Monday, February 19, 2024

Yearlong Song Challenge, Day 23: Gilson

Prompt: "A song whose title asks a question"

Selected by Gilson


"Why, Pt. 2"
Collective Soul
Blender, 2000

The idea of a guilty pleasure has always been something I outwardly embrace but privately kind of question. Like, why should I feel guilty about liking pro wrestling, or some other thing that not everyone loves? Why shouldn't I just embrace what makes me happy? Tell me why I've got to feel this way. 

I fucking love Collective Soul. They are pretty candy-ass. They are trying way too hard to jam difficult instrumentation in to otherwise straightforward pop rock songs. There's been only very few singles up their own ass like "The World I Know" was. But goddamn, this band is fun. They eschew the whole idea of a guilty pleasure in itself, because this is a band that came out of the same scene that Bush and Silverchair did, who came up in the wake of bands like Nirvana and Pearl Jam struggling with their own celebrity. Collective Soul didn't struggle with it. They love (loved?) being famous. 

I saw them in Atlantic City once, in like 2004, and you know what? For a straight-up rock show, no bullshit, it was one of the best shows I've ever seen. This singer believes he is a rock star, so he is. 

Listen to and enjoy whatever makes you happy, and stop being guilty about it.

No comments: