: Fair enough. This is where my ignorance is coming through.
Joe: I don't think I'm rooting for whom I think is the most attractive to win, at least not this season

Allison: i dont think it's ignorance, the beauty of a competition like this is that there are SO many different types of drag and while Ru has the final say, the fans get to choose who they fall in love with

Hannah: So true
Hannah: As a first time watcher were you surprised by any of the transformations
Hannah: Or what it takes to get dragged up

Joe: Hannah—not really. I mean, I appreciated the skill it took to transform in that way, but I get the professionalism aspect of it. These chicks are good. I trust 'em to do well with the drag (doesn't mean I didn't still scoff at some of the outfits)
Joe: Allison—definitely wanna get back to Ru's influence on this.
Joe: But yeah, to clarify, I think being "good at drag" is the most important thing, with personality and actually looks coming tied at second
Joe: But I'm saying this as me, dunno if RuPaul thinks differently

Hannah: She must because bob won

Joe: And Bob the Drag Queen does not have  a good personality?
Joe: I'm asking I don't know

Hannah: Looks

Joe: Okay

Maeve: Hahahahaha I love bob so much

Allison: Ok, hang on, if your going to come for Bob i'm going to have to get my husband, a true Bob stan

Hannah: Haha get him !

Bridget:

Maeve: But his makeup is not great, but I love him

Hannah: Reading is fundamental

Allison: "who did she expect to win that season, fucking Britney Spears motherfucker"

Hannah: Hahahaa nooooo but did you see derrick is back on all stars

Allison: uuuugh

Hannah: I know im not a fan

Maeve: Hahahaha Derrick has one talent

Maeve: Joe, have you watched the HBO show We’re Here starring Bob, Shangela and Eureka? It’s like Queer Eye but for drag queens? Every ep is a real tear jerker

Joe: Nah, Pam's been watching it, I dunno if it's the show for me

Hannah: Yes joe and go watch season 6 7 or 9 of Drag Race

Joe: I was going to say "too feel-good," which sounds awful to say, but that goes back to what we expect out of these shows... where's the drama?

Allison: It does seem like a lot of the drama has been pushed to Untucked (which i have not watched this season)
Allison: And even then it's manufactured

Joe: It was weird during the reunion when the NY chicks were like "yeah we're all friends," like, I don't want you to be friends, I want you to be cuthroat
Joe: Which, again, is bad, which is probably why I shy away from reality TV in general
Joe: brings out the worst in me

Allison: True, but I think at this point, winning isnt really everything
Allison: the prize is great, but the exposure is what they really want

Joe: Which is a detriment to this show, I'd argue

Hannah: I think that you would see more drama on honestly any other season and in an in-person reunion. Joe go watch those other seasons and report back

Bridget: I agree! You need more of a taste!

Allison: yes, watch all 11 seasons and then lets regroup

Joe: Okay, see ya

Allison: Season 7 is wild

Bridget: I’ve honestly only watched the more recent seasons and I even know the difference

Hannah: But the show is about some thing bigger with some of those other reality shows are not about.  Every single one of these people no matter how popular they are or how much money they will make after the show have been either disowned by their family or will never “fit in” society

Bridget: True. Love their personal stories!!!

Hannah: As much as they may disagree with each other they are all suffering the same thing.

Joe: You're right, Han. And that's why this show is IMPORTANT, for sure.
Joe: I know it's not right to lust for blood here

Allison: But, at the same time, the show wants to push the drama

Joe: "Can it have it both ways," basically?

Allison: pre-commecial edits are always "shady out of context comment" "biiiiiitch"

Maeve: There were more spicy comments in the reunion during the “reading” than in all of Untucked

Hannah: But Allison don’t you think that’s an ingrained part of the culture? Where are they are allowed to read each other and then come together at the end of the day?

Allison: Oh for sure. I just think the editing is a little suspicious sometimes

Hannah: It’s almost like they are satirizing drama on reality shows

Joe: Oooh, that's an interesting point. Satirizing? I don't know if I picked that up, but I want to hear more.

Hannah: I don’t know if I just used real word

Joe: No, I'm not mocking, I legitimately think that's an interesting point. I would not have thought of this as a satire, but is it?

Allison: I think the first few seasons are a great example of what Hannah said

Pam: OMG I CAUGHT UP

Hannah: Ha ha Pam thank God you’re here

Pam: DAMN YOU WILLOW AND YOUR SUMMERTIME BEDTIMES!!

Allison: they had mini challenges straight out of Fear Factor

Hannah: And the whole thing is a knock off on Top Model

Allison: right!

Pam:

Pam: Season 2 is weird drama bc of that psycho phi phi ohara

Allison: OH and All Stars Season 1 (terrible) was basically Amazing Race
Allison: (Season 4)

Pam: Oh yea they had that weird final challenge where they had to drive around in a van to all those different spots

Joe: Was there anything specific about S12 that was a satire?
Joe: Or are they playing it straight at this point?

Allison: The America's Worst challenge
Allison: i guess more spoof than satire

Pam: The debates challenge...?

Maeve: Season 12 is just insanely self aware to the point of spoof?

Pam: I honestly hate those. When they did it in that same first season of all stars it was just as (maybe more) awkward

Hannah: Beyond all of the obvious references and ingrained stuff (e.g. bring back my girls) the actual drama isn’t satire but the way they market it with the voiceovers is mocking of Real Housewives “prostitution whore” like memes they try to make happen

Hannah:

Allison: (Jackie Cox was great in Snatch Game by the way)

Hannah: She was good at that Allison

Pam: She was good—I'm a Jackie Cox fan

Maeve: “My husband, Harry Hamlin”

Pam: I wanted her to be in the top from the beginning

Hannah: Pam not sure if you caught this but she’s middle eastern

Pam: Is she?!

Hannah: (I’m laughing at myself you guys)

Bridget: I’m laughing at you too hehe

Joe: I think Jackie Cox was probably the queen with the best comedic timing / sensibility? I don't know if that translates to competent queen?

Maeve: Who did you guys think would be in top from the beginning? It felt clear Gigi and Sherry would be

Hannah: Yes agree Maeve

Bridget: Gigi for sure!

Pam: Almost every joke from Gigi after snatch game felt like she was a one-trick pony... like that robot thing was her only schtick
Pam: But yes I did think she was gonna be in the top (Gigi)

Joe: That's a good point... I liked her a lot more toward the beginning than toward the end
Joe: She got stale

Hannah: Yeah she showed her youth and inexperience I think as it went on

Maeve: I totally agree! I soured on her but felt like the producers were having her not win and that was her emotional arc

Bridget: Yeah true

Pam: I still think she might win the whole thing
Pam: BUT I WANT CRYSTAL TO!!!

Allison: It could be anyone at this point

Hannah: You think the producers make that call outside of ru

Joe: Hold up, let me ask a question about this

Bridget: Also crystal always made me die with her outfits and makeup

Hannah: CRYSTAL

Maeve: I liked her at the reunion!
Maeve: (Gigi I mean)

Allison: Crystal might be at a slight disadvantage with Yvie Oddly as last years winner

Pam: Ugh! Yvie Oddly is the weirdest win

Maeve: That’s EXACTLY what the podcast I listen to said, Allison!
Maeve: Like two out of the box queens back to back

Pam: I thought Brooklyn Heights was gonna take that season
Pam: Yea thats a good point though

Allison: Oohhhh that shoe reveal!

Hannah: YVIE ODDLY UGHHH
Hannah: Allison please don’t tell me you liked her

Pam: Hannah who do you like more? Yvie or Bob?

Hannah: Bob
Hannah: 100000%
Hannah: Bob is actually really talented

Allison: Last season was also pretty meh for me

Pam: Im a Bob fan too. I've been watching that HBO show... it's fo sho Queer Eye + drag (Maeve I think you said that ^^)
Pam: Yes besides Miss Vanjee last season was a little stale

Allison: I liked Yvie because she was weird and something new. But I also liked Brooklyn (but felt like she was using Vangie for screen time but that's a whole other thing)

Maeve: Vanjee truly killed me on this seasons reunion

Pam: YES

Maeve: Same! I really liked Brooklyn and was never annoyed with her dancing

Allison: She's a dancer? from Canada?

Pam: But couldn't do a proper Celine accent LOL

Hannah: Lol

Maeve: LOL but also I hated Silky so much last season but I think the producers thought we would all LOVE her

Pam: OMG Silky. I have mixed feelings about her.
Pam: I liked her towards the end but she was a little TOO much in the beginning

Joe: Let's get all the previous-seasons discussions out of the way.

Allison: I was just reminded that she was in the TOP 4?
Allison: Throw that season in the trash

Pam: Yes throw it out the window!!

Hannah: Ok joe back to the deep stuff. I’m ready for ya

Joe: Haha thank you.
Joe: So when we're saying things like this chick as a good chance of winning, this chick has a disadvantage, etc., what do we mean by that? It's been brought up a couple times and brushed over. Is RuPaul the one with her fingers on the scale? Are the producers deciding this? Who or what actually determines the winner here?

Hannah:

Pam: OMG I'm literally LOLing at that Silky gif

Bridget: Silky is STRAIGHT TRASH

Hannah: I also can’t stop laughing and Joe I’m googling To find out

Pam: I always thought Ru had the final say... I never questioned that until... this very moment

Maeve: I feel like Pam and Allison would know better because they’ve watched every season, buuut I think it’s a mix. I think the talent level is very apparent, but the producers probably have a hand in who should stay overall, but Ru has the final decision?

Pam: Is Michelle a producer?
Pam: Looks like Michelle has 3 producer credits

Allison: So, not to harp on last season, but this became more apparent to me when thinking about Silky
Allison: did anyone like her? But Ru kept pushing her because i dont think Ru is sitting in a director's chair watching the werkroom dailies after every challenge

Pam: Oh yea I feel like Ru makes a point to NOT know what's going on in the werkroom...?

Joe: I brought that point up to Pam earlier in the season, how I thought it was weird that all this shit that they do seems to come down to the whims of RuPaul that day. But she pointed out that it's the same with other competitions. The judges from British Baking make the same kind of decisions. So I dunno. Maybe it's just a matter of "do I trust RuPaul's judgment?" And the answer for me is "sometimes?"

Pam: So just based on performance alone—Silky kinda killed it
Pam: Like she was amazing as Oprah in the Rusical

Hannah: I wouldn’t want anyone but Rupal to make a call
Hannah: It would be disappointing to me if it wasn’t mostly him

Pam: Same
Pam: I think Ru and Michelle really liked Aiden too and that's why she lasted as long as she did

Allison: I do feel like the judging is all over the place

Bridget: Omg she should have gone home week 2

Joe: I dunno, he was giving some bad advice this season

Hannah: Like what?

Joe: The whole Heidi's name thing, trying to get people to change their snatch game personas

Hannah: The snatch game persona thing happens every season

Bridget: El DeBarge!

Pam: Well maybe if Jan had switched to Kris Jenner she would have done better!!

Bridget: Like it’s not completely planned out already...

Pam: Like Bernadette Peters was... fine

Hannah: I truly think the name thing was kind of a joke but also ru being like get with the times

Maeve: Aiden lasting long made me think the producers were like “keep a non-professional small town queen longer so we don’t get shit online” but also I think the pod I listened to put me into conspiracy corner

Joe: Bridget, exactly. Like, if you come into this competition preparing for something, it's shitty for Ru to tell you to do something else

Pam: And I think Ru was also joking about Crystal doing El DeBarge for snatch game

Joe: But not for Heidi to do a Housewife she didn't even know

Pam: But even if you know like the tiniest bit about someone you CAN make it funny if you are funny

Hannah: They tell them to come with a couple of options that we know. Ru makes a point every single season of telling the girls what will be successful and calling out the ones he doesn’t think are gonna be funny

Pam: Like when Katya did Björk

Allison: Is it ironic that Ru and Michelle will often tell a queen to not rely on this or that but then RuPaul is like "you have a mullet, that is all i will reference now"?

Hannah: Yes it truly comes out to like are these girls funny!

Joe: I dunno... as someone who is so so bad at improv, and would absolutely need to prep for this, I empathized with those who Ru told to change up last minute

Hannah: Flashbacks to Joe’s improv 101 audition

Joe: UGH

Pam: yes watching them like makes my palms sweat in the snatch game if they are tanking bc just the thought of improv gives me anxiety

Maeve: I feel like whenever they listen to Ru’s advice, they’ll at least be safe

Joe: That's the only reason Heidi lasted that long

Allison: She took SO many ideas that Ru handed her
Allison: which she'd be stupid NOT to take
Allison: but she needed so much help!

Maeve: Exactly! She kept doing whatever Ru said

Pam: She DID!

Hannah: Oh no you betta don’t

Joe: But isn't that weird though, that Ru gave GOOD advice to someone, and it was only GOOD because he was also a judge?!

Hannah: It’s like when your boss gives you advice and is also in charge of your raise

Pam: Yes but Ru is also an EXPERT

Allison: Ru is not an unbiased impartial judge. She is more akin to a god.
Allison: She plucks you from obscurity, hands you an opportunity, and you better not fuck it up

Pam: Has anyone ever done really well with a last minute snatch game change up?

Hannah: And if you do a little digging on RuPaul you quickly learn that he is is not really in this for the drag. He’s like a life coach and Oprah like personality
Hannah: Who happens to be worth $60 million

Pam: A cool $60 mil

Allison: Ru will not do drag unless she is getting paid

Pam: Did anyone watch Ru's SNL ep? No drag

Hannah: No but I did watch his awful Netflix show

Pam: SNL was disappointing, but it usually is these days anyway lol

Hannah: Lol

Joe: Tangential point: I hate how he says the word "dollars"

Bridget: Doll hairs

Allison: Hahahahaha, I think that's an homage to his mother
Allison: i thiiiiink

Pam: There are so many coined phrases from the show now that I don't even notice that it's not the right way of saying things
Pam: "Condragulations"

Hannah: What’s the documentary about the balls in the 80s? Joe needs to watch that because a lot of this culture comes from that

Allison: Paris Is Burning
Allison: Darliiiing

Hannah: Yesssss

Pam: Ah yes... in the great tradition of...

Joe: I didn't do a lot of prep for this, clearly

Hannah: Joe if you watch anything else watch that
Hannah: It’s actually an interesting piece on the early communities of drag and trans in nyc and how dangerous it was

Pam: That show Pose was all about that too but it was a little too weird for me when I first watched

Allison: I still havent watched Pose!

Bridget: Ahhh I need to watch both of those things!

Hannah: I loved pose but it was really hard to watch

Pam: We watched maybe just the pilot

Joe: Okay, here's a devil's advocate question
Joe: is Drag Race too SAFE?

Hannah: In what way joe give us more dahhhling

Pam: Like safe how?

Joe: Well you said that in Paris Is Burning, drag was dangerous. No one is getting beat up at a RuPaul taping. Thank god, obviously. But does that take the edge away?
Joe: I regret asking this already
Joe: I don't wish violence on anyone
Joe: obviously

Allison: Season 4 lip sync Mini Imfurst v India Ferrah comes to mind

Joe: But is there enough "me vs. the world" mentality in Drag Race, or is that an integral part that's missing

Allison: It's true that drag is much more mainstream now than it was 11 seasons ago.

Pam: I think if anything, drag race is educating people about that history
Pam: ::ahem:: herstory

Hannah: I mean you got a little glimpses of it when people talk about their past and sometimes even their current. I don’t think the intent of the show is to provide a place for people to talk about that but rather a place for them to be themselves away from that
Hannah: And obviously is part of the therapy some of the hurt comes out
Hannah: Celebrity drag race is starting to inch that Way in putting very masculine men in drag

Pam: And usually if there's an old queen on the show, they like to let the youngins know that they SHOULD know their history (Chad Michaels and Jiggly Caliente... right?)

Hannah: But if anything ru has gotten criticism for not being Forward thinking enough. E.g. with his stance on trans

Pam: What is his stance on trans?

Hannah: He doesn’t really comment on it publicly and allison maybe you know more than me But with gender lines blending he has been hesitant to open the door completely to trans people

Joe: boomers, amirite

Allison: Ru has said some problematic things in the past

Allison: something along the lines of a trans woman on drag race is like an athlete on steroids

Pam: Yea I guess usually they reveal that during the show...I guess meaning that Ru hasn't picked someone knowing that they are trans
Pam: Except Gia Gunn but she was an all star

Allison: There have been a number of queens who have transitioned after the show or come out as trans on the show
Allison: I think Peppermint on season 10 was openly trans while filming
Allison: Ru has also to walk back the use of the word "tranny"
Allison: and the pre-filmed rupaul message to the queens at the beginning of every episode used to say "Ooooh girl, you've got she-mail"

Joe: Asking this out of ignorance again—is a drag queen defined as a cisgender male who dresses as a woman? Or is it more nuanced?

Pam: In the HBO show they put anyone in drag—gay men, straight men, women

Joe: So is the definition of drag queen something that has evolved over time?

Pam: Oh yea! I didn't even think of the connotation there...

Hannah: Yes over time.  But I’m no expert

Allison: I think the more that drag is regarded as an art as well as a form of self expression the more it has been widely adopted

Pam: It seems like... drag is for anyone but being in a competition... maybe those born female or trans women might have unfair advantages?
Pam: Like real boobs and butts

Hannah: Yes I think that’s rus argument

Allison: I think it will be a long time before a cis-female drag queen on drag race
Allison: But maybe a drag king?

Hannah: Even some of the stuff they do though like with the pit crew in undies seems a little outside the times

Allison: It's still camp

Hannah: I can’t imagine they will get away with that for much longer

Maeve: Celeb drag race had two diff eps with cis-female drag queens, Vanessa Williams won! But clearly that was the exception to the rule

Allison: A few years ago they did Drag U which was old contestants making over regular women and it was... fine

Pam: Yea I remember one of the roasts they were roasting Ru about Drag U but I've never watched

Hannah:

Maeve: Yeah, the transformation on these celeb drag eps were always “ehhh, that’s slightly more makeup than normal?”

Allison: Oh, here's a thought
Allison: Crystal won for a challenge doing a male drag
Allison: and they LOVED IT

Hannah: I was thinking about that too Allison because they used to give people so much shit for wearing pants

Joe: Crystal consistently made me realize I know jackshit about drag
Joe: every other getup for her, I went "oh god, no" and then she would get so many compliments

Pam: In the past they usually read them for doing male drag

Allison: Season 7 Milk wore a beard on stage and they were like A BEARD?! THIS IS DRAG RACE!
Allison: No, season 6
Allison: then season 7 they were like "category is: bearded queens"
Allison: evolution, i guess

Maeve: RIGHT?!

Pam: I think Crystal gets praised bc as weird as her looks are, they are complete looks

Hannah: But the one with chest hair they cannot accept

Bridget: Ahhhh that sounds awesome. I need to watch old seasons

Allison: She fully commits to everything she does

Joe: Alright, good segue to get back to season 12!

Pam: Sorry one more thing—Milk was SO SWEET in her first season and then became a complete psycho on all stars
Pam: just had to get that out

Allison: I saw Milk live at Voyeur a few years ago and it was... weird

Pam: OMG really?

Maeve: WHAT
Maeve: Next time I see ya, I need a full review of that

Pam: SAME

Hannah: You sure it wasn’t my friend Aaron they look alike

Pam: hahaha they do
Pam: same nose

Allison: shit, i hope not. i paid money for that!

Joe: no beard though for aaron

Hannah: Ok joe hit us with your hard hitting q

Joe: haha nothing too hard hitting, but I feel like we need to talk about sherry pie a little more... did they handle that whole thing as best they could've? Or was there a better way to work around her?

Pam: UGH Sherry Pie how you fucked this season

Hannah: I guess it really depends on what the season looks like with her in it

Allison: At times i wish they had leaned into it more. Like, blur her face and distort her voice
Allison: fast forward through her runways

Bridget: I think how far she made it she would have been a main focus

Maeve: I truly can’t picture how they could’ve handled it better because it was all filmed and to not show the season would’ve been awful for the other queens

Hannah: Like if she was a complete and total bitch I should’ve just left it as is and we all would’ve been cheering to surprise find out that she was a creep

Maeve: Sometimes they didn’t show her runway when she was safe!

Joe: I think i agree with what you said earlier, Allison—sexual creep or no, she didn't seem like she deserved to make it as far as she did

Hannah: Joe why do you say that

Allison: She wasnt exactly ground breaking

Joe: She was completely one-note in a way more grating way than Gigi ever was

Hannah: I’m waiting for Joe to tell me she wasn’t attractive enough

Bridget: She should have been out for the product challenge!!!

Joe: I mean, she was definitely the worst looking...
Joe: But I'm not judging on that, I swear!!!

Pam: But she was super polished and funny and good at the acting challenges

Hannah: Yeah I think she was honestly pretty professional

Bridget: She’s only 27!!!!!!!!!! How insane is that

Pam: yea that is a shock

Maeve: Same. It made me mad that she was professional, polished and prepared for the challenges, but so was Jan and they knocked Jan for being “over-prepared” etc.

Allison: I will say in the makeover challenge, i could not tell her and her partner apart

Hannah: Was what she did illegal?

Pam: And I kinda feel like not showing her the werkroom just made it look like she had her shit together
Pam: Like there was never a moment where Ru questioned what her plan was or gave her advice

Hannah: I agree it made it look like it was an easy glide in for her

Maeve: [two 100s, both double-underscored]

Joe: I honestly didn't think she was doing a good job, but I was curious about self-examining, whether I thought that because I truly thought that, or if my knowledge of her sexual crimes subconsciously influenced me at all.
Joe: Hannah - I honestly am still not sure, but I feel like it's the same as a lot of the #metoo stuff, it doesn't need to be illegal for it to be wrong

Allison: Allison ^^ I agree I 100% thought she had that makeover challenge in the bag...I was so surprised that Jaida won!!

Hannah: Oh no you’re right I totally agree it was wrong I’m just wondering if she’s going to jail

Allison: They cut her almost entirely out of the work room

Pam: Joe knowing you I think you let that stuff influence your opinion of her

Allison: I would love to see the original cut of the show

Hannah: I also think that if there was legal issues there is a different way the situation must be handled

Joe: I tried googling "is sherry pie going to jail" and it suggested "is sherry pie alive"
Joe: is she?!

Bridget: Oh dang

Pam: OMG I just said that to Joe the other day... like I'm sure she's getting death threats and shit...

Maeve: Those people have to be suing her though, right?

Hannah: She caught coronavirus while in character as Catherine Hepburn and the hospital chose not to treat her because she looked so old

Pam: The fans of drag race sound pretty relentless with that kind of stuff

Allison: The fandom is pretty brutal

Pam: Hannah did you feel personally offended having also played a Katherine Hepburn character in Philadelphia Story
Pam: who did a better job?

Allison: http://www.shadebutton.com/

Hannah: I think our performances are indistinguishable from one another

Pam: Sherry Pie didn't get to tongue kiss Sam Fran though

Joe: Sam was tricked into jerking off on webcam

Hannah: Sam‘s grandmother did think I had extremely big feet in the production so perhaps she thought I was a drag queen

Allison:

Pam: "I FEEL VERY ATTACKED"

Joe: Seems like a good place to start wrapping it up 
Joe: Having a good time though!

Bridget: Yeah what an interesting convo!!!
Bridget: I, like joe, need to go back and watch some older seasons!

Joe: Final questions? Who do we think is GOING TO win, and who SHOULD win
Joe: one at a time

Maeve: I think Gigi is going to win, I think Jaida should win, I want Crystal to win

Pam: Gigi will win. CRYSTAL METHOD SHOULD WIN!!!

Bridget: I think jaida is gonna surprise everyone and come out on top

Hannah: I think crystal or jaida will and anyone but Jackie should

Pam: Most I've been rooting for someone maybe ever

Allison: With this bizzaro world zoom finale it's really going to be anyone's game BUT I think Gigi will win but I would like to see Crystal win

Pam: Sherry Pie should win

Joe: If I'm going gut reaction, I want Crystal to win, but I think Jaida earned it, and I think she is going to win it

Pam: Jaida probably earned it more than Crystal but I just love Crystal

Maeve: Totally agree Pam

Hannah: Let’s see how weird these virtual lip syncs are

Maeve: I cannot wait

Pam: Right???

Joe: Oh yeah, we didn't talk about the COVID of it all
Joe: Kinda sucks, right?

Maeve: They said there’s 5, right? Am I imagining that’s what they said on the reunion?

Pam: Are they going to be on some kind of stage? or just at their apts??

Hannah: It sucks for the queens but for us the watcher it’s actually kind of interesting

Pam: Yep, 5

Allison: This would have been a great year for Valentina

Allison:

Maeve: Allison, that made me laugh so hard. I want a Valentina mask

Pam: Valentina...the "fan favorite"
Pam: Also GUYS I HAVE TO WERK ON FRIDAY NIGHT SO NO SPOILERS ME AND JOE WILL BE WATCHING SAT

Hannah: Time for bed for me

Pam: Oh wait  - so Heidi is gonna get Miss Congeniality, right?

Maeve: yes! I think so?

Pam: Or Jan?

Allison: Poor Jan

Maeve: It's between the two of them for sure

Pam: BRITA, Miss Congeniality
Pam: HAHA

Joe: fuck New York, goodnight everyone

Allison: Miss Vangie! *walks backwards out of room*

Bridget: Going to pluck my brows like aiden zhanes! Byeeeeeee

Maeve:

No comments: