Tuesday, February 27, 2024

Phony Beatlemania: "Getting Better"

Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #35 and is featured on pages 222-225. See the full list of their Top 100 Beatles Songs HERE.
 
 
"Getting Better"
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
1967

We can all agree that it feels good to feel good. I like the songs about feeling good, and "Getting Better" strives to be one of those songs. There is optimism abound on this thing. The narrator used to feel sad, and he used to see all the negatives in life, but his perspective has been altered, and now he sees everything that is good and kind and true. Not only is it good now, but it's going to be better soon. There is value in having this kind of outlook on life, and in general, I find it helpful when quality songs like "Getting Better" assist in maintaining that outlook.

I believe in the power of optimism, and I even believe in the power of forced optimism, which is what we have here, I think, after further review. Apparently John, ever the fucking pessimist, added the callback line "it's can't get no worse!" to Paul's song. My first thought was that this sullies the optimistic nature of "Getting Better," and that Paul should've told John to fuck off with that bullshit. But the more I think about it, the more I like that the pessimism was allowed through the cracks, just a little bit. It's like when they tell you to keep smiling even when you're sad, because the muscles in your face are going to force the blood to pump more quickly and will literally help make you happier. I don't know if that's physiologically true or just an urban legend, but I like to think about it and use it metaphorically, and it fits here. Yes, fine, John, the world is shit. But if I keep telling myself that it's getting better, then maybe it actually will. 

This should tell you that I take slight issue with the intense focus that the book places on "the power of love" in fueling that optimism of the narrator. Sure, it's "love" in this song, but it could be anything. I'd like to believe that "Getting Better" is about the ability to feel happy and content by any means necessary, not just the act of "falling in love" (especially in the oppressively heteronormative framework that the Beatles, being products of a different time, mostly worked within). But no one has yet accused Spignesi and Lewis from even attempting to dive through the text and into the subtext, and so we shouldn't start now.

The "why it made the top 100" section, by the way, has devolved past the point of saving. I don't even know why these idiots are still bothering. The "why" for "Getting Better" was basically: 1) it's a classic rock song (um, yes?), and 2) it was on Sgt. Pepper's. "We're sure the Beatlesfans would accept without question." No we wouldn't...? What exactly about the context of being a song on Sgt. Pepper's says anything about "Getting Better" itself? There's a lot to say about the album, of course, but I wouldn't describe it as "pessimistic" or anything like that. Most songs are either optimistic or at the very least psychedelically neutral. What makes "Getting Better" special? What makes it the 34th-best Beatles song of all time? Crickets from our authors. I know at least two people who are not getting better all the time as we move through this project.

Ah, see, though, that's not me being optimistic either. I don't need two boring-ass authors/strangers to tell me that happiness is important for me to know that truth. I'm fine with the Beatles singing about it, though. They do it well here.

BEATLES TRIVIA: I'm reprinting this anecdote from the book in full here.
"[The phrase 'it's getting better'] reminded Paul of Jimmy Nicol, the drummer who filled in for Ringo briefly in 1964 when Ringo was sick... After every concert, John and Paul would go up to Jimmy Nicol and ask him how he was getting on. All that Jimmy would ever say was, 'It's getting better.' That was the only comment they could get out of him. It ended up becoming a joke phrase, and whenever the boys thought of Jimmy, they thought of 'it's getting better.'"
While I'm sure the drummer was specifically referring to his drumming abilities, and how he was getting better at emulating Ringo Starr as time went on, and I am tickled by the fact that there was a dude who fell ass-backwards into a temporary gig as part of the most famous rock band in recorded history, and, knowing that it probably wasn't going to get any better than this, he still found the ability to be optimistic and state that it's getting better. Will it get better? Probably not. But if Jimmy Nichols keeps telling himself that it will, then that means it will become true. Mad respect.

BETTER BEATLE: Hmmm. Let's go with another Sgt. Pepper's track. This is the third track on the list so far, and, for the record, I think that "Getting Better" is better than "A Day in the Life" and "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds." But I also think that there are a few songs that are better than "Getting Better." "Good Morning, Good Morning" is at #65 here, but I think it's better. I'll be interested to see the authors make their case for a better song being 30 positions lower on the list (and yet I have very little faith that they will be able to make a coherent case at all).

NEXT TIME: I have been dreading this... the next "song" is "the Abbey Road medley" at #36, which is absolutely ridiculous

No comments: