Thursday, February 29, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge Monthly Roundup: FEBRUARY 2024


It's Joe again with some general and specific thoughts about YSC as it existed in the month of February. The January roundup took way too long to put together, so I'm going to do my best to streamline this.

— The triplicate of best song / worst song / song in between, at the beginning of the year, was designed to act as a sort of way to get a sense of where people are, musically speaking. But I think the triplicate of folk/emo/rap at the beginning of February worked even better in this regard. Where you stood with certain genres told us a lot about what kind of music you listen to generally. It was fun! Thanks for sharing your picks!

— The emo day especially gave me a lot of music to check out. I don't want to overdo it, so I'm going through the albums I'm now interested in listening to one per week. The list you see below of "albums I want to download" will list all of them, but please know that it might take me until like April to get through them all.

— The hip hop day was a good lesson in "you don't have to LITERALLY answer the prompts sometimes." I might argue that at least half of the songs weren't actually part of any "east coast v. west coast" rivalry, and yet, everyone absolutely nailed the spirit of the thing. The prompt says one thing, but means another. It actually meant: how do you feel about hip hop? A very enlightening and fun day.

— The old songs gave some good write-ups, and some terrible songs. Also: the original template of each write-up is intended to include song title, artist name, album, and year released, but when it comes to older songs, I tend to play it fast and loose. If you choose classical music, often times it'll be the composer instead of the artist, and the movement instead of an album, and shit like that.

— The new songs you hate and the curse words songs and the disgusting/gross songs presented me with a conundrum that I hope you'll indulge me with for just a quick moment. There are songs that I don't listen to because of the artist who made them. A few of them on here—Jason Aldean or Morgan Wallen, or Guns N' Roses or Brand New or Gnarls Barkley, for example. For those songs, I'll publish as normal, but I just won't include them on the YouTube playlist when I make that. There are other songs that I feel, in my opinion, take the idea a bit further, to the point where I feel uncomfortable even embedding the song on the blog. The MSI song and the R. Kelly song are the examples of this from February. As always, I'm not going to tell anyone that they "aren't allowed" to listen to something. Freedom of choice to listen to any music you want to listen to. But I can't help it if my own feelings about certain music are going to bleed through into some of my editorial decisions (and those decisions will be presented to the author first). I'm open to having this discussion in more detail if anyone is interested. Hit me up!!

— As I said for the hip hop prompt, there are some prompts that don't have exact answers, and allow ample leeway for creative decisions. There are other prompts that are strict. The "I'm in love" one, for instance. There was at least one song that did not have that phrase verbatim. I've said it before and I'll say it again—I'm not going to tell someone that they can't use a song if I think or even know that it doesn't meet the requirements of the prompt. That's not what this is about.

— That being said, I am being strict about no repeats, and that's really the only time I'm going to tell someone that they can't use a song (or maybe if I have reason to believe that what is sent me is not a song at all, but I don't know when that would happen). That happened at least once this month! I feel bad and I will do anything I need to do to help rectify the situation. But if it means that the write-up is going up a day late, then that's just how it's gonna be.

— I was shocked how many "asks a question" songs did not feature a question mark. The question mark was not a requirement, so I'm not saying that anyone fucked up. I'm just making a personal observation here, how many artists refuse to use question marks in song titles. From a grammatical perspective, I hate it.

— A lot of great pairings, by the way, for the question/answer days. I have opinions about write-ups and about the songs themselves, but a third opinion is how well the answer song answered the question, and how creative/funny it was. In that specific regard, here were my favorite punchlines:
  • Should I stay or should I go? I don't care.
  • How low? Low.
  • What's new, pussycat? Meow.
  • Why? Because.
  • Why are Sundays so depressing? Work bitch. (my overall favorite)
— As I noted in a comment, I made at least six of the prompts this year correspond to a birthday of a Summer Song Challenge participant. The "tear a door off its hinges" was a Dave thing (and I'm glad that the prompt confused some people). I let Dave know on his birthday that there were songs ready for him. I don't know if he checked it out or not.

— Am I commenting too much? Let me know. My usual M.O. so far is to wake up on a day when the songs are posted, and start listening to them as soon as possible, and then just leaving comments with whatever thoughts I have during that time. Which means I'm dropping like seven comments at eight in the morning. Not sure if that's annoying. Don't be afraid to tell me I'm annoying.

— A list of the gross and/or creepy things that happened in a song: murder; global war; the sin of self-righteousness; grooming; B&E; serial killing and probably necrophilia; sexual harassment; not sure, didn't listen to the R. Kelly thing; institutional rape; sticking your penis is a jar of grape jelly; putting period blood in a stew; digital penetration with Anthony Kiedis' middle finger; sexually harassing a seven-year-old; giving Yoko a death threat; letting P. Diddy sample your song; being a cast member on SNL; murder again; turning children into ground meat.

— I'm writing this before February 29th, so I'm not including the leap day songs in this roundup. I can include them in the March roundup.


SONG CHALLENGE MOVIE CLUB
  • Love Actually
  • Shogun Assassin
  • Creed
  • Clockers
  • White Christmas
  • O Brother, Where Art Thou?
  • Stand by Me
  • South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut
  • Hercules (twice)
  • Shrek 2 (three times)
  • Shrek
  • Saltburn
  • Ready to Rumble
  • Garden State
ALBUMS I DOWNLOADED OR AM GOING TO DOWNLOAD SOON BECAUSE OF SONG CHALLENGE
(In other words, these are the albums I'm not familiar with but that I'm interested in exploring more of, directly because of a song choice or a write-up or both. This is an important function of Song Challenge for me! Thank you to all those who gave me the recommendation!) (Also: some of the albums connected to the songs chosen are coincidentally upcoming for my Year of Blind Spots project. Those albums are not included here.)
  • The Progress EP by the Progress (Allison, Day 16)
  • Louder Now by Taking Back Sunday (Maeve, Day 16)
  • You'll Be Fine by Hot Mulligan (Nate, Day 16)
  • Ocean Avenue by Yellowcard (Bob, Day 16)
  • A Fever You Can't Sweat Out by Panic! at the Disco (Brianna, Day 16)
  • Four Minute Mile by the Get Up Kids (Gilson, Day 16)
  • Commit This to Memory by Motion City Soundtrack (Sara, Day 16)
  • Fear of a Black Planet by Public Enemy (Sunny, Day 17)

SONGS I'M GOING TO DOWNLOAD SEPARATELY
(They were really good songs, but I'm not really interested in exploring the album their from, through no fault of the person who picked them of course.)
  • "Accidentally in Love" by Counting Crows
  • "I Think I'm in Love with You" by Jessica Simpson
  • "Sorry (I Ran All the Way Home" by the Impalas

BEST SONGS (THAT I WAS ALREADY FAMILIAR WITH)
(Also, should go without saying that the songs that I personally chose are disqualified from this list.)
 
WORST SONGS
(Obviously, some prompts call for a bad song. So, for many reasons, the songs aren't on this list because of anything the writer of the blog post did. Let us separate the song from the reason the song was chosen, and let us separate the song from otherwise excellent write-ups for that song. These are just bad fucking songs, period.)

The best write-up from each individual contributor (minimum five on-time submissions this month), with a brief description of each (I can't copy and paste this time, takes too long, honestly:
  • Allison — Day 24 — The Couch
  • Beth — Day 18 — the history of a church song
  • Brianna — Day 15 — Brianna's classroom
  • Bob — Day 24 — anxiety
  • Boober — Day 16 (NOT Day 24) — an emo childhood
  • Bridget — Day 20 — a precious body part
  • Erin — Day 23 — The Horse Stable
  • Galia — Day 20 — sea kayak camp
  • Gilson — Day 21 — past concerts
  • Jeanine — Day 22 — first smoke
  • Laura — Day 24 — Laura's classroom
  • Maeve — Day 15 — from the Bob Dylan archives
  • Nate — Day 15 — dog shit
  • Pat — Day 15 — Welcome to San Francisco!
  • Sara — Day 16 — yearbook camp
  • Sunny — Day 23 — Dan Rather
  • Zach — Day 18 — The Notebook
  • Joe — proud of Day 17, happy with Days 18 and 21, disgusted with Day 24

7 comments:

Pat said...

мы сообщим царю

Sara said...

I love all the comments and camaraderie! Also - is it safe to assume you just don't like folk music from the 60s?

Joe K said...

I love '60s folk, assuming that all my friends eventually remember that there are more '60s folk songs than that Simon and goddamn Garfunkel SHIT.

Pat said...

такой как Скотт Маккензи!

Joe K said...

да, эта песня была не так уж и плоха, я думаю

Boober said...

More comments> everything

Boober said...

Not me picking something that’s not Simon and Garfunkel and making your worst songs list 😭